It's Not Really My Own Little World Anymore

- Or Isn't It?

John Leonard

John Leonard
Location
Shoreline, Washington, US
Birthday
August 12
Title
I think
Bio
I suppose that I should give some sort of Bio - I'm a superannuated Boston transplant to the Seattle area who came out when the bottom fell out of the Telecom industry a few years back. Engineering just ain't what it used to be and it's unlikely it ever will be again. I'll get over it. I've lived here for five years and doubt that I'll ever get used to the west coast. That may not be a bad thing.

MY RECENT POSTS

John Leonard's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
MARCH 24, 2009 12:05PM

Collateral Damage in the War on Drugs

Rate: 11 Flag

Back in 2003, Savana Redding had a very bad day at school, you can read about it in today's NY Times . She was a 13 year-old eighth grader at the time, and it seems that one of her friends, having been caught with a couple of tabs of prescription-strength ibuprofen (Advil to the rest of us) informed the school administrators at her Safford, AZ middle school that she got them from Savana.

To make a long story short, Savana was strip-searched for Advil without there being any real evidence that she had hidden any on her body. She says that she wasn't even asked if she had any before being searched.

Now, I'll admit that I'm no phararmacologist, but I don't see Advil as a drug with a high abuse potential, even the prescription grade stuff which is 400 mg vs. the 200 mg pills we all pop out of the bottle.  But, it seems that the school had adopted a"zero-tolerance" policy regarding drugs and Advil was, in their eyes,the same as crack cocaine.

The school's lawyers stated that  the scool was “on the front lines of a decades-long struggle against drug abuse among students.”. I think this says more than the lawyer really wanted to say about the school administration's minsdset. In many, if not most, jurisdictions being a child verges on being a criminal offense and prison inmates have more rights than students. But it seems that at this school, students have now advanced to being illegal enemy combatants. Well, the battle has progressed to the SCOTUS. I expect and hope that she will win there, but on the Scalito court nothing's for sure.

Unfortunately, the collateral damage will include not just Savana, but the rest of the kids in the school system and a small town's taxpayers who will need to pay for a school administration's knee-jerk policy.

Author tags:

news

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
How pathetic this zero-tolerance policy (and others like it) is. It rests on the premise that there can be no extenuating circumstances. There can ALWAYS be extenuating circumstances.
Exactly. I think "zero-tolerance" been taken up in multiple areas in an effort to avoid judgment calls and to limit school administrations' liability. What it actually does is create a guilty-until-proven-innocent system that make over-reaction and dehumanization a virtual certainty.
I'm surprised at nothing about Arizona. Arpaio and border vigilantes and groping thirteen year olds. And, of course, the gun laws:

Child Access Prevention Law? No

Rifles and shotguns:
* Permit to purchase rifles and shotguns? No
* Registration of rifles and shotguns? No
* Licensing of owners of rifles and shotguns? No
* Permit to carry rifles and shotguns? No

Handguns
* Permit to purchase handgun? No
* Registration of handguns? No
* Licensing of owners of handguns? No
* Permit to carry handguns? Yes

Carrying:
* A handgun carried in a belt holster which is wholly or partially visible or carried in luggage is not considered carrying concealed.

Advil - NO! Guns - YES!

WOOF
Schools should stick to educating, and leave matters of crimefighting to the police.

I can understand the whole zero-tolerance thing regarding weapons in school, but ibuprofen? Seriously? If that was my kid, I'd be suing the bastards too.

Thumbed.
we're on the same page. Absolutely disgusting what they did in the name of Zero Tolerance. (sic)
thumbed
CCC - We need to remember that the controls needed in a rural area are not necessarily the same as those needed in an urban one. But, I do think there need to be some minimum requirements, e.g. training and a background check. But yeah, the disparity isn't lost on me.

Bill and fingerlakeswimmer - I'm right there with you.
Excuse me - that should be "fingerlakeswanderer".
Nah, bored kids never get into trouble. Why, let's examine my own sterling record as an example ... on second thought, let's not and just say "plus ca change...
What those adminstrators did was disgusting. Rated.

Also please see my post, "War On Drugs = War On Sanity."
I agree 100% that zero-tolerance policies are a lazy person's substitute for having to make judgment calls. It is also a horrible example to set for the children! Don't think, kids. Just have a set of absolutes that you can call on to absolve you of responsibility for your actions (or inactions).
Interesting that there are pockets of people who see such polarities in everything. There ARE terrible things, but Advil is not one. Here the slightest dip into "gray" = BLACK/BAD. What kind of people really want to live like this?
Unfortunately, neither guns, nor drugs, nor bureaucratic idiocy know any bounds as far as small town or big city. They are everywhere. But decisions can't be made in a black/white world. It would make life simpler, but it's just not the world we live in.
They did not have to call her parents or anything? That is insane. Ibuprofen in high doses makes me sick to my stomach so I really can't see anyone being addicted to it! I hope she wins too.
Apparently not, SJ.

I think that (to borrow a phrase) they were of teh mindset that "Screwing over a kid means never having to say you're sorry".
I read the story in the NYT, and I've read 3 or 4 columns on it here, and it still gets me steaming mad. Man, if that'd been my kid, they wouldn't have had to worry about a lawsuit, they'd have had to worry about me in their offices avenging my kid, and I can be much scarier than a lawyer.

Ahem.

The above attitude is what made me a really really good foster care clinician. :)
Christine, remind me to *never* piss you off!
Heh....you are not the first person to tell me that. Don't worry, I won't be scary at you, I like you. :D