The View from Abroad

Hard hitting commentary from an American living overseas

Kenn Jacobine

Kenn Jacobine
June 03
Kenn Jacobine is an international educator currently teaching History and Economics for the American School of Doha, Qatar. He has also taught at international schools in Ecuador, Mali, and Zambia. His political transformation took place over the course of many years. Starting out naively as a big state liberal, he became a Reagan Republican in 1982. Disillusionment set in with the realization that small government rhetoric rarely translated into limited government actions. On Christmas day 1992, he became a libertarian. In 1994, Kenn ran for the State Senate in Pennsylvania on the Libertarian Party ticket garnering 5 percent of the vote. He has been active in freedom causes ever since.

Kenn Jacobine's Links
NOVEMBER 4, 2012 11:30AM

Another Unintended Consequence

Rate: 2 Flag
Almost all actions of politicians have unintended consequences.  In times of tragedies their mistakes are amplified.  Last week, before during, and after “Super Storm” Sandy hit the northeastern United States, governors and attorneys general in that part of the country put out blanket warnings that violators of so-called anti-price gouging laws (laws meant to protect consumers from “excessive” pricing of essential goods and services during emergencies) would be thoroughly investigated and brought to justice for violations.  While these actions may be reasonable to the emotional observer, when one applies economic logic to the circumstance it is easy to understand how anti-price gouging laws have actually caused the current gasoline shortages in the Northeast.

In essence, anti-price gouging laws are price controls.  That is to say, they prevent suppliers of goods from charging market prices if those prices are deemed excessive by government.  Needless to say, since suppliers are not in the business of losing money, when the price of any good exceeds a government mandated maximum price, suppliers will stop supplying that good.  They obviously are not going to sell an item at a loss as that is a sure recipe to put yourself out of business.  Consequently, a shortage of that good develops.  We have seen this happen time and again most notably with beef during the Nixon price controls in the early 1970s and rental properties in New York City under rent controls.

So how does this apply to the current gasoline shortages experienced by motorists in the Northeast?

Faced with threats by state officials including reductions in profits, fines, directives to set up reimbursement funds, and other penalties, merchants were intimidated to comply with the anti-price gouging laws.  Consequently, a critically important market mechanism was prevented from kicking in – namely rising prices in the face of potential shortages caused by disruptions to market flow. 

You see, in the free market, something valued that is in short supply will always cost more than it does under regular market conditions.  That is why the price of meat rises when there is a drought.   Instead of a drought, the supply of gasoline to the Northeast has been disrupted by a storm.  Although they are different climatic events, the effect is the same.  Yet, governors and attorneys general prevented gas suppliers from raising gas prices to meet market conditions.  Because of anti-price gouging laws consumers were able to purchase gasoline before Sandy at below market prices.  It’s no wonder this temporary price control on gasoline has caused shortages in their states.  Demand was allowed to exceed supply.  If the market were left to its own devices, prices would have been allowed to rise and there would be gasoline in New York City right now for emergency use.  But instead, state officials imposed a cap so every Tom, Dick, and Harry could fill up their tanks unnecessarily before the storm.

At the end of the day, anti-price gouging laws are indicative of how we have been running our economy for decades.  All sorts of schemes have been implemented to help the poor, homeowners, consumers, students, the sick, the handicapped, etc, etc, etc…  They all come with unintended consequences because they are based on emotions not logic.  During normal times their consequences are bad enough.  In times of tragedy they simply make things worse.

Article first published as Another Unintended Consequence on Blogcritics.          

Kenn Jacobine teaches internationally and maintains a summer residence in North Carolina

Your tags:


Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:


Type your comment below:
you can see your theories realized in somalia.
The comment from al loomis cracks me up.

In the face of the undeniable fact that a "gouging" law (which is simply a textbook "binding price ceiling") creates shortages, distorts the market, allows for the misallocation of scarce resources, eliminates the incentive to bring cheap gas into the affected region, and generally makes life more miserable for those affected, nothing else comes to the mind of al loomis other than a ridiculous non sequitur.