The Observatory

The Truth Shall Set You Laughing

Jeremiah Horrigan

Jeremiah Horrigan
Location
New Paltz, New York, USA
Birthday
February 04
Bio
Former Knight of the Altar, St. Martin's parish in South Buffalo, NY. Old enough to remember ducking-and-covering from the nukes that Sister Jeanne assured us were coming our way, defending Santa Claus until age 10, hating sports, being effectively blind until fourth grade, wanting to fly, escaping to Westchester County for three years, re-escaping to Buffalo for most of high school, escaping to Fordham U to grow a moustache and smoke a lot of oregano-laced pot, escaping school, getting political, getting arrested, getting tried, convicted and released for crimes against the draft. Husband to Patty, father to Grady and Annie. Housepainter, cab driver, idiot, then newspaper reporter in Poughkeepsie, years of freelancing (Sports Illustrated, New York Times, Negligent Mother Magazine) and shameful indulgence, followed finally by 15 more years of reporting, column-writing, some awards, discoveries large and small along the way, including these: Sister Jeanne was full of beans, writing is good for the soul and I'm the luckiest man alive.

Jeremiah Horrigan's Links

Salon.com
JULY 26, 2010 9:26PM

Political Corruption, 2010. Is Blago the Best We Can Do?

Rate: 12 Flag

It looks like the fate of ex-Governor Rod Blagojevich, the bad-haired boy of Illinois, will soon be in a jury’s hands. Excuse me if I fail to be shocked at his decision not to take the stand in his own defense. Did anyone seriously expect him to do what he said he’d do? 

 

In the nearly two years since he was indicted, Blago, as the tabs have tagged him, has shown himself to be a potty-mouthed, highly self-regarding pol – a seeming political throwback to the kind of big-city machine politicians who made this country and its cities what they are today, for better or worse. To paraphrase the immortal words of another, far more successful pol from the bygone days of unbridled municipal thievery, poor Blago appears to have merely been caught in the act of seeing his opportunities and failing to take them.

 

That other pol belongs to a long-gone (but not completely extinct) tradition whose Boswell was a former Democratic New York State Senator named George Washington Plunkitt, a proud -- and wealthy -- son of Tammany Hall whose words of wisdom bear remembering at times like these.

Plunkitt's wealth came from his political connections. But, as he insisted throughout his life, he made his money honestly:

"It was honest graft, and I'm an example of how it works. I might sum up the whole thing by sayin': 'I seen my opportunities and I took 'em."

Plunkitt described to a biographer more than a century ago how, for example, knowing where a new bridge was scheduled to be built might be a valuable bit of information when the bids went out and the once-worthless land that he'd bought up for peanuts just the day before could be sold at a handsome profit when the proper time and opportunity rolled around.

"Ain't it perfectly honest to charge a good price and make a profit on my investment and foresight?" he wanted to know.

 

To agree with Plunkitt's question might seem like I'm endorsing political chicanery.  And that's what I'm doing, for two reasons: I have yet to find a living, breathing victim of Blago's alleged malfeasance, and I have a particular fondness for political chicanery in the classical mode.

 

The only victim of the Blago allegations is political naiveté, someone's idea of political propriety. The prosecution – and, I’d wager, a goodly number of voters -- seem to think that a seat in the Senate shouldn't be put up for sale like a something at a yard sale. Putting a million-dollar price tag on it, as Blago stands accused of doing, is so . . . unseemly. So tasteless. Yet it’s a commonplace that millionaires are the only people in the country who can even countenance a run for the Senate.

 

My love of the classical notwithstanding, I still think Blago is a bum. It’s not his alleged greed but his utter lack of style that makes him such a tiresome disappointment to aficionados of political gamesmanship.

 

Here’s a short list of some of his post-indictment activities, according to a story by David Mendell in the July 26 edition of The New Yorker: he’s gotten fired by Donald Trump on “Celebrity Apprentice.” He’s proclaimed his innocence on Letterman. He’s posed as an Elvis impersonator at a Chicago street festival. And this:

 

“His wife Patti ate a tarantula in a contest with the actor Lou Diamond Phillips in Costa Rica for the reality how “I’m a Celebrity . . . Get Me Out of Here!” The couple later explained they needed the money.”

 

The story doesn’t say what Lou Diamond Phillips’s excuse was.

 

Imagine for a minute what a pol like Plunkitt would have done if he’d been caught with his hand in the municipal cookie jar. Or imagine what The Kingfish, Gov. Huey Long of Louisiana, would have done, or what he would have said. Or James Michael Curley, a chunk of whose fourth term as mayor of Boston was spent in a federal penitentiary.

 

These men were political masterminds of the first water, men who gave the people what they wanted by manipulating the levers of political machines they had conquered and controlled. Yes, they were greedy and corrupt, and reformers of their day thought of them as the devil’s very spawn. But the names of the upstanding moralists Plunkitt called "goo-goos --" good-government types -- are lost to history, while characters like Long and Curley are still remembered as friends of the working people they fleeced but who also delivered whatever goods or services those folks needed or wanted.

 

The results are great cities, built by charismatic thieves whose peculiar strengths and weaknesses are the stuff of legend. (And Pulitzer Prizes. Robert Penn Warren’s “All the King’s Men,” based on Long’s legend, won in 1947 and Edwin O’Connor’s “”The Last Hurrah,” which drew on Curley’s career, won in 1962.)

 

Blago is the unworthy inheritor of that colorful tradition. His alleged chicanery was all about him. His constituents hardly have seemed to have entered his mind, let alone his political agenda. His greatest achievement as governor? Funding free bus rides for senior citizens.

 

Perhaps worst of all, he talked nakedly about his self-enrichment plans on a telephone he suspected was tapped. That's plain stupid, and whatever you want to say about the Plunkitts and the Longs and Curleys of the world, they weren't stupid.

The indictments claim he’s a corrupt politician. But, by the measures set down by the big-city machine pols of the old days, Blago’s worst crime is that he is a dull and inept politician, someone who couldn't play the game by rules that have been in effect since before the days of the Roman Senate, rules that have nothing to do with propriety and everything to do with making things happen, sometimes for the good of the public, sometimes for the good of Caesar and sometimes for the good of all.

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
What Blago did says in the open is what goes on with lobbyists and campaign contributions all the time. You're right. He's just too dumb to do it the big boy way.
Kind of goes to the adage of "honor among thieves." Blago is a laughing stock, but, then again, so, too, would a lot of the old grass roots pols like Tip O'Neil, the former speaker of the house from Cambridge whose main slogan was "all politics is local."

The media age has reshaped it. Hair does it.

But ... you gotta love a woman who can swallow a tarantula.
Bob: Thanks. I see enough no-class, dishwater-dull pols at the local level to expect a little something more at the statehouse -- but an Elvis impersonator? Takes a special kind of guy.

Geoff: No argument on the tarantula front, at least in the abstract. But what I want to know -- and The New Yorker failed to tell me -- was the thing alive when she bit it?
Jeremiah,
I think you've swung me on this issue. There's never been any doubt for me that Blago was about Blago-24 hours. I think he wanted to be "famous" more than he wanted to be governor. He's gotten his wish.
You've nailed it: It's emblematic of our entire 2010 culture that our politicians can't even rise to the level of scoundrel...
Lorraine: Blago's next career move -- he writes his memoirs from the same place Michael Curley led Boston in his last term.

Nikki: Not even close. Alas, and thanks. Took me about 1,000 words to say the same.

Stellaa: You got that right. Kind of scary to imagine if he HAD gotten the memo.
Way cool, Jeremiah. Not what I expected.

If you are going to be a seedy grafter, at least be a colorful, complex, talented, seedy grafter, worthy of literature. Otherwise just shut up and go serve your time.
sigh. i suppose in the pol pot brew, as long as more people are fed then poisoned the recipes O.K.
Greg: Amen, brother.

On the cultural front, I'd add these choice selections of artistry bred of big-time political hubris: Broderick Crawford won best actor for portraying Willie Stark, Huey Long's stand-in in "All the King's Men."

Sean Penn didn't do as well in the later and by-now forgotten version of the same movie.

Musically, the Kingfish himself is credited with writing his own theme song, "Every Man a King," which can be heard on Randy Newman's fantastic "Good Ol' Boys" album, which in turn was inspired by a biography of Long by Harry T. Williams which, in turn again, won the Pulitzer for biography in 1970. (Among the other great songs included on "Good Ol'Boys" is one called "The Kingfish," about you-know-who.

On the nonfiction front, the great A.J. Liebling and, if memory serves, H. L. Mencken both wrote about Long and (whew) in 1985, Ken Burns did a documentary about him.

Oh yeah, Sinclair Lewis is supposed to have used Long as a model of his home-grown dictator in "It Can't Happen Here."

Long died at the age of 42, either assassinated or shot by accident by one of his bodyguards, depending on which legend you chose to believe.
Maria: When these guys get completely out of hand -- when a political system collapses or is taken over from within, yes, that's when scoundrels can become monsters, their impact measured in the blood of millions.
Excellent and insightful piece, my friend. Well written.

Monte
Thanks Monte. It was fun to write.
R. for getting me intterested in this guy.
I was reading an article about Obama recently that described how Chicago machine patronage politics has been eclipsed. Gone are the politics of bodies and door knocking, replaced by pandering to wealth for campaign advertising.
This might explain Blago to a degree. Instead of a patronage system of mutual benefit, the only one left to benefit is the politician...and the wealthy donors.
So, yes, I agree there is much to be admired in the machine pols of the past. At least the people were closer to governing for their benefit.

I wrote a ditty about Blago back when the story broke. Desperate federal agents finally managed to catch him on video in an Italian restaurant, offering to trade the Senate seat for a platter of calamari.

I'll let you figure out the pun--chline.
Jonathan: Thanks for stopping by.

Paul: They didn't call it patronage for nothing, eh? It seems that what you're saying is that money has become the ONLY source of power in Chicago, and that wouldn't surprise me, though it's disheartening.

Here's a thought: I can't help but wonder how if Obama can make the people-politics of a long-forgotten radical community organizer (Saul Alinsky) real again, why can't someone revisit the current political scene and wrest some control from the millionaires? I'm probably being naive here, but, who'd have thought Alinsky's rules were still to be reckoned with?

I think what you say does indeed go a long way in explaining Blago -- who rose to his level of incompetance with stunning speed, as far as I've been able to see.



This might explain Blago to a degree. Instead of a patronage system of mutual benefit, the only one left to benefit is the politician...and the wealthy donors.

So, yes, I agree there is much to be admired in the machine pols of the past. At least the people were closer to governing for their benefit.

I'm going to hit your back pages to find out the punchline. Calamari -- octopus -- Blago -- platter -- splatter -- this is why I'm not a songwriter.

Thanks for pitching in -
Jeremiah,
Sorry it took so long to get back here.
I think the Dem leadership, nationally, has also given in to the new political paradigm. Even when they have a populist idea on their side, they won't use it.

I took down my Blago post some time ago.
The pun--chline was that, by taping Blago's calamari-for-Senate seat offer...the FBI finally had the Squid Pro Quo act they needed to convict.

I'll groan for you.