Almost exactly a year ago, I sat in a downtown pub having a shot and a beer and a bowl of chili with a friend who writes for the local newspaper. We were commiserating over the difficulties that writers of all stripes face in this competitive, impoverished society. Simultaneously we were attempting to solve all of the world’s problems.
We were both in way over our heads.
During our conversation, my friend mentioned a web site that some of his writer friends liked to use. It was a creative writing site, he said, a blog site, that seemed to enjoy decent visibility and readership. He was familiar with my work and recommended that I give the site a look.
The next day I found that I had written “open.salon.com” in my notebook. What’s this, I wondered, some gay haircuts place? But it was in amongst my notes from my evening at the bar and I recalled (barely) the discussion about the writer’s site. So I looked it up. It was interesting. It was attractive and well designed, there were interesting articles and it seemed to be easy to interact with. You could even leave comments. So I signed up and posted my first post. I got one comment (BBE) and about 10 reads. Ten people! I was pumped.
_________________________________________________
“The next day I found that I had written
“open.salon.com” in my notebook. What’s
this, I wondered, some gay haircuts place?
_________________________________________________
I posted another dozen pieces to little fanfare before I sent ”I Witnessed A Murder” off into the blogosphere. As I checked on its progress, I noted that someone had placed a little box on the front that said “Editor’s Pick”. Suddenly my reads went from the 10’s into the 100’s and the comments went into the 20’s. So THIS is how this blogging stuff works! I was hooked.
In the year gone by, I have gotten a half dozen EP’s and four OS covers. It’s no Saturn Smith or Jocelyn Testes-Harder but I’ll take it. I figure I’ve posted in the neighborhood of 150 times (although I’ve taken more postings down than I’ve left up.) Slowly, I’ve built up a comfy readership that now assures that anything I write will at least get looked at. Some posts do very well, some fail miserably, but most settle in with low double-digit ratings and very nice comments. In June I won the Father’s Day Essay contest with “When The Baby Exploded” and, of course, in January I was awarded The Tiara for which I am enormously proud. The best things I’ve written are “A Young Man’s Encounter With A Hawk”, and “Mountain Cabin With A Tin Roof.” The things that have most escaped people’s attention are “Dad, They’ve Taken Grandma To The E.R.”, “Where Do Mountains Come From?” and “The Unorthodox Church Of The Holy Moly”. There are at least three that are totally regrettable. But all things considered, it has been a very good year. I’ll take it.
The biggest effect OS has had on me over this past year is that it has made me a much better writer. It has provided me with an outlet, and I can’t express how important that is. It’s been perfect for focusing and developing those out-of-the-blue ideas that pop up while I’m driving in the car or walking the dog. It not only provides me with an outlet but it forces me to be more productive. As a result, this year has produced a body of work that I certainly wouldn’t have produced otherwise – a pile of pretty good stories and essays that I can continue to rewrite, edit and shop.
My experience with OS has made me realize the importance of a snappy, interesting title and explosive opening sentence: no matter how brilliantly your piece is written, it won’t get read if it doesn’t get looked at. You have a very brief opportunity to state your case before your reader is off down the feed. That’s why “I Witnessed A Murder” works, it explodes out of the blocks.
I’ve realized the need to be brief, succinct and to the point. In my opinion, the reason that most posts don’t do well is because they are unfocused; they ramble on beyond the main point. They may initially make a point but then they hit it again and again unnecessarily. Beginning, middle, end – hook your reader, make your point, seal the deal, hit the afterburner and get out.
There’s also an unfortunate trend towards avoiding capital letters or punctuation. Why ignore the tools you’ve been provided? More to the point, why not use every tool you can get your hands on to say-exactly-what-you-mean? I can only attribute this to the texting/Twittering trend. I generally avoid those posts… and the three word comments that follow.
When to post? Good question, I haven’t figured this one out yet. I used to think that around 10 a.m. (EST) was good because both coasts are up and the editors in NY are making their morning EP choices. But that doesn’t seem to make any difference. If I have something that is of a lighter, more raucous nature, I sometimes post at night when the night owls are prowling. Late night posts sit on the feed a little longer because there’s less traffic. Personally, I’ve come to enjoy posting on Sunday mornings. There’s always a good group of readers that are up with their morning tea and content to spend a little quiet time with OS. They’s my kind a folks.
I’ve often described OS as a marketplace of ideas. But over the past year it has grown and evolved into something resembling a loud and boisterous foreign bazaar – colorful, bloated, difficult to navigate and easy to get lost in. It can be disorienting, distracting and confusing. Similarly, the barkers and merchants have become louder and more insistent as they compete for customers and attention. Whereas a post used to stay on the feed for most of a day, it’s now there for a couple of hours before its buried down the line. Unfortunately, because of this constant barrage of material, I have become more of a skimmer than a reader. I glaze through the “most recent” and “favorites” lists looking for something of interest. As a result, I often don’t really read ANYTHING and, consequently, I often don’t feel qualified to comment. I am parsimonious with my rates because I feel they mean something. Sometimes I will rate without comment, sometimes I comment without rate.
My biggest concern about posting on OS is becoming an even larger concern and I’ll have much more to say on this later. But I am realizing that anything, once “published” by OS becomes part of the public domain and, in a sense, is no longer mine. Even things that have been removed remain “cached” online by OS, Google and god knows who else. I certainly don’t want to put anything I value on OS (and I value EVERYTHING I put on OS) and it makes me regret some of the things I’ve already posted here…
When I first started blogging here, I was in awe of a couple of bloggers who I felt were most certainly stars. At one point I sent them PM’s, asking for any advice or shortcuts on getting into the writing business. I was sure they were wisened old writers who were successfully secure and who only did this for fun. I got no reply. Only slowly did I realize that, with only a couple of exceptions, NO ONE here on OS is successfully secure, everyone is struggling, NO ONE is making a living through their writing. If they were, chances are they wouldn’t be here.
As I roll into my second year on OS, I’m planning to take a different tact. For one, I spend far too much time here just futzing around (oh, you too?!) and I plan to seriously cut that back. I am a writer first and a reader second. Socialite comes way down the line. I don’t see my involvement on OS as tit for tat. I’m not going to leave meaningless little one or two word comments just to check in. I’m not going to “rate yours if you rate mine.” I’m not keeping score. When I do find something sparkling, meaningful, thought-provoking, heart-felt – I will say so, rate it and recommend it to others.
The way that I plan to continue to use OS is as a platform, a store front, where people can find me. (Although guarded, given my comments above on ownership.) It’s a place where I can direct people to find my writings, it’s a place to showcase some of my material. I post articles on bonsai, which on OS only get a few rates and a few comments. However, they are my most widely read articles when they reach the web and I get regular emails from places as distant as China and New Zealand in response to them. I am thankful for my regular OS readers, but I can’t count on the same dozen, or 100, or 200 people as my sole audience.
This second time around I am making the following resolutions:
1. I won’t “flounce” to great fanfare. You’ll know I’m gone when you realize you haven’t heard from me in a while. If I’m gone, it’s a good thing, it means I’m directing my energies elsewhere. But frankly, I love this little window and hope to always leave it open at least a crack.
2. No more “metaposts”. This is my last. No more navel gazing, no more searching for my own reflection in the mirror. No more obsessing about OS. No more worrying about who’s getting EPs and covers, who’s getting ratings and comments, who’s tumbling from site to site just to make trouble. No more posts on the process or messages about the messenger - even if the very mention of OS in the title does guarantee a bump in readership.
3. No more reacting to stupidity; no more becoming caught up in other people’s personal dramas. It serves no purpose and never ends well. Even though whiners, one-issue wonders, creationists and Rove Republicans drive me crazy, I’m going to just shake my head sadly and move on. What’s the old saying? “Never try to teach a pig to sing. It will only wear you out and it annoys the pig.” There are some seriously needful folks out there who are like black holes from which not even light can escape. (If this stirs you to write an angry PM, don’t. Ignore me and move on.)
4. Keep profanity, scatological and genital references to a minimum. Sure, it ups your readership, and sometimes it’s the only way to describe something - I mean, WTF?!? But usually there’s a more descriptive set of words. They’re just a little harder to find. I consider it a challenge.
5. Post less. I’ve already started doing this. I’m going to let things sit on my page longer and let the “favorites” list work its magic. This past year I’ve posted on the average of every second or third day. I’m going to try to settle in at around a post a week, sometimes two. My experience is that there’s a swirl of activity when you first post, another when people return to their computers and then a slow dribble as people read from their favorites list. When the dust from the latest brouhaha settles, my stuff will still be sitting there.
6. Expand my sphere of influence and expression. I need to open blogs elsewhere, resurrect some old projects, fight harder for current ones. I’ve become too dependent on OS.
After a year here, I feel pretty confident about how this site works and what I can, and can not, expect from it. I get a kick out of being here and will forever be thankful for the experience that it has offered me. In return I offer a heartfelt “thanks” – to OS itself and especially to a nuclear group of readers who have remained loyal throughout. I could start naming names but I’d just leave someone out…
But you know who you are. You’re reading this now.
Thanks.
J.


Salon.com
Comments
scupper: We're blogoversary mates and post mates. Here's more mud in your eye. Onward!
scanner: Thank you, really. I appreciate your kind words and your presence.
Lea: It's the only course I've got.
Denise: Thanks for your thoughts... and good luck to you as well.
Yeah! This is the one. OS can be addictive and can actually get in the way of doing other, more productive things like work or looking for work.
Great stuff, Jeff. I've been coming to the same conclusions as you have although your thoughts on length and making your points are something I haven't thought much about. They're totally accurate though (you just helped me have a minor ephiney).
Dr.Spud: My concern about the ownership problem is not so much that people will steal, but that short articles may be deemed by publishers to be already published... I look forward to another year of laughing and marveling at each other's stuff. (And my man, I'm getting old by the second!"
Stellaa: Don't you love getting up in the morning and grabbing your notebook to find out what you've been up to?
Walter: I live for minor epiphanies. My work is done here. Thanks old man!
R
Glad you're here, Jeff. Hope you don't decide to slip away, and wish you all the best on your other ventures.
I haven't completely found my sea legs here yet, and your advice makes a lot of sense as a palliative for some of the same ailments you describe. The only tip I would disagree with, as a newcomer, is the tit-for-tat rating game. As comments and ratings seem to be, aside from the mysterious EP criteria, the only way to get exposure on the cover (in the feed or on the "top-rated" list). This is especially relevant given the "boisterous foreign bazaar" atmosphere you described so well. In this light, exposure seems to be the best way to gain the name recognition that draws readers.
Of course, as cartouche points out, such familiarity must be associated with rewarding reads, else it can work in reverse. I tried a tad too hard with the marketing at first, which undoubtedly sullied my name with certain epicures, and that's a regret. But there are so many exciting writers and appreciative readers here that it quickens my metabolism every morning just watching my computer boot up.
BTW, I do believe ClarkK will be adding this post his invaluable file of OS keepers, which is listed with links on his blog.
Did I congratulate you on your anniversary? Well, I hereby do, and pledge that before the day is done I will read the highly touted "Mountain Cabin," which I'm certain has not been touted in vain.
rated for many reasons
So much of what you say strikes a chord in my feelings regarding OS. Especially the fact that it's forced me to be more productive, less procrastinating. The meeting of wonderful writers I would have never known otherwise. And the contemplating whether to post certain things, things too precious to me, and I waver between posting or not. The question has answered itself and I thank you for that.
Thank you, Cartouche for pointing me here.
Rated.
v. seijo: "I 've been here for a few months..." Be sure to note your own evolution here as well as your development. It's fun to watch.
Dr. Spud: Slinking is a right, not a privilege.
bbd and Froggy: Thanks.
Jimmymac1025: Thanks.
Gigabiting: You can't go wrong following cartouche's lead!
Elisa: Wow! Can I send that to my mom? Thanks.
Oh well. Looks like we came in around the same time, Jeff . . . I thought you'd been here much longer than me, but I guess that shows how green I was/am. So many of your stories have had an impact on me . . . reminding me of the best of educators and storytellers I've met along the way, inspiring me to keep at it . . . keep hacking my way through the brambles.
I'm glad you're planning on leaving the widow open, just in case . . .
Robin: (No exxxing and ohhing in public.)
Critiques and commentary are always more beneficial when you respect the source. I know that praise from musicians I greatly respected added greatly to my confidence in my songwriting abilities. Critiques from so-called "professionals" in Nashville? Not so much. I mean, what sort of value is there in a critique of a song called Real Men that reads "Who are you to say what a real man is?"
Guess I must have cut a little too close to the bone with those lyrics.
You seem to enjoy your comments....so I'll leave you one. Thank you for the veteranly advice. Happy Blogoversary!
Glad to have read this piece and am interested in reading more of your work. I recognize some commenters here and am urged to read more of your work because of them.
Greenheron: I do enjoy comments. Given that this is somewhat of a birthday card, I'm trying to respond to all. Othertimes I don't say a word. Thanks..
Anna1leise: You are very correct, and the encouragement, critique and comment that you get here is very valuable.
emma: That is always preferable to "I object!"
Little Kate: Welcome. I hope you find here what you are looking for. (Just between you and me, I also write under another avatar and no one reads me... )
Holy Moly, the last woman leaving the nudist swim hollow and that dumb ass fighter jock buzzing your bike are my favorites. I look forward to another year of better than I deserve reading. monkey fingered.
i love your stuff, rarely miss one. good observations. happy blogoversary. see ya around.
oh, and the "no caps" for me is because i have horrible carpal tunnel syndrome, both hands, and have less trouble (on my ergonomic curved keyboard) if i don't move my wrists off the rest. hitting the shift key makes me lift 'em up. so no caps in comments when i'm typing really fast. i'm sure that's TMI, but oh, well. ;
BBE: "Teaching her to bamboozle authority at an early age. I approve. monkey fingered." This remains my favorite comment of the year gone by.
I haven't been here long enough to develop any theories about the culture, except to say that I have always felt embraced and welcomed, instantly mentored. So I appreciate your insight. Again, I look forward to poking around your blog's offerings.
I look forward to reading your work. Many thanks to cartouche for sending me your way.
Cheers~
What you are seeking with your writing will happen. I seem to know these things.
R
"I’ve realized the need to be brief, succinct and to the point." Hell to the yeah, on that one. Too much rambling going on, too little paragraph breaks, too little punctuation, grammar checks. It's not just annoying - those pieces won't get read. Who feels like sifting through a big, fat block of unedited text?
As for ownership, I hear your concerns but that's not the whole story. The Internet doesn't "own" your writing after you post it - you do.
This has been debated here at length but sometimes we fear more than we need in that department. If you decided to publish a compilation of your works, some of which have appeared here, you can, of course, because you're the author.
Anyway, excellent points, across the board.
Halo...
"When I do find something sparkling, meaningful, thought-provoking, heart-felt – I will say so, rate it and recommend it to others." After reading the above quotation from you, I feel quite honored that you even left me a comment!
Congratulations on your first year anniversary!