jlsathre

jlsathre
Location
Illinois,
Birthday
July 30
Bio
I'm a lawyer in my past life, who got the kids through college and decided to try something different and a little more fun. A used book store sounded like a good idea, so that's where I am for now. I just hadn't counted on a recession or E-readers and am a little afraid there's going to be a third act. In the meantime, I have plenty to read and a little time to write. Not a bad way to spend a day.

MY RECENT POSTS

Jlsathre's Links

Salon.com
JANUARY 4, 2012 9:38AM

The Occupiers and the Candy Bowl

Rate: 9 Flag

I couldn't go into Debby's house without drooling over the candy bowl.  Through the back door, one step into the kidtchen, a hard left, and I was there.  It was the first thing I saw in the pantry--almost the first thing I saw in the house. A big wooden bowl, perhaps intended for a salad, but filled instead with full size Hershey bars, M & M's, Zagnuts, Charleston Chews.  It was  a Halloween bag dumped out in July.  Except that this one was filled from visits to only the richest of houses, with no apples or snack size candies. And this one was there every day of the year.  

To my never ending chagrin, Debby hardly even noticed it.  It was only on rare ocassions that she would stop to grab a Hersheys and thereby give me implicit permission to grab one too. 

Debby was rich.  Or at least she seemed so in the eyes of a ten year old who wore hand me down clothes, waited for Christmas to get her Sears bike, and lived in a wood frame house that needed paint and had only one bathroom and no shower.  Debby got a new Schwinn in May for no reason, had a stack of comic books that she hardly ever read but that grew taller every time I visited, and  lived in a big house, with five bedrooms, two and a half baths, a sunroom, a piano room, two staircases, and a wooden bowl with an unending supply of full size candy bars.  

In my insular world of a small southern Illinois town of 3,000, she was my one percent.  I wanted those candy bars.  My bar was set low.  

Fifty years later I watch the Occupy movement and ponder the unequal division of wealth and power between the one percent and the other 99 percent of us, and I hope that the attention they bring to issues of inequality and unfairness makes a difference. 

But I  can't help thinking that the 99 percent that they represent might not all be on the same page and that there's  a deeper divide and a broader problem than the chasm between the 1 percent and the 99 percent. 

We're a society of consumers.  We want what we don't have, with little regard to what we need.  As years pass, we want more and we want it bigger, better, and right now.  And all too often in our desire to get what we want, we convince ourselves that it's what we need.    

When I go back to my hometown, I still marvel at the stately beauty of Debby's old house.  But it no longer stands out like it once did.  Bigger and more ornate houses have popped up everywhere around the perimeter of this rural town that is inhabited solely by 99 percenters.  There are swimming pools in backyards and new cars that rotate in and out of driveways on a yearly basis.

I watch the "House Hunters" show on TV and hear young couples buying starter homes describe how they need four-plus bedrooms, granite countertops, hardwood floors (dark wood, not light), three-car garages, walk in closets, double sinks, and, oh yes, it has to have stainless steel appliances. 

I see these houses and I  can't help wondering if the problem is not just with the one percent, but with those of us who think we need it all.   With me, who thinks I need new shoes even though I have a closet full of them, who walked past too many Salvation Army bell ringers at Christmas, only to go inside to buy a People magazine.  Who supports the Occupy movement,  but doesn't do all I could to help those who may see me as their one percenter. Who walks past that candy bowl without even slowing down to let the person behind me have one.

I support the Occupy movement and am hopeful that it brings about change--that we see a more equitable division of wealth and power, with health care for all, living wages for hard work, across the board access to a good education, and a greater say in governance.  But I can't help worrying that what too many of the 99 percent really want is an even bigger house with stainless steel appliances. 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
It must be horrible to be so greedy and demanding. I am perfectly content in my hundred year old bungalow filled with antiques that I found for next to nothing at garage and estate sales.
The occupy movement is nothing more than a huge hypocrisy; it’s too bad you’re just starting to figure it out. I mean, in the same vein that occupiers want stainless steel appliances and new shoes, despite a closet full of shoes, the 1% wants those things too. The irony is that in the name of “fairness” the occupiers think it’s OK to take from the 1% in order to provide for the 99%. That’s not fair, that’s socialism. Sure there is inequality in the system but I know of no socialist economic system that succeeded. In fact, moving up the economic ladder is what made America the land of opportunity.
Hmmm, you do make a great point and I agree.

" As years pass, we want more and we want it bigger, better, and right now. And all too often in our desire to get what we want, we convince ourselves that it's what we need."

I'm glad to be able to say that as the years pass I see less and less stuff that I "need." Sure, I may have been nudged, even forced in this direction by the failing greed economy, but it's been a good life lesson in.. well, humility. Foreclosed and forced to down-size, I left much behind, and in doing so became more appreciative of life in general. My needs are simple... hot and cold running water, enough food to eat, simple transportation, a roof that doesn't leak.. too much, and some treasured friendly human (and animal-- my little doggie partner in poverty who loves me) companionship. Even being "poor" I realize now how lucky I am to still have what I need.
Really provocative piece
I think there's a lot of accusations of *entitlement* and all that jazz, sort of like Cain saying if people don't have jobs it's their own fault, and (I think it was Gingrich) saying to Occupiers to take a bath and get a job. It's easier to make accusations like that than to look at what's happening...and to consider that it could happen to oneself.

There was just a Good News item on CNN, about how Dunkin' Donuts was planning to double their numbers over the next however-many years, and the talking head said that was wonderful - all those new jobs (all those slave-wage jobs).

I don't get the impression from people here on OS (not a representative sample?) that they're whining about not having granite countertops.

Hi Miguela - My house is nearly twice as old as yours, but the contents, obtained from the street curbs and dumps and garage sales, don't qualify as antiques. I like it tho.
Thanks for reading and commenting.
Miguela--I agree. Maybe we've crossed paths at garage sales because I'm at them all the time.
Johnny--You've got me pegged wrong. I support the occupiers and believe they're there for the right reasons and a good cause. I just think there are also people in the 99% that are so caught up in obtaining more and more that they lose sight of people that don't have the same advantages or opportunities.
Trig--Thanks. I'm sorry you were forced to downsize. I've downsized too, although fortunately by choice, and have found I don't need things that I thought I did. It's kind of freeing
Jane--Usually I borrow my sister's magazines, but occasionally I splurge.
Myriad--I agree. This is a good bunch here. But I think as a country there's a lot of greed, self absorption, and too much emphasis on consuming that prevents us from helping the people that aren't as fortunate. And I don't think that's limited just to the 1%.
You have nailed, and well, the problems that exist within the 99 percent. Problems that many continue to refuse to acknowledge, despite the economic bloodletting the world has suffered for more than three years now. Great piece.

And thanks for saying my snow story had some magic. It did, I guess. I was lucky.
You put this so perfectly. Thank you.