Joan's Blog

"Watch Me Pull A Rabbit Out Of My Hat"
Editor’s Pick
NOVEMBER 21, 2010 3:05PM

Norman and Martha Don't Live Here

Rate: 57 Flag

Every Thanksgiving I did my best to make the holiday as Norman Rockwell~ish as possible. There was always a turkey. There were pies.  There was a huge mess in the kitchen. 

Last year my daughter asked if we could have a Cajun-style turkey from Popeye's. Yes. That Popeye's.  Since it was her first visit home from school, we indulged her. It was actually pretty good.  I'm certain several relatives rolled over in their graves and I suspect some of my friends here are reading in stunned silence. That was the year Norman Rockwell left our home for good. 

 Thanksgiving became complicated after I married my husband as I was promptly disowned. I had no family on my side to bring to the table. My daughter would have to make do with one side of the family in her life.

 That is why the first Thanksgiving I was pregnant I insisted my husband's family get together for the holiday. I wore my red plaid maternity dress and orchestrated a Thanksgiving meal in my mother-in-law's kitchen. My baby was going to have a family, dammit. And I knew no one would argue with a half-crazed pregnant woman wearing a dress that matched the tablecloth. 

I made turkeys. I made some weird yogurt-Cool Whip pies. (More rolling over in graves, I know.) I did my best. We had a wonderful time. We had chosen the right side of the family to be a part of.

  We continued the annual Thanksgiving tradition until my mother-in-law died.  After her death we seemed to lose touch with one another.

Until this year. My sister-in-law is the one who called to resume our Thanksgiving tradition.  I am once again excited to assemble like a real family. I am excited to eat together, watch football,  (not so much), catch up with each other and eat some more.

My childhood Thanksgivings were filled with the most elegant food and served in the most elegant setting. Yet as delicious as the food was, it was served with a side of sadness so big, it made it hard to swallow.

I rarely equate Thanksgiving with perfect, elegant food anymore. (I think the writing was on the wall when I carried home Thanksgiving dinner with all the fixins from Popeye's  last year.) 

We will drive to Baltimore and have Thanksgiving with the only family my daughter has known.  It will look nothing like a Norman Rockwell painting or a page out of Martha Stewart Living.

It will be loud and informal. We will sit with plates on our laps and the football game will eventually make some of us carry our plates into another room to be heard.

 I will listen closely as my nieces talk about their jobs and their boyfriends. We will discuss shoes at length.  We will trade stories about their grandmother and how much we miss her. I will ask my nephew to show the home video of them as little kids at a family barbeque.  After the pie, (which will most likely not be yogurt-Cool Whip,) we will take pictures. The girls will look as beautiful as any of the models in the magazines.

And on the drive home we will wonder why we waited so long to get together with our family. 

DSC_0365 

 

 

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
There must have been a sale on white tights that year...
Happy Thanksgiving, everyone.
Never ever argue with a pregnant plaid-clad woman with access to cutlery. (One of the rules I live by.) Your Thanksgiving sounds grand...Flesh and blood trumps artifice every time. Happy Thanksgiving and time with family. I give thanks for your presence, example, friendship and sharing here...and for your writing ...endlessly delicious as any pie! Happy Turkey Day Joanie! r
I'm reading Aimee Bender's "The Particular Sadness of Lemon Cake", where the central character discovers that when she eats, she feels the emotions of the person who prepared the food. She makes your sentence very liveable: "Yet as delicious as the food was, it was served with a side of sadness so big, it made it hard to swallow." I'm glad to hear that it won't be so, this year.

Happy Thanksgiving to Joan, Husband of Joan, and Daughter of Joan.
Beautiful post, Joan. I'm happy for you that you found family and acceptance with your husband, and it makes me grateful for mine, in all their annoying weirdness.

And I LOVE the white tights photo. It's classic.
I want to write about Thanksgiving and I can't.
Canadian Thanksgiving is the first Monday on October. It is a feast and leave holiday.
Nothing like American Thanksgiving. I have no memories so I will live through all of you.
rated with hugs
This was wonderful; you finally got the family of your dreams.

But you should NOT have mentioned Popeye's cajun turkey -- I have a feeling despite whatever other turkey and fixins we're having, some friends of mine and I are gonna now have to make a Popeye's run... R
The Thanksgivings of my youth and when my children were small are the ones that I treasure diligently. I am contemplating this open call. I am so glad you will be surrounded by the ones that you love! Happy Thanksgiving!
Persistent Muse, I appreciate you so much!

Bard, oh, that is the next book on my list!

froggy, thanks so much for coming by. I think the white tights are hilarious.

Linda, love and hugs to you EVERY day. You bring so much to us here. It doesn't need to be a Thanksgiving post.

Antoinette, be sure to get the cajun gravy...
Sounds much better than Norman Rockwell scene, And they are adorable, but you already knew that.r
"And I knew no one would argue with a half-crazed pregnant woman wearing a dress that matched the tablecloth."

Wonderful Joanie. I think we are all much better off when we kick out Norman & Martha from our lives.
Cannot believe I forgot to rate!!!!!
past voices, I hope you write it!

hugs, me, thank you. It's hard to believe two of them are old enough to drink!
Beautiful memories!
Oh little girls with ponytails in dresses.. how adorable! My nieces and daughter always complain about the big bows we used to make them wear. Happy day and enjoy. I will be doing the same at my brother's home. It may be very loud you may hear us in Baltimore,we will be outside Silver Springs.
I LOVE the picture and I hope it is as wonderful as it sounds it will be. Happy Thanksgiving!
After my first Child, my mother brought me turkey from Boston Market. One Thanksgiving, when it was her turn, we had ham and Spanish rice. Yours sound lovely.
I wore my red plaid maternity dress and orchestrated a Thanksgiving meal in my mother-in-law's kitchen. My baby was going to have a family, dammit. And I knew no one would argue with a half-crazed pregnant woman wearing a dress that matched the tablecloth.
Such great writing, Joanie (I hope I can call you that-it's what I call my sister, too). Happy Thanksgiving. Darling pictures of the girls.
nobody will miss the big ole side of sadness. that photo of your daughter and nieces is very charming. was it taken on black friday?
that's exactly how Thanksgiving should be, family and a bit of craziness
My family knows better than to let me cook, they, however, swear by my flan
loved the pic!
heysuz, thank you!

Rita, the next time you are anywhere near Silver Spring call me!!!! (I'll send you my # for future trips.)

Mary Ann, thanks so much!

Snarkychaser, I've learned that the food is important but not the all and everything. Thanks for coming by.

Janice, thank you and yes, please call me Joanie!

diannani, I had to think about your comment for a minute. Then I laughed out loud. Someone found a sale on white tights and black shoes... :)
I had a dinner once sitting under that Norman Rockwell portrait. I hardly ever remember that! The only ingredient really required and sadly missed when it is not there is love. Lovely the family unafraid to love.
Sounds like a lovely Thanksgiving--enjoy it! Love the picture.
My kind of Thanksgiving. Have another Happy One.
rated with love
I think I'd rather hang out with you than with either Norman or Martha! (The picture is adorable!)
Sounds like a wonderful time!!! RRRR
PS Beautiful children!!!!
Joan
Thank you for sharing your Thanksgiving memories. Whether it is homecooked or brought in from Popeye's, it is family that makes the dinner special. I wish you and your family much happiness on Thursday (and everyday...)
xx
R
it's no surprise, joanie, that you get thanksgiving right since the ones of us who lived through the saddest and loneliest of them know it's never been about pretty table settings or shiny silver. i love your sister-in-law for putting the gang back together and you for the earlier ghastly plaid dress and the tolerance of football and having popeye's turkey because your baby girl wanted it. oh, and there aren't more adorable children than those girls in the picture. have a great day, friend.
Even your least impressive culinary Thanksgivings are better than anything I could have put together! I'm glad you guys will be with extended family this year - that so often makes Thanksgiving even better. Have a very happy and safe holiday! R!
I remember Thanksgiving as a large family event. Honestly, I enjoyed it. But each year it's gotten smaller. Now there's only my sister and she prefers to have dinner out with her single friend. And while I've been invited to hand with a friend's family, it doesn't work for me to do that. So I'm going out to dinner with MY single friend. And that will be fine.
No need to apologize for Popeye's or Plaids. There are always means to convert 'mistakes' into outrageously cool statements of independence and totally hip:) Have a terrific family holiday, all! This is a wonderful piece of writing, Ms. Joan!
Each year I lobby for a distinctly non-Rockwellian lasagne for Thanksgiving. Each year she refuses, but I notice that, lately, her defenses seem to be wavering. This year we're buying the main courses from The Machine Shed in Des Moines and making the family's favorite sides and desserts (I favor peanut butter pie, which would no doubt cause martha to rent her garments in distress but which suprisingly, my wife said she would allow on her table) ourselves. This trend suggests that a Thanksgiving lasagne cannot be too far in the offing!
I've served Popeye's Cajun Turkey a couple of times, with great success. What's missing, though, is the yummy aroma of turkey slow-roasting for hours on end in the house. My over-indulged son politely requested that I roast a "real" turkey the next day.
Anything for His Nibs! Your Thanksgiving will be wonderful because you'll be there. Love is all that really matters anyway.
Happy Thanksgiving to you and all the beautiful little girls (now not so little) in the adorable photo.

Lezlie
Oh, I think that sounds like heaven. The joy of your upcoming family dinner ALMOST balances out the notion of a yogurt-Cool Whip pie. Almost.
I want to go to your house for Thanksgiving. And as we all know, there's grub there from Whole Foods.

Happy Thanksgiving Joan H. and loved ones!
thanks for the chuckles today--esp. dinner with all the fixins.
In h.s. I wore the popeyes polyester orange uniform for a full year, believe it or not
Have a wonderful thanksgiving Joan, it sounds perfect
This "disowning" thing people do makes me so sad. How much beautiful texture to their lives they are missing. The precious little girls in the picture made me catch my breath. Beautiful! Happy Thanksgiving, lovely lady.
I love your now Thanksgiving, as family is what we are all thankful for yours sounds perfect!!! Happy Thanksgiving!
Aristocratic is as aristocratic does.....

I'm glad you chose the true aristocrats to be with.....

Love and Huggzz to you all.


^R^
Joan, I saw this earlier but was working on my own piece and had to focus knowing I'd be back. Family, you know it when you find it, for sure. I found a bit of it here tonight. Thanks, my friend. Gorgeous children. Is Julia in front there?
@Scarlett, I'm tempted to say she's the one with the white tights and black shoes, but yes, she's the cutie in the front. :)
Your family situation resonates with me, and I'm particularly impressed that unlike me, you can write about yours gracefully.

Beautiful.
I am so glad to hear of someone breaking tradition and doing anything different than the herd.

You rock Joan. Popeye's cajan.
Excellent.
I understand the Popeye's. A couple years ago, due to illnesses, we did Boston Market with all the fixins. Doesn't matter. If you're with the people you live, it's alright.
I meant the people you "love." Hunger kills my spelling.
Love this...Happy Thanksgiving, Joanie H! :)
No pictures of you wearing the red plaid tablecloth/dress?

Happy Thanksgiving Joanie!


{[R]}
I think you're going to get exactly the kind of Thanksgiving you always wanted. Hooray!
joan! day after thanksgiving is biggest shopping day of the whole year! finally, shops are in the black! black friday! i had to think about your response to my comment for a little while, and then I LAUGHED OUT LOUD! whew! we're nuts!
Thanksgiving is always "illuminating" somehow. I loved reading your perspectives on Thanksgivings past and future.

Ours will be the oddest Thanksgiving I've had in a while. We'll be up on Hopi for only one full day because my daughter's boyfriend (I've written about him before--suffice it to say, I could live without having him along) couldn't get two days off--twelve hours of driving, up and back for just a few hours out home.

My Hopi "sister's" family won't be there due to our grandmother's emergency bypass surgery in Flagstaff. And the majority of my ex's huge family will be in Phoenix. Our beloved Pom pup Bijou won't be there to beg tidbits--we lost her this year. And she will be missed...

But my ex will be there, with his father who is getting old and feeble and has been asking to see us all together one more time.

I'm still thankful...but mystified...and waiting to see what the lesson for this year will be...
We've skipped "family" T-days for several years, preferring our eclectic life and friends to the "side of sadness." Viva your family Thankgivings!!!
I love the idea of giving thanks for one's blessings and having a day set to celebrate. It's the people one's with and whatever food one can enjoy in good health that matter for me. Happy thanksgiving to you and your loved ones Joan. ~R
I had to finish rolling over in my not-yet grave when I read the Cool Whip part (tastes like soap to me). Gorgeous kids and I'm all about the "different". Have a wonderful time with the family. The other half really missed out, not you.
Great story. Just perfect. Your family produced a total gem and chose to toss it away. What a loss for them. What a find your husband and his family are, and I bet they feel the same about you.

Your last sentence echos. We should all remember it and gather to give thanks for each other more often than once or twice a year.
Wishing you a wonderful holiday. This is an amazing sentence, btw: "Yet as delicious as the food was, it was served with a side of sadness so big, it made it hard to swallow." So simple, and yet the reader instantly "gets" your family.
Loved your post (and your pic). Everyone's Thanksgiving should be special to them, what they make of it, their own tradition. Tears are coming to my eyes as I remember the chaotic Thanksgivings of my childhood, when my mother was alive with all the aunts, uncles, cousins..what a scene that was. I miss it.

Have a wonderful Thanksgiving and enjoy your family.
Family and fun are what the holidays are really about anyway. I have my table set with the vintage dishes and bowls I have found at garage and estate sales--even so, it looks pretty elegant. Friends are bringing assorted side dishes. It's all good. Happy Thanksgiving.
Thanks for sharing such a beautiful memoir. Happy Thanksgiving. -R-
Popeye's makes Cajun Turkey? Restores my faith in the fast-food industry.
Loud and informal sounds just lovely.

Happy Thanksgiving, Ms. Joan. Not around OS much these days but so enjoy your posts when I'm here.
Lovely story. Wonderful picture. I hope your Thanksgiving is the best ever.
And it happened exactly like that except I had forgotten how much I love them all...
There are days when my grocery list reads "milk, bread, white tights." And ponytail holders. Beautiful memory & picture, Joan. Hope your Thanksgiving was filled with blessings.
Sometimes it's not the family we are born into, but the family we create that sustains us. I'm so glad for you. Happy holidays to you and yours. cheers-
Every year my daughter asks for green bean casserole made with canned mushroom soup, and Spaghettios for Thanksgiving. I always make them for her. Thanksgiving should be about eating things that please you, not putting on a show of being a gourmet. Yours sounds absolutely lovely.
Cajun turkey sounds delicious. I confess that I've never understood the appeal of Cool Whip.

In the last few years, we've often gotten sweet potato pie from a wonderful shop in our neighborhood - right down the street from Popeye's. ;)

In the end, sharing the day with people who matter to us is what counts. I'm glad you've been able to do that in spite of your biological family being out of the picture. It sounds like your husband's family has been more of a real family to you. That's a gift worth treasuring.
Love this story, Joan....and you're right, Thanksgiving is much more delightful with love than with silver settings and/or elegant food and sadness.
I hope you had a blast this year!
very nice. It was the first Thanksgiving that I cooked everything. And it all was great. I was so pleased.