There will be no images in this post.
The images were always the worst.
In the summer of 1999, in Jackson, Mississippi, I entered the culture wars in a way I'd never imagined.
I had been married for five years and had two children, the youngest was one year old. I found out I was pregnant. I had pre-eclampsia with both children, so I went in to the ob/gyn early to be sure I had the right care.
Everything the doctor said in that appointment sounded like it came from the depths, like hearing someone talking to me with my head underwater. I was only six weeks along, but my blood pressure was already sky-high. I had early onset pre-eclampsia, the doctor said. He told me I probably would not make it through the pregnancy, the baby certainly would not. My body hadn't "figured out yet" that I wasn't pregnant anymore, so it just carried on the symptoms from my last baby. I didn't know that was a possibility. I had waited the recommended year before getting pregnant again.
I was told by the doctor that he "could not recommend" I have an abortion. This was Mississippi after all. I had to have a life threatening reason to get an abortion from a hospital. I asked what that meant. I was told I had to have a stroke first.
I looked up abortion clinics in the phone book. I called and made an appointment. The first time you go in, they give you a pregnancy test and there is an entrance session involving brochures about adoption and public assistance. Then there is a 24 hour waiting period. The next day you go back and have the abortion.
The first day I chickened out. I saw the line of people on the sidewalk, holding signs and screaming. I knew what was coming. I had been an escort at the 9th Avenue clinic in Pensacola when I was a teenager. That was before Dr. Gunn was killed. Back then we could feel feminist and dangerous without actually thinking someone was going to gun us down in the parking lot.
The second day, I was just angry. I blasted my way through, hearing the people scream at my husband, "What kind of MAN would let their woman do this to their child?"
I did what I had to do, then left. The third day, I went again. It was like a trial by fire. I was even angrier. And I felt guilty. Very, very guilty. Abortion is not easy. Especially if you don't have the extra $100 for sedation. You basically get a mild sedative, then have your insides sucked out with what feels like a garden hose. I hated myself but I hated those people outside more. I had lost my baby and they had made it harder.
As I sat in the recovery room, I saw the "Help Wanted" sign up on the wall. They needed an intake counselor. The state's laws required that someone sit down with each woman and lay out the options, adoption, WIC, state assistance. The duties also included telling each woman what their due date would be and answering any questions.
I'll be honest. I took that job for two reasons.
1. I believed that the women who went through that should have a kind person there to answer their questions.
2. I wanted to see, feel and touch what I had just done. I hated myself and I hated the way I felt. I wanted to roll around in it and force myself to see what I had done. It was a path to absolution. It was self-torture.
My first day on the job, I was screamed at in a way I simply did not believe was possible. The team of "screamers" as we called them, was led by a husband and wife. The wife was a Catholic ob/gyn who did not prescribe birth control. The husband was a man who had nothing better to do than stand on a chair and scream.
I walked directly up to the woman and told her I was the new intake counselor. I reminded her that they had lobbied for the law which forced clinics to have these counsellors in every practice. I was the only person in that building giving women the alternatives to abortion. I was the person they had wanted to be in there. Please don't kill me.
Somehow the woman got the idea that I was one of them. A mole on the inside working for Jesus and His little fetuses. I did not disabuse her of this notion. She said everyone had their path to walk and I had chosen one that wasn't safe. I could be contaminated by the abortionists.
She evidently didn't remember that just last Tuesday, I was one of them. I suppose all the faces start to run together after awhile.
I saw a veritable parade of women. Dozens a day. Little tiny white girls clutching teddy bears, no more than 14, big-eyed and terrified, dragged in by their fathers. Young black women in flip-flops, their tears were so shiny they were like mirrors on their dark skin. Older professional women in suits, going back to work as soon as it was over, iron-jawed and unhappy. Women my age, in their twenties, obviously already mothers, mothers of many, who just looked tired and poor.
Every one of them had something in common: They needed to tell me why. It wasn't my business. I never, ever asked. But they needed to tell me why. My office was the confessional in this anti-church. They needed me to know that they were not bad people. They needed me to know why it wasn't their fault. And every last one of them said they were sorry. They apologized to me because they didn't know how else to do it.
About a month after I started, the clinic owner's son tied a rope around the chair the husband stood on so he could look over the fence at the people going in and out. He sat on the other side of the fence, waited until it was funny, then pulled the rope. The husband fell on his butt in the grass, much to my horror. But, the worst was the jar.
The jar had a baby in it. It was filled with what could only be pickling fluid and a small, very dead, baby. This jar fascinated me. I wondered where they put it when they went home. Was there a special shelf in the living room next to the family photos? Did the baby stay in the car, waiting for the next day's work? Did the baby sit on the table like some horrible centerpiece?
As he fell off the chair onto his rear, he let go of that jar. Really, the jar flew out of his hand. Up and over his head, over the sidewalk, out onto the road, where a car was coming. The jar shattered on the asphalt and the little old lady driving what could have only been the largest 1970's land barge on the road RAN OVER THE BABY.
The look of horror on everyone's face played out in slow motion. The land barge screeched to a halt. The little old lady jumped out of the car. He dashed out into traffic, and picked the baby up from underneath the tires.
I expected absolute carnage. I mean, how do you run over a pickled fetus and not squish out the insides? I was horrified. Then I saw the tire tracks. Then he dropped the baby again. It bounced. The baby was plastic.
It was the most terrifyingly hilarious thing I had ever witnessed. Sociologists say that laughter is a fear response and everything we laugh at is funny because it isn't happening to us. Our horror at putting ourselves in the place of the guy getting hit in the face with a pie makes us laugh. Oh, I laughed. I laughed until tears came streaming down my face. Then I cried until I laughed.
Two months later, I came home from work and a man was standing on the sidewalk outside of my apartment. He said hello and told me I "didn't want to go to work tomorrow." I went inside and called the police. They were unimpressed. It takes a lot to impress the Jackson, Mississippi police department.
The next morning, I went to work. I had developed the almost obsessive habit of checking the dumpster outside my office. It sat on the other side of a brick wall from my desk. Someone had left a present. Literally.
It was square and yellow with a big blue bow. It looked fake, like it had been created by Martha Stewart as a stage prop. I ran inside, told the manager and the police were called. Six hours later they showed up and took the package away. It was blown up in a field somewhere, yielding nothing but a lot of pieces of cardboard box.
I never went back to work.
Every single day I regret the abortion I had. I wish it had been different. And every single day I regret that I can't do that job. I loved that job. And I wish the screamers could have seen what I saw.
Today I have four children, healthy and perfect. I wonder what my baby would have been like, who they would have been, if it was a mistake. Sarah Palin's candidacy has reopened this argument in America. The rhetoric has become shrill and accusatory. I do not question Ms. Palin's choices as a mother. I can't. All I ask is that she not question mine.
That, my friends, is feminism. It is choice. The debate about a Palin Vice-Presidency should not begin and end with what sort of mother she is. There are many, many issues other than abortion when it comes to running this country. But until you've held a 13 year old rape victim's hand, looked into her eyes and told her it'll all be over soon, keep your hands off my uterus.


Salon.com
Comments
rated
In some ways, I think you are a perfect example of the need to keep abortion legal. I know you regret having the abortion, but it sounds like you were in considerable danger if you didn't. Not having that option could have left your family without a wife and mother.
I live near that clinic. A few times a week one or two people will be standing on the sidewalk with signs. Only occasionally is there a sizable crowd. The couple you speak of--the OB-GYN wife and her non-working husband--are pretty seriously cracked in my opinion. The husband is particularly unhinged.
I also know one of the doctors who occasionally worked at that clinic long ago. I can't wait to tell her your bouncing fetus story. It won't surprise her, but it will give her a laugh.
Thank you, dear. You are a gem.
(I know OS time is ridiculously fast, so I am deliberately ignoring the time stamps.)
Oh, that was an interesting time. Jackson is a rare bird amongst cities. When they busted Eric Rudolph, he had a list of clinics in his car with a veritable pantload of C-4. We were on his list.
Good times...
That guy's name was Roy. I remember that. His wife looked like a nervous little finch. Shouldn't they be getting too old for this b.s. about now?
Man, the hours we could spend sharing stories, particularly if we had a bit of bourbon or wine to keep the conversation flowing ;D
I'm so glad you steered me to this piece. I didn't know about it. This is so powerful. Have you considered writing a book? We should talk.
I had a second-trimester miscarriage. Some folks, when they found out, asked me if this had changed my mind about choice. Or, friends found it difficult to express sympathy because they didn't want to think of that fetus as a person. But we know the difference between a pregnancy that is welcomed from its very moment and the ones that send us to clinics.
Thank you. Just thank you.
Everyone has their different ways of dealing with things. I have met a lot of women who felt so badly over their own abortion that they became serious anti-abortion activists. There's something inside every woman that reacts viscerally to this topic.
For me, I needed to SEE it and FEEL it as much as I could. I worked through what I needed to in order to survive. If I can use that to change the way folks think about the issue, then it wasn't in vain.
My only serious regret is that I cannot do this job again. I loved this work and it made me feel like I was *doing* something. But, I can't put myself in that kind of danger when I have four little ones to think about.
What a world...
Is it possible to re-post pieces? If it is, you might want to consider reposting this one so it has the chance at a bigger audience. Very well done.
This is a masterpiece. I'm sorry you had to go through what you had to go through to get here, though. But this is the real.
Rated with pleasure.
(Is there some kind of medication one can take to cure word-drop? I do it constantly.)
The reasons women have for needing an abortion are wide and varied and, as one who can speak from experience, if I decide I need and want one waiting for 24 hours won't change my mind, nor will the crazies with plastic fetuses in jars (that was very funny BTW, with a Tim Robbins style twist.)
I don't blame you for having the crap scared out of you by the bombers, we all have just one life, and that is our own. The lack of police protection is as abominable as are the rules enacted by and imposed by the State, once more having the most deleterious affect on those who are poor. Some states have so few clinics that a poor woman who cannot afford to stay overnight somewhere may be forced to endure a home abortion or to birth a child she cannot properly raise.
Whew.
(Followed a link from a comment on your equally thought-provoking "Equal Rights" piece. Felt compelled to sign up so I could leave this comment.)
Peter B (23), Ireland
I woke up this morning thinking of Sondra Sotomayor, and how "pro-life" groups are raking her over the coals already, and wondering: didn't we settle this goddamn argument in 1973 already?
I'm a mother who carried two planned pregnancies to term, I know what it is to have that choice, and that's what I want for my daughters.
Mary Elizabeth Williams's apt question reminds me of the OS question the other day, asking how the CA Supreme Court's decision on Prop 8 "affects you." It affects me in the same way that the continuing noise--not debate--over abortion affects me: It distracts people from dealing with real national issues because they're focusing instead on what are, in truth, deeply personal and not political issues.
Yes, it should all be about choice. I'm not in favor of abortion. Who is? But I am definitely in favor of choice. As a man, I know I can't imagine the feelings of a woman, or girl, who chooses to have an abortion--or not to. (Though this piece certainly provides some inkling.) But who the hell am I to tell a woman what she has to do? How she must live the next decades of her life?
No, when the Founders wrote the Bill of Rights, they didn't think that the rights reserved to the people would include aborion. But they didn't think that it was necessary to stipulate that those reserved rights included the right to decide whom to marry, or how to raise one's children, or whether to have children, or where to live, or any of the myriad personal decisions that the government has absolutely no business dictating.
Once again, a great piece of writing--and an important statement in the (alas, ongoing) national debate.
From what I understand, that is the only clinic. They do the waiting period, obviously, to make you come back so you have to go through the rows of bastards again.
I once got information on starting an abortion fund--how it could be done--because I'd read our state didn't have one, and I'd read of women who literally had a baby because they couldn't afford gas money to our clinic or ones in AL or TN.
I'll admit, I never got far, but I still think of doing it. My grandma died at 42 of cancer, and I will always wonder if the fact that she lifted heavy furniture to induce miscarriages and not bring more children into her brutal, impoverished life was part of the cause.
YOU ARE ONE COURAGEOUS BROAD!!! You have nothing to be ashamed of. Why are these people even allowed near the clinic?? Because our state senate allows it, I guess.
You are quite right that people should not scream. It starts there. On both sides. That I have never understood, even though I, like John Walker, am not a favorite of current abortion law for a variety of reasons, although I am the first to point out what the Right will not admit, which is that the current economic order is way too selfish for its own collective reproductive and spiritual health. Look at family life these days; kind of a distant, fading echo of a much more connected world not too long ago.
But........ that does not excuse simplistic abusive rhetoric about the abortion question, and especially actions, like threatening poeple; not acceptable, period.
Most people who think about abortion have mixed feelings, just like many of those who have had them have mixed feelings about them, from what I have seen. Ya wonder, what if...? But that is life.
Lots of parents are bitter about the kids they have too; I know someone who told him constantly that if abortion would have been legal, he would have been gone. That was hard to grow up with. I know someone who was difficult as a child, whose mother is trying to kill him daily.
But then, people who give their kids away for adoption have mixed feelings too.
I have witnessed that, a wonderful woman, with some issues for sure, like everyone else, which everyone likes to stomp on because it is easy, if you are a coward, cry for almost a year most nights, after giving her baby girl away. Forgive yourself.
Pro-life people talk about adoption as an option, but there is a deep pain there too, sometimes a lot, for a lot of people.
Unless you were celibate before you marriage night on the Christian Right, quit judging people too harshly; judge not that ye not be judged
Although I think that part of the Right is half right that part of the biggest American problem now is in fact a collapse of sexual restraints that we need as a civilization in order to maintain order; not very exciting, but it beats the alternatives.
But I still look at my eye's own timber, not my neighbor's splinter.
You did the right thing in your case, as far as you, or anyone else, can know. In a place like Mississippi, if he said that, he probably thought you were in real danger, life and death, and that if it was his daughter, that was the right call. I am from Alabama, that is why he did it I bet. :)
I think mandatory counseling is reasonable for abortion, if done right, for exactly the reasons you spoke of in your piece.
People wonder. Not counseling to pressure, but like, o.k. what is the whole situation here, can we bring people in, like the potential father, the potential grandparents, who raised me for example,can people stop the screaming at each other so we can think minute, is there an adoptive/foster care parent that resembles them in a computer database, or a relative, and get together, and come up with a reasonable plan and/or list of options. Help, in the right form, but not judge. That is cruel, and not given to us by God.
Because I am glad I am here, most days, but I also do not judge others, because you have to live a life inside someone's head completely to understand it. rated.
Thanks for sharing.
Kudos to you.
On another note, I am really, really distressed at some comments you have made about personal attacks via email (non OS) and PHONE CALLS! I am so sorry that the misinterpretation of your words could provoke such an appalling invasion of privacy.
Please be well this weekend, and I look forward to your next post.
I am sending a lot of good, good vibes your way.
This blog entry is the most personal thing I have ever written. It is important to remember that no matter what your personal feelings on abortion are, there is a person in every clinic in this country doing this job. I mourn that I cannot do it safely.
I lost my child because I didn't want to take the risk of leaving my other children without a mother. I made the decision to stop doing the job for the same reason. I continue to fight for reproductive rights for all women.
If you want to protect that right, please visit NARAL: Pro-Choice America. If you're Pro-Life, please consider volunteering in a pregnancy crisis center. I've been both a volunteer and a beneficiary of PCC's and I honor their mission.
Above all, speak with your children early and often about sexual issues. Protect them by educating them. Limiting the need for abortion limits the number that are performed.
I appreciate the compliments about my courage. Before I was a counselor I escorted at a clinic for two years. Believe me, that was much worse. There was no retreat into an office. I've been hit, kicked, punched and shoved. After you have someone scream, "BURN IN HELL!" and then spit in your face, a phoned-in hissy fit looks pretty minor.
I suppose that no matter what the context, I never obey when told to sit down and shut up.
At least when I'm done with my statement I'll give good hugs.
Peace to all of you and to the millions of women touched by this heartbreaking issue.
Rated.
If we could all sit down together and share our tables and our lives, we would all be better for it. Great points, RL. No one should have to be afraid.
I have my own shoes I have to wear, but they seem an awful lot like yours. I have shared my story elsewhere, so I know of the courage it took to hit post, twice.
Rated
Sarah Palin would do well to read this post or, better yet, sit down and listen to your story in person. I think she is like too many people who can't get past their own blind revulsion and even try to appreciate how difficult a choice these girls face. But then she couldn't be as digestibly black-and-white as she is.