After reading mypsyche’s recent post, Don’t Hate Me Because I’m Beautiful, and Mark Pritchard’s earlier post, Question for Beautiful Women, I started thinking about French women. The French women I’ve known, and this includes French women from Quebec as well, really do have a certain je ne sais quoi. They carry themselves with a true sense of self-confidence that is so alluring. It shows in everything they do; how they eat, wear a scarf, walk, sit, sip a glass of wine, even smoke, you name it. This confidence makes ALL French women appear beautiful. It emanates from their core, and like a beautiful flower, it attracts birds and bees alike.
So where do they get all this confidence? And why is it so elusive in North American society?
I have a snapshot in my head of an early experience that speaks to this. I am in the bathroom with all my kindergarten buddies. At one point, I look towards the mirror and see myself amongst my playmates for the first time in my life. The very first thing I do, and what I can remember so distinctly now, is judge myself. My head appears larger than everyone else’s and my pixie cut just doesn’t look as good as Janet’s, my dress isn’t as pretty, I am either too tall or too short. I can still see that mirror image in my head.
So, why does this self-assessment still resonate with me 43 years later? And what could I have possibly learned by the age of five that would make me judge myself so harshly?
Well, I don’t think it is so much about what I’d learned prior to that but more about what I didn’t learn after that age. My Dad loved us and told us, my mother, sister and I, that we were the most beautiful of any, but that didn’t hold much water in the real world. As young girls, we are taught that it was egotistical to like yourself or to think yourself pretty. If you wanted to lose friends fast, just be the prettiest, best dressed, most confident girl in class. Or just think you are. Get a boyfriend before all the other girls in your class; you must be a slut. The criticism I first levied against myself quickly became the same criticism that girls levied against each other on a regular basis.
Whatever we were supposed to be, it was only to be found out there. It was always what someone else had and pretty much unachievable. And it was a Catch-22 because if you did manage to achieve it, you were ostracized by the very friends whose very acceptance you coveted. And so, burdened with all this baggage, girls trudge towards womanhood in the hopes of finding a worthy mate and life. But worthy of what? Worthy of the person we wish we could be or worthy of the person we think we are? How many years do we waste in therapy, retail or traditional, trying to come to terms with these conflicting images?
Mark thinks that women are being disingenuous when they reject compliments. But in truth, this knee-jerk reaction is part of our programming. It is expected. To do otherwise is to face the taunts of the other girls and to risk losing friends. You can be good, and you can be pretty, but don’t be too good or too pretty. That is the law of the land—well it is the law of North America.
I think this sucks. I think it is the root of many of our troubles on this continent, from weight problems to credit card debt. Despite being burdened by beauty, mypsyche found her inner compass, and along with that, self-acceptance. But too many women wrestle to find self-acceptance through dieting or acquiring more clothes, jewelry, trinkets, etc. We never truly get to know ourselves, thus we eat the wrong things and often buy the wrong things (hello velour track suits). This makes a lot of retailers and diet gurus rich and happy, but it does nothing for our womanly self-image.
We’ve allowed advertising and fashion industries run by men for the profit of men to define beauty. It is time we define beauty on our own terms. So, today I declare myself a French woman. I am not going to wonder whether I am beautiful, I am going to KNOW it, I am going to walk it, and I am going to live it.
Today, I’m going to wear my best jeans and a beautiful scarf—to Home Depot. And I will not wear mascara, (screw you Maybelline). Rather, I will know that my eyes are beautiful without that crap because they are the window to my soul. And I will invite everyone who looks upon me to peer inside my beautiful soul without making them crawl through greasy black gunk to get there.
I declare this day, October 24th, 2009, My Beauty Emancipation Day. And I ask all North American women to join me. Today, dig out that beautiful scarf you’ve been hiding in a drawer and carry yourself like a French woman. You are beautiful. Own it.
Screw you Hugh Hefner. And screw you Karl Lagerfeld. And yes, screw you Calvin Klein and your kiddy porno ads. The women of North America are all beautiful just the way we are.
I know the women of OS are all beautiful because I read it in every piece. I want you to declare it in this comment thread – no caveats allowed. Join me. Be a French woman. Accept that you are beautiful. I know you are; now you need to know it too.


Salon.com
Comments
:-)
(one teensy exception: no mascara is a no-go. my eyelashes are blonde. can't look like the easter bunny -- to myself) ;;
R...but do I have to wear a scarf? I gave all mine away.
Avec Amour,
petite willie
What the hell - I'll give it a shot:
I am beautiful. I will declare it to myself, for it is not ego to say so, nor does it harm or diminish anyone around me to believe that I am beautiful. Today, I will allow myself to believe that I am beautiful.
The French are just BETTER at some things. Important things like food and sex. Not that North Americans aren't above giving them a run for their money. N. Americans will *never* quit trying, which is probably 1/2 the explanation.
Feel beutiful everyday dammit. You deserve it.
Yes. It's great but the French have nothing on me!
Thank you for letting the world (of OS and Home Depot) experience your charming french side. Nous sommes les femmes fatales! Salut.
I loved this post. I´ll go and read the links now.
Kisses,
Marcela
I am saying through tears that I join you in being a French woman.
Screw them all!!!
"I am beautiful." And I'm going to start acting like it.
"Bien dans sa peau,": comfortable or at ease with yourself.
Of course they have tons of rules that they learn from a young age, how to eat, what to eat, what to wear, what is done, what is not done.
But, like a good cultural imperialist, I gleaned the parts I like from the French.
Tant pis.
It's a problem, because the most sincere compliment is treated with suspicion, or worse, self-derision. They can really, really, seriously tick me off.
And you're obviously as bad as they are. So I support your revolution; I hope it spreads throughout OS and beyond: Aux barricades.... le jour de gloire est arrivé
Rated
Spotted, bienvenue beautiful woman.
Carrie, I don’t have to count you in, you were always among the counted. Everyone is. Merci.
Consonantandvowel, mais oui. Tres bien.
Nana, there is a little known link between Doukhobor culture and the French. I will post on that some day. ;)
Noisy, you look mavellous dahlink. I always refer to my flannel as “Flannel No 5.” It makes it seem so much more elegant.
Nick, merci.
Chuck, your French roots serve you well. Merci.
Femme, tres bien! You are always beautiful babe – bunny lashes and all.
Cartouche, if all you wear to Home Depot is those boy briefs and a tank top sans bra, I imagine you are quite the hit. ~smile~ It was some of your comments on this that got me thinking along these lines. I imagine your mother as you describe her enjoys this quite elegant sense of self. I celebrate your beauty all the time. Merci mon ami.
Buffy, no scarf required. It is more symbolic as the French do it so well. Your confident beauty always shines through. You inspire me.
Littlewillie, and a beautiful French woman you are I bet. Je t'adore.
Noisy, you are certainly both.
Owl, you ARE beautiful – body, mind, heart and soul. Love ya sista. Vive le revolution.
Nick, the French are better at some things because they believe that, and they pass that on to their children. THAT is part of our problem here. In order to teach our children to love themselves unabashedly, we first have to love ourselves. The change starts here for me.
Frank, I think I’ll enjoy a little French vino tonight as well. Salut.
Kathy, don’t they do that look well. I love watching the women in Montreal. They are so well put together, but rarely gaudy or over done. Simple, elegant – this is the key. Merci.
Maddie, good for you. Wear those heels with pride baby. Today I chose my favourite boots. I love the way they make me feel.
Mypsyche, look at what you’ve started!! Shopping really only does bring us momentary happiness. It is a crutch we need to toss aside. Vive le revolution! (or is it la?)
Marcela, you don’t need to join; it is your birthright. I always thought women in your country would be more akin to the French in this respect. Your confident beauty always shines through. Kisses on both cheeks.
Roy, ~smile~ back. Merci.
O’Really? Absolument. You smell beautiful.
Sharon, no tears required. You are beautiful. Welcome to the club that you were always part of. Strut your stuff woman.
Marecelleqb, good for us. Merci.
Michael, please post pictures. ;) Thanks.
Stellaa, I love that saying. I am going to tattoo it on my ass. Je m’en fous is now my battle cry for life. Good for you for gleaning what you needed from the French. I wish we could teach our children more rules of good living and not just more rules.
Boanerges, you should not be chastised for telling the women in your life they are beautiful because they ARE. Le jour de gloire est arrive indeed. Merci.
Never the less, having the artists eye, I am addicted to beauty, hence my dating pattern was much like that of Charley Harper (Charley Sheen in Two and A Half Men) but with the relationships lasting a good deal longer, often months rather than days.
So, for me, at least beauty is a gift from God, and I love to be near those so gifted. Nice piece of writing JKB.
Cindy, cindy, cindy. You are missing the point. You ARE beautiful. It emanates from your heart. Fuck how everyone else looks or what they think. Or as I will soon have tattooed on my butt, je m’en fous.
Drew, I've seen some interesting french braid treatments that challenge your assessment of the hairy armpit. I'll PM you some links. ;O
Professor, "Charley Harper?" ; "inversely proportional to sanity?" Do tell. It sounds like you've led an interesting life. Merci. Your artist's eye gives you a unique perspective.
Just yankin' your chain. Whether I want to defy reality and say I'm beautiful, or whether I just say beauty schmeuty, they boil down to the same attitude--superficialities are meaningless.
But I do think I am in a way beautiful. I have gorgeous eyes that can look into your soul and a charming smile. If you can get past my age 56( look 46) and my weight ( you really didn't expect me to tell that) you would find a most beautiful woman. Make-up or not. Do I always feel this way, no. BUT I will try the French thing and see!!
I could never leave the house in shabby clothes sans makeup unless I was going for a hike somewhere remote, but as I've grown older I notice that I don't mind wearing a whole lot less makeup in informal situations, and my clothes don't always have to be "matched." I admire the confidence women who are comfortable going to the store in their underwear with naked faces, but that is just never going to be me.
Am I among them? Probably. And the irony is, Irish thought I am in every cultural marker, I am, by a fluke, actually one-quarter French. Suffice it to say that, between my clumsy, awkward walk (the legacy of having been born with a skeleton that was sort of a "second"), perpetually rebellious mick hair, and gigantic behind, you'd never be able to suss out my Gallic heritage in one million years.
Eh, at least my sense of humour's still intact--even if it is that nasty, dark Irish kind. :-D
And I have no doubt that _you_ are beautiful, hon. Vive la libération!
Just for the totally irrelevant dish of it, Mark's first wife was a gorgeous Frenchwoman. Film star beautiful. I'm his second wife. We're all good friends. How French is that?
That much, I think we can all manage
I think the explanation of the reasons for the differences in attitude towards beauty between us and them is infinitely more complex than the distillation as you present it here. Nevertheless, I bow to your experience and hop on board with both feet--Vive la revolution.
Right now I think I'll take the leopard scarf off my bidet and arrange it around my shoulders.
Lunchlady, I suspect we don’t all speak French, we have a smattering of French and a good google translator. ;O You are beautiful regardless of your weight, age, makeup etc. Just know it.
Brian, it is all about the soul. Thank you for sharing your beauty here.
Sweetfeet, merci. :)
Myriad, you are in whether you want to be or not. Scarves aren’t for everyone. You seem to have a knack for hats.
Billy, my sister gave me a Joe Cocker album when I was 11. I’ve loved him ever since, and someday, I’m going to ask her what she was thinking. I like your perspective on beauty. I love the close up view of people. And you have to break through some barriers to get that close. Maybe that’s it.
Sheepie, I think woof, woof is the same in French. Vous aussi.
Zuma, well done. An interesting statement. I must think on that one a minute.
Emma, it is about the effortless “look.” And the French never confuse an effortlessness look with being sloppy or putting in no effort. I believe much effort goes into looking as though no effort was employed. They choose classic styles that require little effort and then add those little touches.
Deargdruchtach, it’s not about the “we,” it is about the “I.” It is about recognizing your own beauty and not judging it based on what other people think. But you are right. There are many people who are ugly from the inside out, but that is their problem. Vive la libération!
Tai, mais oui. Bienvenue.
Bluesurly, a comfy sweater is like mana from heaven. You look mahvellous dahlink.
Dragonlady, live your inner French woman wherever you are. It will rub off on your grandchildren. Maybe you can rent a cottage in the French countryside some summer and take them with you. Merci.
Renee, bienvenue.
Sirenita, that is so typically French. I love it. You and Mark continue to inspire me with your openness. Tell Mark thanks for the inspiration for this post. Merci.
Odette, the 25th will do. Actually, any day will do. Free that scarf. Let it enjoy the light of day and the closeness to your smile.
Peppermint, that is a great outlook. Happiness really does emanate from within and brings out our natural beauty.
Karin, enjoy the football game. The right pair of good flats are as good as any heels. My favourite boots are flats and they look fabulous with jeans. Maybe they won’t yell so loud once they realize an elegant French woman is standing among them. ;)
Ghost, I wasn’t trying to explain the differences. Actually quite the opposite; rather than rationalize it, I want to claim it and move forward from there. Welcome to the revolution; there is no turning back now.
Lea, I hope to get to Bali one day. I also found the women in Tahiti had great style and grace, but of course, there is that French influence there. Yes, take that leopard scarf off the bidet and wear it to the grocery store. Merci.
I agree that French women have a certain something, they sure do! As for me, I think American women are too stunning for words (Jean Houston, Madeline Allbright, etc.) I''ll write more later. Right now, I'm headed to Home Depot!
Thanks for making me smile!
Bobby...good one. I love it. No wonder American women are confused.
GiGi, well said. Watch out at Home Depot...I never escape without a huge dint in my gucci purse.
Surly, don't you teach Parisienne waiters how to be surly? Your pits are not suitable topics for this blog, but I am sure those hamsters in your head are churning out a post on this subject as we speak. Great pits from the 70s perhaps?
The French are great! Good post, JK....
I missed your "no mascara, just a scarf weekend" but I will wear the look proudly to my office tomorrow....though, at camp it's really not that unsual!
I distinctly remember standing in front of the mirror with my six year old pixie cut and asking my mother if I was "cute". Someone had mentioned that I was a "cute little girl" while my mother and I were traipsing through the Sears and Roebuck.
My mother snatched me away from the mirror and told me that it was vain to look at yourself in the mirror, and I certainly was not cute but just like everyone else. She didn't say ugly, of course, but cute was out.
Recently, when I turned 50, she told me that she felt it was her responsibility to keep me from becoming conceited. She saw the way people looked at me and was afraid for how I would turn out. Thanks, Mom -- how do you think THAT worked out?
Yes, she did a great job. By the time I was a teenager, I had little self-confidence and it carried through my adult life. I wore no makeup until I was 30, and only after age 45 did I start to wear foundation. I never wanted to be beautiful, certainly never ever "cute" went the childhood record.
Now, I am an obese 51 year old and think back to the days when I was thin and could have looked better than I did if I had chosen to do so. What did I miss in result? Not too much, I think. What do I miss now? The ability to move without grimacing.
I do like being a "D" cup and having men look at my breasts 'cause I was pretty flat growing up. There is always something we can do for ourselves but that inner beauty needs to be nourished over a lifetime, I think. I do envy those with self-confidence...I really do.
i dont know how the french women do it.
I work at a company that employs many French women and men and has an office in Paris. Here's what I've noticed about my French colleagues: they are confident and they are restrained in every way except speech.
The two things bear some relation to one another. Because they are confident they wear less makeup, fewer pieces of jewellery, their clothes are neither loud nor busy, and they are restrained in their physical movements - hand gestures aside. In meetings, they sit still, not fidgeting, fussing with their phones, or endlessly playing with their hair. (I do all of these things and it makes me look considerably less elegant.) They are clear when they speak, less ambling.
They love food and talk about it a LOT, but when we have lunch together they always leave food on their plate - men and women. They eat more slowly that I do.
Now I know these are all enormous generalisations but they're based on my day-to-day experience. Beauty can come from confidence. Beauty can appear very simple, minimal, easy, carefree, a non-event really. It's very relaxing to be in the company of someone who isn't fussing over their beauty.
I think a lot of this comes from growing up in a place that likes women - not every country does - and believing you are as attractive, deserving and smart as anyone else around you. Random thoughts on my colleagues... Thank you for your post.
Harvey, amen. And really who else's love do you really need.
Sirenita, you give me a great idea. Yes. Paris for my 50th. I love it.
Melissa, you don't need mascara. I love you just the way you are. :)
Larry, if the real French in the crowd ever looked at how we've butchered their language here, we'd start another war. Don't worry, that phrase has been used by many, and for some, it actually works. (by the way, there is another pirate wimmen insurrection in the works. I'll send you a new apron before it happens. )
Yup. I shop with my wife all the time, and it totally floors me how you get ripped off on clothing and all the accessories. It is abominable. Once, she picked out a sweater she liked and showed me the price tag: it was something like $75. I went to the men's department, found THE EXACT SAME SWEATER, priced $35. The only difference? Clothing for women is cut a little different to accommodate ...uh... that which needs accommodating.
I have always said, you have to be happy with yourself FIRST.
BTW, if memory serves me correctly, Italian women have the same attitude. But why quibble? It's a good day to be a french woman.
Well, if you don't mind, I think I'll just be an American mongrel male today as usual. ;-D
Smithie, you are as perfect now as you were in college. French women are not taught to question it, and they are subjected to the same images as we are – perhaps more. But French men also learn how to appreciate women of all ages. They don’t seem so interested in cookie-cutter versions of women. There is much work to be done. Start today by channeling your inner college self.
Steven, thank you, and thank you for the quote. I use it often.
Kirsten, “I think a lot of this comes from growing up in a place that likes women - not every country does - and believing you are as attractive, deserving and smart as anyone else around you.” Exactly!!! Thanks for adding your observations to this post. That is a post in itself, and I hope you’ll consider writing more about your experience some day.
Peacemonger, it was a coin toss between Joe Cocker and “I love you just the way you are.” I love Joe, so he won. I can look past Joe’s lurching and see the beauty within. What would you have chosen?
Kolika, Vive le France indeed. Vive la revolution! Vive us!
Mark, thanks for kicking this off. Now perhaps you have better insight into why women deflect compliments in this society. Merci.
Lisa, I agree completely. Hitting 40 was a gift in that respect. I never want to be THAT 20 year old again. But I wonder what it would have been like to be 20 and have the confidence of a French woman.
April, I do without the cigarettes also. That continues to confound me. Wear that scarf with pride. Merci.
:-)
mypsyche, I am only a year or so behind you. Maybe we can go together. I think Catherine just turned 60 and she has not changed a bit. Love her.
Terry, let that French woman out of the closet. Now is the time. Let your scarfs fly free.
717judi, I say that counts. Wearing beautiful undergarments that no one will see definitely channels your inner French woman. Carry on soldier.