FROM the BAY to the LAKE

Liquid Writing Therapy

Cathy GF

Cathy GF
Location
Mt. Tam to Freel Peak, California,
Birthday
December 29
Title
Writer by desire. Poet by nature.
Bio
How much time do you have?

Cathy GF's Links

New list
APRIL 25, 2010 6:29PM

"They shoot horses, don't they?"

Rate: 28 Flag

I have watched my daughter, a Vet Tech, assist in the "putting down" of a 1,500 lb. horse, while both she and the doctor had eyes overflowing with tears.  They never get used to experiencing a once viable, beautiful animal, falling to the ground after fighting with what little strength is left in their giant bodies, struggling in vain before death's waiting victory.

 The memory of that recent event haunts me deeply.  The sound of the impact of the horse against the metal trailer and the last long breath, brings moments of unbearable sadness and a sight that will live inside me always.

Having said that, I do agree with "assisted suicide."  So much so that I inferred that she may need to give me a horse shot someday if I am really incapacitated and miserable.

Then I realizied how unfair that was to say to a daughter, who could never and would never assist me in that morbid endeavor.

There will be a doc for that, I am certain.  I have long believed that suicide will become the #1 cause of death, over cancer, heart failure, or any other fatal desease.  I sense we are heading in that direction for a multitude of reasons, one of which is or will be, that health care for the elderly will degenerate as quickly as  the enormous "baby boomer" generation is "going down hill," growing older faster than any governing body over medical care will be able to provide to the majority of us.

Not given to morbid fantasizing over medical issues facing those I love or god forbid, those I may be facing, I hardly warm to the notion that we are all headed in a similar direction.  Once a forbidden, murderous act, I can easily see how the option of assisted suicide would be so appealing.  A time and place of your own choosing, given the circumstances and prognosis for any kind of quality of life are no longer present, we could ease on over to the "other side," loved ones by our sides, if so chosen.

The thought that for so many, there are excruciating, lingering illnesses with no cures in this lifetime, that financial resources are quickly drained to the point that you can no longer die in the comfort of your own bed and that your loved ones and family are watching helplessly while nothing else can be done...is just too much to take in.

No one should be forced to be on sustained life support if there is no quality of life to be expected, ever.  If doctors have exhausted all medical options and nothing more can be done to lessen the degree of physical suffering, mental and emotional anguish and financial ruin, what else is there to do? 

I once had a dog that was so chronically ill, I went to three different vets seeking solutions, both holistically and medically, trying a varitey of diets, medications and anything to help this poor animal from further suffering.  After two and a half years of treating her to no avail, this poor animal would repeatedly, dig  holes so deep in the ground and cover herself with dirt, seeking some relief from her constant pain.  This heartbreaking sight made me realize that she wanted to die.  She was simply allergic to life and everything in her environment.  The vet concurred that nothing more could be done to help her.  It would be kinder to let her go.

It was the most painful decision I had ever made to that point in my life.  Finding the words to explain to my young daughters , that their beloved "Frosty," was going to be "put to sleep," was as unthinkable as the act itself.  It was the only solution left for our beloved dog and an end to her life long suffering.

Nearly every week, my eldest daughter is faced with the same dilema, over and over again, when a horse is dying or is in unbearable pain with no end.  It is often her call and decision to "put the animal out of it's misery."  I cannot imagine having a job where there is so much illness and death on a constant basis.  I am in awe of those who can manage this type of stress and the challenges of deciding when death is the best outcome.

I am not ready to make this call on my behalf...not yet.  The day will come, I have no doubt.  If only the one real fantasy was true.  That I could simply and peacefully just die in my sleep.  That would be just fine.  It is likely to come down quite differently, I fear.  Though I do not dwell on such morbid thoughts and feelings or the what ifs, I do occasionally have a sleepless night, wondering how and when it will happen and if I will have any choice in the matter of my own dying.

I like to think I would.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
On the question of "assisted suicide." As painful as any decision could ever be.
"It would be kinder to let her go."

worth.repeating.
thank.you.for.this.
I like the way you wrote this.
I have also been told so many times when pets are ill, "the best thing is to end his/her suffering" yet, we cannot do this for an elderly parent or suffering relative. For this is more humane to watch them suffer for weeks.
It's a great parallel. People are more humane to their animals than they are to their grandparents and parents. WTF, right?

Great article, and I agree. When the time comes, I want the choice.

Rated!
"...that you can no longer die in the comfort of your own bed and that your loved ones and family are watching helplessly while nothing else can be done...is just too much to take in".

Whatever happened to the good old days where you DID die in your own bed, surrounded by those who have helped make you comfortable, friends not strangers, and it was an expected part of life - not something to be avoided at all costs?
A very thoughtful and heart wrenching look at what so many of us are examining. My thought, like yours is that I may have some say, a step further than the DNR order.

Brave and sad post.
Brilliantly spoken. It is an act out of kindness, and unselfishness. One I don't really care to think about either. But I do know my choice would be.. But like you say, of course the time will come where we will have to make the decision for ourselves or for someone we care about. Don't we all wish the only real fantasy would come true, and we could only die in our sleep? Unfortunately I know it is not going to go that way for myself, either, that would the easy way out.. yeah right? me?? Easy way??
My girls already said they were just going to bury me in the back 40, burn all my things, and take the money, if I ever got like a horse that had to be put down. God?? Why did I raise them to be SO MUCH like their mother.?? I have no idea what money they are talking about either..grins..
Incredible price you have hear. I could relate to everything you had to say, and you said it so well. Thank you for this.
Having been raised on a farm and having a ranch of my own now, I am well aquainted with having to put a suffering animal out of its misery. It is, of course, a sad occasion but at the same time there is relief that the animal will suffer no more. Those who provide this service are to be respected for the suffering they relieve.

What I could never understand is why on Earth could we not do the same thing for loved ones with no hope of recovery and facing long periods of pain before death.
"It would be kinder to let her go." Indeed!

Beautiful piece, Cathy. You made a compelling argument.
Rated.
Sometimes the best healing is to let go. Kudos to your daughter, it takes a special person to do that job.

This spoke to me in many different ways, and I thank you for that.

-R-
This is a very well written, compassionate article, Cathy. Thanks for writing this thoughtful piece. I agree. I've always been dumbfounded that we end an animal's suffering by putting it to sleep but god forbid we should have the same compassion for a precious human being. The sadness and suffering of spending years watching a loved one suffer or become demented with nobody home is far worse than timely putting one's self to sleep.

If I were in the position of a prolonged incurable illness and/or dementia what would I choose? Hmmm... That's tough. I can (a) die, or (b) suffer and die. I pray I have the right to choose (a). Thanks again for writing this. R xoxoxo
Such a thoughtful post, Cathy. I'm with you...I don't know if I could make that call for myself, or if I'd even have the choice. I but I hope I do...some power over your situation is better than none.
Wonderfully said. Lots to think about here.
So well told, Cathy....thank you for this....xox
I don't know when prolonging life became so confused with prolonging suffering. The hospice method needs much more attention and funding.
To me, this is a no-brainer. It is not a choice between life vs. death; it's a choice between agony vs. death. Well done, Cathy.
Lezlie
Thanks to all of you for taking time to read and comment on a very sensitive and painful subject. All your thoughts and perspectives are very appreciated.
Cathy, hi Sweetheart. I don't know what else to say. There is no reason to believe that a simple death in your sleep will not happen. Or at least, something quick and painless that you never know of. That's the real issue for me. I just don't ever want to know it's coming. And I absolutely want a safe and legal choice should the occassion present that I need one when it is my time - if I have to go that route. XO
As our generation (boomers) finally comes to the point irreconcilable degeneration, the option gets examined more in depth. I think it takes place to some extent now with hospice care. The patient voluntarily stops IV feeding and the body starves as pain killers are administered. It is more and more common. I saw it happen with my father. This was after all options had run out with his colon cancer. A time of unbelievable dificulty for families.
Gary - You are right abou Hospice care and that is an avenue of gently letting go, depending on your circumstances. However, it is not cheap and is an option for those who can afford this care, I believe. My father-in-law recently passed away in this manner, after his bone cancer spread rapidly after a few rough years of chemo and battling the demon. He was moved into a Hospice home, made very comfortable, said all his loving goodbyes and in a matter of only two days, passed on with the assistance of Morphine.
Thank you for bringing this to light as this will be of some comfort to those who are able to go this route. For others, however, there will be no option to be hospitalized and/or referred to Hospice without devastating financial loss to themselves or their family.
Cathy--Hospice is completely paid for by Medicare. The only requirement is that an attending physician signs a statement stating that in all likelihood, the patient is in the last six months of life. The critical aspect in our experience is that family members take control of the situation. There are documents to be signed, Do Not Resussitate orders, which take the hospital off the hook. Absent these steps, hospitals will do everything they can to keep a patient alive because they are legally required to do so.

Wonderful post.
Jimmymac - I would have thought so too, however, My FIL did have Medicare and was moved into a Hospice facility for which he paid a daily fee, for sure. Maybe there was something else, but he was in his last few weeks of life which turned into only two. Either way, the real financial drain comes in the hospital, as you mentioned, until paperwork is done, etc. For me, doing a Living Will and Trust with an EOL was invaluable and one of the best investments for my end of life wishes that could be done.
What a shame. Don't know how she does it.

I recall a grandmother and an aunt told me that they prayed every night to die while still in good health in their sleep closer to the end if their days. God Bless her and I hope she does not find her work hideous. the problem of death is one I address in a new post which URL I shall send you.
Professor - I'll look forward to reading it.
Excellent post. I also had to hold my beloved dog's head in my lap and pet her while the vet eased her passing. It was the kindest thing to do. It is one of the hardest things I have ever done in my life, bar none. But I know she was with the people she loved most at the end, and here at home, not at the vet's office. She was where she needed to be.

Why, why can't we be so kind to our own families? I would want someone to do this for me when my time comes, to hold my hand and speak soothing words, and slip the needle in to end the pain.

Death will come for all of us. This is a one-way trip through this world, yet we all want to pretend the end won't come if we just don't think about it. It will. And death comes, whether we face it rationally or not.
Froggy - That was such a penetrating, thoughtful and compassionate comment on this subject. Thanks!
Brilliant, Cathy. Simply brilliant.
Very compelling and poignant piece, Cathy. Difficult questions which we much all face sooner or later.
Rated.
Love this and agree 100%. But I'm making my kids do it. They owe this much!!! Ha.