Kathy Riordan

Kathy Riordan
Location
Florida, United States
Birthday
April 27
Bio
One woman's view of life and the universe. Follow @katriord on Twitter.

MY RECENT POSTS

Kathy Riordan's Links

What I Can't Write About
Poetry, if you like that sort of thing:
Christmas
New to Open Salon?
Where I've been, where I'm going:
Twitter from the Inside:
Posts on World War II:
Some of my work on Iran:
Some of my favorite posts:
I also write here:
Editor’s Pick
SEPTEMBER 8, 2010 2:02PM

On Not Being a Mother

Rate: 70 Flag

cradle-bed-okooko 

 

"The moon lays a hand on my forehead,

Blank-faced and mum as a nurse."

- Sylvia Plath 

 

 

My mother reminds me there are many ways to mother, that biology doesn't have everything to do with it.  

I know this.  

I've known it for decades, known that those who adopt children are no less parents than biological parents, that those who 'mother' are not always those who give birth. 

I expected to be a mother.  It came with my earliest cultural programming--girlhood, young womanhood, wife, mother--all wrapped up in ribbons and bows.  It didn't account for all those mysterious things in life that make up a human being, or those quirks of fate that take them on a different journey.

I was a little mother first, the oldest of six, an only child for almost five years so by the time my youngest siblings came along and my mother was stretched to capacity (as many are), I was highly engaged in their caretaking, bottles, diapers, nurturing, watching, being a big sister.  By the time my youngest sister was born on my first day of high school, I thought she might as well have been mine.  We followed a pattern not particularly unusual in larger families, where oldest sisters take care of the young ones.

Just after my seventeenth birthday I left home, and two summers later as a college junior I worked in a small 28-bed hospital in southwestern Wyoming where among other responsibilities I was in charge of labor, delivery and the nursery on my shift.  At a time when women and their babies were kept in the hospital several days after a normal delivery and generally kept apart, I bathed, bottle-fed, rocked, changed and loved dozens of babies in their first week of life.  The moment a woman in labor arrived at the hospital I accompanied her in the labor room, prepped her, attended to her, and prior to her delivery I went into the very sterile, very white stirrup-ready delivery room to open all the sterile packs, then stood next to the attending physician while during delivery, handing him sterile instruments and bottles of Procaine.  When the baby came, I took it immediately from the doctor, wrapped it and wheeled it down the hall to the nursery, weighed it, measured it, footprinted it, gave it its first bottle, its first bath, and rocked it to sleep.  

Over the next several days I gave each baby several bottles of infant formula while its mother slept away down the hall (very few women breastfed then).  Once or twice a shift I'd take the baby down the hall to the mother who was also my patient, but hours I spent rocking them, bathing them, changing them, making it difficult not to be attached to them by the time they went home.  It was a different time in the life of hospitals, so different from labor and delivery and newborn nurseries today.

When my siblings first started having children, I was the aunt who came to help, first to Seattle when my oldest niece Megan was born, and then to Salt Lake City when another niece, Shaelyn, was born.  My sister had been bedridden for a month before Shaelyn came with a difficult pregnancy anticipating complications while her husband was a young medical student; while I fretted over her welfare I sewed an entire nursery set out of purple and yellow Laura Ashley fabrics--crib quilt, bumper pads, pillows, even a little music box that looked like a house--all long gone now. 

Marriage brought a husband who already had children and a wedding day that made me both a stepmother and a grandmother.   My grandchildren were all fairly young then, the oldest less than ten, the youngest not born, but my husband's children were all old enough to be out on their own. I know that my grandchildren love me and know how much I love them, the youngest now in high school and the oldest just returned from fighting an uncertain war in a faraway land.  

It might not occur to them readily that a woman who married their grandfather was their grandmother the same way a woman who married their uncle was their aunt.  Having stepgrandmothers myself, perhaps I understood it better.  I remember with affection when my youngest grandson made the connection on a day I picked him up from elementary school and he proudly announced it to his teacher.

Three years ago, we raised a thirteen-year-old niece for her seventh grade year, a child who had enough issues with her own mother and didn't want another one, yet we loved her as deeply and unconditionally as if she was our own, gave her what we hoped was stability, security, and the knowledge that she was loved.

I have cared for many children in many different ways, siblings, nieces and nephews, grandchildren, children in a hospital nursery, yet still, family members know if they want to really hurt me, the shiftest and surest way is to go right for the heart and say, "You're not a mother."  

You're not a mother.  Whether fate chose not to make some mothers or they chose it for themselves, moral authority does not suddenly shift in the direction of those who feel they are superior by virtue of being able to procreate.  The ability to conceive or give birth does not bring with it the automatic ability to be a parent (would that it did), and children in this world don't always go to those most capable or most deserving.  My sisters forget when they think I know nothing about raising children that I came to their sides when they needed me, both as infants and as new mothers.  I wasn't just the exotic aunt who flew off to Paris and knew nothing about children, or mothered anything beyond fur and feathers.

There's an exquisite hand-carved French swan cradle in our guest room up north, a happy find years ago in an antiques store in Carmel, which has remained forever empty but not without purpose. 

I've nurtured, loved, cared for, rocked, cradled, wiped away tears, bandaged, diapered, bathed, sung to, tucked in and blessed countless children, children who had other mothers.  I long ago came to a place of philosophical peace with not having my own children, though I understand the pain and the longing of those for whom biology oppresses.

I am not a mother.  But I have mothered, like countless others.

 

nursery 

 

(top, photo of Float cradle bed: Okooko; bottom, photo of author working in the nursery at Uinta County Memorial Hospital in Evanston, Wyoming, summer of 1975

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Kathy, so many are better because you have mothered them. We should all hope that we had your influence in our life. In truth, we must raise each other because sometimes those elected to do the job cannot. You are a mother, a wonderful one!
This was very moving, Kathy. And I had no idea that you'd been a nurse!

Like you, I always expected to have children (at least one) but it just didn't work out that way, as it doesn't for many women, for various reasons. It's a loss that I made peace with years ago, but it's still a loss of one of the primary experiences in life that I do feel strongly at times.
I am so honored to be the first comment, given how much this post resonated with me, and how well it was written. I am "not a mother" either but have raised a little sister inside a broken home and have very special, close relationships with my two nieces, one of whom I "fathered" for the first two years of her life. I have skipped birthing by choice because I have satisfied that part of myself through raising others. But yes, I also hear "well you don't have kids" as the insensitive answer to various situations
This is such a meaningful post. My mothering was done by my aunt. My mother was toxic to me.
beautifully written, Kathy!
Clearly you understand motherhood better than many women who have given birth.
Kathy, you are a mother.. you are part of this earth, where we mother those who need, be they our own, family or strangers.
Rated with hugs
Some people have been cruel to you. At best they were thoughtless. At worst there's not a thought in their heads. On their behalf, I apologize.
I love that photo of you holding the newborn. And I remember what a profound impression this piece made on me when I first read it as a new writer here. How many children received such a wonderful introduction to their lives at the loving hands of a college junior. You are one of a kind, Kathy.
This was beautiful. You were the best infant nurse ever, I can tell.

A line from "Goodbye Mr. Chips" has always stayed in my mind. Someone tells him what a shame it is that he had no children. Mr. Chips looks at the quad full of students and replies that he has hundreds of children. As you have.
What a beautiful view on motherhood. Nice image as well. Bravo
This is beautiful Kathy...
Kathy, I remember reading and enjoying this post earlier-- did you post it around Mother's Day? Re-reading it now, it is equally moving and beautiful. I am glad to see it on the cover today so even more people can see and learn from it.
Like you, I'm a non-mother who has mothered many. Sometimes it makes me sad but mostly I'm at peace with it. Thanks for your perspective.
{{{{{{HUGS}}}}}}

You just made me feel pretty good about being a "mother".

Thanks for that.

(I STILL suck at it, though ;~) )
Great post -- totally rated.
Bravo. I hate when people think "mother" is only a biological process. Some of the most mother-like of people I've ever encountered, have been like you . Rated, with support.
I loved this post, Kathy. It takes a village, and our village is a better place thanks to people like you.
Such fine writing, Kathy--perceptive and a really wonderful hushed intensity. I think there'd be a special place in the netherregions, a small annex, perhaps, for anyone, family or not, who would utter "You are not a mother."
You don't have to mother any children anywhere to have profound value in this world as a woman -- although the larger culture will never allow for such a view. I don't have kids or nephews or nieces and the only kids I've ever cared for were those I have babysat for.

But I have mentored many writers over the years and that's my gift, every bit as much as any more traditional female "mothering." Women are forever defined by their willingness and ability to take care of children.

It is a terribly narrow view of what we do.
You are so right about what qualifies one to be a mother. I am, but at times I wonder what it really means when it seems he holds against me the fact I did what was best for him, not for me. At any rate, I have admired you even before I knew all of the things you wrote so beautifully about.

R
Gosh, this one really got to me! If you've ever written any better, I haven't read it yet. It sounds as if you believe your sisters say that sentence deliberately to hurt you. I hope that's not the case, but if it is, they are an ungrateful bunch, aren't they?

Lezlie
Kathy you are a mother. One does not need to give birth to "be a mother." There are those out there that have gone through the birthing process but have not mothered. People can be so cruel, so thoughtless. This is a beautiful story, beautifully told.
People say the cruelest things. They ask what *I* know of mothering when I had only one. True. The others all miscarried and I only carried one to term successfully. But like you, I diapered and rocked my siblings and later, their babies, and so many more.

I love that cradle at the top. I'd like to take the babies that are uncared for ans shaken and abused and set them in little floating cradles like ships in a bottle and let them float away to someone that would love them instead of hurting them.
This is just beautiful, Kathy...xox
Please combine Lea and David's comment and you will have my thoughts exactly. You have mothered many and how lucky they have been to have you.~r
What a lovely, moving post. Giving birth does not make one a mother.
I had so many "other mothers" in my life and some of them had never given birth, but mothered and mentored and loved. Before she died, I used to send my former professor/mentor/other mother Mary, who never had children of her own, a card on Mother's Day acknowledging all that she had done for me and for so many others.
This was lovely, Kathy and I hope you realize how important you have been in shaping the lives of countless people! My husband was adopted after being the only one found alive in a blazing building at the tender age of 2 months and he remembers how his mother read to him and encouraged him and how she cried when she told him he was adopted-she was more upset than he was! He loved her so much and travelled so far to be by her side when she left this earth. It's a long story but to cut it short at the connivings of his wife his step-brother disinherited him after she had told me that they were all to have "equal shares!" They took everything of value but left all her birthday books and bible etc but they didn't realize-that was the only things he cared about! He knows he was loved!
I was adopted when I was 6. She was the woman that lived next door before my father married her when I was 2. She has been more of a mother to me and an even greater example of love than my biological mother was ever even capable of. Biology has nothing to do with being a mother. Nothing.
You've been more of a mom than many biological mothers I know. Well said.
"children in this world don't always go to those most capable or most deserving"

such true, true words

But you are, you are.
You definitely earned the mother badge. If all women reproduced, we'd have a hard time making a world in which their offspring stand a chance to thrive.
my tears flow and meet with yours when you said those words, and you said them so beautifully and truthfully. congratulations!
You've done the Mom job. THanks. It really does take a global village to raise a child. Glad you're in the caring circle of this village.
Beautiful, Kathy. There are so many ways to care for children, and so much attention that they need and rarely get. You have been there for them, and you have been a mother. Rated.
This so eloquent Kathy.. You are a mother in every sense of the word. The naysayers are blissfully ignorant. Enjoy your brood.
Beautifully written journey through your life of motherhood. You are a mother in the heart, Kathy, and have touched so many lives.
You're not a mother, but you've given love to so many children who needed it. That's blessed work.
To say those who carry and pop out a puppy are the only mothers be--Love makes you a mother. You just skipped the fun part--gaining forty pounds, stretchmarks and breasts that reach your bellybutton! But you get all the smiles, giggles and joy that all children bring--oh and the hugs and kisses!
As Cranky said, blessed work indeed. I come from a family full of shuffled kids...aunts and cousins raising other cousins. My beloved "big sister" cousin has only one biological child but has adopted and fostered several more. There are so many ways to support and nurture children and you were right in there doing your part, and more that most. Someone here said that they could tell you were the best baby nurse ever: my thoughts exactly!
This is a very beautiful piece. So many are truly blessed because of the "mothering" that you have done.
A lovely piece. You are a mother, indeed, and the world is better for it.
I'm not a mother.

No one has ever ragged me for it. Of course. I'm being a little flip, but (think) I have a point.

"My sisters forget when they think I know nothing about raising children that I came to their sides when they needed me, both as infants and as new mothers. I wasn't just the exotic aunt who flew off to Paris and knew nothing about children, or mothered anything beyond fur and feathers."

I have a feeling that you have, as you stated, stepped up to the plate when absolutely most needed and performed admirably. Extended families are extremely lucky to have someone that can help in the unique way that can only occur when a blood relative has the personal resources to be there when needed most.

I just have this feeling that you are suffering on some level over this. The road not taken and all that.

And some parts of the experience that you just missed.

And your sisters are never going to really understand and give you the recognition you deserve for the contributions that you have made.

I do know the feeling that occurs when family is unable or unwilling or just too self absorbed to acknowledge your actual contributions to the well being of the group.

I don't know how to get beyond it, or I would write it up and it would be a best seller.

The problem of regret that you could have had a different life that would have had a different set of rewards -- that's kind of universal. This is a big one, because you would have been a hell of a good mother. And, I'll bet if your nieces could vote, more than one of them would trade for you in a heartbeat. Your sisters probably know it also.

This is a well written piece and it is presumptuous to suggest that however close you are to getting over the pain caused by your sister's comments, you seem to still be feeling hurt. And you don't deserve that.
I have occasionally had this thought: "I wish that (someone I know) had had or would have children." I know my sentiment is different than others here (and I agree with all of them, both about how moving is your account and how unnecessary is motherhood to meaningful existence), but I want you to know that if someone ever says that to you, it's a deep compliment. It means that they think so much of you that they want literal copies of your DNA floating around to impact future generations on top of the good that your own DNA is doing now.

I'll be frank and say that it's the many, many women on OS that I've "met" over the last two years that have caused this thought to pop into my head more often than ever before. I just want the world to be filled up with the kind of intelligent, thoughtful, compassionate DNA that fills Open Salon, and maybe they can crowd out the hateful crazies out there. It's just a little wishful thinking, that's all. In the meantime, thanks for all you do to make the world a better place.
Oh, but I think you are.
Very nice post to remind us all that mothers and mothering takes many forms. Great post!
Beautifully said, Kathy! Rated - because, how could I not?
Wonderful, poignant writing. You've pointed out what makes a mother--love and commitment to the needs of the child. Nothing to do with biology.
This is so powerful and touching. rated
Kathy, well said!! These phrases, most particularly:

~... that those who 'mother' are not always those who give birth. ~


~It might not occur to them readily that a woman who married their grandfather was their grandmother the same way a woman who married their uncle was their aunt.~

~The ability to conceive or give birth does not bring with it the automatic ability to be a parent (would that it did), and children in this world don't always go to those most capable or most deserving.~

You've offered some important insight. {{{R}}}
Very simply...all that really matters in life is your view of your divine self. you are a mother and what counts is that YOU know it. How blessed all those kids are that you were able to mother so many more than most of us. What a love you are....
My mother reminds me there are many ways to mother, that biology doesn't have everything to do with it.

Your mother is correct. There are many ways to mother. Biology doesn't have a damn thing to do with being a mother. You are a mother, Kathy. Both of my sibling sisters have no children and they are mothers to many.
I too have mothered other people's children and grieved over not having my own. This spoke to me so personally. Thank you for sharing. Rated.
You are a Mom, a great one because you chose to mother those who needed mothering.
Kathy, belated thanks for this beautiful post, heartfelt and real. I relate so much, also being "childless," and having "expected" to have kids. Funny how life's scripts turn out differently than planned, and yet, and yet...we can't turn back time. So we have to accept what is and live every present moment I guess. Nice to share this struggle with you and others who've commented.
This is one of my favorite posts from you--I found it very moving. I disagree with any family members who say you are not a mother.
Mothering is so much more than biological motherhood. Thank you for putting it so beautifully.