Judy Mandelbaum

Judy Mandelbaum
Location
Brooklyn, New York, United States
Birthday
June 01
Bio
Freelance writer, editor, and first citizen of Judy's World.

Judy Mandelbaum's Links

Women and society
Travel
No links in this category.
Fiction
Haiti
The Jewish world and Israel
War and peace
Women and Islam
History
Africa
MAY 21, 2010 11:39AM

Malawi's "barbaric" homophobia has "civilized" roots

Rate: 4 Flag

American and European human rights activists are right to decry the conviction on Tuesday of a gay Malawian couple for behavior “against the order of nature.” They are also right to denounce the way some Americans, particularly fundamentalist Christian clergy, have taken an active part in promoting the persecution of gays across Africa (see Jonathan Wolfman’s OS post today). But the West’s effort to demonize gay people actually reaches much deeper than most of us imagine. 

Felix Zalimba 
Homophobe Malawian cleric Felix Zalimba
(Source: All for Jesus Church)

Many of those who regard anti-gay laws like those of Malawi as “barbaric” are unaware that it was the “civilized” European powers and American missionaries who introduced them in the first place. The Malawian law dates back to 1940, when the country was a colony of Britain. It only gained its independence in 1964. According to human rights activist Peter Tatchell, writing in a guest commentary for The Independent 

Before the British came and conquered Malawi, there were no laws against homosexuality. These laws are a foreign imposition, they are not African at all. Despite independence, these alien criminalisations were never repealed. Today, the minds of many Malawians – and other Africans – remain colonised by the homophobic beliefs that were drummed into their forebears by the western missionaries who invaded their lands alongside the conquering imperial armies.  

Citing historian Rudi C. Bley’s book The Geography of Perversion: Male-To-Male Sexual Behavior Outside the West and the Ethnographic Imagination, 1750-1918, Tatchell reveals that

[t]he missionaries preached a harsh, intolerant Christianity, which has been so successfully internalised by many Africans that they now claim homophobia as their own culture and tradition. While many African leaders decry homosexuality as a “western disease” or a “white man's import”, the truth is very different.

The Malawians, Steven Monjeza and Tiwonge Chimbalanga, both in their twenties, had already been living together for five months without incident in Chirimba township when they decided to invite their neighbors over for a chinkhoswe or traditional engagement ceremony. After the local newspaper presented a front page story on the ceremony, they were arrested on December 28 and have been held in a maximum security prison ever since. Far from wishing to start a sexual revolution, the men claim they were merely naïve about the legal consequences of what they regarded as a harmless public declaration of love. They were sentenced to fourteen years of hard labor yesterday. 

Malawi couple 
Steve Monjeza (left) and Tiwonge Chimbalanga are shown
celebrating their engagement last December

Upon hearing the news, "Apostle" Rev. Felix Zalimba, pastor of the “All for Jesus Church” in Blantyre, proclaimed to a jeering homophobic crowd that “God calls homosexuality an abomination, which is greater than a simple sin. … These two must repent and ask God’s forgiveness. Otherwise, they will surely go to hell.”  Thirty-eight out of fifty-three African nations have passed legislation criminalizing gay sex between consenting adults, and they have received a lot of outside help in doing so.   

Tatchell continues: 

Prior to colonisation, many tribal societies and kingdoms had a more relaxed attitude to same-sex relations than their subsequent colonial occupiers. …[T]he existence and, sometimes toleration, of same-sex acts was used by the colonising European nations to justify what they saw as their “civilising” mission. To them, homosexuality among the indigenous peoples was proof of their “barbarity” and confirmation of western theories of racial superiority.   

 

None of this can justify the cruel sentence that a spiteful Malawian judge has imposed on two of his fellow citizens. But it should serve as a reminder that in this case too, Africa’s path to “modernity” has had to take a long detour through what we were once proud to call “Western civilization.” 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Thanks for reporting on this.
Rated.
Judy,

While your comments might be 'true', emphasizing the origins of the willingness to persecute gays is like giving a pass to a murderer because he/she had a tough childhood.
Overcoming the bad influences of one's childhood, not yielding to them, is a mark of achievement and civilization, unfortunately sadly lacking both in Africa and the West.

L
I disagree with the post from "L, the traveler" criticizing the article for describing the origins of homophobia in modern Africa, instead of solely attacking that homophobia as it now stands.

I am grateful to Ms. Mandelbaum for pointing out the origins of this hateful nonsense, and for mentioning that it is still happening. I'd like to go further and identify one of the sources: the C Street cult in Washington, DC, known as "The Family" and consisting of several congressman as well as its ordinary members. Jeff Sharlet has written a book ( also called "The Family") and Rachel Maddow has given their anti-African-gay efforts coverage several times in the past year.

And by way of additional background, I'd like to mention that Tiwonge Chimbalanga identifies as a woman, though she is anatomically still male. See

http://www.rhrealitycheck.org/reader-diaries/2010/05/22/interest-equality-malawian-womans-identity-erased
Ankhorite,
Thanks for mentioning "The Family," it has a very long arm indeed.