BlogShots

Jonathan Wolfman's Blog

Jonathan Wolfman

Jonathan Wolfman
Location
Maryland, Northwest of The District,
Birthday
January 26
Bio
Visit, too, please: www.talkingwriting.com www.doesthismakesense.com www.reortergary.com (pal talk news network)

OCTOBER 29, 2010 7:43AM

In Honor of The Series: Why The Bums Really Left Brooklyn

Rate: 26 Flag

    

 

     There were New Yorkers in my parents' day, who, if asked Who Are The Three Most Evil Men of the Twentieth Century? they would fast say:

Adolph Hitler

Josef Stalin

Walter O'Malley.

And it was somewhat more than a darkly comic joke.

     Among my favorite books, and I'm recommending it here as we're approaching the end of another season, is one that lays blame for The Bums' move from Brooklyn not at the feet and stone-cold heart of the Dodgers' owner. Michael Shapiro's social history, The Last Good Season, tells the  day-by-day on-field tale of the Dodgers' last Miracle Summer in Brooklyn and the intrigue behind Mr. O'Malley's devastating, gut-wrenching decision to move the team west.

     The Giants, now in the Series of course, made a similar trip a year after Pee Wee, Don, Roy, Sandy, and the rest.   Shapiro recounts this last, glorious Brooklyn campaign from the perspectives of all the old Dodger Greats, from Robinson, to Campanella, to Koufax, Snyder, and Newcombe...all of them.

     At the same time, Shapiro lays bare in poignant detail the back-office and governmental machinations that, at one point, considered a re-do of Ebbets Field as well as the then wholly radical idea of new-stadium funding as a combined public-private venture. Could the Brooklyn shrine have been saved, could baseball in Brooklyn have been saved, had New York's movers understood where the future was headed? Los Angeles clearly 'got it', so it wasn't an idea doomed to die at jump simply because too new. The real 'bad guys' in this saga may not be whom you imagine them to be.

     This is one fast-paced, electrifying read for anyone who loves The Game as well as those interested in the origins of modern America's urban politics.                                                        

   

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
You don't have to love baseball to love this book...it's as great a social history of urbam America at mid-century as exists. A great book abt the intersetion of sports, economics, politics...Enjoy!
I will need to read this book - there was another book that I read recently (forgot the name unfortunately) that also detailed the reasons for the departure - it went into great detail about a plan to move the stadium to an abandoned railyard and how the plan was eventually scrapped due to politics.

From what I have read, it was a true shame, because the Dodgers' departure tore the "heart and soul" out of Brooklyn - but, other accounts do detail how attendance had lagged in the year or two prior to the move to L.A. so (blasphemy, I know) perhaps the Borough residents may also have themselves to blame, at least partially.
I am sure there so many parallels to today's sports environment! Thanks for bringing this to our attention! R
sounds like very good read, will check it out........why you calling my Yankees "bums" smack! :)
wait...lol....i read comment wrong....you called the dodgers bums, not my yankees..sorry...i guess i am so use to you dawging the yankees....:)
I'm surprised Leo Durcoher isn't listed here as he went crosstown to managed the Giants.
Andy many would say the attendance issues had a lot to do w Ebbets Field's decrepit existence. Sad, sad story!
OE he's in the book, too.
Glenna Brooklyn had affectionately called their Dodgers The Bums forevah!
Lib you're gonna love this one!
This is a field of total ignorance for me, Jon, but one day, maybe if I have the time and interest. . . I'll try to acquire tid bits of knowledge from your post in the meanwhile. Thank you so much. ~R
I can't wait to read it. Even after all these years, you can still hear some men, and a few women, talk trash about the move. Great Post Jon!
FusunA this book's so well-written I bet you'd love it!
It was one of my first "it's all over now, baby blue" moments.
I have never been a baseball fan.. I am a hockey girl.
I am NOW a baseball fan.
Go Giants!
Rated with hugs
Matt you will adore this book!
I look forward to reading this. I love baseball! Thanks.
Roger pls tell me what you think of Shapiro's take on this when you've read it!
Great recommendation, Jonathan! So excited about this series, of course, with our Giants on a roll! Hope it lasts!

GO GIANTS!!!!
I 'm not much of a baseball fan so probably won't be reading this book. Interesting post though. -R-
Cathy while they beat my Phils, Giants deserved this. And i am not sure Texas is part of the United States.
Looks interesting. rated
I don't follow baseball, although I enjoy the game . . . this looks like a book I'd like . . .
Caroline I hope you try it!
Well, always good to learn of a new book. I am not a very good baseball fan. R
Ahh, Willie, Mickey and the Duke.
As the song goes, "Those were the days, my friend~~".
I went to my first White Sox game in the 1940s.
The then Wa Senators had lost over 10 games in a row.
My father took me to Comiskey for a Sunday double header(Remember those?) and, the Senators won both games.lol
Can you imagine what it would be like to go to where Ebbets was today?
Bring yer gun.

I'll read the book, Wolfie.
XJS enjoy tho as to neighborhood you're assuming that thnere wouldn't have been any neighborhood improvement over the years w a continually retrofitted/renewing ballpark...I assume otherwise!
I remember watching an HBO special about it. O'Malley originally wanted to stay in Brooklyn, but Ebbets Field was inadequate for the increasing number of fans who were now coming to the game by car. (In fact, he offered to build a new stadium in Brooklyn where the NJ Nets are going to build their new arena, with access to mass transportation.) The roadblock was the autocratic Robert Moses, who wanted them to build where the Mets current stadium lies. But that was Queens, not Brooklyn, and O'Malley didn't want to go there. So while O'Malley has been the villain these last 50+ years, much of the blame has to go to the NYC government, especially Moses.
Crank AND... Robert Moses also thought the idea of public/private joint financing was a heretical idea.
Thanks for this--I am getting this one! I almost had to go to a Dodgers game in L.A. alone because my partner is from Brooklyn. Even though she was born after the Dodgers left, there is no forgiveness.
Sophie you both will love it!
For me, the Dodgers have always been in Los Angeles, having grown up in Los Angeles in the 1960s and 1970s. While I knew they used to be from Brooklyn, the reality of the situation never allowed me to think of them from anywhere but my home town. I'm not even much of a sports fan these days, but I do remember rooting for Steve Garvey and Ron Cey back in those days. My best friend at the time's mom used to date about half of the team, too.
Kate ya hadda be there hehehe and I'll lool up that piece!
I will look for this one Jon
TankEngine I know for sure you're gonna dig this one!!
interesting, Jonathan! Thank you and I will add this book to my list!
Catherine having read your sports entries I believe you'll so dig this one!
@ Cranky and Jon -- Moses couldn't wait to built public housing on both Ebbets Field and Polo Grounds sites. Read the Power Broker.
OE yes tho the explanations for his behavior are many and what you say, and what Crank and I say, are not mutually exclusive, TY!
Excellent blog, Jon!
Also, people might want to check out "The Boys of Summer" by Roger Kahn. This is an excellent account of the team too.

Buddy
Sounds like a good one, Jon. I'll keep an eye out for it.

R.
Henry it's just so good!
Veronica yep and you'll just love it!
I was too young to know anything about baseball when the Dodgers left, though I lived in Queens then. The only comparable sports story I know is what it was like when the Colts left Baltimore - I lived in Maryland then. One morning the city woke up, a city that was integrated with and possessive of its football team to an extent that might be rivaled by Green Bay, and the team was.....gone. The Baltimore Colts marching band existed for years after the Colts left - they may still. I can remember hearing stories on airplanes from people visiting Baltimore from Indianapolis (on business or whatever) who, when asked in a restaurant where they were from and answering "Indianapolis," the restaurant got quiet.
Kosh I realise the ravens have won an SB but I wonder if B-more embraces them as they had the Colts.
Loved this book, though my heart stays in Philly. Great description of a wrenching time for so many in so many different ways.
Comments are now closed.