Kathy Riordan

Kathy Riordan
Location
Florida, United States
Birthday
April 27
Bio
One woman's view of life and the universe. Follow @katriord on Twitter.

MY RECENT POSTS

Kathy Riordan's Links

What I Can't Write About
Poetry, if you like that sort of thing:
Christmas
New to Open Salon?
Where I've been, where I'm going:
Twitter from the Inside:
Posts on World War II:
Some of my work on Iran:
Some of my favorite posts:
I also write here:
Editor’s Pick
SEPTEMBER 15, 2010 4:41PM

When Polygamy Gets Silly

Rate: 36 Flag
images-5
 
 
Watch out.  Polygamy is busting all over your television screen these days.
 
Although I'm admittedly not a big "Big Love" person (probably because I don't subscribe to HBO), I have seen it, here and there.  But when Lifetime's made-for-TV movie of "The 19th Wife" aired Monday night (based on the David Ebershoff novel of the same name, inspired by Ann Eliza Young's "Wife No. 19"), I felt compelled to watch, just to see how wrong (or right) they would get it.  
 
Having a few polygamist ancestors myself, including at least one who went to prison for it, I am intrigued by the current fascination with it as a cultural phenomenon.  Too often, however, television is getting it wrong.   I cringed watching "The 19th Wife," and have had moments of the same with "Big Love."
 
Now I see that TLC is offering up on its fall lineup a reality TV program, "Sister Wives," following the lives of Kody Brown and his three-almost-four wives, and I confess I will likely watch.  
 
At least they should get the nuances right.
 
kody-brown-sister-wives 
Kody Brown.  Polygamist.  Soon-to-be reality TV star. 
 
 
Here, as a public service, I'm offering an Idiot's Guide to Making Television Programs about Polygamy, for those in the media who need a little extra help: 

 

Get the pronunciation right.

It's Zion (ZEYE-un) (rhymes with Ryan and lion) not Zion (ZEYE-ahn) (rhymes with ion or fly on).

It's Deseret (Dez-uh-RETTE) (rhymes with barette)  not Dez-URT (rhymes with hurt).

It's you (yuh) not you (yew).

It's to (tuh) not to (too). 

It's creek (crick) not creek (creak).

It's feel (fill) not feel (rhymes with meal). 

It's that (thut, rhymes with hut) not that (rhymes with hat). 

All one syllable words get a two-syllable slide (ha-ard, ba-ack, ma-ail).

T's are in the back of the throat, almost non-existent (moun-un, not mountain). 

Forget about L's in the middle of a word.  It's walk (wok) and talk (tock). 

Never spell it out when a contraction will do.  It's it's (itz) not it is, and aren't (arnt) not are not. 

 

Get the vocabulary and expressions right.

It's not "the Heavenly Father."  It's just "Heavenly Father."  

It's not "the elders."  It's "the Brethren." 

It's not "afterlife."  It's "next life." 

 

Get the dress right. 

Sister wives from FLDS compounds can look a lot like Amish women, with homemade simple dresses going down to their wrists and ankles and up to their necks, or they can look a lot more like contemporary women.  In either case, though, they generally won't be sleveless or showing cleavage. 

 

080514-bountiful-hmed-1p 

Real:  Sister wives  from a fundamentalist sect in Bountiful, Canada, playing basketball.  

sister-wives-tlc 

Real:  Sister wives from TLC's new reality television show, "Sister Wives." 

MarBarNic 

Fake:  Sister wives from HBO's Big Love.  Note the short sleeves, sheer fabric and plunging neckline.   And grumpy looks.

 

Get the accents right. 

Utahns have an interesting and unique accent.  It isn't a southern accent.  It isn't a redneck accent.  It's got it's own thing going.  Find a dialogue coach to teach it. 

 

jonheder 

Jon Heder might be available.  It not, you might try Mitt Romney.  It's something between there.

 

Get the props right.

If a Mormon mother is going to be inviting her daughter over to talk about going to the temple, it won't be over china teacups filled with tea.  

 

edraw2b 

This is Mormon tea. 

 

pouring_tea 

This isn't.   Although Ellen Burstyn is pretty darn good.

 

Get the prophet right. 

Sure, even the fundamentalist groups have their prophet-as-leader, all hearkening back to Joseph Smith who started that ball rolling.  But they tend to look more like computer nerds and businessmen than the cowhand you hired last summer or Tal Bachman doing country.  Ditch the long hair, corduroy jacket look.

 

It's

warren jeffs 

(looking sufficiently  late 70's computer geeky) 

not

Not geeky enough.  Too much like that guy in the bunkhouse or the back of a motorcycle

 

Get the theology right. 

Mormons (even fundamentalist ones) don't talk about the prophet being infallible.  That term isn't even in Mormon vocabulary generally.  It's Catholic.  They might talk about 'Following the Prophet' or how great or inspired he is.  But they won't talk about infallibility. 

 

Get the names right. 

Sure, there are a lot of historical names (Eliza, Emma, Brigham, Hyrum, Parley) and a lot of composite names (LaVerl, Nordell, LuDawn) and some modern names with geographic twists (Morgan, Jordan) or Biblical (Jeremiah, Benjamin), but what you won't find is typical WASPy names or names after Catholic saints (Mary Katherine, Ann Elizabeth, Francis Xavier).  Don't just take any two names and put them together and think it works (BeckyLyn) or use names that sound like a pet (Queenie).

 

Get the history right. 

Don't start confusing fundamentalist Mormonism with mainstream (Salt Lake City Mormonism), except where they overlap, and be sure to get the point of departure right (Mormonism officially stopped practicing polygamy in 1890, although some members continued on afterward and fundamentalist branches arose out of that, including primarily on the Utah/Arizona border, and in colonies in Mexico and Canada).  Brigham Young didn't start the practice of polygamy, although he might have been more famous for it than his predecessor, Joseph Smith.   

joseph-closeup215pxwidebrigham-young-bornemann 

The founders of modern American polygamy, Joseph Smith (left) and Brigham Young.  Although Young is better known for his plural wives, said to be 55 in total, Joseph Smith is reported to have had at least 34 women married to him.

 

 

Promo for TLC's upcoming reality TV series, "Sister Wives," which premieres September 26th.  I'll be watching.

 

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
i've only had one mormon friend, but as he got through a quart of vodka every day, he was probably lapsed. i think he drank cuz he didn't have even one wife.

how any man copes with two or more is a source of wonder. you have to suspect oppression, with whips and bondage, or at least a naughty corner.
But, I want to see the polygamy that features hot chicks in arranged marriages to old fossils, it gives me hope for the not so distant future. Excuse me now I have to go see to my cult building.
Hey, it's a switch up for TLC, otherwise it'd be nothing but 28 kids and counting, I had Triplets 9 times, and other baby shows of huge rate!!!

Good times!! :D

Rated!!!
I am huge fan of Big Love and Missed this because Steve was watching other things..
I love bad trash.. I will catch up with it, but thanks Kathy, I had a feeling it was bad.

Just got home and a little late reading..
Rated with hugs
Seriously informative post. ~r
Interesting.

Hmm - does anyone pronounce the el in walk and talk? (Or psalm or salmon?)
I don't understand the picture for "Mormon tea" - ??
Polygamy is a subject that frankly turns my stomach. I completely do NOT understand the current rising fascination with it. Throw Hollywood into it and it becomes even MORE nauseating! Thanks for attempting to set them straight and congrats on EP! Woo Hoo!
Hey, I think I caught some of that "19th wife" thing at the gym. Thank God the sound was off. It gave me the creeps how they were shunning this woman. Evil trash.
Interesting. Never could stomach polygamy and Big Love nauseated me.
I hope the producers are printing this out as a primer! I don't watch any of those shows and find the idea of polygamy repugnant -- not the idea of multiple wives so much but the subjugation of women within that culture.
The expression "oh, my heck!" was something I only heard when living in Utah.
And the biggest horselaugh I ever heard in a movie theater was in a multiplex in Layton, Utah, during a showing of that 'save the whales' Star Trek movie wherein Kirk attempted to explain some of Spock's odd behavior in present-day San Francisco by saying, "He did to much LDS in the 60ies..."
I may be the only OSer with a copy of a parody cookbook called "No Man Knows My Pastries" by Sister Enid Christensen ... LDS humor - and, yes, there is such a thing.
Thanks for your diligence in putting this together, Kathy!
There sure are a lot of rules for everything aren't there ? Very interesting post. I find this totally fascinating although i can't imagine why. Very interesting post..thanks r
How do they say "salmon"?

And isn't it interesting that three cult religions came out of the same small area near Syracuse at approximately the same time? I've heard that epileptics of the day commonly claimed "heavenly visions" to cover up their fits.
That Kody is a looker! Like a big blond Malibu surfer dude. I thought polygamist hubbies are over seventy and missing a few teeth, so there's another myth you dispelled for us.

Similarly, whenever you see a movie star playing a guitar, he'll be fretting a G chord, but all kindsa chords are what your ears are hearing. Or when some movie star painter character "paints", by going over and over and over and over the stroke that a real painter painted first. Sheesh. I might take look at that Kody though, if I owned a tv.
Great reporting, I am wondering how they will stay out of jail after the authorities see the first episode. Or are they now in the reality show protection plan.
rated with lots of love.
maybe they should hire you...
It's always been a source of wonder to me how women accept polygamy.
some women, obviously, not all
I don't get the Mormon tea picture either.

And I read the "The 19th Wife." Thought it was quite good, but is it also off base fact-wise?
I'd wondered what was "on" and what was "off" in Big Love. Thanks for a fascinating primer!

myriad and sweetfeet: Mormon tea is an herb that grows in the Western deserts, better known as Ephedra (yes, that ephedra.) Mormons did not (and do not, as I understand it) drink tea or coffee because of the caffeine, so instead they made "tea" out of this desert plant. Joke was on them: ephedra is a powerful stimulant. It's also known in Chinese medicine as ma huang.
one commenter wondered how women accept polygamy, it's easy:

"better to be a rich man's mistress than a poor man's wife."
it's almost like any publicity is good publicity. the more people are aware of it, the more they learn and will try to investigate.
The producers are using river rocks fastened top a bra rather than the Urim and Thummim fastened to a breast plate :-)

I watche the first two seasons of Big Love and found it somewhat fascinating just how much of the culture they did have right. But as with most series two is about all I can handle before it becomes absurd and redundant
Not sure why I liked this post so very much aside from the fact that it is terrific writing...perhaps the allure of those festive pale full length basketball dresses? I think I'm a liberal (cleavaged) quaker at heart...at least stylistically. This was thorough...and thoroughly delightful...funny but enlightening! thanks Kathy! r
Great post, Kathy. I read The 19th Wife and enjoyed it, especially the back and forth between past and present. This stuff fascinates me, and your knowledge feels authentic indeed.
This is just plain fascinating. Wow. I now realize I knew Nothing about Mormons or their beliefs or their lives. I must catch up to the 19th Century.
What a peculiar cultural practice. I bet polygamy never catches on in China, not with an imbalance of something like 20 million extra males in their 20s and 30s. Unless it's multiple husbands. Who thinks that would work?
I've read a few things which suggest America was really ripe for it's "own" homegrown religion at the time Joseph Smith started having his revelations, and that'd be an interesting area of study. I think the only reason Hollywood's infatuated with polygamy is thanks to the built-in sex factor--I mean, if we're not shocked by Snooki anymore, I suppose it's natural that polygamy would follow...
Thanks everyone for the comments here. Myriad and sweetfeet, Ruth got the Mormon tea explanation exactly right. Thanks, Ruth. If you Google "Mormon tea," you'll get a photo of an ephedra plant, which is commonly called "Mormon tea" in that part of the world for reasons Ruth explained.

greenheron, that Kody is a looker, isn't he? And I think maybe I recognize that oldest wife from somewhere. Sgt. Mom, I'm laughing at the "Oh my heck!" because I almost included a video with that in here. Your cookbook is priceless. David, Fetlock, I think all the revivals in the area at the time had something to do with it, but I couldn't say for sure. It is interesting.

I appreciate everyone's thoughts, kind words and questions and sorry I wasn't around more today to respond.
Hmmm... I always thought "Mormon Tea" was condensed milk, (canned milk), with hot water added to it.

All of my father's family is Mormon, except for me and my brother. Great, great, great Grandpa emigrated from England in 1853, to join The Brethren in Salt Lake City. My grandfather had one wife, but all the others had three to seven wives.

The Mormon Church excommunicated my father, and he took that as a badge of courage. He told them what he thought about their beliefs and practices - "It is all a bunch of hooey; and, it is a religious cult." Dear old Dad did not want to have anything to do with it. (I agree, by the way.)

One of the things that bothers me the most about the Mormons, is the apparent subservient roll of the wife. The husband is, for all intents and purposes, the lord of the manor. In these days of equality, that strikes me as a tad odd.

One thing for sure, one does not hear much about plural husbands.

In 2010, turnabout should be fair play. One wife and seven or more husbands - one for each night of the week.

Of course, the chances of that happening would be the same as me becoming the next Czar of Russia.

Another disturbing aspect of the Mormon Church is the leadership. Somehow, elderly men suddenly open a channel to God when they become the president of the church.

Anyone, the so-called preacher in Florida who wanted to burn Islamic religious texts, or any other church leader, who says gets messages from GOD, is more than likely mentally ill, and in need of comprehensive treatment, including good quality medications.
David--they pronounce it "sammin." Rhymes with jammin'.
Whistleberries--three words: Paint Your Wagon. That was the first place I ever saw Mormon polygamy portrayed on screen, when Jacob Woodling offers second wife Elizabeth for sale, and she ends up taking two husbands (played by Lee Marvin and Clint Eastwood).
For those who are interested, I've hyperlinked histories of a couple of my polygamous ancestors in the body of the post above.
What do you think is behind the sudden fascination with Mormons? We watched Big Love for a season or so but got bored (as we do with 99% of all TV shows, to be fair.) Seems like there's at least a little romanticism involved.
LL, I think in part it has to do with the fact that the FLDS and Warren Jeffs were in the news in the last few years, and in part with the LDS Church's involvement with Prop 8. The issue of polygamy and marriage rights is inextricably linked in the minds of the leadership of the church, which is why they are working so hard to defeat changes to marriage law.
It is impossible to fall out of love. Love is such a powerful emotion, that once it envelops you it does not depart. True love is eternal. If you think that you were once in love, but fell out of it, then it wasn't love you were in. There are no 'exit' signs in love, there is only an 'on' ramp. (( B_l_a_c_k_w_h_i_t_e_C_u_p_i_d . c_0_m ))
Lots of my friends found their lovers through the service. You may have a try... ;)
Free Shipping Activities discount 40%discount
=== nike-alliance c o m ===
Our company specializes in manufacturing from located in CHINA and Australia,,With more than 6 Years of experience,we are mainly dealing with are:Nike shox,Christan Audigier t-shirt,Ed Hardy,COACH Bag,New Era cap ,Tiffany_Ring. More products.
Supply . COACH Bag,Nike shox.Ed Hardy t-shirt.
Safe Payment.Paypal
Fast Shipment.5-7 days you can receive your order product.
No min order request.You can order only one product
Free Shipping.The price on our website are including everything.
=== nike-alliance c o m ===
This is so terrific Kathy...very entertaining post. I am a big fan of "Big Love", although last season was pretty lame, but I always figured they weaved a lot of hollywood into the FLDS culture. I like it mostly because the acting is very good. Also, it's just not quite like anything else on TV. I will probably watch "Sister Wives" too.
Kathy,

I grew up in Boise, Idaho where the kids in high school were either Mormon or not (and there were no black or Jewish kids). In public school, the Mormon kids would take seminary classes in the building across the street from the school during the school day. The state legislature couldn't enact school reform because the Mormons didn't want to lose their seminary hour.

I learned that the Mormon religion believes that there are several levels to heaven. Only a man can attain the highest level in heaven and the only way a woman can get to this level is to accompany her man. When the religion was getting started, more women joined than men so polygamy was introduced so that women could get to the highest level of heaven.

Is this correct? Or were Joseph Smith/Brigham Young just men who were a little kinky?
I don't have (any use for) HBO so, I've never seen big love.
I actually thought is was about fat people.
I am not kidding.
Now that I know it's about this wacko, sexist bullshit, I know I'm not missing anything.
It's crazies like them and this jeffs character who make people think that there is one too many m's in mormon.
In fact, I only came here to read this because Kathy consistently posts such good stuff.
Very interesting. I just might watch the TLC show, too, if I can get it here. Thanks to your post, I'll know if it's real or scripted!
Good article, K. Also enjoying the comments. This is a very misunderstood topic and experience. I hope it gets the fair and intelligent debate and attention it deserves.

For many years before the recent TV interest in the topic, I've joked with my wife that even as a teenager, I thought about the rationale of having multiple wives, a communal environment of multiple mothers for the children, the support group that sister wives provide a woman, having multiple wage earners supporting the household, allowing pregnant and post-birth women the luxury of sisters to support her financially and physically during tough times, more children in the household to re-enforce and help teach siblings good manners and proper behavior, etc, etc.

Of course, on the other hand, the topic seems sexy because of the (imaginary) male ego boost -- I say imaginary because only a man who has really thought out the details can understand the prospect of having four women in a house together...and they are all mad at him at the same time. With that said, any man who can keep the peace and his sanity in a house with four women...and sacrifice his own ego and needs to make them happy in the hope that four women can forgive him for his flaws the same way one woman may be willing to do, is a man who has indeed earned the right to have four loving caretakers to share his life and his time here on earth with. And in my humble opinion, that is what the art of polygamy really is all about.
It was my feeling that the Victorians were titillated about the plural wife thing because they did enjoy a good vicarious thrill about non-standard living/sexual arrangements. In the early days of the LDS there might have been some justification for plural marriage, in that extraneous women were guaranteed some kind of home and standing in a frontier society - but the suspicion is that some LDS men were using that as a excuse to get their own sexual jollie remains. I thought that Mark Twain's take on the Mormon 'peculiar institution' in "Roughing It' was particularly hilarious.
When I found out that I had an assignment for Hill AFB in Utah in the early 90s, I was reminded of the joke about women from Utah who fled to Iran, seeking personal and political freedom - but then when I got there, I met all these outspoken, confident and independent women. When I remarked on it to a friend, the friend said, "All the subservient ones are locked up at home!" I eventually concluded that Utah is a good bit like Texas, in that women either adapt to the rigid expectations 100%, or they rebelled totally. There was no middle way - either you conformed completely, or you revolted completely.
This accounts for the high percentage of outspoken, independent and self-confident women in either place. Just my .02 - your mileage may vary.
In what way were Smith & Young different from your pampered pasha with his extensive harem? What self-respecting woman doesn't spit on the memory of all three?
I especially loved the two commercial postings in these comments. It makes me wonder who ( in their right mind) would ever follow their links? Ah, the Asian dude who has nearly zero command of English and is purveying cheap shoddy knockoffs-- hope springs eternal I suppose-- that posting such crap enough times in as many sites will produce sales! Perhaps he ought to offer "Genuine Fake Mormon Tea" made in China with Melamine guaranteed included? And the dating site poster? Is that placement there to suggest we can have or become sister wives by using that site?
Mormonism yesterday and today:
Then: My Great great Grandfather had a large family in Utah. After meeting his eldest sons fiance he took her from the son, married her and went to a Mormon polygamy town of Cardston in Alberta Canada. They had several children. He rarely came back to visit the Utah family.
Now: My father had one wife. But if he is to get to the highest kingdom in Mormon heaven he MUST have more. This is commanded of God in one of their holiest books. Mormon women should be aware of this. They will have to share their husband "for time and all eternity" just like the T.V. show.

Is there official word from the LDS Church on the pologamy commandments of the D and C book which they believe is the word of God? Mormons I talk to are over sensitive and hurt if you try to get them to talk about this issue. "Pay your tithing, attend temple sessions and let the Lord worry about everything else!" Did a church leader once tell members to only read faith promoting information? Will this give anyone a balanced view, or is this what a cultist would say?

My TV will be set to TLC this Sunday night.

FYI: I have one wife and don't think we exist after death.
Kathy, Well written and informative post. If anyone is wondering about the population increase in the US, it is due to immigration AND the LDS church. I have met several married young woman here who are about 26 and have about four kids already, and are not considering birth control. Shocks me.
I also thought they believed man and dinosaurs walked the planet together.
I just have to say thanks! You've got a lot of the facts straight about Mormons (who do not practice polygamy) and Fundamentalist Mormons (who have some of the basic beliefs but are way WAY different than the typical "Mormon") If you haven't guessed already, I am a Mormon myself (the type that does NOT believe in polygamy). I've noticed a lot of people, especially the media, who don't have their facts straight about Mormons or "Latter Day Saints" so its just nice to see that you've made it a point to share that difference.

Just one last thing. Been watching some clips of the new show Sister Wives and I can't wrap my head how those wives can share their husband with each other. I don't see how the husband can say he is committed to one wife and then is also seeking another wife to marry. It doesn't make much sense to me how the wives are okay with that. Especially the ones who didn't grow up in a polygamist family. How does that work?