Joan's Blog

"Watch Me Pull A Rabbit Out Of My Hat"
Editor’s Pick
SEPTEMBER 28, 2011 10:58AM

Part of the Whole

Rate: 36 Flag

Tonight begins the New Year for Jewish people everywhere. Because I had a Jewish mother, I can claim my Jewishness if I want to. I never found it that easy. 

The most Jewish part of our home was the food.  The first time I set foot in a synagogue was at thirteen for a classmate's Bar Mitzvah. Maybe it was because I was born so much later. Thirteen years after my brothers. After all those years and a surprise pregnancy, I don't think my mother had any strength left for the High Holidays. 

I knew she didn't believe in a God. But she worried what the other Jews thought. She turned the lamb chops over in the shopping cart in case someone she knew saw her buying non-Kosher meat. On Yom Kippur, she would say, Just fast until noon. The Jewish mother in her didn't want her child starving for something even she didn't care much about.

In college, she bought me an unusual present. A Star of David. I never wore it, but  kept it next to the Saint Michael necklace in my jewelry box. I never understood that gift, as it was given without any explanation. Perhaps she secretly hoped I'd find my Jewish roots one day. I don't know. She took it back and gave it to someone else.

I was an equal opportunity spiritual seeker. I went to Catholic services with a friend in college. I fasted at Ramadan one summer with another.

And at Rosh Hashanah, I ate apples dipped in honey and wished my Jewish friends L' Shana Tova.

I accepted it all. There was no choosing just one way. I had reverence for the Old Testament, the New Testament, the Koran and the teachings of Buddha. I realized I would never be able to follow just one religion.

I raised my daughter with a belief in God. I also raised her with the knowledge of Christian traditions as well as Jewish. She had books on Islam and Hinduism and anything else I could open her world to. Mainly I raised her to be kind and compassionate to her fellow human beings.

Today, I have made peace with feeling that I am a part of everything but claim nothing as my own. Spirituality is the most meaningful when I'm in Nature. I know that I am a part of it all. I know that all religions are the same, just packaged differently.

My daughter identifies herself as Jewish.  I take great pride and satisfaction in that, although I would feel the same no matter what path she chose. There is something wonderful about her choosing (without any push from her parents) the path that is most meaningful to her.

No matter that I don't identify myself with any religion, I am Jewish at least by birth. So the Holidays come, and I make my matzoh ball soup and put out a plate of apples and honey for my non-Jewish husband to ensure he has a sweet year too. These are the traditions I have taken and made my own.

I take what I need from the other religions too.  A friend calls me a Pagan. Maybe. I'm not sure.

What I am sure of is that I am part of the whole. 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I am amazed at so many universal things in so many religions. I prefer to see the similarities.
I have always found liberating the fact that being a Jew is a matter not of specific belief-adherence but a matter of birth according to Jewish law.
r.
I have been browsing a book by a Rabbi.
He is into the Kabbalah. It's s mystical.
Cultures change. He is helping explain.
`
I recall about January 9th, 2009 ref:
`
@ Salon
The topic was then`Israel/Palestine.
I had been researching the topic much.
I had been in Israel in 1973 on a kibbutz.
I left just as the Yom Kippur War broke out.

I have a dear Friend (Hannah) who teaches.
Robert H. Deluty helps me think and ponder.
Deluty dedicated a poem book to me ( wino-o).
Read his poems? I often quote Robert Deluty.
`
Thanks Joan.
I respect You.
I am very calm.
I write privately.
People here walk.
If on a boat you:
waddle walk like:
ducks or alligator.
No steal the shoes.
People here Smile.
Atlantic air is Pure.
Nature is so potent.
We human beings.
Hasidic, and what?
I like to just Be a`
`
Simple Human Beings.
We are interconnected.
People are part/parcel.
`
Thanks. I think on this.
Eat beets, kale, no kill.
I gotta go walk a beach.
I too had a Jewish mother and an Anglican father. My mother spent most of her short life in the hospital so I was raised in church.
I live with a non practicing Jew who ignores my pleas to go to shul.

But I passed on my beliefs to my kids who ignore it all. Or do they?
We do our best in life with our beliefs and that is all we can do.

HUGGGGGGGGGG
I have had a similar experience with my son. I refused to indoctrinate him into any religion at all. Instead I focused on teaching him to live his life according to the concepts that all religions worth their salt teach. He now has a stronger belief in the existence of God than I ever will, but has embraced no particular religion. He has a deep faith.

Lezlie
I can relate to this great post. Even though I didn't learn about my Hebrew heritage (on my mother's side), I was raised in a Jewish neighborhood in Maryland and always enjoyed the traditions and felt a kinship somehow. Maybe the blood knows.

Our Sephardic heritage was hidden during the Spanish Inquisition when my relatives came to this country with Don Juan de Onate and denied when they settled in New Mexico. They became Presbyterian and not Catholic as a result.

I enjoy the Jewish customs and food and while I won't eat seafood or mix milk and beef, I LOVE bacon.
PS I learned about our Jewishness in 1998.
A beautiful post, Joanie H! Thanks for sharing your thoughts on spirituality, and of being part of a whole...I especially love this, "Mainly I raised her to be kind and compassionate to her fellow human beings."
I love these honest words about such a complex subject Joan.
The feel fresh from your heart.
TY. I needed this.
snarkychaser, me too. :)

Jonathan, yes. Thank you for reading.

Art, I wish I could walk on the beach for the New Year. Thank you for coming by.

Linda, all I really cared about was that my daughter was a kind and compassionate person. To me, the rest is where we get into trouble...:)

Lezlie, I have no doubt you helped make him into a wonderful human being. xo

Miguela, that is fascinating. I am not 100% sure where my family was from, but I have heard the possibility that some of them were originally from Spain too. Thank you so much for coming by.

clay ball, it's really what matters most, right? Thank you for reading and commenting.

Mission, I'm so glad you stopped by. I've been thinking about you and wondering how you are.
"All religions are the same, just packaged differently." Amen. I always tell my daughter God has many names. I was raised Catholic, but I haven't practiced for a long time. I'm like you, I take a little bit from here and a little bit from there. I'm what my friends call a "cafeteria" Catholic, which is fine by me. Recently, my daughter announced she wanted to become Buddhist. She was baptized in the Lutheran church, made her communion in the Catholic church and now she's turning toward an Eastern tradition. Looks like she's filling up her tray.
Victoria, I love that she is "filling up her tray." Thank you for reading and commenting.
I like your take on all this, your method is so much more peaceful than a rigid stance without meaning or joy...
I love the Great Mystery of it all,
and for me as well, off in Nature is where the holistic sense of belonging in the world is strongest in my heart...
and I think our heart intrinsically knows more about these spiritual things than our minds can possibly convey.
Does one say Happy Rosh Hashanah?
I wish the best to you and yours, Joan...
: )
Beautiful.
I am "half Jew", whatever that means. I've never understood the obsession with what religion, what percentage and who's your daddy kind of thing. Maybe because I was never embraced by it. I can't blame anyone for that.

I love that your mom gave you a mazuza. When I read that I thought maybe she was like my mother, trying to cover the bases for you, hoping to protect you via any means available. Then I read she took it back. Your mom was hard to figure. Hard to live with too, I'll bet. Especially for a gentle kid because I know that's what you were and are, to this day. A gentle soul.

IF there is god, then we are god. God is life. Maybe death too, I don't know. I don't know anything. All I know is I'm a part of something here and grand and big and I am so grateful. I wish it could last forever. And the thing is, maybe it does.

Love you Joanie. I'm so glad you are here. (wherever that is)
Just Thinking, I think Happy Rosh Hashanah sounds just right. (Purists may not agree...) :)
This piece was a whole lot of beautiful.
Monkey, (so very not foolish), I love this~ " All I know is I'm a part of something here and grand and big and I am so grateful. I wish it could last forever. And the thing is, maybe it does." Damn.

Mary, thank you that. I appreciate it.
Traditions are what it's all about, I think. I always feel closest to the Creator when I'm enjoying nature while recognizing that we live on a planet where everything eats everything else. This was really interesting, Joanie.
I love how you feel about religion and belief. I definitely agree, though I have a tendency to group myself into religions I grew up with. But I've never felt those were more important or full of better knowledge, etc, than any of the others. L'shana tova to you and your daughter.
Joanie, a beautiful way of looking at things. Why can't we all just get along?
I liked this piece. When I read this, there were a lot of similarities, I felt like I was reading something that I might have written in a way. I have done similar for my children, I built a foundation but as I had learned and studied myself, I have encouraged them also, to the extent of their comfort. Congratulations on the EP. Great writing.
Thank you,Joan and Jonathan,you two make me feel at home.
What beautiful sentiments. It's good to recognize what is good and true in any culture or religion.
"she worried what the other Jews thought"
Because that's what Jewish mother's do? Right?
I was the opposite - I had a Jewish father and was brought up Catholic. My mother was an only child so all my aunts, uncles and cousins were Jewish. We always felt like we were the "black sheep". Every Christmas my mother would make lox, eggs, & onions and my Dad called the Christmas tree a Hannukah bush.
I think it's wonderful that you gave your daughter a foundation in different beliefs so that she could make up her own mind. -R-
This lovely post with its beautiful sentiment made me smile. Thank you!
Mazeltov on your graduation from a single religion in competition with others.

Lovely little bit of writing here.

-r-
this is a nicely written piece, joanie. from the bottom of my athiest heart, i wish you happy new year. :) and i'm sure next spring i'll see you in the garden.
Candace, most of my favorite people are atheist or agnostic. I live with two of them! xoxo
I'm half-Jewish, but not religious. There are just a lot of Jewish qualities I really identify with. Some good, others not so good:) Rated!
The world would be a much more peaceful place if everyone felt the way you do.
The first person to posit this theory to me was actually a character in a trashy romance novel written by Bertrice Small. I now believe it firmly. Being raised Methodist in a Catholic town I still have a strong streak of Christianity, but I argued a Baptist to a stand still when he tried to tell me that it didn't matter how good a person was, there was only one way to get to heaven. Personally I'm hoping for reincarnation. And hoping that I've learned some lessons in this life time so that the next one is easier.
I believe in Thor and on certain days Zeus. They were perfectly good gods at one time.
ok i agree but:

i would correct it
(a trait some ladies find very annoying:)

"Today, I have made peace with feeling that I am a part of everything but claim nothing as my own.

Spirituality is the most meaningful when I'm in Nature.

I know that I am a part of it all.

I know that all religions are the same, just packaged differently."

Nature is an "it all", a unity, of which you are indeed
a part, in the material world. you are a strand
in the web of life. your actions affect others
who share your ecosphere.

but...


a leap has been made by Nature, the "it all",
a QUALITATIVE LEAP,
into consciousness, or ,
better, self-consciousness.

of course you are still OF and IN nature,
but what is your
nature?

your nature, human nature, IS Nature.

yet once in a great while we feel above it all,
above the animality of our genetic heritage.

our evolutionary past.

what are we then?

some like pierre de chardin or
alot of others say we are immanently transcendent.

or vice versa.

in which case we become caretakers of Nature, sort of.

which is problematic because we must some how rise above
it no matter how briefly.
such as to say Mother nature, gaia, the biosphere, the globe,
is sick, and dying..

this means we are too.

but noone, not even mother nature, wants
a sick doctor.
I don't think believing is too hard. As humans we are "wired" to believe. I choose to understand the phrase "be like a child" that way. Choosing to believe as an exercise in wonderment. However, accepting dogma is a very difficult thing and a whole other "monster". Mostly, because it's created by humans intent on trying to understand the Undefinable. And making a mess of things by the way.
As you well know, I received confirmation but a little while back that I have Jewish ancestors. I choose to honor that, too.
L'shanah tovah tikatevi v'taihatemi
I know little of the reasons behind them, but many Jewish traditions speak to me on an intuitive level. Leaving a stone on a grave when you visit, covering a mirror when someone dies, apples and honey for the sweet. These are actions that translate some inexpressible truth.
This atheist says: L'shana tova, Joanie.
I've always thought that being as kind and ethical as possible is what any God would want most. I could be wrong.

Interesting that your daugher would identify as Jewish. It's got me thinking.
I didn't even realize it was Rosh Hashanah tonight. That makes me feel .... guilty. Lshanah Tova to you.
You said a lot in relatively few words. "Today, I have made peace with feeling that I am a part of everything but claim nothing as my own" -- I related so much to this, but am not quite at peace yet.
"Mainly I raised her to be kind and compassionate to her fellow human beings." The Golden Rule - that says it all. Very nice post.
Many people who don't identify with any particular religion may be more spiritually alive than you would think. You find a use for it. It's necessary. You don't need to take it all out the the same can.
Joan - Thank you for your thoughtful and beautiful post. I am Jewish but not raised as religious, but these these two holdiays always make me stop and think about my Jewishness and spirituality as a whole. You put it into words as I never could have.
Beautifully written and expressed!
Sarah, yes, exactly.

Alysa, thanks so much for coming by.

Bea, I know, right? :)

Sheila, I think many of us are just natural searchers. I think I will always be fascinated by what I find.

Heidi, thank you for coming by and commenting.

Grace, agreed. Good to see you!

trilogy, you make me want some lox and bagels for breakfast. I think it's a good thing to have been exposed to more than one religion. You get to choose what is right for you, or even nothing at all.

Christine, more than anything, I just hoped she would learn that the essence of religion had more to do with treating others right, and being of service to others more than the actual rituals.
It sounds like you're a Unitarian!:) Like me. I loved your story and the way you write. Very honest. My father was Jewish and I didn't discover my Jewish roots until I was 19 and got to live in Israel (by my own choice) to work on a Kibbutz and study Hebrew. Then I felt like I was really Jewish after that. But I wasn't. I never truly felt accepted when I returned, going to various synagogues and able to sing the songs and read the Hebrew - but that wasn't going to really let me in the door. My mother wasn't Jewish, therefore I wasn't. When I discovered UUs about 10 years ago, I finally found a place where I felt accepted. Still, because of your story, I will feed my children apples and honey today. Thank you.
Sounds pretty Buddhist to me, Joanie - part of everything? Or is that Transcendentalism? I think just the curiosity and drive to pursue spiritual teachings of any kind is itself a religion. Unless "religion" requires a certain discipline, which is something you demonstrate most persuasively in your writing. Have a sweet year, dear.
Sally, I appreciate that!

dunniteowl, thanks so much for reading and commenting.

Candace, I know I already answered you, but I also wanted to say, why is that some of the best people with the most integrity and kindness are atheists? Just my observation. :)

Christina, thank you for stopping by.

Margaret, thanks. As Bea said, "Can't we all just get along?"

phyllis, personally, I am hoping for it too.
I grew up in a community that was almost exclusively fundamentalist christians, lowercase intentional. They thought the catholics were WAY out there in their beliefs. I'm not sure anyone in that community even knew, really knew, that Judaism existed. And I'm poorer because of that fact. I share your habit taking the good wherever I find it, without regard for how it is labeled. Thanks for this post.
I read this last week and loved it so. And yes, you are part of the whole and I am part of the whole and so is every person on this planet. Here's the hope. R