Kathy Riordan

Kathy Riordan
Location
Florida, United States
Birthday
April 27
Bio
One woman's view of life and the universe. Follow @katriord on Twitter.

MY RECENT POSTS

Kathy Riordan's Links

What I Can't Write About
Poetry, if you like that sort of thing:
Christmas
New to Open Salon?
Where I've been, where I'm going:
Twitter from the Inside:
Posts on World War II:
Some of my work on Iran:
Some of my favorite posts:
I also write here:
Editor’s Pick
MAY 23, 2011 9:24AM

Can Anything Good Come of the Strauss-Kahn Affair?

Rate: 21 Flag

hotel-housekeeping-400ds062 

While it's difficult to find a bright spot in the case of a New York City luxury hotel housemaid alleging sexual misconduct by the former head of the IMF, a small but significant portion of the population might actually benefit in the wake of the case against Dominique Strauss-Kahn.

A New York legislator has proposed a bill to outfit New York state hotel housekeepers with panic buttons.

Democratic Assemblyman Rory Lancman from Queens, currently chair of the Subcommittee on Workplace Safety, is introducing legislation which would require all hotels and motels in the state to provide emergency buttons to be worn by their housekeepers, which would alert hotel security in much the same way that elderly, infirm and homebound wear medical alert buttons.

Both The New York Times and the Associated Press ran stories this weekend about the dangers facing hotel housekeepers, indicating the problem is very real and far too prevalent for the quarter million employees who work in that industry in the United States.  Despite safety practices like propping open the door to a room while cleaning, housekeepers remain vulnerable to a spectrum of threats, including the unwanted advances and bad behavior of some of their guests.  

Hotel housekeepers share that vulnerability with workers in several others industries, including real estate agents, medical staff and spa services providers, where workers need to be vigilant when alone with clients or guests.

Lancman hopes at least to provide something for New York's hotel housekeepers, something that if the Sofitel maid had in her possession last Saturday, the news of the past week might be quite different. 

 

On the Web:

Behind Closed, Sequentially Numbered Doors - NY Times 

NY Case Shows Daily Dangers Faced by Hotel Maids - Associated Press 

Strauss-Kahn case raises question:  How safe are hotel employees? - Christian Science Monitor 

Recreating an Encounter - NY Times 

EXCLUSIVE: Strauss-Kahn Told Maid 'Don't You Know Who I Am?' During Alleged Sex Attack - FoxNews 

 

 (photo: Getty Images)

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Love that Kathy, panic buttons for maids! That seems like a little progress. Thanks for the follow up. (I know my thoughts about sex crimes are a little unconventional, so I appreciate you being a sport with me about it on your other post.)
Helvetica, I would recommend to you the fourth link above, "Recreating an Encounter," which appeared in the NY Times, for a little better understanding of the layout of the room, the timeline, and the allegations of the housemaid, very enlightening. And, thanks for your comments. I appreciate your perspective and your input.
On paper, it sounds great, but in reality, panic buttons would result in lots and LOTS of activations over ridiculous things. Having worked in security for a large hotel chain on the west coast, we gave maids radios at one point (for a similar reasoning) and what ended up happening was an endless stream of time-consuming calls that were irrelevant, impractical and ridiculous. What we discovered was that the possession of the technology advocated an immediate desire to use it (even for no reason). Strangely enough, we discovered the most overused reason for activiation was "I wasn't allowed to take my break on time". No matter how many times we tried to inform them that the radios were ONLY for emergency of their safety, it was finally discontinued after we kept getting nonstop activations for ridiculous reasons. With several hundred maids, it would cause an activation at least three times an hour.
Seems like a pretty plausible idea . . . sucks that they are necessary, but then, we live in the real world . . .
Excellent point, Duane. Maybe cameras would be a better idea--then they could be taking pictures of those nude Frenchmen and selling them to the tabloids.
I looked at the layout of the suite and it was a blind dogleg into the bathroom! It is a rapist's dream room. Yes for panic buttons, but also no dead ends in room layouts.
You're so right, Owl_Says_Who, and Linnnn (extra comments deleted). That's one crazy layout in the hotel suite. I wonder where the mirrors were placed. I understand although the standard charge for that room was $3000 a night, he got a special rate of $800 a night, and still, why, if he was there only for personal reasons and not on business, he needed a suite at all.
I worked as a hotel maid for a summer, it was hard work and definitely scary sometimes. All sorts of characters who think you are a complimentary gift from the hotel. Panic buttons would be a blessing!
Poppi, I do think there's a particular mindset, limited to a small group of guests perhaps, but there, which compares the maid all too closely to a fruit basket.
Another example of the new normal, alas. Anytime you enter a room where the door can be easily closed behind you, there is vulnerability.
I knew a female real estate agent who was leery of showing houses to men. Maybe women should be given self defense training from kindergarten on. Sigh. What a world.
Kathy, this incident may impact two other aspects too. European journalists have stayed away from focusing on the private lives of public figures. An example is Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi. Another example is President Nicolas Sarkozy. The notion is that "personal indiscretions" and the job should remain separate issues. That perspective may change.

Further, privacy laws may be reviewed. Does the public have a right to know about the "personal indiscretions" of public figures? For now, privacy legislation affords politicians, actors, musicians and others some protection. Perhaps, that is undergoing an attitude shift. A lack of judgement in one's personal life may a comment for suitability in public service. In the United States, few people would vote for John Edwards now, even for a position on the local school board.
Awareness never hurts. The reference in comments about "over use" leaves me puzzled, would that mean that interrupted security gaurds are more worthy of consideration for people who are in physical danger? You want them to stop using them for the wrong reasons, write them up for it, believe me they will stop.
This is really great news! Thanks for showing us the bright side of a pretty dark situation!
seems like a good idea, and not hard to do.
I was just brunching yesterday with an immigrant from French Guyana who first came here in the 80's. Because the government at the time would not allow them to transfer thier funds, they had to start from scratch and all the women worked as chambermaids. She said the work was grueling and the treatment by guests could be demoralizing. She also spoke of some hotels who have a adopted policies to mitigate their liability. For intance, if a guest has just ordered a porn film, he will be sent a male housekeeper for his turndown service. Some hotels in the islands are doing away with female chambermaids altogether.

Interesting piece Kathy.
More and more, it seems like everyone is going to need a panic button - maids, cab drivers, pizza delivery guys. Sigh.
Housekeeping staff need those buttons. Happy that something good did come of this. I bet so many women are raped and don't report the crime for fear of losing their jobs. It really enrages me that he treated her like his own personal property, as if she came with the room for his own amusement. Ick.
It was attempted rape, which sounds more accurate than sex crime, which makes me think of flashing, which though disturbing, is not as serious a crime.
The phenomenon of viewing and treating service personnel as less than human is nothing new. It is a late gesture--though a welcome one--to start taking measures to protect them. We have ignored for too long the disgraceful things that happen to these vulnerable people, and it is about time we start acknowledging the problems and working to solve them.

Great post--as usual. It only took a dozen attempts or so before I could access it, but that is another matter entirely.
alleged still. and he will be back in France still, but having done some good hopefully through your great post.
When I waited tables in my youth, on more than one occasion a male customer would take it upon himself to grab me in one way or another. Thank God for pots of hot coffee. They let go quickly when they see that coming their way. Some people think they are entitled to anything they like upon the unbridled impulse they find arising within themselves. I slapped and pushed away hands, poured coffee on one guy, ice water on another. I ejected customers from the restaurant as a manager too. If men would do that in an open room with many people present, it follows that being alone and unobserved in a hotel room would be even more dangerous. As you pointed out to Helvetica, "Recreating an Encounter" on the NYT website clearly shows exactly how dangerous such an encounter was in this instance.
amusing. escorts often tend to carry the same "protection". in the form of a cell phone and a pre-entered # to their "security"
I want to point out, don, and everyone, that the word "alleged" should really be on the cover page with this article. I have no control over that, but want people to be clear that I understand the charges are alleged, not proven.
Great idea! Thanks for sharing and congrats on the EP!
R
Great idea. Sharp, pointy-toed shoes would help, too. Kick the creep, then call security.
and of course congratulations on a well-earned EP. Two in a row, and both very well done.
Good? Yeah, like maybe a French-American war that's won by America.
To Duane - somehow I think housekeepers could differentiate between a panic button and a walkie talkie and use it properly.

To Kathy - some good seems be coming out of it in terms of a rather loud and indignant dialogue in the French press. French feminists are finally up in arms over the laissez-faire and exculpatory attitudes being demonstrated in defense of the alleged rapist - mostly by other prominent men.
Panic buttons are a good idea. Course most upsetting and unfortunate verbal assaults you are supposed to just overlook and consider part of the job. :/ Unless you want to look like a wimp or trouble maker. (if being a maid is anything like nursing, and it sounds like it is)
Duane, I think you convinced me. I don't like panic buttons after all. I think stun guns, mace, pocket knives, and a good martial arts class would be more effective.
There are more profound and strategic political reasons why Strauss Kahn was picked up and stopped from going to Europe. Check out this interview by EIR editor Jeffry Steinberg http://www.larouchepac.com/node/18252
Paul, are you suggesting that Strauss-Kahn was stupid enough to allow himself to be set up?
We had one of these under the desk in one of the galleries I worked at once. Ringed in to the police station two doors down. I was working alone in a building with one way in, one way out, so yeah, I was glad for it, though I never needed to use it.

And while I agree with the European journalists that a man's private life should remain private, there's a difference between being a ladies' man and being an accused rapist. DSK's consenting adult mistresses are solely the business of his and their families, but in the U.S. sexual assault is legally considered a crime not just against the victim but against society itself. (The chambermaid can be called as a witness for either the defense or the prosecution, but the trial will be the State of New York vs. Dominique Strauss-Kahn.)

To say that someone "has a way with women" implies that he's a great seducer, and seduction depends on consent.
Thanks for this, Kathy. You bring up a good point, and one I really hadn't thought about before. I'm always annoyed at maids' leaving the room open. I worry that someone could run in and steal something. It never even occurred to me WHY they would need to do it. This whole story is just so heartbreaking. Here was a woman, a refuge just going into work everyday, and she's not only assaulted but the subject of international attention. I do hope some good comes out of it, even if it is only that more of us become aware of the working conditions with which some of us have to contend.
I looked at the NY Times recreation. If it was a guy cleaning the room he woulda bit down on that weiner really hard and got away.