Kathy Knechtges's Blog

Kathy Knechtges

Kathy Knechtges
Birthday
December 25
Bio
Writer and meditator, with an Independent bent. Has written for California and Midwest publications. Interests are the loss of the middle class, American manufacturing, unions, immigration, and the welfare of families and children.

Kathy Knechtges's Links

Salon.com
SEPTEMBER 11, 2009 10:01AM

MEET BILLY & HU, BOY LABORERS. america's future

Rate: 37 Flag

                       -- REPOSTED BECAUSE OF WISCONSIN

 

I want to introduce you to Billy, a Pennsylvania child coal worker. It is 1910, and these are the days of the real America.

Billy, and  a crowd of companions who look about 10 years old, are wedged into a coal "breaker room" from dawn until dark. They pick through the black rocks in total silence. No complainers here, though minor accidents of broken and smashed fingers are routine. One knows when a serious accident occurs only when a scream pierces the silence, and a boy has fallen into the coal machinery and is mangled; or disappears, to be found later suffocated.

Free from the tyrannical hand of government, Billy's boss can pay a good competitive wage, $3 a week tops. Such is their work ethic and loyalty, that these employees won't even take time off from their jobs to go to school. The children are so hard-working that their backs actually become deformed and bent over like old men, from hunching forward all day. The children share a joke when a raw recruit has developed his deformity. "He's got his boy to carry around with him wherever he goes," they say.

Modern American workers find this golden age of American commerce   unbelievable. But Billy's story  is all true,  and it was only 100 years ago. People are still alive that saw his day! It shows how easily America could be restored to what it was before the unions ruined everything. It was as recent as 1935, that President Roosevelt signed the National Labor Relations Act, giving Americans the right to organize and bargain collectively. That was only 74 years ago! And it only took 74 years for most Americans to realize the evil of unions and big government. But they  have really begun to reverse these mistakes. Average wages have been declining for decades, and bloated benefits are falling like rain. Fat and lazy "middle class jobs" are becoming non-existent for the average worker.

 Millions of destitute employees have been smuggled into the country who are willing to work hard  for a lot less.

Los Angeles has been a great innovator in this area. About 1/3 of all employees there  now work off the books -- totally out of the reach of the dead hand of American government. Thriving L. A. entrepreneurs are free to imagine any possible working conditions that they desire, and to see those conditions make them money!

 

 Well, it is now time to meet our next boy laborer. Hu is  an 8- year- old Chinese lad who works in a brick kiln. The comparison between he and Billy is a touching example of the universality of the human experience. Though they live in totally different cultures and eras, we shall see that they have much in common.

The first thing we notice about Hu is that he is wearing a filthy and worn school uniform.  This signifies that he is a kidnapped employee. The Chinese industrial miracle has resulted in part, because local police and local government officials have worked with Chinese business  to employ Hu. Note the Chinese method of working with business, instead of working against business,  like the  government  in the  U. S. A. We also notice that Hu has infected sores on his body, and that he is extremely gaunt. The brick industry has found it profitable to lock Hu and his coworker friends  in windowless dorms, and to feed them little. Guard dogs, beatings, and whippings for recalcitrant children round out their competitive labor practices. Another key feature at the plant is that the air surrounding it is extremely polluted.  Poor-country business owners are seldom hamstrung with any of the environmental regulations that have so crippled American manufacturing. A few nutty environmentalists still protest this, but most experts agree that it will be a long time before the filth China pours into the world's air and oceans daily reaches the U. S.  The Chinese boys are also not fettered by any foolish labor or safety regulations. Not all Chinese workers labor as competitively as Hu, of course,  but practices that have been incorrectly labeled  here as "labor violations" abound in China.  American workers, again, find these Chinese  efficiency practices hard to believe. But we are not making these working conditions up!

 It is no wonder that China now seems to make almost every consumer product bought in the U. S. Though a few bleeding hearts obsess about child labor, most Americans neither know nor care.

And if  Americans  can get any product they need for the cheapest possible price at Wrong-Mart, it is their God-given right to do so.

In closing, we wonder what message Hu might have for American boys and girls regarding their future.

If Hu could speak English, we guess he might advise  something like this:  "Wake up, Americans! It is no wonder that you are losing the global economic race with your spoiled workers and big government. American kids,  you have a long way to go before you can out-compete Hu! But don't give up, you have Billy's great tradition to draw on! And  it is encouraging that America is definitely moving quickly back to Billy's American  free-enterprise system once again."

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Yes Kat, if only we would quit spoiling American kids, we would be again the greatest nation in the world at producing goods. What good in educating these kids with a high school diploma, when you can literally wipe you ass with one.
Great Post!
Rated and agreed with wholeheartily.
"Once I built a railroad, I made it run, made it race against time.
Once I built a railroad; now it's done. Brother, can you spare a dime?
Once I built a tower, up to the sun, brick, and rivet, and lime;
Once I built a tower, now it's done. Brother, can you spare a dime?"
Yip Harburg
This should be tattooed on everyone's forehead. Of course the tiny print would require reading glasses so we could be reminded how we get all these marvelous, incredibly cheap items that fill our lives and basements and garages and attics. Do you think they'd make enough reading glasses for us in some third world hellhole factory if we asked?
It makes me laugh when I hear some people complain about the "power" that labor unions have. What a joke. There are many well-funded organizations whose one and only goal is to bust unions. And they are succeeding.

We never learn anything, do we?

Well written, good structure. Rated.
A poignant post on an often ignored subject. rAted!
Rated for you story telling and astute observation and commentary.
Thank you
Thanks. Follow the Feed. The writer/thinker Mr Porter wrote:`The Magi died in 1910? He also wrote:`O ' Henry. He wrote about women, and his wife once bought her partner:`Mr. Porter a chain for his watch.
He sold the chain and bought some luxury gifts for his wife. I heard that at 12:00`Clock noon. I was coming up the driveway to my home to wash clothes, wash mold off jugs, and see What's the heck:` Que Pasa? What's Happening? Fun? In my pickup truck, on The Garrison K.'s:`Prairie Home Companion. Ya learn something.
`
D.L.Lawrence? H wrote the poem 'Figs' (?) and Lady C.'s Lovers. D.. should read Open Salon? He's be a Ed's heehaws Jade Mule Jade Toothpick? Chopstick? He ate monkey meat? He never embezzled money from the Bak like Mr. Porter did. Porter like to drink Porter beer in N.Y.C.
Honest. He said all homes in N.T.C. have drama and unique charm. He's but a West Virginia coal child MINOR:` (?) a Papst Blue Ribbon American Beer. They won the Blue Ribbon Prize at the county Fair in 1900's? True. Porter would but drinks for elites?
No. I heard Porter also bought beer for rich, drunks, whores, divinities, Blonds, red heads, grey/silver bearded wino's and wine bibber farmers.
`
~
Meg Carney:` She wrote "no worry" and keep a "hue style with visualized beauty"
She wrote "when a plane flies overhead after 9/11 the city people Look into the sky and cringe" and fear what flies bye in the air" etc., She wrote "a terrified Moose runs into the city if lost" and This:`Leave the "terrorist"where you left the fear. No fear."
`apologies if the remembrance is faulty and are too paraphrased.
`
Thanks for this.
I better wash up!
I want peanut butter and jam!
Wed Table needs popcorn too!
Jelly, goat milk, Chinese Cheese!
~
We can get jobs in India and Cuba?
I hope this no make Ya too cranky?
We common sense or presentable?
I don't know? No stub toe and wed!
Thanks a lot for this Scanner!
How are things in Chicago?
Torman and Jane, appreciate the visit.
At Home that song is so great!! how perfect

No Frills your thoughts are appreciated.

Jeanette and Chuck I thank you.
I appreciate your nice comment Walter!
Wow! Wonderful post! What an eye opener!
Chillingly scary, but oh so true. Thanks for the much needed nudge.
Excellent! Now "ain't THAT America?"

I agree with nanatehay's recent pronouncement about our core American values and all it takes is a thorough review of history to see it.

Rated.
We should all know this, but too many people don't. Why isn't labor history taught in schools? But that would be counter-productive. I hate the globalization trojan horse and we need to buy American, even if that means we buy less. I understand that some people are so poor that cheap Chinese goods may be all they can afford, but if you have a choice, buy American.
I have spent a summer walking a picket line with my husband before his disability ended his career and it was not pretty. I was told a couple of times to get in the truck as the ones building the houses that were not union got mighty pissed when we stood out in front in the sun handing out flyer's. I couldn't took 'em but chivalry is not dead among union workers. It was an eye opener.
I have always thought that if you take your company built by American workers and move it to China or Mexico you should be taxed to bring your product back into the U.S. Or maybe not allowed at all. It is all about how much profit can be made not about the workers who helped you build it in the first place.
Kathy, I'm with you all the way. I now see that capitalism guarantees a certain freedom of capital, but there is no guarantee of freedom for humans (we aren't in the equation except as pursuers of profit).

The only thing I've come to disagree with is this, "And if Americans can get any product they need for the cheapest possible price at Wrong-Mart, it is their God-given right to do so."

I used to think this too, except that I realized how many Americans would love to pay a little more so that someone wasn't stunted and in a sweatshop to produce it. However, I believe that the rules of publicly traded company compel (or "market forces") companies into a race to the bottom for the costs to produce something, and if they raise the price it will not be to help the workers but to help the stockholders. They price the item so that the maximum number can be sold (which is why it is cheap--the cheapness isn't because of the cheapness to produce, although that's a necessary requirement).

Does this make sense? This is why I believe in government interference, or let me make that clearer: citizen interference. I think we have the option not only as consumers to buy or not to buy, but as citizens to vote for politicians and laws that will protect the rights of workers when "free market enterprise" will not.

I know this makes me a raging pink commie!
oh, and it makes you one too =)
Yet another reason I don't support big box stores. Excellent post, Kathy.
Great work Kathy. Now i get to come up with another idea for my next labor post;)
This is an important post. Nice work Kathy.
wow, this is a fabulous post! thank you, love. i don't shop at walmart, not because i'm so aware, sadly, but because it's out of my agoraphobic safety zone. i will pay closer attention from now on. we lecture the Chinese about human rights and then we enable them by flocking to purchase these goods. i'm glad right now that i'm so poor because i don't comsume much at all anymore. love lvoe lvoe and gratitude
this is certainly not something I think about often so I am glad for the opportunity to think about it and about how i can be more conscious of what I buy and where i buy it.
Well done Kathy and, like Cartouche, I patronize small local businesses if they have what I need. I get to know different kinds of folks. My pharmacist knows me by name and helped me set up a way to manage my donut hole. It meant less money for him but better care for me. Go figure!
The 'china predicament' is no doubt a matter for discussion for liberals of conscience, especially now that there is an opportunity since we have a government that doesn't deny moral issues..

As conditions improve there, it is hard to believe the government can continue to exercise the total control they have, but china is not a western country and the idea of "unions" or some such organization is hard to imagine in a country with "communist" roots even if they are not being practiced in the way they were.

You bring up an interesting question: as they adopt more and more capitalist practices what will happen next?

A prescient and insightful post. thank you.
Excellent satire. Sad that it is so true. Good post, Kathy
This is why the good of days of the faithful laborer who did not need a union is a lie and always has been. But the average American is ahistorical therefore he does not know his own history as a laborer, slave or otherwise, and seeks the good old days of no government interferance.

The Right-Wing Anacist that call for smaller government or no government at all are the traitors in the gait, not the patriots they claim to be. 350 plus Americans need an affective inquiring government for protection as well as unity.
Arthur, I think this is the most creative comment I ever got! Thanks for this.

you are so kind Patricia

glad to feel "the Wind" passing through my blog!
Kevin and Serinita, so nice of you to stop by!
Lunchlady, I see you and your husband have been right in the trenches. Solidarity!
Rated - Great post Kathy I just gave a verbal smack down to someone I knew way back when. He was lamenting "when will the next Reagan come along." I wish I had read this first. I could remind him of just how more unsafe our airways grow everyday thanks to Reagan busting the air traffic controllers union. And he was a former president of a union that boasts about how few of its members work during any given year.

It is disgusting how many of people I knew back when being a hippie was cool have abandoned the the principles they had back then. They don't seem to understand that if you abandon a principle than you can never describe yourself as being principled.

One last point - These people that want to go back the "free enterprise years" are the same ones who rail against drug violence. They don't don't want gun laws; they want everyone carrying their guns to church. They have forced us to go back to the years of the wild wild west. You know shootouts in the streets, banks being robbed everyday, honest lawmen dying trying to keep law and order. I don't know about y'all but I was taught that America had progressed from these backwards times.
Ah, the good ol' days. There were no taxes either. No Medicare. Just use up the workers until they fall into the machinery. Rated for the reminder of how far we've come and how much further we still have to go.
delores, you may be a commie, but you are a kindred spirit!

thanks for checking in Jon and Cartouche

bobbot, Brie, Teddy thanks
Ariana, Pati, I hope more people will join us in watching where they shop.
Ben thanks for dropping in.

Thanks a lot Monte.
Mary, great to hear from you, as always.
Barry, I again, I am really grateful.
Good to see you Kris!
There is a balance between the dynamism generated by greed and social cohesion, although we as a species are poor at finding it, for sure. Enjoy the balance while it lasts, because it never, ever does.
Great job Kathy, as always. Your voice is very important in this area.
Hey Kathy,
Of all your posts that I've read, this is my favorite. It was sweetly sarcastic with the most important message. As Americans we like to claim we uphold certain values, such as human rights, but we'll only take it so far. This post urges me to go a step further. Thank-you.
Great post - wish our lawmakers, and apologists for globalization (like Tom Friedman) could read this. Of course, chances are they know, and just don't care.
Rated with me ---Brings to mind the minimum wage here in this country right now and all who oppose it. I think I will have to look at the labels more carefully. Well written and important.
no picture? but can relate and rate
So well done, Kathy. A great read, and rated.
think feel
rolling
gal 80 thanks so much to all of you!
good to see you Mary Ann!
Kathy, you need to be writing for The New York Times, or some other nationally read newspaper! Keep up the good work, you are great!
I forgot to mention, that you are now among my heroes! This piece really needs to be published outside of our little circle here at Salon. That was what I meant by my comment.
America, really needs to wake up to what is happening. The Right is slowly bringing us back to "the good old days". People are too dumb to realize, or they are just too self centered to care.