Kent Pitman

Kent Pitman
Location
New England, USA
Title
Philosopher, Technologist, Writer
Bio
I've been using the net in various roles—technical, social, and political—for the last 30 years. I'm disappointed that most forums don't pay for good writing and I'm ever in search of forums that do. (I've not seen any Tippem money, that's for sure.) And I worry some that our posting here for free could one day put paid writers in Closed Salon out of work. See my personal home page for more about me.

JANUARY 3, 2009 10:29AM

Kent’s Selected Open Salon Readings for 2008

Rate: 26 Flag

This is not a Best of 2008 list. There were many best, and I surely overlooked many. There were too many even to read.

This is not a complete list of all the posts that I liked best. The bookkeeping is too hard. I didn't keep track and they're a pain to search.

Also, the nature of some of it doesn't lend itself to picking out and listing later as a recommended reading. Politics changes quickly and very quickly becomes, quite literally, “yesterday's news.” In particular, Saturn Smith wrote a ton of outstanding analysis that was thoughtful, insightful, and in-the-moment. It was precisely the kind of thing I come to a site like this to read. And yet for me to point to any one post as something anyone should go back and read is hard, not because it was even wrong—much of it was right on target—but because these things move on. I managed, fortunately, to find one of her posts that has more of that enduring sense, so I'm happy to include her. But others I didn't and not always because they had nothing to say.

So here's my list, for what it's worth, in no particular order, by the way. This was accumulated by a kind of random walk through friends and friends of friends and I just took the list in the order I managed to scrounge things:

  1. Leonce Gaiter: Somewhat More Visible Man
  2. Karen Novak: Ode to my Husband
  3. CoyoteOldStyle: Charlie's Story Begins
  4. Rob St. Amant: If my subconscious had its own OS blog...
  5. Saturn Smith: Democracy: WTF?
  6. Kirsten Edmondson Branch: Our "Moon Shot" is Far From a Clear Shot
  7. Francisco Patiño: This financial mess was well planned and executed...
  8. Travellini: Crashing Myths
  9. Jason Korke: A Grand Old Parting (of the ways)
  10. sandra miller: Good night.
  11. Bob Eckstein: The Sad State of Publishing; My Disastrous Holiday Book Tour
  12. Jon Henner: The Unbearable Lightness of Being Wealthy
  13. Gary Justis: Giving it Up
  14. T-Bucket: T-Bucket's Wacky Tips to Survive Being Broke in a Recession
  15. Dennis Knight: The Passing
  16. Susan Mitchell: A Pause for Something Pretty (which led to numerous others that bbd enumerated here)
  17. mishima666: My 25 Things
  18. norman kelley: Agents of Intolerance: “Soft-porn Racism”
  19. suzyishere: Poor...White...Southern...I write here on Open Salon
  20. Freaky Troll: Freaky Troll Book Club: Part 3, Cheese Danishing
  21. Harry Knapp: Eartha: A True Story
  22. Tom Cordle: Proposed Amendment to The Constitution
  23. David Brin: Suggestion #5: Avoid a crisis caused by "just-in-time" (and others in this thoughtful series)

If you got value from this post, please "rate" it.


Updated: The original post had 20 items. I later extended it,
and might add a few more as they come up.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Thanks for the mention, Kent. There seem to be a few here that I haven't read so I'll make the time now.

rated
Great list, Kent!
You have one post by Francisco Patina which should be required reading if you want to know why the economy bombed. It was planned. I generally do not credit conspiracy theories but have heard of this one years ago from a reputable source. It is excellent, and you, Rick Lucke and I are the only ones to see it.
My highest recommendation.

http://open.salon.com/content.php?cid=36038o
You've picked some of my favorite people on OS, Kent. Thanks for the list. (It's also interesting that it tells me you and I have something in common, shared interests and preferences. I would have figured this out eventually, seeing your comments on the posts I read, but this is a lot faster.)
Kent, This is very kind of you and I am honored you chose the one piece I keep going back to.......I was just commenting about my late brother Greg this morning. Yesterday was his birthday.
Thank you so much Kent.

BTW, 13 is my favorite number......How did you know?
Gary, it was just a lucky accident.
Coyote, I was hoping people would find a post or two they'd overlooked. :)

o'steph, yes, I found Francisco quite thoughtful and hope he resumes posting. And speaking of posters who haven't been around, does anyone know what's happened to Karen Novak? I'm terribly worried.

rob, glad it tells you something interesting. I've often wondered what kinds of personality info can be gleaned merely from pointers from one person's pages to another. I'm sure someone is mining and classifying us as we speak. So it goes. The price of community, I suppose.
Kent, I also have the same problem -- so many good posts, but it is difficult to remember them all. As for Saturn Smith -- she should have her own byline here, and also Monsieur Chariot, especially now that he has reappeared after a long absence.

What about this for an idea: be able to rate posts in a way that expressed degrees of enthusiasm, perhaps a "star" system something like this:

* - recommended
** - highly recommended
*** -- a "must read"
**** -- a "must read" of superior quality

I think that such a system would make it possible for high-quality posts to get more attention, even if not many people had come across them.

For example, one post might have been read by 30 people but have an average rating of one star. Another post might only have been read by 5 people but have an average rating of three stars. Under the current system the second post might remain largely ignored. With the "star" system other people might want to see what all the excitement was about and check out the post. I think this could be especially helpful for newer members who aren't well-known and don't have many "friends."

By the way, thanks for including one of my posts in your list. You are too kind. I'm going to check out your other recommendations too.
mishima, I sometimes think a star rating system would be good. And yet I think it's good for people to not have to feel thus judged. I think it would risk spoiling some of the community feel. There's a particular style of community here which is similar to the TableTalk feel where a certain set of kind of blunt choices (only one bit worth of rating, only linear discussion rather than tree-structured) leads to a more party-like atmosphere. I think you can go to larger numbers of people and the stars will be necessary to navigate the larger space. But in the process the character of the community will almost surely be lost. Just my guess, though.
Thanks for this, Kent. I can't wait to read 'em all. Amazing to me, is hwo many are my faves as well. We must have a few things in common.
I do feel honored that any of my posts made this list. I would like to list a few of my own. I would like to do a lot of things. Mission is taking up alot of time right now. I am so thrilled to have her.
Kent, I am truly honored to be on your list, since I am usually only found on somebody's shit list. It still rankles that I didn't make Richard Nixon's.

As for ratings, while that would be useful, I fear it would be unworkable on such an egalitarian forum. There are simply too many areas of interest and too many differences of opinion.

We "suffer" from an abundance of riches here, and as a consequence, some brilliant writing and much-needed insights are unfortunately going to be swept away in a tsunami of postings.
I've often wondered what kinds of personality info can be gleaned merely from pointers from one person's pages to another. I'm sure someone is mining and classifying us as we speak.

Oh, great. I can't wait for the osHarmony commercials to start: cheesy music, posters talking about how glad they are to have found such special commenters, and so forth. :-)
Thanks for the list! I've only been around for a month or so, and this helps me find what I otherwise would have missed. Raaaaaaaated!
This was yet another thoughtful and generous post. I joined OS in the latter part of November and know that there is an enormous amount of great writing I missed. As I entered these waters, it was hard enough to keep up and learn at the same time. Both you and Rob have been wonderful at leading the way from a technical standpoint. I also loved Rob's comment here.
You have given me much more to read but I know that you have never steered me wrong. Rated (as always) for value.
I'd like to offer up my thanks too, Kent. VERY helpful hearing about the good stuff gone by.
Kent...shocked to even be on your radar my friend. I think you're probably one of the more if not most thoughtful writers on OS. You're steady hand has surely helped shape the integrity of this community we would all like to remain smart.

Unlike many here I'm a drifter who often has nothing but an itch to share however it's starting to feel like my favorite bar. So many wonderful storytellers...many can write...few capture honesty.

Thank you for that.
Kent, thanks for doing this. Thanks also for including one of my posts, I am very touched and flattered that you did so. Among the many people on OS, yours will always be a comment I value highly. I notice that other people whose comments and posts I particularly value are also on this thread. But I'm not ready to join OSHarmony - yet. I am, however, looking forward to reading the posts on this list that are new to me.
I hope Kent doesn't mind this addition, but there are a few posters whose work (in posts and comments) I've noticed (or has been pointed out to me) in the past few weeks. They're not all new to OS, but they're new to me and I've been impressed: Harry Knapp, Greg Correll, and T-Bucket.
Rob, T-Bucket and Harry Knapp are in my list already. I'll have a look at Greg Correll's stuff. But if you or someone has a list of good commenters, it might make a good separate list. I didn't have a very organized theory of that.
Thank you, Kent.

I think that I am off to do some reading.

Dean
Thanks for putting this together Kent. All too often it feels like one is at an all you can eat bar, and the menu is gigantic. I trust your work and will investigate these.
Rated
Rob, T-Bucket and Harry Knapp are in my list already.

Right, of course, sorry about my poor phrasing. (I did see them in your list.)
I had already read 11 of them.
Will complete the list.

Nice work.
Kent, I am very happy to see the photographic explosion included on your list (A Pause for Something Pretty/bbd's post and list). It was a remarkable moment on OS, where the community of artists was exceptionally apparent. It was both a communal dance of joy & relief that I was found to be free of my cancer and an exuberant release of creative energy amidst a tumultuous and often depressing political/economic environment.

I would recommend many of your own posts for that list ;) I am one of your biggest fans because of the intelligence and clarity you bring to whatever you address. I especially appreciate your willingness to keep pushing for the changes needed to keep Open Salon a place we can all enjoy. It's a thankless job, for the most part, but there are at least few of us who are very grateful!
Susan, thanks for the kind words about my posts. I'm glad to know you've enjoyed them. It is a bit of a dance figuring out how to frame the critiques of Open Salon so they are useful/constructive and not just a bowl of sour grapes. As to thankless, well, maybe, though probably the Open Salon staff has me beat in that regard.
Thanks, Kent. As a newbie, I wasn't familiar with most of these bloggers, and you included older posts from some of my favorites that I hadn't seen.

I've now read all your list, a rewarding undertaking
Roy, I'm glad you found it worthwhile. I'd hate to have wasted anyone's time, and it's good to know the full list has been “vetted” in some sense.
YAY! I was mentioned! Where do I sign up for OSHarmony?
Great commenters (which does not preclude them from being great posters, either, I am just focused on the comments); these people either make you think, or make you glow, or both, and enrich the experience on OS tenfold:

Mishima666
Rob St. Amant
Kent Pittman
Lonnie Lazar
Jodi Kasten
Bill S.
Rich Banks
Gary Justis
Verbal Remedy
Liz Emrich
Chicago Guy
Tom Cordle
Monte Canfield
Lea Lane
Msr. Chariot

this isn't an exhaustive list but rather one off the top of my head; if I"ve neglected someone, apologies, but I'm sure others have more to add as well
Actually, just for the record, my last name is spelled with a single “t” ... but no harm done. People often either leave off the “t” from my first name or add an extra one in my last name. It mostly balances. It's nice to be thought well of in whatever form it comes.
Yes, it was a typo but I didn't want to annoy you by cluttering up your blog w/ a repost, all for a 't'. But now here I am cluttering up your blog with this explanation about the typo.
Hey, wow, Kent, thanks for the inclusion and the note. It's always nice to be recognized, but so much better when it comes from someone who would easily make my year-end must read list, too. I agree with Harry when he says "Your steady hand has surely helped shape the integrity of this community we would all like to remain smart."

And I share in the shuddery, but amused horror at the idea of an osHarmony. (Is it pronounced o'sharmony? If so, I think I know who must run it).
I just found myself on your list - what an honor, Kent!! Thanks!