BlogShots

Jonathan Wolfman's Blog

Jonathan Wolfman

Jonathan Wolfman
Location
Maryland, Northwest of The District,
Birthday
January 26
Bio
Visit, too, please: www.talkingwriting.com www.doesthismakesense.com www.reortergary.com (pal talk news network)

DECEMBER 18, 2011 9:19AM

A Delicious Contradiction at the Core of 'The Wizard of Oz'

Rate: 33 Flag

  

    

     I saw it for perhaps the hundredth time last night.

      I love the 1939 masterwork and nearly everything about it, from Ms. Garland's extraordinarily nuanced acting and voice with a range that had to be gifted her from Beyond, to the marvelous green-faced machinations of Ms. Hamilton's deliciously wretched Wicked Witch, to the sepia-toned B&W shooting of the Kansas countryside, to Mr. Lahr's so very, very over-the-top red-bow-maned, if not outright and proudly gay-iconic Brooklynesed Lion, to the torrent of political satire wrapped in the pompous, deleriously self-involved Wizard.

     The film defines the Latin sui generis. It is wholly Of Itself. Nothing about Ms. Garland's character or performance, nor of all the others', had theatrical antecedents, nor have they been remotely mimed thereafter.

     God Bless You, Ms. Garland, the writers, the composers, the lyricists, the directors, Munchkins, painters, stage-artists...for your genius

and your overarching message of  thoroughgoing acceptance of people for just who they are.

For that---and NOT the tired, sappy 1939 politically-correct pablum 'There's No Place Like Home'--is the

                                          real

                                                             and

                                                                           obvious

lasting message of Dorothy's Ever-Reigning Rainbow.

     And Yet.

     And yet I have to say I am wholly with the director John Waters ("Hairspray", etc.) who recalls seeing the film as a child in the Black-and-White '50s, wondering:

          Why In Hades Would Anyone Sane Want To Return To THAT Drab Kansas?

...to the colorlessness, to Aunt Em's plain smock dress, to the carnival barker's broken down covered-wagon...when she could have been 

crowned Queen of Oz?               

     Nonetheless, and to all who worked that magic and for All-Time: 

                       Bless You. Thank You.

          I choose, and you should, too, choose, to remain in Oz.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I am so thankful for Mr. Baum, Mr. Arlen, all of them.
Holly :) I'll take Oz over Kansas any day.
What a wonderful and delightful post, Jon. I loved the movie, too, even though those flying monkeys terrified me as a child and would be a major deterrent to my return to Oz. Not so our gentle heroine. In the book series by L. Frank Baum, Dorothy has many further adventures in Oz. She commutes between Kansas and Oz fairly often.
Miguela I am delighted to know it! :)
I'll take Kansas any day over a land filled with flying monkeys, talking trees, and coma-inducing meadows. I lived in Kansas ten years and it's not nearly boring as it looks. Started my career as an educator there and wrote and saw my first plays there where anyonebcan put on a show. The first play I wrote was based on Aesops' fable of "The Tortoise and the Hare," a musical with talking trees. But that's fantasy! Real-life is much more fun thann any fantasy. Besides, everyoune in Kansas knows where the tornadoes take you. It's not over the rainbow. It's to Oklahoma! Love your movie critique, however, I just watch long enough to hear Judy Garland sing "Over the Rainbow" and I'm out of there! Margaret Hamilton scaresbthe hell out of me! Rated
Diva I adore you anyway. :)
Too bad she couldn't bring Oz with her.
Matt as Bert Lahr's Lion says "Ain't it th truth!?"
Because Oz is phony and Kansas is real?
Jan oh no it's not. Oz is far realer.
I was afraid you'd think that.
Jan it's ok; I'll hold your hand in the theater when the Flying Monkeys fly. :)
I'd rather not get involved in conspiracy theories.
There is no BBQ in Oz.
Larry and I do love KC-BBQ.
I think I'd take Oz too. Kansas? No offense but I've been there and it ain't all that. The flower in that meadow of sleepy times are poppies, symbolic? There was not much in the way of diversity there in Oz either, the only person of color was green and apparently could not have bathed. One thing that bugs me (no pun intended) is the "little insect" that the Wicked Witch sent to "take the fight out of them. We know now it was "The Jitterbug" but hey the number was cut before release, was MGM to cheap to re shoot the scene or was that just a goof? Oh yeah, why in hell didn't Dorothy just keep flipping that hourglass before the time ran out? On second thought, it is a lot easier to get the hell out of Kansas.
Ever wonder why queer folks adore Ms. Judy and Wizard of Oz so much?

It's partly because she was one of the first openly "out" Allies, but mostly because WoO expressed that "you have it inside of yourself to be free and happy" regardless of whether mean old ladies in ugly hats (the church???), witches with flying attack monkeys (the bigots and the homophobes???) and the faithless man behind the curtain making believe he is "all powerful" (the government???) tried to do to keep you from reaching your goal.

BTW, that movie single handedly made the rainbow the gay icon of the "Friends of Dorthy".
bob perhaps she had faith the lion would save her someone hadda have faith in him :)
Amy yep yep and yep It is

precisely

why I referenced her Rainbow, above. :)
"Why In Hades Would Anyone Sane Want To Return To THAT Drab Kansas?"
You know the answer to this as clearly as I do. It's right in the plot of the movie and it's incredibly simple; a lesson that's as valid to all of us today as it was in 1939:
"There's no place like home. There's no place like home."
And from another source but equally definitive:
"Home is where the heart is."
Where was Dorothy's heart?
Walt I know where MINE wuda been. :)
I live in Oz Jon.. I am not going anywhere
HUGGGGGGGGGGG
Linda bless you, too. :)
Wasn't Oz kinda totalitarian, a big-brotherish, pretty frightening WofO fronting for an unseen presence running the show, and what with rumors of war, couldn't the desperate need to embrace the middle-America values of Kansas represent a kind of isolationist politics? Just speculating.
Jerry 1939 sure tho of couse Baum was 40 years earlier. :) :) Love this speculation! I really do: that's part of what great art does for us.
And yet... Mr Baum was himself a bigot who publicly advocated the complete extermination of Native Americans.
Mrs R Evil People can be, nonetheless complex. I am not even sure HE would recognize his characters in the hands of MGM's artists.
Its also a fun children's movie. I watched it every Thanksgiving. My grandma would sing "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" as a lullaby to me and my sister every night when we were babies and toddlers. As such, it has a special meaning for me.

Although controversial, one school says the book is a commentary on late 19th century politics, a critique of Capitalism, secretly supportive of Progressive Populism and that Baum hated John D. Rockefeller.
RW Baum also called for the destruction of Native Americans. Complex guy.
You know, I love this movie too. When I was a kid, I never thought of the portrayal of the Cowardly Lion as being gay. I didn't know what "gay" was. But now that I look at it from an adult perspective, he was being a "sissy", and little kids growing up in small town 1950's Illinois knew it was verboten to be sissy. Just as I never questioned why it was so funny to me when "Uncle Miltie", Milton Berle, when he dressed up as a woman in pearls and satin and lots of lipstick on his big mouth. There is so much cultural subtext and propaganda in our children's favorites. But I think I prefer to watch the Wizard of Oz from my innocent, naive, child's perspective. :-)
CC ah and I see it as abt Dorothy's (our potential) acceptance of everyone as they really are. It's a revolutionary idea, yes? :)
Well said. I think this is the same thing I have a problem with in "It's a Wonderful Life" - the idea of settling, no matter how P.C. it is.

But with "The Wizard of Oz," which is one of my favorite movies, the difference, I think, is in who Dorothy is - she's a simple farmgirl. I have a hard time imagining her falling in love with someone outside her species/culture, and I imagine that her life goal is probably to have a family some day. I don't say that in a derogatory or cliche way - it has nothing to do with where she's from, etc - I just really get that vibe from Dorothy. And so, I'm much more at ease with her going back to Kansas than with George Bailey reconciling himself with his current life, instead of trying to achieve his dreams while still being a loyal family man and friend.

Also, the book the movie is based on was merely an allegory for changing our currency standard; the character of Dorothy wasn't meant to be very profound. AND don't forget, there is a whole series of books about Oz (and a few movie sequels, I believe) where Dorothy does indeed go back to Oz!
Bert Lahr's performance of "If I were King of the Foresssssst" is one of the best scenes in movie history.
Jonathan, I consider this post a gift from you to oz of us. Love!
(When I was writing a novel, I chose as a setting for one of the early chapters the town in which Margaret Hamilton was born. A small secret in words and a way of making tribute to one of my favorite-ever characters in a movie. Ahhh, the power of words to bring things "home.")
An all-time favorite. And I think it's very easy to take BOTH messages from this movie. Hmmm....may have to watch it today. :)
An all-time favorite. And I think it's very easy to take BOTH messages from this movie. Hmmm....may have to watch it today. :)
While home is a great place to return to, I love the visits I have made to places that made me feel like I was in OZ
Wonderful post
rated with love
But Matt (and Jon) that IS what she does: brings Oz with her. That's the message to the myth. The magic is in her own backyard, no matter how drab appearing it may be. It's Oz Within.

(I thought you were going to bring up the fact that the Scarecrow carries a gun at one poitn in the movie, which I also found strange and certainly a contradiction.)

There's also a message re: reaching too high, going too far into the land of magic. You need a home base to return to, to ground yourself. Like the myth re: whatshisname getting too close to the sun.
The trouble with Oz is thinking you're going off on a short stroll, cutting through the beautiful meadow, then Wham. Passed out from poppies, only to awake to a glowing green city ruled by a disembodied head where you're told to take out the evil witch but her creepy flying monkeys might get you first!
Whew.
No wonder the poor girl couldn't wait to get back to Kansas.
: )
I always enjoy the melting of the witch. =o) The Flying Monkeys used to terrify me, though.

But yes, what IS so fantastic about Kansas????

rated
I never saw Kansas, but I always carry Oz in my heart.

Thank you for a magnificent piece, Jon.

R♥
Jonathan, I agree true love is to accept people as they truly are, and as God made them. God doesn't make mistakes. I wish people would see with eyes of love instead of fear. I guess that's what I was clumsily trying to say. Look with the unjudging eyes of a child. It's only when we "grow up" and look with the eyes of an adult that our ideals become tarnished and we see how they've become twisted by the expectations and lies of society.
JW- There is no place like home but there is no place like where you dream. Rated with a Jali Smile. :-)
NOTE:


Thanks so much to all, all of you who have commented thus far. I'm learning a lot from you. I had to be out for a while.
-JW
I liked your allusion to the Lion JW. Once I got old enough to clue in to these things, I wondered if that character had been written and/or directed as gay. As for why return to gray old Kansas, of course the message is that family trumps location. But at a certain age I can see why the appeals of the dark side of the moon would hold the winning hand.
Jon:

Do hope you have read or seen: Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West is a 1995 novel by Gregory Maguire, which provides a backstory regarding Elphaba, the Wicked Witch of the West, and how she came who she is.

The play was a huge hit.
Abra & Kate Thanks so much!
JW, I am very distantly related to L. Frank Baum. Weird. Anyway, I watched it again last night mostly because I was immobile after a day of shopping movies and parties. There is so much to discuss in this movie and there always has been. I am fascinated by how people interpret it. I have always used a personal analogy, there have been times in my life where I felt like I was moving from sepia into Technicolor. Not sure I would want to go back to sepia. Great piece JW!
How serendipitous: my mom and I watched it today at the nursing home. It is timeless. Yes, but, why would one want to return to Kansas? Peace, serenity, flat lands, and kind people are what come to mind.
Erica well not ALL of them kind. :)
Nice one Jon. But those flying monkeys are still scary!
TTE they so are not. ... ... ...
I thought I was living in Oz- it's Ohio in the 50's I miss.
...to never be ashamed from whence you hail...Kansas has it charms!
My all time favorite fairly tale, movie (all versions) and the wonderful "Wicked" Broadway hit and tale, from the "wicked witch's POV! Could write a post on this, but suffice it to say, you've done it proud!
uprated for outstanding film sense.

but i can well understand why dorothy would want to go back to kansas. even though she was an orphan, being raised by auntie Em, she was loved, and part of a loving family.

why would anyone want to remain in a land of evil flying monkeys, murderous witches, conniving carnival side show charlatans, etc.?

people we love - and our connection to them - are what make our lives special.