Bankruptcy Blues

One woman, two cancers, and a cash crunch

Julie White

Julie White
Location
Ohio, USA
Birthday
June 16
Title
writer, editor, dreamer-in-chief
Company
self
Bio
After careers in teaching and librarianship, as well as a stint at editing, I jumped ship to become a freelance writer. I have worked primarily in educational publishing. Two years ago, I took a part-time job at a library, trying to make ends meet. I'm using a pseudonym, but in my real life I live in a walkable village and try to avoid crazy cat lady tendencies by sticking to two at a time.

MY RECENT POSTS

Julie White's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
OCTOBER 22, 2011 8:37PM

Stiffing the Hospital

Rate: 15 Flag

The latest and last-for-now hospital bill had finally arrived, so I could file for bankruptcy. I knew the full extent of my indebtedness to all three hospitals where my seven surgeries had taken place. The last one wasn’t awful, in and of itself—under two thousand dollars for the half day required for an outpatient surgery. It covered the nice woman at the reception desk, the pre-op nurse, the bed and its warming system, the drugs (though not the anesthesiologist’s service), the use of the operating room and its equipment and personnel, the post-op nurse, the discharge folks. And of course basic stuff like helping to pay for the electricity and running water. A bargain, really.

I didn’t and don’t begrudge them this. They earned it, and this bill was only a small portion of what the services would have cost on the open market. The original total charge was $13,341.47, which my insurance company whittled away because this hospital is in their network. Which means I won’t drop insurance yet—the almost twelve thousand dollar difference for just this one statement makes it cost-effective. If I can’t pay even the bill I received, how could I hope to ever repay $13,000? And I’m mindful of the fact that I have needed one of these surgeries annually since they found the cancer.

This hospital offers a partial payment plan—I would have to call to set it up, just as I had done with the other two hospitals. One of them didn’t charge interest, but the other did. I was new to this hospital (what a way to begin the relationship!), so I didn’t know what their policy was. They offered financial assistance, but I was not at or below the federal poverty guidelines.

They also presented the option, as all these invoices do, to pay with Mastercard, Visa, Discover, or American Express. I once had all those cards, but they’re no longer an option.

Going into surgery, I knew that I had been advised to include this bill with the bankruptcy. I felt, and still feel, fraudulent about this. My lawyer’s advice sheet states plainly Do not use credit cards within 90 days of filing! What about surgery 90 days before filing? The healthcare system is still broken. The hospital and I will both go on; I’m the only one who feels guilty and broken.

Broken, not just physically with cancer, but broken because I can’t do math and don’t care about money. If I were living in an ancient African civilization, I might have been able to care about cowrie shells—they’re pretty and tactile, a great form of currency. But paper money (invented by the Chinese, by the way) especially with pictures of dead presidents and statesmen, nary a woman in sight, all of it green, without even a variation of color as Canadian money has, or interesting birds or flowers as some Caribbean paper money depicts, just doesn’t do it for me.

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
So much for "the best health care in the world." In fact, our health care system is almost literally off the charts due to it unique combnation of high costs and crappy outcomes. Thanks for posting this.
Sad, sad commentary on a broken system. I am on Medicare-- and all of us should be!
My husband is in the healthcare business, and I still feel outraged at stories like yours. May you be blessed with good health from here on -- and hospital bills be damned.
Well, in the "socialist hell" that is Canada's medical system, this would never happen. You would definitely be out of pocket on some items, but you would not be bankrupted.
Speaking of Canadian (hi Emma - you're all over OS tonight!), under our system your medical expenses would be paid out of a pool of tax money collected by the government. You don't have to negotiate with hospitals or anything, and health insurance is not tied to employment. There are no blood-sucking health insurance companies deciding how much coverage they'll give you. Nobody here goes bankrupt from medical expenses. The American system is stupid and venal. If the entire *occupy* movement were just about health-care, it would be understandable. (But there's so much more there in the good ole USA - we don't have foreclosures on every block and our banks were regulated. However, the American mess may ultimately take us down too...and maybe the rest of the world with it.)
A bill of $13,341.47 that can be whittled down to under $2,000 by your insurance company means that that $13,341.47 is a totally false cost. Real discounts are 10 to 15% of a cost, your bill had an 85% "discount."

What's really going on is wacky accounting designed to manipulate Medicaid, Medicare and insurance companies. And anyone without insurance gets hammered by a ridiculous bill which is 7oo% higher than the actual cost of care.

I think there should be a class action suit to prevent this kind of price gouging.
Malusinka - I think there should be riots in the streets. Trouble is, sick people are in no condition to riot.
I don't care about money either. Just get well and be happy somehow. And thanks so much for writing about what people face everyday. It is a horrible system.
Ditto to everything said so far, can't think of anything else to add.

Just wanted you to know that if/when I find myself facing a health crisis I'll be paddling in the next boat over from yours :(.

Rated for sympathy.
Rated in solidarity. My husband has cancer. I wrote about the impossibility of ever paying off our bills in my now-nuked blog, and will do so again, if I ever get a chance. I typically work 60 hours a week as a special ed teacher. We shop at Goodwill and get our food from the food bank, and ends still refuse to meet. Never thought an intelligent, hardworking person with a Master's degree and a job could ever get this poor, but it's happened.

Only in America do you have to be healthy so that you can work so that you can have health insurance which you don't benefit from unless you're unhealthy which means you'll lose your job and you won't have health insurance anymore. Looking Glass logic.

Respectful best wishes to you.
It is wonderful that you got care. Was it good? Are you satisfied with the actual care?

If, and maybe I'm missing something, the bill is about 13,000, you could opt for the payment plan. We do it with other things in life and maybe you'll consider that option.

This actually shows that ONE) Medical care is very expensive, but TWO) is available to those who don't have the cash up front to pay for it (which is most people) and THREE) hospitals, at least in your case which I suspect is not atypical, WILL work with people to help them arrange a payment plan.

It is awful to have debt, but it is at times part of reality and at least you have your health and, it sounds like - unless I'm missing something - a way to handle this short of bankruptcy.

BTW, I do admit that maybe I misread and the bill is more than 13,000 or so??? If this is annual, that is steep, but it is something that you may find you are able to handle.

Good luck.
Thanks to all for intelligent and sympathetic comments. Barbara, the problem continues to be that care continues, and from the moment of bankruptcy, one is responsible going forward. Payment plans, yes, and now discounts because I make so little money at my part-time job in academe, where health care is bestowed on the favored, full-time faculty and staff. (My monthly salary will cover my self-pay insurance, which goes up every year by more than $100/month, but doesn't stretch for rent, too.) I cannot count on freelance work to make up the difference. I will be setting up a payment plan for the most recent CATscan and surgery. I have no complaints about my medical care--my doctors and nurses have been terrific! Emma, if Canada could do something about the climate, I'd move there in a heartbeat! Can't stand the cold--and of course now I'm so settled, with friends, church, and excellent healthcare providers that it would be emotionally wrenching.
How is it that in one of the richest countries on the planet we are all just one catastrophic health issue away from bankruptcy? 60% of bankruptcies are due to medical bills. I'll bet that most of them had employer provided health insurance too. Here's how it works: Something happens medically. You go on short-term disability (at 60% pay). After about 90 days you go on long-term disability and your employer can cancel your health insurance. But you make too much on disability for Medicaid or any other assistance. So you are left without health insurance coverage when you need it the most.
I'm sorry to be so late to see this, but it makes my blood boil. I will share and tweet and link as much as I can. R and Hugs.
so you are bankrupt

i hope your words help you

note: the editor won't help you
There is no shame in bankruptcy. Seriosuly, best choice I ever made.
Barbara J:

It is a definition of screwed up if our insurance system can't protect an insured person from bankruptcy or poverty because of their medical bills. That the hospital didn't turn her away isn't worth much congratulations.

As for the idea that medical care is expensive, it is our screwed up system. I live overseas and when I applied for health insurance I discovered that any insurer, British, German, Danish, or even American charges half as much for Worldwide except the US coverage as for Worldwide including the US. Even Aetna, which is one of the biggest American insurance companies. Now, that can only be because our costs are out of control.
I was fantasizing about quitting my loathsome full-time, full-benefits job today, but your story reminded me why I can't. I am so sorry you have these egregious money problems and that you have had to endure seven surgeries! So, so wrong, I don't even have the words.
It is sad that people do not know that almost ALL hospitals have a grant program. It takes only seconds to apply and all your bills are free, even the priors. I had it at Methodist on Houston and Dartmouth in NH. It was wonderful, even covering my scripts.
I've got to set the record straight. Dianne Schuch - Lindsey may have a good deal going for her in New Hampshire, but I can assure her it is nothing like that here in the Phoenix area. Yes, Banner Desert had patient financial assistance available, but it took me three years of declining income before I qualified, and then I had to go through a four-month process of providing copies of three years of income tax returns, all our medical bills, bank records, and worst of all, we had to apply for and be denied AHCCCS, Arizona's medicaid plan. That took forever. When we finally went through all that, they forgave 75% of what we still owed, but they certainly didn't refund any of the $14,000 we'd managed to pay out on our own by draining every last asset. If New Hampshire is this friendly toward the impoverished chronically ill, then my husband and I need to consider moving there.