Joan's Blog

"Watch Me Pull A Rabbit Out Of My Hat"
Editor’s Pick
JANUARY 4, 2012 11:57AM

Loving Langston

Rate: 71 Flag

This week I am teaching a third grade class. This particular class is one of my favorites. Like the rest of the elementary school, it is a mix of black and white, Asian and Latino, rich and poor. 

We sit cross-legged in morning meeting. Each child gets a turn to speak. They are excited to share what they did over Winter break, and what presents they received. The boy next to me asks what "black Friday" means. Kids call out things like, it's when you get stuff on sale, and it's when people stand in line all night for TV's and X-boxes. The boy says, I thought it was the day black people get to shop 'cause stuff is cheap and black people are poor. We're losing our house soon. It tumbles out of him in one long thought.

I'm sorry, I say. I'm sorry you are losing your house. It's a lame statement, but I am caught off guard, and I'm not sure he really wants more than that. I'm not sure he even expects more than that. This is his sharing for today. 

I can't get it out of my mind, the differences in this one classroom, this one elementary school. There are children of diplomats and children who are bused in from neighborhoods many never venture into. In the classroom, I get to hear the stories of the kids whose parents work at the White House and the stories of the kids whose parents have no job.

My head aches as I lean over their desks, explaining fractions. In this city, as in many others,  I am struck by the enormous gap between the haves and the have nots. I choose a book from the shelf to read aloud during their snack time. It is a book of poetry by Langston Hughes. I watch them unwrap their apples and Hostess cupcakes, their edamame and their Cheetos. It's a varied selection of snacks. 

I start to read. I need to hear his words, and I want them to hear them too. I read the poem called "Mother to Son." It includes the memorable line the mother speaks to her son, "Life for me ain't been no crystal stair." 

The kids get it. The mom is saying her life hasn't been easy, but she doesn't give up, says one of the girls.  She's telling her son to never give up, one of the boys yells out. Life is hard, but it's beautiful, offers another child. I love that answer.  Langston Hughes never actually says that it's beautiful. I ask her about that.  She explains. Why would we give up on something that we believe has something beautiful for us?

I believe Langston Hughes should be a part of every third grade class.

They get it. 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I agree, he should be!



Oh, and a flippant pat on the back for writing such a wonderful post and a big flippant "R" (inspire of your excessive comma usage!)
Very cool that you've got Langston Hughes' excellent poetry to share with them and that they get it.
Excessive comma usage? They're used effectively for clarity here, unlike the long murky phrases spawned by the lack of commas in so much writing today. Yes, the breakdown in English grammar, apparently related to texting, is one of my pet peeves. ;)
A great combination for all those lumps of clay: Ms. H and Langston. They could not have landed in a better place, whether by serendipity or choice. I know your potter's hands will shape beauty.
No third grade class here in Florida is going to hear Langston Hughes unless you come here and read it to them.

Nice post.

r
It's so great that they "get it"..and good for you, Joanie for getting them.
Amy, I actually abhor commas. xo

bike, it was meaningful on both sides...

Barry, you are very kind. Thank you~

toritto, that made me laugh until I realized that it's probably true.

trilogy, either this is a very deep class, or we don't give kids enough credit.
The same thing you see every day I see but I do not hear the words. I just see the faces. I had never read Langston Hughes and one day I found a well worn copy of one of his first books I was to sell on Amazon.

I sat down and read it. I had never read anything like that in my life. I do not know how you do your job. I would be taking them all home with me.
HUGGGGGGGGG
HUGGGGGGGGGG
She is one wise soul. It's amazing that someone so young already knows that beauty lies in every moment of life.
makes me want to get a copy and read it too. thanks.
your kids are lucky to have you.
we are lucky too.
Langston Hughes is amazing. I learned "Dream Deferred" in sixth grade, and the words stick with me through the years, unfolding as I age and understand them more than I did then. Yes, kids get it.
Very poignant piece. They're lucky to have you as their teacher.
"trilogy, either this is a very deep class, or we don't give kids enough credit."
I think it's the latter. I taught third grade. I think they are the coolest grade in elementary school. Not babies, not yet jaded, and razor sharp. Your classroom sounds like a microcosm of the real world, and that's a good thing.

Lezlie
Whew! Lucky kids to have you for a teacher. R
Joan, those children are so lucky to have you as a teacher. What great joy to share poetry a loud with them, what a gift you have given them! RRRRRRRRRRRRRR
You may recall that it was a Langston Hughes poem that got Jonathan Kozol fired in "Death at an Early Age." So we've made some progress.
Linda, thank you for coming by. He is one of my very favorite poets.

Belinda, I thought it was a very wise statement, too.

dianaani, you will love it!

froggy, I love his poetry more and more as the years go by. But yes, the kids get him.

jlsathre, thank you. Unfortunately I'm only with them this week...

Lezlie, now that I am working with different grades, I have to agree with you. Third graders are wonderful. (I can just see you as a third grade teacher.)

Thank you, Deborah. I wish it was not just for the week.

Bea, there is nothing I'd rather give kids than an appreciation of books.

Smiling and waving at you, Con! Thank you for coming by!
Love this, Joanie. You brought art and life together in this lucky classroom. We never heard the name Langston Hughes in our lily white school. Would've done us a world of good.
Super story and a much deserved EP. You are very right about Mr. Hughes.
Brought tears to my eyes. Lovely and well written. Thanks for sharing.
Kids always get it - they lose it the older they get - this so great - I wish I would have had you for 3rd grade.
Beautiful. I think I have to go read the rest of that poem now.
Why do I cry every time I read you? It's a good thing. I get you.
DC? I really believe equity in education should be the next Amendment and that schools hum with social services and programs for ALL the kids, but until then some poetry will do.

I taught third grade for 6 years and loved every minute! But, I love each grade I've taught. Its their minds and spirit mingled with learning and being together "The Lion Cubs" that make loving the days I spend with my "children".
Beautiful. The joy of working with children. Nicely expressed Joanie.
Just seeing the name Langston Hughes makes me thing of the poem "A Dream Deferred," one of the most eloquent things ever written in the English language.
Nothing as darling as wise kids who know from suffering. Glad but sad that they "get it."
Yes, Langston Hughes a remarkable poet makes it so easy "to get." A wise teacher you are to choose this poem. I recall Dr. Spudman did a post on Langston Hughes way back and quoted the same poem. I miss him. Thanks for reminding me.

I come away from this wishing all the kids had the same chances and even the same lunch. The healthiest possible, chock full of protein, good carbs and fresh veggies and fruit. And homes, most of all, loving homes ...
The most important lesson for the day is that literature can be healing or at least consoling. Wonderful post, Joan.
"Life is hard, but it's beautiful"

Wow and tears... real tears..
Wonderful...simply wonderful
That's a bright and optimistic age. I fear for their future - both the rich and, especially, the poor.
Langston rocks! And those kids need him more than ever!
Love Langston and love this story, Joan. Well done.
Thanks Joan. I wanted to set some Langston Hughes pieces to music, once upon a time. But they were among a small set that spoke too directly, and my own experience wasn't up to the task. Thank you for giving him to the kids.
The fact that you knew intuitively which literature would reach those kids makes you a great teacher. My heart aches for them, having to know such hardship at such a young age, but at least they have the experience of a teacher who understands.
That was the best choice for the moment, feeding both students and teacher..
Kids hearing poetry -- Yes! Poetry & music are essential, but I know there are kids who have never heard a poem, even though poetry can get you through some hard times. I had that Langston Hughes poem on my wall for years, until it got all cracked & yellow & stained. I think if I was teaching, & seeing that big economic crack in the world, I'd have to come home & read poetry every night, wanting some magic.
I used Langston Hughes often when I was teaching English in DC and Chicago. He was always a hit.
I'm struck by the kids' snacks, as diverse as the kids and their backgrounds. Like edamame and Cheetos. I agree with Lezlie; the differences are dramatic and that's a good thing. And how great that you'd pick Langston Hughes and know they'd get it. Your post is also poetry, pure and bittersweet.
Oh, Joan, reading about your classes is always so hard and so inspiring. Namaste.
"crystal stair" What a beautiful image. Thank you for bringing such wisdom to the kids and to us.
Chicken Maan, I remember third grade clearly. We read Carl Sandburg's poetry and Rootabaga Stories.

Thanks, Mary.

Firechick, thank you, I appreciate you coming by.


LammChops, thanks for the kind words.

Pauline, if I knew how to provide a link to the poem, I would. I'm so bad at that kind of thing. It's worth looking up, though!

Jaime, thank you so much.

Mango, I like to work with all ages too, but somehow third graders seem smart and savvy, yet still innocent.

Rita, thank you. It's a great thing to share with kids.

Jonathan, :) :)

Cranky, that's one of my favorites too. I love Langston...
Our Poet of the 20th Century.
Some tribute here, Joanie.
Gosh your kids are fortunate to have you.
r.
This is a fascinating approach. I hope it catches on!

Rated for audacity.
I teach Langston Hughes to 9th graders as well in the Bronx. Gwendolyn Brooks as well. One of the most badly behaved, gang-affiliated boys in the class wrote the most insightful and thoughtful response to We Jazz June. Sad how well he could relate but thank god for poetry.
I love the wisdom of children and the compassion of you. Superb writing and heart, Joan.
A rich full snack time...lots to digest in word, thought, and Cheeto.
Who said third graders don't have any insight?
Oh, for there to be more teachers like you. And the words of poets such as Langston Hughes should be read everywhere.
What that child said at the end was beautiful! Thanks for this message to start the new year with!
Beautiful details and message. As usual.
Good for you for sharing with them something they could actually relate to. A Puerto Rican girl once told me that she didn't want to read Shakespeare because it had nothing to do with her life. I think my efforts to explain the universality of Shakespeare were wasted on her.
I love third graders. :)
Beautiful post, Joan. Kids zero in on the truth unlike we adults. Rated.
I remember the first time I heard Langston Hughes' poetry, in college, and nearly fell over in a swoon. What concise beauty. Perfect for kids of all ages.
Joanie,you do indeed touch people's hearts,and every time I see your face on OS,I think I should go to your blog,because I, like many others,would like to be near you.
I have had a teacher in grade five who was the best teacher I had ever.Apart from teaching,he taught us the most beautiful songs that I can't find in any book.I loved him dearly,and I still sing his songs when I am out in the fields bike riding.
You remind me of him.During the entire school year I was happy to have him as a teacher.
It was the poesy of the songs,the loving nature of this man and his talent to encourage the children to believe in their abilities that made him so special.
Thank you ,Joanie,for sharing,I am glad to know you.
Have a great year 2012!!!
I wish my third-grader had you for a teacher. I think she would definitely get Langston. As a sub in suburban Fairfax County, I too often marvel at the ecclectic mix of students.
Hughes, not Common, yes.
Very fortunate kids, wherever they come from.
Oh, to be that age again, when life is full of possibilities. I'd love to sit in a class of yours. You'd have to help me up from the floor, though.
Thanks to everyone for reading and commenting. I will miss this class~
Beautiful! I barely have time anymore to go on OS but this morning I randomly went on in the middle of the morning chaos and saw this. I stopped rushing for a moment, and read it to my 3rd-grade daughter before she left for school. I'm not sure she understood why my voice was cracking as I read but I told her to ask her teacher today if they could read that Langston Hughes poem--I hope she does.
Great post Joan! Langston is one of my favorites; he takes a deep message and plants it amidst understandable language. 3rd graders can "get" him...and one day grow in tolerance when they find out such a wonderful author was a black gay man:-) rated!
@Karin, thank you so much for that. I really hope your daughter's teacher will read it to them. :)
Lovely post. It's wonderful to hear the kids' response; that is a great age to teach. I wish that I thought there was some chance the kids here would learn Hughes' poetry in school, but I think that's a big, giant pipe dream! Anyway, I need to start exposing Jacob to poetry - he's old enough.
Oh so good! I'm getting some Langston Hughes for my boys now.
After having taught third grade for 18 years, I recently left the classroom for an administrative job. Thanks for helping me remember all those great moments.
You teach yoga, fractions AND Langston Hughes?? Those kids are so lucky :)
Yes, yes and yes--to the subject, to the writing and to the last line.
We do underestimate what children are capable of understanding. You get children, and that's a remarkable talent, Joan.
This is a very sad story, very well written.
Wow. Just wow. Although I'm still worried about the little boy who is losing his house. So do you, but poetry goes a long way towards making beauty from the ugliest times.
oh shit!

I'm crying. this is so good. I think what makes it so damned good is I KNOW you do this stuff, this beautiful feeling creative stuff for them. And I know you're making a difference, enriching these children with (not just langston hughes, whose pretty damned formidable) but YOU. you are an immensely gifted woman giving your loving, generous soul to them.

I know you're not a saint joan, I know you're a flesh and blood american artist sensitive creature human being woman who probably has 'moments'. but what a teacher. these kids are so lucky to be taught by a poet, in poetry.