It’s Not My Place to Forgive My Son’s Murderers
Jessie would be starting his senior year in high school today. Would he have grown tall or been short like his father? Would he have been as fiercely handsome? Would his sensitivity shone through, his essence been bold, and his hands have been large? It is a relief to me today that I am in a place where I can imagine such questions.
I hope I would have raised him to not smoke as much pot as his father or drink as much as I did when I got pregnant. Although, the odds would’ve been slim, for at this time, I was a full-blown teenage alcoholic with undiagnosed mental instabilities in an on-going traumatic upbringing whose partner was on his way to becoming a petty drug dealer. With a trumped hand like this, my instincts tell me it would’ve been rough for him.
~
His dad and I still managed to have hearts of wonder, desires to live “right”, and a deep, albeit tenuous, love for one another. The instabilities always outweighed our good intentions though. Eventually, our own separate failure to face the truth divided us. We grew up and traveled far away from each other. My heart still feels a connection for what was shared (and lost).
Okay, I just choked up. You know, the cheek tightening, ugly grimaced, eye-flooding type of emotional onset? It feels inconvenient while I’m trying to exude a sense of wholeness around a desperately dark circumstance. They still come.
~
Fast forward twenty plus, years later: here I am hunched over my computer. Two decades of counseling, nine therapists later, multiple diagnoses (most incorrect and eventually some amazing help), two treatment centers and several psychiatric bungalows are in arrears. I am a grown woman with long-term recovery from addiction, codependency, and mental illness from an off-the-charts traumatic childhood. I held firmly to the viewpoint we were victims of a horrible crime and I refused to have a victim mentality. This stance shaped me to be a woman of compassion, tolerance, and eventual even-handed objectivity (although time shaped this last aspect – it was shorter in coming). Now, I have a moment in space and time to share a few things due to my rare experiences.
Grieving has become a specialty of mine. Seriously, I think there is an artful flow to it. I decided early on grief (rage, spit, and throwing fits) is God too. How could it not be? If He is omniscient than He is I and I am He. Therefore, He is every ounce of my being and what flows from it – body/mind/spirit (including the snot on all those tissues). This freedom helped me shed my AAA personality and get right down to the gut wrenching, body-fluid-flying, hysterical experience of full blown RAGING at his killers. And, I did it, over and over and over again. And again.
~
Time passed. With every release, a bit of the divine filled the spaces where the caged heaviness of fury had physically weighed me down. The numbed out grey lens I viewed the world through began to slowly welcome color again. Activity helped, allotting myself certain amounts of time each day to feel the pain salved the deep aching, and most of all, refusing to let anyone tell me what my truth was saw me through. Canned platitudes and minimizing anecdotes sent me into a deeper rage than how I felt about his killers at times - friends fell away.
Each step built the mountain of strength I have today. Blind hate gave way to serenity. Judgment transformed into objectivity. Freeing myself from the agony awoke my soul and informed my spirit.
~
Eventually, my son was returned to me. His body wasn’t recovered; it was his essence that began speaking to me. I have finally evolved to a place where I know nothing, or no one, ever truly took him away…not even death. This was closure, the bookend to years of suffering through a loss I hid, even from myself at times. My memorial is ongoing. It is through acts of kindness for my daughter especially when I am infuriated with her, art I create in various mediums, and sharing about him so I don’t have to carry the charge of it alone any more. For that, I sincerely thank you for listening.
I have been asked do I forgive the men who murdered him? My answer is, "it is not my position to forgive them." That piece of soul business remains between them and Jessie. For me, the connections for forgiveness run linearly between the victim and the victimizer. My piece of life work was to grieve the loss of my son. And while I will always experience pangs of emotions that arise, today I welcome them.
I feel immensely blessed my Jessie has returned to me, we talk all the time.


Salon.com
Comments
My heart aches for your son, and for your family. I love that you know he is with you, as he is.
xo
Check out her first post, everybody--she's the real deal.
As for the content of this piece, well, I just don't know how any mother survives the loss of a child. Congratulations on reaching something like serenity. I am overwhelmed at the notion.
Amazingly evocative writing, gut-twisting even. I am so very sorry for your loss (even though it seems a long time ago, but then when does time matter when it is our loved ones?).
Though I am not a Christian, I hope you won't mind if I use the traditional farewell:
Peace be with you.
Before you all start writing screeds, I lost the great love of my life, my lover Scott when I was in my twenties. I all-but ruined my life afterward due to the hate I felt and I only began my recovery when I forgave the man that killed him. I could only start to release the pain and loss after I had forgiven. So, I understand the pain of losing someone so deeply loved and I understand even more how hard the step of forgiveness is. However, only through forgiveness does the self-healing start.
Forgive, Ms. Bishop, so you may recover. Doing so is most certainly your position.
@MacAdvisor: I am sorry for your loss as well. While I don't want to engage in advice giving (actually a part of my healing process), I will say I respect that forgiving the murderer of your lover is how healing worked for you. It is not how it worked for me. I don't believe there is any one "right" path in many matters, and something as agonizing as this requires each human to find their own way. Jessie and I found our way. As for the state of my healing, I wouldn't be so quick to pass judgment. I think if you truly read my words, you will see the hate, anger and rage was a stage, it has passed, and I am not carrying anything around but serenity (most days anyway). Best wishes to you, me and our lost loved ones.
I won't be defending my process of healing - I will simply say, this is what has worked for me right up to this moment and I am thankful.
"Blind hate gave way to serenity. Judgment transformed into objectivity. Freeing myself from the pain awoke my soul and informed my spirit...Eventually, my son was returned to me."
Call it what you will, this is a perfect model of a survivor's "success story." I feel so sad when I hear the families and friends of a murdered person say that they will only have "closure" (a terrible word for a beautiful concept) when the murderer is him/herself murdered, or made to suffer terribly. Your way is the only way. I'm so happy for you.
Thoughts?
@wakingupslowly: I do know he is with me, it is the biggest blessing. It hasn't just changed this experience, it has changed EVERYTHING!
@O'Really: Thank you, sincerely.
@patricia k: YES! I believe in the power of the "light"
@Lainey: It's a love affair...
@GirlyBoyMama: Ditto on the mother note; thank you for your support.
@Bill S: And also with you. I've finally decided to take what I like from religion and leave the rest...heck with the crazies. Your support is felt and I am indebted with gratitude.
@grif82600: Your private and personal support is touching. Thank you. Check out the author interview on Salon today about the addorall diaries - sad.
@lunchlady2: I am sorry for your loss; I understand your pain. Isn't it comforting when you *feel* his presence though? It is a great paradox, for both to be true at the same time. Blessings.
@Outside Myself: Thank you. It is definitely a path everyone has to find their own way on.
@Verbal Remedy: Clever name! Thank you.
@Jennifer C: Appreciated - yes I have become an advocate of non-violence (at a personal level). Gandhi embodied this so well, he is one of my role models and the whole Satyagraha movement.
@Michelle Fergensen: Blessing to you, too!
@Kristy CC: Peace to you, too!
@Dave - it has taken a lot of love to pick up the pieces of a life I tried to wreck and then the joy of putting it back together to be so much more than I could have imagined. I am so lucky today. Thank you for wanting to share more moments of my life with me... as a writer, especially when it is about my life, I feel a sense of immense fear others will not want to know about me. It's an odd sensation. Of course, I often fear judgment, too. But, then, you throw in the towel as I finally did and say...I've worked to hard not to share my truth. I'm glad I finally did.
@Hope - thanks, and ditto what I said to Dave.
@Macdelt - yes, this is where my heart comes from. A lot of hard won wisdom I'm afraid. It shaped my professional life, too, as you have now heard. I just want to thank you, too, for your bravery in your "when is rape not rape post." I believe the only solution to these nightmares is love for both sides of the equation - victim and victimizer. It also requires both sides to do their respective work - none of which is easy. A whole lot of love helps us all - thank you for being one of those types of people. Love to you and yours.
It is no less painful to read a second time. But you seem to be coming to .....well, for lack of a better word.... an accord of sorts with what has been. It's all we can do, anyway - come to terms however we can, as we can't change anything. What's done is done.
I'd rate this again if I could. Sadly, they only let me give one.
And a huge Yes on this: "I decided early on grief (rage, spit, and throwing fits) is God too. How could it not be? "
Having worked in the "death area" (hospice etc) I am saddened by how allergic American society is to grief. It's one of our last taboos. Grief is good, even when the reason for it isn't. It's the most natural emotion in the world, and a very active one. I'm glad you're living yours.
@Bill S. - I appreciate you taking the time to comment twice. I am a very blessed person to have met such great people like you.
@nofrills DEVIL monkey - I love the new avatar. You change it up so nicely. Thank you.
@Silkwood - I am so glad you understand this. Exactly, the reason it never relished, but the relief from learning to grieve is so welcome. I am thankful for knowing this process, and realizing it is absolutely life-affirming.
@JK Brady - Namaste. I am thankful to have met you, too! ::sincerely::
"Canned platitudes and minimizing anecdotes sent me into a deeper rage than how I felt about his killers at times - friends fell away."
I have mostly not lost friends, but people should be forewarned not to come near me with minimizing b.s. I am glad you are here.
Your words are all at once beautiful, intense, and ultimately filled with hope.
Hope
XOXOXO
I'm getting so chocked up now as I am re-reading this for the third time. I can not imagine the grief that you must feel. I'm so terribly sorry. My heart goes out to you and yours.
I'm so pleased to hear how you seem to be handling it however. You are a strong, strong woman.
God bless.
DOHSS - Your kindness is appreciated.
Clarissa - It has taken time, however, it heals more every day, especially from the kindness of strangers like you.
Harriet - Your welcome - and thank you for coming by.