Joan's Blog

"Watch Me Pull A Rabbit Out Of My Hat"
Editor’s Pick
JULY 16, 2011 8:19AM

When Do I Stop Boycotting?

Rate: 59 Flag

 It seems I am boycotting another product or service on a weekly basis because I don't agree with their politics or where they are putting their money. It's  like the Whack-a-Mole game. I give up one thing and another one pops up.

This one gives money to anti-gay groups~ whack!  Now this one over here gives its money to anti-choice groups~whack!

I've stopped eating Chik-Filet, Dominos Pizza, and all things Nestle and Hershey. I don't shop at Wal-Mart and now I'm told Urban Outfitters and Anthropologie should be on the short list of unscrupulous companies I should avoid.

The truth is, none of these are huge sacrifices. The $100 I spend a year (at the most) at Anthropologie and Urban Outfitters, I'm betting is not going to be missed by them.

I don't really like Chik-Filet enough to care, but because they take an anti-gay stance I "boycott" them if I happen to be in the mall and hungry. I keep walking.

I live nowhere near a Wal-Mart, but if I did, I  probably wouldn't shop there based on their treatment of female employees.

When I found out that Dominos Pizza contributes heavily to pro-life groups, it was easy enough to switch to Pizza Hut. And if I find out Pizza Hut's politics or practices don't match my own, I will move on to Papa John or make my own. 

 I don't have enough money or clout to make much of a difference. Sometimes I think I am whistling in the wind by taking a stance against companies that use child labor (chocolate and coffee being the worst offenders) or companies whose politics I just don't agree with.

My education began when my daughter was in sixth grade and an enlightened teacher taught them about child labor and chocolate. The teacher talked about children who were forced into picking cocoa beans for little or no money and did not attend school. That year our family learned about Fair Trade.

That was all my daughter needed to hear. She never ate a piece of chocolate from Hershey or Nestle again. In the seventh grade, the class trip was to Hershey Park. She petitioned the principal of her school to change the trip to another amusement park and stated her reasons in a thoughtfully laid out paper. The answer was no and my daughter was the only one who did not go on the Hershey field trip that year. I had nothing but respect and admiration for her.

 Fair Trade chocolate became the only chocolate in our home.

Years later, I am still boycotting the major chocolate companies. Not shopping at Urban Outfitters or its sister company, Anthropologie is harder for me. I tend to rationalize a bit.

I spend so little, I think. By not buying those earrings, how am I hurting them?

The truth is, I'm not. I don't have enough money or power to hurt them.

It comes down to this: If my conscience bothers me, I boycott.

 If I think/know that children have been used for labor, I pass. 

My little acts of rebellion are not going to hurt these companies or change the world. But if more people thought about where their money was going and then more and more people gave it some thought, we might just have a revolution on our hands.

A positive one. 

Just last night my daughter and I were stuffing Sour Patch Kids into our mouths. She looked at the label and said, Oh crap. These are made by Kraft. 

Wait a minute, I said. We don't eat Kraft either? 

We talked about the Whack-a-Mole theory and how at this point, we have to go with the Jiminy Cricket school of thought and let our conscience be our guide.

We decide to give those cute little Sour Patch Kids a pass. For now.

 

Originally published on Does This Make Sense? 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Regardless of the amounts involved, a personal decision to boycot is often What We Can Do.
When the Times, in '93, exposed the Wal-Mart practice in 50% or more of its stores of locking-in overnight workers--and it caused at least one death and many intractable injuries bc supervisors wouldn't let people out even for emergency-aid--I made it a point to make sure no one in my extended family ever shopped there.
(The expose put an end to the practice.)
I applaud anyone who won't 'go along' just bc 'I am only one person'. The $100 you denied Urban Os may have been replicated elsewhere, friend. :)

rated.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts and approach, Joanie H! I guess everyone's choices do add up, little by little...sounds like your daughter inherited your thoughtful, brave, & caring genes... :)
now I'm going to have to look up Fair Trade chocolate...

Most times I tend to think big companies are too big and they will invest in whatever makes them more money, not considering if it hurts others. Sadly, in developing countries, child labor is considered by the many of the families afflicted as necessary for survival. My grandparents left school so they could work and sustain their families. It was the "normal" thing to do. The change will not be caused by them who even nowadays are in such desperate straits, but by the customers who have the means to choose.

I don't think your effort is too little, on the other hand. You reach out to many people and this piece should be on the cover. If you touch a thousand people who read this, and they in turn reach out to their own relatives and acquaintances, soon enough we will be in six degrees of separation territory. Like ripples on a pond.
just did a little research and came back

it seems Cadbury chocolate is fair trade, the other brands I found were English, if anyone knows of another chocolate manufacturer who is well-known (remember I live on an island and we don't have as many options as other walk-in stores on the mainland) please let me know
Jonathan and Clay, thank you for reading and commenting.

Vanessa, yes, like ripples in a pond. Exactly.
I have a family member who made millions in a developing company and employed many children in his factory. His rationalization was that they needed to work to help the family survive. I think there has to be a better way...
It seems no coincidence that products and services from corporations who do business without a conscience also tend to be unhealthy for the body and mind. I've been boycotting much of the stuff on your list without even knowing that I was. There is nothing at Walmart that I need.
Rats! My favorite candle is the Volcano scented one from Anthropologie...Luckily the Fair Trade store in Rockford has great earrings too. My guess is that you'll stop boycotting when the world is a much better place...or when you've moved into and onto a much more just state of being. The short answer is - when I do. Jon's answer is so fine. R ! and thanks!!!
I deprived myself of Jif Extra-Crunchy for years because of Proctor and Gamble. I don't think it was me that caused them to rethink animal testing, but whatever. I'm crossing off Hershey's and Nestle after reading this. I wouldn't eat Domino's regardless. There is no Chik-Filet in Vermont, and I can't afford Anthropologie and Urban Outfitters. Wal-Mart is still a struggle, but I only go there once a year. Just please don't tell me I have to give up my Extra-Crunchy Jif.
I guess we do what we can, we have to live with ourselves at the end of the day. The SuperBigBox WM near me has so many food items that are 1/3 or so less expensive than the other markets, and when my husband and I were staring down bankruptcy I had to go there. We haven't rebounded much but enough not to resort to it again. I also feel bad for the employees, my neighbors who have lost jobs and have to work there. It's a no win situation.
These are the seemingly little things we can do that we think don't count. But they do. -R-
I don't boycott any company for such reasons unless they are truly egregious. I assume that if you look deeply enough, most corporations are doing stuff of which I disapprove. And I suspect that a lot of alternative "progressive" business practices are really ineffectual.

The last time I deliberately boycotted a company was my favorite brewery, Sam Adams, several years ago when they sponsored, and their president was present for, a shock-jock radio stunt which inspired a couple to have sex in St. Patrick's Cathedral in New York. I was appalled by the lack of decency and decided to boycott the company for one year, and I did. It made me feel better about my own principles. But I was under no illusion that it made any impact on the company and its management.

Comment originally posted on Does This Make Sense? (Translation: I'm too lazy to think up a new comment.)
It's amazing how you can take a serious topic and make it humorous! I admire your conscience, but I'm not going to start boycotting based on fairness simply because I think most of corporate America is unfair, unscrupulous, and immoral. If I boycotted everything, where would I shop or purchase things that I need. My duty as an American is to vote my conscience and that's why I am a pro life Democrat/Progressive Liberal. I'm hoping my voting choices will make a difference in this country, although I am even doubting that, also. Until the practice of the rich corporate America buying off our congressmen stops, our indivdual middle class votes won't mean anything.
Nice essay. I tend to boycott the big offenders like Walmart and Dominos. I can't fight every battle and to try would exhaust me. I didn't realize Anthropologie was problematic. But, I stopped shopping there a while ago because their stuff wasn't as cute as I once thought.
I think boycotting is a step in the right direction. I wish everyone would really band together to do so and really affect change. I'm very guilty of apathy, cause I didn't even know about so many of the companies you mention, and mostly I sit on my can and complain.
I think, though, that we should have a triage mentality. First, let's focus on trying to conquer homelessness, suicide, injustices, diseases etc. etc. There is so much wrong with the world and so much we can do. It's exhausting just to ponder
I love hersheys chocolate bars and just bought an anthropologie shirt from the goodwill. I feel awful ;>(
I do the same thing Joan, and I do think it matters. I cannot single handedly right the wrongs in the world, but I can act according to my beliefs. It is an old saw by now, but I strive to think globally and act locally. I've yet to convince my daughter that it will make any difference, but I believe it does. Imagine the effect if everyone did it.
Nice piece. What is it Eleanor Roosevelt said, it is better to light a small candle than to curse the darkness. That's what you are doing. Good work.
You do your best to live with integrity, when you can, and as you can. It takes a lot of pain out of the process, you are choosing certain foods instead of abstaining from others. I see fast food strips and malls as a food and retail desert, and don't find myself there enough. Am I supposed to care that I am not fashionable? Like with the world of cosmetics and beauty, you don't need a lot of money to look like you are not rich. Once you don't care, then it doesn't hurt so bad.
Not Anthropologie!!!!!! Damn, one of my favorites. But I can't afford their stuff anyway, so I guess I won't miss them. *sigh*
Not only do you personally make a difference, Joan, but by spreading the knowledge you create a battalion of boycotters. Ultimately, they will feel a pinch. Also, this negative publicity might make them reconsider their possibilities. In any case, it makes sense to boycott optimistically instead of being pessimistic and not doing so. At least you have some chance of a positive revolution in the first scenario.

Lots of love and respect to both you and your daughter!
Alan Coren, a British humorist, did a great piece about this subject some thirty years ago--a party where nobody could eat or drink anything or sit down, etc., because all products in the house had some kind of moral taint, real or imagined.
We always have a choice, soo why not choose the companies that are doing the "right" thing rather than the wrong.
My daughter did her internship last year at Anthropologie, I'm curious as to why they are on the - - - - list?
I boycott everything. I don't buy anything.
"My little acts of rebellion are not going to hurt these companies..." Joan, I disagree. All you have to do is let seven people know. In turn, if those seven people pass the information onto seven other people, the information multiplies. If that network goes to seven layers, you are at a number over 800,000 people. One more layer and it is way way way into the millions. It becomes viral.

One disgruntled customer has the power to go viral with just a few friends. Now I'll go send the link to this article to some people on my email list. - Joan, with the internet, companies worry about people like you.
I think almost everyone can identify with this. You identify the dilemma very well.
Thanks you everyone for your comments. My first comment should have said, "I have a family member who made millions in a developing *country* not *company* and employed many children in his factory.

Anthropologie is owned by Urban Outfitters which was involved in something unscrupulous. (I will find the link and post it. I didn't go into it much because to me it was not as egregious as what other companies are doing in my humble opinion. Some would disagree.
I can't afford it anyway, and as Christina mentioned, their stuff just isn't cute anymore...
Yes, by all means continue your boycott. Just because working or not eating is the only choice for these children, I think you and your friends should continue to make their jobs not necessary so they can go hungry and end up on some late commercial begging for money to feed them.

That ripple effect goes a long way. The one it really hurts is not the shareholder.
@Catnlion, you must not be familiar with slave labor. In many countries, children are not even paid for their labor. I hope you will learn more about this heinous practice.
Please tell me what our humanity has come to when 5 year olds have to work for food...
@trilogy, here is an article from the Vancouver Sun about the issue I mentioned~
http://www.vancouversun.com/life/cool+Urban+Outfitters+cool/4851915/story.html
Great article Joan. For the longest time I boycotted Coors because they funded right wing groups. But then I was told I'd overshot by a few years as the younger generation of Coors had put a stop to it. I still don't buy them as there are many other brands I prefer. I guess I lose some of my former moral satisfaction.

Dominos, Walmart and Bacardi are on my current boycott list. The latter because they had a long history of funding the more extreme anti-Castro groups.
@Abrawang, I had no idea about Coors. But I don't drink beer, so it probably wasn't on my radar. Good on you.
If even a small percentage of shoppers takes their $100 elsewhere...it does add up! (Anthropologie is my "shopping cart" guilty pleasure; I just rarely hit the "buy" button.)
The answer, Joan, is of course, "Never!"

I sympathize with your frustration at what you perceive are the inconsequential results of your boycotts. So what? Stay with it.

Another excellent piece perfectly consistent with your others in that regard.
We are soul sisters! I, too, boycott these chocolates and Wal-Mart and Tyson! Okay, I do give in to Hershey's every so often, but for the most part, I am pure!
We've seen the power that the banding together of thousands of "little people" can wield. I'm standing with you, bravo for Julia, there are lots more too. If nothing else, it's a start. (And Jiminy Cricket is the best kind of role model).
MAWB, I forgot about Tysons! See? Whack-a-Mole! Oh yeah, and Smithfield Hams even though I never buy a ham...
I'm sending this to boycottwatch - http://www.boycottwatch.org/
Your nickel-and-dime boycotts may not shut down any of those corporations, but writing about it certainly raises awareness about these issues.

I think about this too. Am I making things financially harder for my family by refusing to shop at Wal-Mart and paying more at some smaller store, while doing nothing to stop big companies from doing business as usual? Maybe.

I have to believe that if enough people voted with their wallets, corporations will eventually get the message. Rated.
Joan, I think you've answered your own question in the title. Let's not forget Nestlé dumping its baby powder formula in third world countries...countries and cultures that had little or no access to fresh clean potable water. There was a longstanding boycott against them and all the varied companies they owned around the world in the 70s and 80s. I believe the sustained boycott against them had an effect on policy, though they should have known from the get go what would happen to babies drinking formula made with bad water. They made a lot of money though. That boycott started with one couple and spread. The boycott continues today in the Asia Pacific region and there are still bans in effect in many European universities prohibiting the sale of Nestlé products in their shops and vending machines.

No child deserves that result, no child should have to labor for survival. Protect and sustain your conscience Joan, voices united can make change.
@Eve, for what purpose?
Your vote probably won't turn any elections, either, Joan, but collectively - and that is the operative word here - collectively it and others like it/like you probably will change the world. It is the "what difference will one person's gesture make?" that Edmund Burke railed against, and what allowed all sorts of awful things to happen and continues to. Those like you who make the gesture into the wind are heroic, really. Awesome, in fact. Just keep going. Rated.
I try really hard but sometimes we are so broke I know I can get dog food for my dogs there. I do not shop like I used to there. As for Hershey's they had a plant in the town next to us and after almost 40 years moved it to Mexico. I quit buying Hershey's because of that although again sometimes you don't know what it is until you get it home...Thought provoking article..
Ll2, I know what you mean. Sometimes the store you don't want to patronize is the only one around!
I read a great book about Walmart a few years ago. One thing that stuck with me was how several people who were former employees of a company that was put out of business by Walmart said that they shopped there because the could no longer afford not to. I'm afraid I have the same dilemma.
I used to care more about it, then became more and more haphazard and now I don't keep up with specific issues enuf to know what to boycott and what to not. The last thing I boycotted was BP on a trip we took not long after the Gulf spill. It would have been more convenient to stop at the BP, but I went out of my way to cross the road to whatever other station was there, knowing that company was undoubtedly just as ruthlessly greedy as BP, only luckier. I boycotted Burger King for years because they were buying beef in Brazil where the rainforests were being destroyed to raise cattle. I refuse to buy a certain kind of pants decades ago because they were exploiting people in a Third World country. I forget the brand, but its still around. I boycotted grapes and lettuce when Cesar Chavez was organizing the United Farm Workers and I still avoid shopping at Home Depot because they screwed me right after Hurricane Isabel screwed us and our neighbors (I get especially riled when the screwing is personal - which, I am fully aware, is less than righteous). I know there are undoubtedly plenty of products and companies I should be boycotting for one or another reason, but I can't keep up with them all, so I use the ostrich/three-monkey maneuver. Plus, I've gotten so cynical in recent years I assume any big company is probly screwing somebody, if not me and mine. I'm surprised I haven't taken up shoplifting yet. Maybe that's next.
I am so impressed by your daughter's consciousness and conviction as a 6th grader - wow. Kids, at any age, can teach us just as we teach them. I admire you for taking your stands too Joanie. Good job.
Once in a while you get a real dilemma, when one company does something Bad (like support the war in Iraq somehow), and then does something Good (like support diversity in the face of anti-gay protests). This was Home Depot for me, although I'm having a hard time remembering specifics. (Do you ever do that? Start boycotting a product or place and then not remember why? Happens to me all the time.) I think a good rule is to go with their last move. At this point, Home Depot has definitely been upgraded from the dog house.
It all counts.
Couldn't help noticing Catnlion didn't come back.
I promise to boycott cans of Bela lightly smoked and with that added flavor`
`
Lemon with extra virgin olive oil. They are wild caught off the coast of Australia.
Oops. I forgot to mention the boy caught the Bela product is wild caught`
`
Sardines.
I shall explain?
I tell my last date?
She tells funny jokes.
`
John H. Google a DC blog?

http://LoveandCarrots.com /
LoveandCarrotsDC@gmail.com \
call 802-363-9643. You love them!
Mention me? They help dig yards/
Organic Gardening For Locavores\
Honest. She is a Master Gardener/
`
It's her avocation. She is at the same
same Place where You bought beets.
She helps designs/transform lawns.
apology! typo. not John H., but Joan H.`
`
Kerry's new gig? Golden Glove Boxer?
Maybe he put sardines in his britches?
He in Palms eatery eating butter peas.
He lines pea up on a buttered knife.
I'd not eat GMO hormone salmon.
They come to America via FDA.
They are raised in water jails.
Salmon are big and Mushy.
Fisherman warn eaters.
The round cells pollute.
Boats no go to the sea.
Fish catch comes from
polluted foul waters.
Fish get fed hormones.
Fish never swim in sea.
Beware. Fruit is sprayed.
Fungicides may make ill.
Strawberries are plastic.
The GMO's never ever rot.
A berry will shrivel. No lie.
I'd be very wary what to eat.

They stay on shelf forever.
GMO corn will not wither.
Consumers must beware.
Art, thank you, I will check out that site today. And yes, stay away from salmon raised in water jails!

I'm sorry I didn't get back to all the comments this time.
@Lainey, I guess that's how this post came up. I just try to do the best I can. Otherwise, I drive myself crazy.
joan,

It's not okay. But you are using our culture to judge theirs. It's like using 2011 rules to judge what people did in 1511.
However, like it or not, that is what is going on. That is their culture and the only thing your boycotts does is take food from those kids.

Someone here said they didn't buy gas at BP after the spill. So what did they have against their neighbors? BP doesn't own that station. It's owned by someone in your PTA or church. You took food from their family budget. You didn't harm BP one
bit.
you are very much on the right track. I've been like your daughter since i was her age. my parents couldn't have cared less. my mantra when i feel that my part would be insignificant is "---and one little murder wouldn't be bad?"

It is your soul.
Catnlion, in some cultures it is acceptable to stone a woman to death if she is suspected of adultery or having sex before marriage. That's not okay either in my book.

wschanz, "---and one little murder wouldn't be bad?"
That kind of says it all. Thank you.
Joan:

I do the same thing in my day to day life. I try to boycott as much as I can from the Koch Brothers. I don't shop at Target because they are anti-union. Wal-Mart is an easy one. I didn't know that about Dominos. Luckily their food sucks. I try to buy local chocolate here in Portland, OR. I generally try to buy everything used if I can help it. I think a personal boycott can go a long way. On top of that, you're blogging and informing the public. So in fact, you're doing even more. It seems a new company will often come up on the radar and then I'm through with them. I'm okay with that. Even though it costs a bit more, I try to reward local food growers and artisans. In the end, these things are higher quality anyway. Rated.
So well put. I understand completely. I also boycott Chic-Fil-A, but it was much harder for me, since I loved their sandwiches and fries. My big issue is animal testing. It's another hard one, since not all companies are clear on their policies - and at what point, as your title suggests, can or should you stop, if the product was ONCE tested on animals, but is no longer? I love your Whack-a-Mole analogy. But you're right: we have to do what our conscience dictates. Bravo to you and your daughter.
Viewing in terms of 'what am I doing to this company" will result in disappointment. It also contains a degree of vengeance, which in my experience accomplishes little. Rather, I view it in terms of "at least I am not contributing to this problem." Therefore, I am not focused on whether the situation changes. Instead I am focused on whether I go to bed with a clear conscience.
Every little bit matters, and integrity counts for a lot.

I like to give my business to independents where I can, rather than big corporations. In some sectors, we don't have as many choices. Our area has some very good independent restaurants. Many of them offer better food and service, so giving them my business and having more of that money stay in the local economy makes me happier than going to the mega chain down the street.
Joan:

bbd is right about Nestle and pushing formula on African women, and starting a campaign against breast feeding (as you know an irreversible decision once the mother has made it) and Africa was poorer and unhealthier as a result.

We all boycotted Coors in the 80s because they openly discriminated against gay employees, fired them if they were found out and refused to hire them if they suspected they were.

Coors is a horrible beer anyway, but with Nestle they make so many products you really have to read the lables.

I admire your daughter's refusal to go on the field trip. Looks like she takes after her mother!
@Kate, you said it! Nestle owns a lot. I gave up that yummy spinach souffle Stouffers makes after I saw that Nestle owned that too!

Thank you again, for all of these thought-provoking comments. For me, the bottom line is my conscience. The Jiminy Cricket school of thought works every time.
When the whole "Michael Vick" thing started I wrote a letter to NIKE asking them to reconsider using Michael Vick as part of their advertising campaign. I received a short letter from NIKE in which they defended Michael Vick. A few weeks later, Vick was arrested on federal charges and NIKE dropped Vick faster than Ben Johnson on steroids. After Vick was released from prison, he became a star quarterback again, and guess who signed him to lucrative endorsements? NIKE
littlewillie, I love that you wrote Nike. I respect that so much.
And no, I wouldn't touch anything made by Nike with a 10 foot pole either.
there are grave limits to being PC, though i have my personal blacklist as well. if i was judged in business for reasons i was unable to control in my personal life it would be horrible. it's why i respect those in politics, for instance, who have the courage to put up with it. think about what if it was applied to you.
Ben, yes, but you do have your own blacklist? I think it is our conscience and our need to do "right" that propels so many of us to have a blacklist, even a short one.
What an tremendous amount of energy it must take to continually keep up with things like that. I just don't have the time to worry about such things. I shop at the place that has the best price, eat at the place with the best food, etc. I do not expect everyone to agree with my politics, nor do I care about the politics of others, nor do I care to waste my time with exercises in futility.
I like your spirit! With all the competition out there, particularly from small producers and farmers markets, you can make a huge difference at no inconvenience to your family. And believe me, the $100 or less you deny the abusers IS felt in a big way!

R.
I do my share of boycotting, but, for us, it is a much bigger decision, I think. In the area I live, Chick-Fil-A is one of the few places the mommies in my playgroup take their kids to eat, so getting them to switch or not going with them was a major issue. We are surrounded by Wal-Marts, and that is where the majority of the population appears to purchase both groceries and clothing. My children see these items and ask for them constantly, even though the things I get for them are often nicer, healthier, and more consistent with our family philosophy. More than any harm my boycott does the company, I think it is my way to wage my little private battle against the mindsets prevalent in our part of the country. It is my way of sharing with my children what I believe, and that it is OK for these beliefs to run contrary to those of the majority of our neighbors and friends' families.
Fantastic. I can totally relate. I rated the crap out of it.
I've been thinking, what is it about this sentiment, activism via consumerism, that rubs me the wrong way? I certainly think people should shop, or not shop, as they please, so that's not it. Is it that it is cringingly privileged and bourgeois? Is it that there's something inauthentic about it, sort of like substituting something ineffectual for genuine activism? Who was it who said, people don't use their freedom of thought, so they demand freedom of speech in compensation? It is something like that, but I can't quite put my finger on it.

Rated.
Jason, it is interesting that something about the act of choosing products and companies that do some good (or the least amount of harm) bothers you so much. I wonder if there are causes you believe in enough to sacrifice something for? Following one's conscience is a clear form of activism...
rich white men designed the constitution so that others could not use politics to interfere in the pursuit of happiness by rich white men.

if they hadn't been so foresighted, people like you would be inviting the electorate to put hersheys out of business. but there is no citizen initiative in america, so hersheys is safe and i stopped calling americans 'citizens.' they are just civilians, when i'm feeling polite, cattle otherwise.
You're doing good and I agree it's hard to keep up. If it makes you feel any better about the hundred dollars, you're spending it with their competitor which makes the competitor stronger and devalues their stock so you're actually giving them a double hit. You're also undermining their advertising and the value of goodwill they try to build.

They want you to believe your boycott doesn't hurt them. It does.
Being authentic and true to yourself is the best policy as life goes along. And in your case, a candle in the darkness can add up to heat and light if enough others also stay true to their beliefs. That's a big "if."
You are making a difference, don't ever think otherwise!
I am the same way and have been for years. Never been in a WalMart after seeing what they did do a rural town where I lived once. Simply destroyed the downtown. I live by this rule, "every purchase is a political decision." It makes me feel better to be consistent, even it doesn't make a difference to those mega corporations.
I do the same. And I expect these corporations are well aware that by using their profits to support a specific poltical agenda, they are making a statement to the other side. That's okay. I get it. So I won't shop and put my money where I ordinarily won't put my money.

It seems to me the conservatives are pushing our backs to the wall with their agenda. Okay. I got it.

You have a special daughter, which is no surprise...the acorn and all that. :)
It's the "think globally, act locally" state of mind that brings me some semblance of peace in this regard.
Anya, thanks for that support~

Lea, I think people have to stay true to their beliefs to feel good about themselves. Thank you for reading.

Hayley, many thanks!

Sheba, "Every purchase is a political decision." I don't think that ever hit home as much as it did reading it in your comment. I agree.

FM, you are so right. " And I expect these corporations are well aware that by using their profits to support a specific poltical agenda, they are making a statement to the other side." Of course!
And thanks for the kind words about the girl... I'm crazy about her.

Linnn, me too!
It can be hard, because most of stuff we buy is made by big corporations. I think it is worth doing it, but I try not to over think it. Boycotting too many brands can be exhausting and life is worth to be enjoyed, at least occasionally. Some things can be done and some are just too complicated. It is easy not to buy GE range (I hate that the bastards do not pay any taxes and TAKE tax benefits which could have gone to schools or people in dire need), there others. It is harder to get mortgage from a credit union and not from a big bad bank when your seller wants to close really fast. I do what I can. SO do you.
You are mistaken that you are not doing much impact. You are. You and your opinions exist, you talk about them, you share, there are more and more people trying to buy responsibly. It will make an impact, in many cases it already does.
Joan, I think I'm reacting to middle-class privilege more than anything else. Poor people, which in my neck of the woods generally means black people, have no choice but to shop at the place with the lowest price. Boycotting a store because it doesn't jive with one's political predilections simply isn't an option for the people of the lower classes. Political activism requires privilege and leisure. So, the argument can be made that by demonizing or boycotting Wal-Mart, which, to be sure, is one of the cheapest places to buy stuff, one is harming minorities and people who have less leisure and privilege. When I go to Wal-Mart, invariably I am checked out by a woman, often a minority, and in that sense I am supporting her livelihood. Maybe boycotting isn't the answer, but dialogue, letter writing, conversations with managers, etc. The problem with this kind of liberalism is that it damages the very people it purports to support.
Jason, I'm glad you came back to explain some of your thoughts. I understand what you are saying. It can seem that it is a luxury to even be able to boycott something. I live in a city that is severely divided into the rich and the poor. I think about this often. People without jobs, people with low or no incomes are not worrying about "boycotting " anything. They are worrying about survival. In the poor neighborhoods, there aren't even grocery stores. You buy what is available at the corner store and you don't worry if the apples are organic.
If I have the ability to avoid companies/products that I feel only exploit the poor even more, I will avoid them. Instead, I try to spend my money on companies that are helping people not hurting them.
You may not think I get what you are saying, but I do. The only thing I don't agree with is this: "Political activism requires privilege and leisure." I am one of many ordinary people who try to make a difference in small ways. It only requires a social conscience and a desire to make things better. And boycotting is only one way to do this. There are homeless shelters, soup kitchens, head start groups that all need volunteers. It's bigger than a boycott.
Look at all the comments you have on this post! You have brought awareness to a lot of open.saloners about what your concerns are with corporate America; perhaps some of them will join you and the companies you mention will then notice a drop-off in sales.
Joan and all, good thoughts. A little self-awareness can go a long way toward peace of mind. And I'm discovering that, in their rush to provide goods to more customers, even chain groceries (such as Kroger) now have a large selection of alternatives to boycotted companies. Of course, kids will want "their" brand ... but I have a friend who substitutes the generic bag of -------- in his kids' box of ---------- and has yet to hear a peep. As in most kid-demands, it's all about the branding. Those cute li'l consumers learn early.

Now, of course, I've recently learned about Apple's questionable practices from a post here on OS and it's beginning to bother me every time I pop open my iBook. Yikes ... in short, it never ends.
The whole boycotting issue is just as difficult as trying to buy only American made products. You just can't win. Good post.
Joan - another really great post, and what great contributions in the comments. Very stimulating, well writen and timely. Breaking the lie of our puny powerlessness is so important, as is calling bullshit as called for. The blacklist, all the steps are important but ... This world wants us in "against" and it sounds like you are switching to standing, buying and acting more on what you are FOR instead of against. Great move, great post. I keep hearing FDR's 4 Freedoms: Freedom of Speech, Freedom of Worship, Freedom from want, Freedom from Fear. I have the pamphlet from the FDR memorial posted on my wall in my writing area. This reminds me of that. (have you ever been and writen about that memoria? I would love to read your experience of that place...) Thank you. R
A small group of thoughtful people could change the world. Indeed, it's the only thing that ever has.

When I was a kid I would get a nickel from time to time to buy a treat when I went to the corner store for my mother. Normally I got a Hershey bar - the storekeeper even called me Hershey. In season, though, I would trade up the Hershey's for a nickel's worth of grapes - I think they were ~.25/lb. Nothing better on a summer's day than munching on cool grapes as I walked home. I loved them more than chocolate. Along came Ceasar Chavez - early '70's? I went years without a grape. Still don't eat them that much.

Hershey's chocolate is going to hell. Some of it tastes like wax. Nestle's went there long ago, boycotting them isn't a sacrifice. (Any day now I'll learn to make a comparable spinach souffle, too.)

Sadly, nothing's purely black and white and there are places where the family doesn't eat if the kids don't work - a hostage dilemma. Last christmas my kids all got cards from Save the Children.

The most revolutionary act: consume as little as possible. Buy local - nestle, hershey, et al make nothing I NEED. Dell & AT&T are my current dilemmas. And Target - they support my son rather nicely but I find that, there, too, I only need what they have to offer once I get inside the store and see all the bright and shiny!

Nothing's purely black & white, we can only do what we can do.
so very true. the sour patch moment, as I will now call it... soon there won't be much left besides integrity. (one hopes.)
First of all, Social Issues in the States (as in hiring practices and social contributions) I take very lightly. The reason why?? It is the same as not attending an Afghani restaurant after 911 and praying for them to shut down. WHY?? They're toooo different from what they should be. Boycotting Chik fil a?? Give me a break...

Boycotting Neslte becasue their treatment ot cocoa producers in the third world give up their schooling to work in the fields....then yes. How about boycotting DeBeers for strightjacketing the growth of the diamond industry with by planning to ckeck mines with small chidren regulary. Boycotting China for slave labor?? Yes, but greater is that you boycott the cheap boutiques that buy the materials from China and bring them here to set up ship without much knowledge of how the whole things worse!!!!

The only American boycott we did was with Taco Bell having a sexy, tall clueless lifeguard show up at a clache of buys who were fainting about her beautiful, scantily clad body. This campaign lasted two days in Sacramento before they caved and asked our advice to run the next campaingn,

Boycotting, like most things worth doing well, will require history and ending with a resolve, One would be worth agreeing we are all wrong anf have a greater decision,

Blessings!!!!
Thanks for a well written, interesting post. I am especially taken with your recognition that your efforts have little if any real impact, but remaining true to your ethics matters - and you're proving to be a good example to your daughter. She might be where your efforts are most powerfully felt - and that's not a waste of time or effort at all.
Ethics is HARD, Barbie!
You wanna pig out on Chick-fil-A?

Be my guest.

Hope ya choke on it.
@David... Are you talking to me? Did you read my post? I don't touch Chik-fil-A because of their politics.
"David Ehrenstein" appears to be an addled troll. I would not engage him/her in any dialogue. Ignore such creatures and eventually they drift away.
I was speaking to the subject as a whole. This is serious business. We are not citizens in this culture -- we are consumers. Our votes in our elabotely rigged electiosn mean NOTHING> The one small sliver of power that we ahve is to refuse to buy the crap they haul out for us -- espeically when profits fund Fundamentalists jihaads
If enough people boycott it could make a difference; however this won't be enough for many things since the same congomerates control all the companies.

We need to boycot corporate candidates and start creating them at the grass roots level. If the public can control who is elected to office then that would help a lot; right now the corporations own most if not all major politicians.
Life is really whacky sometimes or just about all the time now that I think of it. Excellent and more.
I think that what you're doing DOES matter, Joan. We can all fight back in our own way. Great that you and your daughter can fight back together. Rated.
late to the party, again. it does make a difference -- look at the child you've raised, like a seed that will sprout and cast other, like seeds into the world. it matters, no matter the scale.

i was raised to believe that if one sees something that is not right or unjust, if one does not stand up and speak against it, then one is condoning it. (goodness, i almost sound like M. Chariot).

i try to eat local, shop local, look at tags on clothing, and make choices in line with what i believe are ethical practices. if that's all we can do, i still maintain that's a lot.

get 'em, joanie. (r) MOC
someday in the not too distant future,
after the natural disasters wake us up,
and we all become one Race,
the truth will be known about the greedy politically
religiously
psychotic
people who ran our ship into the rocks.
until then, yes, a little conscience may not seem to go a far way,

but conscience is hopefully the Virus that will wipe all our egoistic
ways out.
someday in the not too distant future,
after the natural disasters wake us up,
and we all become one Race,
the truth will be known about the greedy politically
religiously
psychotic
people who ran our ship into the rocks.
until then, yes, a little conscience may not seem to go a far way,

but conscience is hopefully the Virus that will wipe all our egoistic
ways out.
someday in the not too distant future,
after the natural disasters wake us up,
and we all become one Race,
the truth will be known about the greedy politically
religiously
psychotic
people who ran our ship into the rocks.
until then, yes, a little conscience may not seem to go a far way,

but conscience is hopefully the Virus that will wipe all our egoistic
ways out.
someday in the not too distant future,
after the natural disasters wake us up,
and we all become one Race,
the truth will be known about the greedy politically
religiously
psychotic
people who ran our ship into the rocks.
until then, yes, a little conscience may not seem to go a far way,

but conscience is hopefully the Virus that will wipe all our egoistic
ways out.
@James, thanks for stopping by.

Thanks again, everyone. I appreciate you reading and commenting.