Matshishkapeu Speaks!

AUGUST 17, 2009 3:50PM

America's Finest

Rate: 0 Flag

I've been reading Andrew Bacevich, USArmy Ret (Colonel) and agree with his warnings that our glorification of our fallen heroes, supporting the troops, and admiration for the military all pose a threat to democracy here. Polls show admiration for the military to be 4 or 5 times higher than admiration of any political leaders. The threat is, with that kind of admiration, wouldn't we be better off having the military run our nation than the bozos doing it now? In fact, it that question were posed in a poll, I'd bet $100 the "in favor of" would outnumber the "opposed to."

And here's the real, every-day threat: the young people who could save this catastrophic economy, and who could restore confidence in our political processes would rather join the military than take the long, boring road to mature contribution. I know a young man with a B.S. in Numerical Analysis who looked at his employment options, Google, Microsoft, etc and decided being a recon patrol leader looked a lot more fun/gratifying/engaging/meaningful. Another has had the best education his parents could afford and instead of college has chosen the Green Berets.

I am reminded of "Family Business" where Matthew Broderick decides to drop out of his Masters program in high-tech and pull a big heist with his ex-con grandfather, Sean Connery. Broderick's father, Dustin Hoffman, wised up to his criminal father after spending a few years in prison from one of Connery's jobs gone bad. Hoffman has spent the rest of his life in the long, boring slog of building a meat wholesale business, keeping a wife happy, and giving his only child only the best. Broderick looks at his father's life, and his grandfather's adventures and chooses the latter.

I am reminded of that because of the choices being made by very talented, very responsible, very able young people today. As Hedges puts it, "War Is A Force That Gives Us Meaning" and the long, boring slog to being a contributing adult does not! Maybe the difference is that "War . . . Gives Us Meaning" and adult life requires that we give it meaning. As Frankl puts it in "Man's Search For Meaning" if a death-camp inmate asks, "What is the meaning of life?" he will die. But if he asks, "What meaning can I give my life" he might live. Thus, given that there's nothing in our educational system to address, "What meaning shall I give my life" it is no wonder that kids would be attracted to a force that gives them meaning. There's almost nothing in our cultural mileu, TV, movies, music, that exalts the quest of the individual to give meaning to their life.

The threat is real: someday, men whose lives have been given meaning will start running things for those of us who failed to learn and teach how to give meaning to our lives.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
The reason why this is sensitive is because people confuse the military with protecting freedom. The military is only that if it is used for that. If the military is used for an unjust and non-patriotic purpose, it is just that and young kids should stay out of it. Young people join the military because they just assume that we are still defending ourselves from oppressive countries trying to take away our freedoms. Those days are long gone and you will not be fighting the same war, nor in the same military as our fallen heros, your grandfathers.
Your insights are dead on. Another factor may be that of the power of a gun. Pull a trigger (or push a button) and something powerful happens. Anyone seeking power can find it immediately, legally and prosperously in the military. I don't think you would be seeing those high recruiting numbers if we had a truely 'volunteer' force.
Peace Corps recruitment is also up. Ending hunger...or providing health, water, education to those in need is also extremely powerful and satisfying...but doesn't pay nearly as good as the military, or earn as much recognition by fellow Americans. So much for being a Christian nation...
I am surprised that you can get so out of focus on the role of the military and of the people who choose to serve. I know lots of soldiers, and they are not to my knowledge failing in any way to grow up, or simply playing for the thrill of a real life action adventure. Yes there is a thrill, and yes it is one hell of an adventure, but to belittle their service is unseemly. To characterize them as the threat we must avoid is incredibly off base.
The people serving in the military that I know are outstanding folks who see and understand the threat from Islamists and are willing to spend a few years of their lives, at great personal peril in defending the United States and doing what political leaders ask of them.
I know Iraqi's who served for six years in continuous combat as interpreters for the US military and have come to the US and joined the US Army and become US citizens. They understand exactly who the enemy is and what is at stake for the US, Iraq, and every other country that comes under Islamist attack.
You might consider explicitly going after the political leaders who have appallingly mismanaged the wars, but to misdirect your concerns at the people serving is way off.
So my sense is that your essay is so far off that it isn't even wrong.
The men and women in uniform have an important role to play in keeping this wonderful country safe. But should they be used as pawns for special interest agenda by corrupt politicians? Given the recent track record of how we used our forces, I'd join the forces only if I had a real low probability of making it in the real world, as a last resort of making a living.

Most of the recent wars were not to defend our nation. They were the results of our bad policies which stem from powerful lobbies that control our policy makers. Not even my ten year old would buy that Bush/Cheney crap. Not sure how adult men and women put their lives on the line for such BS, unless of course, their cognitive abilities were diminished. Or unles they just dont have a choice.