The View Under the Hat

John Hummel

John Hummel
Location
Tampa, Florida, USA
Bio
Husband, father of three, enjoys rainbows, books, video games, and thinking too deeply about things.

NOVEMBER 30, 2009 6:31AM

The War on Christmas - Batter Down

Rate: 8 Flag

Jesus at FenwayWhen I was growing up, my friends were obsessed with sports. Baseball cards (which they were certain would lead to riches to pay for college) or tracking the stats of any given team. As their fervor grew, there came to be camps favoring one team over the other.

If you were a fan of the local Portland Trailblazers, then you were “cool.” Didn’t matter if you couldn’t name a single player. Didn't matter if you were the guy who knocked over mailboxes and kicked babies - nobody could be a Trailblazers lover and be entirely bad. Everyone was excited to have the Trailblazers win any game. Wearing T-shirts, singing the songs they made up for them on the radio, talking about how awesome it would be to have them win the championships.

Of course, everyone agreed that the players from every other team (except maybe Michael Jordan, who everybody thought was awesome) were losers. They sucked. *You* sucked if you liked any player of any other team ever.

We all knew they sucked! Why? Well, because they didn’t play for the Trailblazers! They had to be rotten players, or cheated all the time, or just all around smelled bad. Like poop.

 If you weren’t a store that didn’t festoon your place of business with Trailblazers regalia, or have your employees where Trailblazers shirts, or hats, or at least a pin – well, what kind of creeps were you? Trailblazer haters, that’s what you were! If the radio of the market wasn’t turned to playing the game that night so people could rush from their cars into the store to breathlessly ask “What’s the score?”, then clearly you were simply unfit to live for the crime of being anti-Trailblazers.

And Heaven help you if you ever admitted to liking some other team, especially at school. It was like the kiss of death for your popularity. You would be shunned into Outer Darkness. Your entire family consigned into utter black holes of reputation. People would even despise your *dog* for being a Trailblazers hater.

You didn’t even have to *say* you didn’t like the Trailblazers. If you didn’t proclaim your love of the Trailblazers – well, then you still sucked. It was the Trailblazers, or nothing.

It’s not just the Trailblazers that inspire this sort of outrage. Any team anywhere in the country – I’d dare say anywhere in the world – can inspire this kind of devotion. Who hasn’t heard of Red Sox fans supportive of their team to almost violence? Or fans of Manchester United taking to the streets in rage when their team wins or loses?

Or – people freaking out because you wish them Happy Holidays instead of Merry Christmas?

You’ve probably heard the stories by now of American Family Association deciding to boycott Gap, Inc because they didn’t mention “Christmas” in their holiday ads. Even though at the beginning of their “Holiday songs”, they clearly did. It’s not enough, we’re told, to wish people Happy Holiday.

Nope – if it’s not “Merry Christmas”, then you suck. You’re evil. You are ignoring everything the holiday is about.  You know, the celebration of Saturnus, or the Yule Gods of Germanic lineage, or any number of things before Christians came onto the scene.

It doesn’t matter that there are several religions that celebrate that time period. See, our team is the most important one. It has the best players on it, the best colors and shirts and hats and if you don’t love it as much as we do – then you must be an awful person! And you smell bad – like poop!

The more I look at the “War on Christmas” nonsense, or really any other “if you’re not in my religion than you must be a bad person” arguments, the more I realize it’s about people treating their faith as sports teams. It’s not about using religious beliefs as a moral code to treat others more humanely, to care for the sick and the poor. It’s not about reading through religious beliefs to get some idea of what reality is, what the Divine has in store for humanity.

Nope. It’s a game with competing players, and if you’re not on *my* team, if you don’t acknowledge that *my* side is the best of them all – then you’re a big hater of my side, and I’m going to hate on all of you and your family and your business and you’re stupid dog until you do.

It’s the same attitude described by American Family Association because The Gap isn’t putting Christmas on every T-shirt they sell with a big picture of baby Jesus saying “Born of 100% Authentic Virgin!”. It’s the attitude of a town hosting a nativity set on a public square that felt that heaven forbid the local atheists group have a sign praising atheistic veterans. I mean – they weren’t even asking to take the nativity set down, just to acknowledge there were other beliefs out there.

Not good enough for that town – it was Jesus plus nothing, or nothing. And since then, people have been protesting because those mean, evil atheists had the audacity to say there was some other team other than the Trailblazers (I mean, Christianity) and ruined all their fun by making them have to take their ball and go home rather than admit another team even *exists*.

Or the family suing because a nativity set isn’t allowed in the public square any more. I mean, it always has before! Everyone knows the Christmas is the bestest greatest holiday ever, and if you don’t agree then you’re plainly evil!

I don’t mean to feel like I’m picking on just the Christians, but there is this vocal annoying subset that gets worked up every year because they feel they are the most important thing on this planet from December 1st until December 26th, and curse you if you feel otherwise. And I ask, with all humility, with all understanding:

Please shut the hell up.

If you’re going to attend your religion, great. Want to festoon your house with lights and trees and Jesus statues next to Frosty the Snowman and Santa offering a crib to the Virgin Mary – more power to you. Want to go to your friend’s houses and sings carols, or host a big event at your church? Swell. I’m all for it.

But if you’re going to get all pissy because I say “Happy Holidays” to acknowledge my Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, Santeria, atheist, *and* Christian friends to include everyone in this time of year – you know, the time decided to “Peace on Earth, Good Will to Men” by your own religion – well, then I guess I’m going to have to take my authentic 1991 Trailblazers basketball and go play with my friends and leave you to rant and rave on your own.

Because you *suck*.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Yeayyy! for you! New way of thinking about it for me. They deal in extreme alienation techniques to make Christianity seem exclusive and the only right religion. Everybody wants to feel special. However, "In my father's house are many mansions," Jesus said. "If it were not true, I would have told you." It gets me how so many people just adapt the Bible to their own xenophobic purposes and call themselves followers of Jesus. Thanks for this.
Thanks. From someone who does not celebrate Christmas (see my post on this called Santa, Baby????Help!) and is so damned annoyed be all this and has been for years.
Unfortunately, the American Taliban will try to make hay out of this. The fact is our country is much more culturally diverse than 300 years ago, slavery notwithstanding.

As someone who is not a Christian, I can relate to this post.
@Penrose: You're most welcome - and I think the term "xenophobic" certainly applies. I'm hoping this is the last, desperate gap of a majority that is feeling their power slip away.

@Lisa: i used to be Christian myself, but even back then I never felt why "Happy Holidays" was so bad. I mean, if nothing else it's better than "Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year" - but I think some people don't care as long as *their* views are the only valid ones.

@OESheepdog: I'm sure they will - which is why everyone has to do more to combat them. My method is shaming them, by showing how childish they are. Others can afford the legal challenges, others are far better philosophers than I. My personal bet is we just have to wait another 20-30 years as the oldest and most stupid either die off or are so marginalized we don't have to care about them - like the KKK, in a way.
My very VERY Christian in-laws have been very vocal about their need to have everything in their home Christmas-y this year.

My revenge for this particular assholery? I sent them Happy Hanukkah cards. By mistake, of course.
@AshKW: Actually, that's my favorite thing. When people do the "Merry Christmas" in the clearly obnoxious way, I wish them Happy Hanukkah - I have enough Jewish ancestry to pull it off ;).
I specifically bought Hanukkah cards, just for them. My husband told me not to waste my energy, but I enjoyed every minute of it.
@Ashkw: You are the wind beneath my wiiiiings ;).
What's even more ridiculous is that the term "Happy Holidays" ORIGINALLY was used instead of Christians saying, "Merry Christmas and Happy New Year." - both of which are Christian holidays! So these idiots are just shooting themselves in the foot by protesting this "Happy Holidays" term - a term that they themselves invented.
i love your post.

i met a woman last year while i was christmas shopping and she'd convinced herself that you weren't allowed to say "merry christmas" at her child's school. she told me all about how oppressed she was and how awful the administration was, and so i asked her how she knew about this rule and whether it could be changed. then she admitted that she'd never even asked anyone about it. i think she made it up.

i really have no sympathy for that. wallowing in paranoia is a weird way to be festive.

and as ash says, it just makes you more fun for the rest of us. mithra or bust!
The sports team analogy is a great one - very apt. I am a Christian and I don't have any problem with Happy Holidays. I don't think there should be Christmas celebrations/ symbols in public schools, or nativities on public land. I will go to Midnight Mass and I will have a Christmas tree, and I know that the two are very different aspects of a holiday that's come to mix religious remembrance with silly secular nonsense. The AFA should shut up in my opinion. I am NOT on any team with them!!
@tregibbs: I'm beginning to think that's the way it works: someone comes up with something for their faith, then 40 years later people forget why it's there and rail against it.

It's like those who want to get down to the "Christian roots" of the holiday - forgetting the Puritans forbade the celebration of Christmas because of its pagan ties.

@bstrangely: I've found that a lot - people assuming that "rules are in place to keep me down", but they can't ever seem to name them. Or who made them (usually "some liberal"). It's like former child actor Kirk Cameron going on a rant about how children can't pray in school. Hint, Kirk: they can, they just can't be lead into prayer or preach to the fellow students during class time.

@Blue in TX: Well, I know you're on *my* team, but that's because you're awesome ;).
Good analogy. I had a lengthy discussion with another artist in my community about our "Holiday Show" which he wanted renamed to "Christmas Show" since it was, you know, Christmas. I explained to him that I wanted Hindus, Pagans, Jews and Muslims to all come and spend money to buy our work. Duh. He kinda got it, but you could see he didn't want to be logical - it was all emotional for him.
@Ardee: What I find interesting is there's clearly a marketing/capitalistic reason to use "Happy Holidays" - it's shorter than "Happy X, Y, Z holiday!" It's inclusive so everyone of all religions can be a part - which means you draw a greater crowd than before.

And yet - the people that seem to think that Christianity == capitalism, but would punish those who want to profit the most by selling to the highest number.
I got the part about the Trailblazers, but what's that got to do with the Fenway Tee shirt. You can trash all the Christmas nonsense but you gotta tread lightly on the Bosox.

Seriously, much applause for this piece. There's actually a house on my girl friend's street that really has Santa, Snowman, Bambi, and assorted other imaginary people surrounding a creche. They've got enough lights on their house to see by a low flying saucer or balloon. I love the seasonal lighting displays and always feel sad when the people take them down again...but Christmas, well, Bah Humbug indeed.
So true, John. In fact, the ultra conservative religious loons are (and have been) pushing for all traditional things Christmas (i.e trees, wreaths, feasts, celebrations, music, presents, etc) to be banned completely, since they represent the pagan holiday, not Christ's birth (which, by the way, was in June, not December). The right-wingers are simply using the fabricated "war on Xmas" as a way to promote their political agendas. It's actually a fantastic litmus test for discovering who is truly religious and who is politically motivated.