jlsathre

jlsathre
Location
Illinois,
Birthday
July 30
Bio
I'm a lawyer in my past life, who got the kids through college and decided to try something different and a little more fun. A used book store sounded like a good idea, so that's where I am for now. I just hadn't counted on a recession or E-readers and am a little afraid there's going to be a third act. In the meantime, I have plenty to read and a little time to write. Not a bad way to spend a day.

MY RECENT POSTS

Jlsathre's Links

Salon.com
JULY 18, 2012 10:16AM

I Wish I Hadn't Said That

Rate: 28 Flag

I'll make a quick comment on Facebook, or OS, or to a group and then, just as quickly, realize that I want to take it back. That it doesn't read like it was intended. That it sounds dismissive instead of funny. That it sounds smug instead of caring. I want to erase or edit or have a few minutes in a time machine that lets me go back and say something different. 

In most cases, no one's paying all that much attention and it doesn't matter. But occassionally the words come back to haunt me.

Years ago, in my 30's at a girls night out, someone started a conversation about the traumas we had dealt with in our lives. One woman was thinking about a divorce at the time, one had just come out to her parents, one had flunked out of college, another no longer spoke to any of her siblings. I was quiet.

I didn't make the cheerleading squad one year in high school, and I had to take a summer school class before I could graduate from college and start law school because I had kept dropping French thinking they'd get rid of the language requirement. But, basically, my life had been a pretty even keel. When all eyes turned to me, I shrugged, felt a little guilty, and said something glib like,

"Smooth sailing here." 

I really wish I hadn't said that because within a span of a few years, our dog ran away after I forgot to let him back in, I got cancer (okay, it was very treatable, but still), I had some outbreaks of late onset acne, I got divorced, and I found myself basically raising two daughters by myself (and, yes, they were good kids, but I still had to feed them every day, monitor homework and listen to them whine when I turned off TV). It was as if the universe was evening things out, wiping away any remnants of smugness from my life.

I was knocked down and yelling, "Enough, already! I take it all back! That cheerleading loss really was pretty truamatic."

Jump forward a few years and I was practicing law for a personal injury firm where we were quick to sue just about anyone for causing just about any injury. The bigger the verdict the better. High fives all around for spreading the wealth to the underdog.

Until I read about the multi-million dollar verdict a woman got for spilling her own cup of McDonald's coffee in her lap. It could have been because we hadn't thought of it, but I found the suit fairly outrageous.

"How can anyone think they deserve a couple million dollars for doing something stupid like spilling their own coffee?" I said, with little or no empathy.

And then there I was, just last month, at the Circle K gas station getting my daily newspapers, my morning cup of coffee and my bag of Cheddar and Sour Cream Chips for lunch. I handed the clerk a twenty, reached across the counter to get my change and knocked my full cup of coffee over, causing  the lid off to pop off, and sending all twenty ounces of the scalding, freshly brewed coffee directly onto my mid-section where it was absorbed by my cotton dress, which stuck to my stomach, and burned like hell.

I was pulling at my dress, hopping up and down, trying to get the coffee and the dress away from my stomach, all the while apologizing for the mess I'd made and trying to look like it was no big deal and that it didn't hurt like hell, even though it did. The clerk was a little miffed at having to clean it up and I was trying hard not to cry.

With the dress pulled away from my stomach and still no relief, I realized that the coffee had also absorbed into my underpants, which were holding tight to my mid-section. I found myself wanting to rip those panties right off in the middle of the Circle K. But I couldn't remember what ones I was wearing. All of my mom's warnings about wearing nice underwear reflected in the eyes of the Ruffles delivery man watching my dilemma.

So, instead, I hopped to my car, calling back apologies and thanking Honda for tinted windows. Air conditioner vents directed at my mid-section provided some relief and I eventually headed to the store. 

When I got there, I took a good look at my stomach and saw that there was a big red mark that still hurt a little, although not quite as much as knowing that I'd be spending the day without coffee, lunch or newspapers.

By that evening the red mark had turned into blisters and, as I'm prone to do, I got on the internet to see if I needed medical care.

It was pretty clear that I had a second degree burn, but not quite as clear whether I needed medical attention. If I was an infant, the answer was yes. Also yes if the burn was on my face or some other obvious place. Or if it was an electrical burn. But little was said about an adult burn on the panty line. I decided I could bypass the doctor if I kept an eye on the burn, wore loose dresses and big underwear, and watched for things like seepage.

A few days later the blisters looked like they were going away and the line where they had erupted started turning dark brown. A month post-burn, that brown line seems intent on staying as a reminder that coffee is hot.

I'm left with what appears to be a scar and a wish that I had never said anything about people suing for spilling their coffee.

I really could have used a couple million. 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Please wish me a good day. Seems someone is listening to you. Really liked this essay/story. I've got a few words and sentences I wish had stayed silent too.
Ah yes...I wake up now wondering about the large family, most of whom no longer speak to me. How'd that happen? As they say down at the barn yard, shit happens. It's not your fault because you made a mental note. Well, okay, watch the coffee cup next time. Great post.
I found myself getting excited at the panty ripping part of your dilemma.....oops, I wish I hadn't said that. R
As outrageous as it sounded at first, it turned out that the lawyer who brought the case had done a fair amount of research about the temperature of the coffee at McDonalds (it is hotter than at other restaurants, but some people like it that way), there had been prior injuries and complaints, etc. The woman may have been partially at fault, I don't recall whether it happened in a comparative negligence state.

But as for saying things you wish you could take back--that one's rather tame. How about "Hey Ronnie--nobody likes you anymore. Your jokes aren't funny."
Ahh the moral travails of the law! Never sued anybody for anything, never will. On the other hand, every lawyer in the country should be in court challenging the voter ID legislation, that is a true travesty of justice.
I have ADD, and almost every thing I say I start regretting even before I've finished saying it. I did learn long ago about the power of jinx. I try not to be superstitious, but if those coincidences had happened to me I think I'd make an exception. Painfully funny story, JL.
gerald stole my line, that old rake!
ah he delivered it better than i could.
for god's sake, woman! watch what u say. seems you have
been selected by karma to be an object lesson
of a weirdly literal type...
usually karma is a bit more poetic,
and with you being such a fine writer, perhaps it is appropriate
she is so clumsily prosaic with you?
Ow. That sounds awful. Great post. I wish I could sue a bunch of people I can think of right now. That would be awesome.
I think we all have those moments, jl, and if the universe is evening out things, I doubt any of it's personal to our own foibles...or at least I certainly hope not : )
I hope all is back to smooth sailing in your life (technology vs books aside), those rough patches show up without warning sometimes...

By the way, my former next-door neighbor, Susan Saladoff, was the lawyer who went on sabbatical for a year and made the documentary "Hot Coffee," and why that whole debacle matters -- which I still haven't seen -- but she could explain 'mud' and make it clear.
Ande--I don't think you want my wished. Whoever is listening seems to ignore the nice things I say.

Rob--I am now very careful with my coffee.

Gerald--Ha. You're much funnier than I am.

Con--The suit actually did have some merit, and it was a comparative negligence state. If I remember right, she was found 20% at fault and the case was eventually settled for an undisclosed amount of less than a million--I think around $500,000.

And yeah, the Ronnie comment was a little less than prophetic.

jmac--I'm with you on that one, and I've never sued anyone on behalf of myself either.

Matt--My youngest daughter has ADD, so I'll give you a pass if you ever say anything objectionable.
Oooh that is obnoxious: "Smooth sailing here."
But, you saw the humor in the lesson you'd then learn.
Life does seem to punish the glib or the cocky. I know firsthand! OUCH.

Really enjoyed this. I enjoy your writing style a lot-- very relateable and authentic.
James--Gerald's pretty quick on the draw, but you're the one that has Rena, so it evens out.

Toxic--I'm pretty sure there's a lawyer around who'll sue them for you.

Just Thinking--All in all, I think life's treated me pretty well. We all need to be brought down sometimes.

fernsy--Hopefully I've matured a little over the years--in ways other than wrinkly skin.

Jonathan--True enough.
I'm always sticking my foot in my mouth. Great story./r
Oh no - that really, really sucks. The only good thing, I guess, is that you didn't get worse burns. But I feel so bad for you about the whole thing.
yes, true, i have Rena. She is nothing less than the perfect woman
(for me, at least). I adore her. Her handicap of 'unreality' does
not bother me in the least.
You are not alone. Been there, done that, too! We're only human, though. Ugh. When I think of all the things I've said and wish I could take back. When we say things, it's almost like we're putting things out into the universe and "tempting fate." There's a reason these clichés are used over and over again across generations. They contain a lot of wisdom built up over the centuries. ... R.
"Of course that dress makes your hips look ... oh, crap."
Wish I'd said "No" a few times with a few people.
Christine--It's easy to do. And online, even easier.

Alyssa--I'm well past wearing bikinis on the beach, so no real lasting harm.

James--We're all a little unreal.

Deborah--Oh, yeah, that heavy hand of fate...

Stim--Nooooooooo!

Lea--I regret not saying "yes" a few times too.
That's gotta hurt. I remember reading that too with McDonalds, and being enraged and I still think it was wrong. The price of coffee went up. A latter would cost half of what it does if people didn't stand on the very top rung, or place the latter on ground that is wet. Buckets have to have a baby picture on them with a circle and a red line through them. To remind parents not to put 5 gal. buckets of water in the playpen I guess. I have never believed in tort reform, but sometimes people are just idiots. (not you, that was an accident that we all do)
I loved this...

Rated with ♥
Am I allowed to laugh? 'Cuz this is really funny in a terrible kind of way. I know what you mean about opening one's pie hole one too many times. It happens to me all the time. :D

Lezlie
I can totally connect with you, cause I do not have English as my first language, and sometimes, while trying to be fully I sound silly, or when I am really concerned, I do not have the right words to say. To give you an example, you in USA, use the word 'empathy' in a totall different way, than we in Greece. You use it meaning sympathy and understanding, while in us, means feeling hatred and being over all prejudiced about one individual. I am in use of a dictionary, but it is true there are comments that where mistaken in the use of language, and I can not correct them. So, please, if ever mistaken, do correct me, cause I can totally understand and sympathize with your essay. Thank you for analyzing this issue.
Let alone typos mistakes, just the one I have just made, while trying to say '' funny'' , and instead I wrote " fully ''.

Sorry for the burn, and the whole situation, you had to deal with. Excellent writing as always.
I remember my initial similar response to the case then I followed it. It was an elderly woman who was with her daughter and she was in the drive through if I remember correctly, as I recall her genitals were severely burned as she had placed the cup between her legs. I think the reason the jury awarded so much was because so many other people had been injured because at the time they served their coffee hotter than what is standard. Something to do with it covering up the poor flavor of cheap coffee seved back then. We're careful with pots of boiling water but most don't expect coffee to be scalding. We expect it to be as hot as what a restaurant or coffee shop would serve.

I had a friend who as a small child pulled the cord on a coffee urn at a church potluck and the urn crahsed on it's side spilling coffee all down on her. She has horrific scars on one arm, her chest and one breast but has grown used to them and wears things any other woman would. In any case McDonalds wasn't harmed at all. It would have been a PR nightmare if an adorable child's face had been been plastered all over the news covered in horrific blisters and needing painful treatment and skin grafts. There isn't much public concern for not so adorable elderly women so I think the worst that happened was they lost a few bucks and reduced the temperature of their coffee to what a patron might normally expect from other places.

Sorry to hear you got burned and am really glad you didn't require treatment, burns are nasty and painful. I too have found myself having more empathy for others after life surprises me. It would be nice if there was a way to avoid them or at least get some payoff but for the most part we just get through and hope it doesn't happen to us again.
scanner--I was kind of an idiot. But I didn't sue, so I've got that going for me.

Barbara--Thanks so much.

Lezlie--Laughing definitely allowed.

Olga--I can't even imagine the mistakes I'd make if I was speaking or writing in a second language. You're to be admired.
l'heure--I don't in any way mean to minimize the horror of burns or the suffering that the McDonald's woman underwent. When all the facts came out, it was clear that she did have severe burns needing extensive medical treatment, that there was probably some fault on McDonald's part, and that the final settlement was much less than several million. Even the initial two million plus verdict only equaled one day of McDonald's coffee proceeds.
Jl - I think there's always a "do over" moment or two in our lives. I don't think there's a Sky Policeman waiting to pull us over (figuratively) when things seem to be going on an even keel, but who am I to question (hear tht, Universe?)?
First, oh you poor thing. It really does sound like a horrible burn.

Second--gol-durned funny stuff (I've given up alcohol and swearing for a while)!

Third--your post has given me a great idea for a new one of my own.

RRRRRRR
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebeck_v._McDonald's_Restaurants

Gotta say, if you come in contact with scalding liquid, then take immediate action. Forget the embarassment.

McDonalds used to serve the hottest coffee I ever encountered, and I could never drink it without it cooling down some.
Just whenever I think someone has a perfect life, something happens, like needing open heart surgery or a death. I never assume.
We've all been there and some of us have similar coffee scars to prove it!
We've all said things that we immediately wish we could take back, or come back to haunt us at a later time. One of the great things about online communication is that you can think before hitting "send," though many people apparently choose that option. Facebook allows you to delete comments - in fact, I deleted one of my own today because it seemed a little harsh.

BTW, I read something the other day that defended the McDonald's coffee woman. Apparently, McD's coffee was 40-50 degrees hotter than the coffee you serve yourself at home, and they'd had many complaints about it over the years.
Actually, I'm reminded of something I did here on OS. I went to a just-posted piece by someone and immediately posted a mockingly celebratory comment about being the first commenter. Then I read the post. Which was about a friend's tragic death.
I meant "many people DON'T choose that option."
cc--I just hope there's not a limit on the do-overs.

V--I look forward to reading your post.

Nick--I think I might handle it better next time.

jackie--I heard a quote once that stuck with me that basically said, "Never assume someone had a charmed life until you know the circumstances of their death."

Bell--I'm not totally surprised to hear I'm not the only one with scars.

Cranky--There was some legitimacy to the McDonald's lawsuit. You didn't hear that from the media at the time though.
Ow ow ow ow OW! I am so sorry and yes I find in life as soon as you say words that you instantly regret fate laughs and bites you in the butt! I knock wood but somehow she always hears me....
I felt bad reading this post but I know those things happen. I've had strings of bad things happen to me and to other people who read or hear of them they would seem terrible, even tragic. But when they happen to us it's just our life. Coincidentally, I dropped a kettle of boiling water on my foot once and it steam-burned me because of my cotton sock. No joke. So I hope you're feeling better--still, I don't believe we curse ourselves with what we say ...
I am not an expert on the subject but from I gathered, the huge amount in the McDonald's case was more due to the fact that McDonald's knew their cups were flimsy (as the flimsy cups were cheaper) and their coffee scalding, but didn't change because they figured they could just parcel out small amounts of money to people who got burnt, which was cheaper than buying better cups. So the large settlement was more to pressure McDonald's into changing their policy. (Although lucky for the woman with the lawsuit).

I also have a foot-in-mouth syndrome. It can get be quite embarrassing; a lot of times I just need to remind myself to think first and speak later.