Kent Pitman

Kent Pitman
Location
New England, USA
Title
Philosopher, Technologist, Writer
Bio
I've been using the net in various roles—technical, social, and political—for the last 30 years. I'm disappointed that most forums don't pay for good writing and I'm ever in search of forums that do. (I've not seen any Tippem money, that's for sure.) And I worry some that our posting here for free could one day put paid writers in Closed Salon out of work. See my personal home page for more about me.

MY RECENT POSTS

MAY 27, 2012 10:12AM

Accelerated Memorials

Rate: 11 Flag

When people die, we have very nice ceremonies to remember them. Often we end up saying things posthumously to or about them that we never managed to say to them while they were alive.

Why do we wait?

Memorial services are more for the living than the dead. They give the grieving something to do. They give the living a reson to believe that when their time comes, someone will probably have a nice ceremony for them. But they don’t do the one thing we might wish for: Let the people we care about actually know that we do.

I wrote a technical article once, on an unrelated topic, in which I referred to a concept I called “accelerated hindsight.” The notion is that if hindsight is always 20/20, and if it’s easy to see forward into time to the point where we can see backward clearly, then why not just simplify matters and admit those things we know will eventually be crystal clear in hindsight? So if we care enough about people to memorialize them after they die, why not do it beforehand—while they’re still around to enjoy the praise and feel appreciated?

To be clear, I’m not suggesting we look for friends or family who seem like they’re about to keel over and inflict some sort of going away party on them. Maybe for some that would be better than nothing, but for some that might add unwanted stress, like others have given up on them and maybe they’re sending a “hurry up and die already” message.

No, I really mean something earlier than that.

Some might say that’s what birthdays are for—a chance to mark the passing of time by getting together with people to celebrate. But birthdays are already heavily ritualized in ways that might conflict. Birthdays are about presents. Maybe they shouldn’t be. Maybe we should refocus birthdays on something less materialistic. But they are what they are, and so I’m not specifically suggesting commandeering that holiday.

Birthdays also come way too often. Not just my birthday, which itself comes way too often these days, but yours, and hers, and his. It’s an endless parade of birthdays any more, something Facebook users are probably acutely aware of. Pretty much every day is someone’s birthday. That takes away some specialness.

Besides, I’m talking about honoring a person’s life achievements, not just what they did last week or last month. But maybe not a whole lifetime; life sometimes seems divided into chapters. Or perhaps one sometimes has the good fortune to live more than one life in a lifetime; I’ve felt that way. Either way, I’m thinking it requires more than a year of knowing, observing, and relating to a person to put their life into perspective.

A retirement party? Well, not all of us have the luxury of retiring, so let’s not require some specific event to happen. Holding our appreciation of others hostage to events serves no one. There isn’t always an event that precipitates the need. The event is the person’s life.

I might settle for something around age 40 or 50, maybe at intervals, where we just got together to take stock and note the passing of time. Something timed to not necessarily be the end of one’s life, though we really never know who will be around longer and who won’t.

I have even, on occasion, thought it might be nice to bequeath a few possessions at such a ceremony. I can be quite a packrat.† I save stuff I wonder if I’ll ever use, but I have no occasion to give it away. Perhaps a “live memorial” event could be such an opportunity. In regard to that ritual, more like a reverse birthday party—a chance to give away things rather than receive them. But really, why wait until you’re gone to pass things along? And by “you,” I mean me. It’s something I’ve been thinking about doing myself. Ridding myself of certain baggage of the past might give me a way of punctuating one of those life chapters, clearing room—both literal and figurative—for a new one to begin.

In a world where money and power are increasingly siphoned off by and for the benefit of a self-congratulatory economic elite, there are ever more people who aren’t succeeding economically. The fact that the game isn’t “zero-sum” doesn’t mean some aren’t getting their due. Our societal processes of incentives and rewards need some heavy-duty reforming, but in the meantime there are many whose contributions to the world are as worthy as they are unrecognized. There are people who will be remembered when they’re gone, but would it be so terrible to remember them while they’re still here? Some of them might not even realize anyone cares.

Memorial Day has drifted from its original meaning, and seems lately—at least in the circles I run in—to be less a day of remembrance and more just the unofficial beginning of summer. It’s just a day to get together with friends and barbecue. And I’m not even saying that’s bad. After all, some of those we value are likely to be present. Nor is the world ill-served by attention to a simple pleasures like conversation and cooking. But it wouldn’t be much of a stretch to add to the celebration a bit of thoughtful appreciation for all of those who’ve affected our lives, even those still among us. That would seem a start anyway.

I don’t have a highly specific suggestion to end on. This is all just me thinking aloud. Maybe all that will happen is that I’ll call or email a few friends and tell them how much they’ve meant to me. Maybe you’ll do likewise. In some cases a public celebration may be deserved, but a private thank you may be all that’s practical.

If you’ve got any other suggestions, feel free to share them.


If you got value from this post, please "rate" it.

†Fellow pack rats may enjoy my free-form quasi-poem The URLs of the Mind.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
i believe a moment of sincere thoughtfullness(?) is fitting for memorial day...have a good one..
Very nice post, I like this idea. We could do roasts like they do for celebrities, only kinder.
rated with love
Steel, thanks. And thanks for visiting.

Poetess, an interesting twist. A kind roast. I'll have to ponder whether there's any overlap in that Venn diagram, but still a fun bit of imagery.
I wonder if it need be nothing formal or in any way tied to a date, but simply sometimes telling someone who has come to matter to us, that they do ... and why ... and what their mattering means ... to us ...
I suppose the telling can be just as personal for the teller as for the one we tell. Sometimes, perhaps, the telling can be as simple as reaching out a hand ... a gentle hand, I think ...
Maybe we should refocus birthdays on something less materialistic.

I've attended birthday parties at which only the person having the birthday was expected to give out presents. I liked that.

I also like your other suggestions. My best to you, not as a memorial but as a bit of clairvoyance, for the future.
Kent: I've often -- very often -- had the same wondering thought. Kent:

I've written many a eulogy -- we them news obits -- for people in the news. The people most interested in what's being said are never around to hear their praises sung. It always seems a shame.

I know of some people who have written their own obits. Seen a few run in the paper. But it's not the same thing. While that may save people from the awful hyperbole and insincerity of the standard-issue newspaper death notice, it allows no room for what others would like to have said.

I think that your idea of holding a living memorial service -- without using that name -- at, say, 50 or 60 years may be the best solution I've heard of yet. A salute, for no particular reason. Because we love you.

I wouldn't try to take such an idea public. I'd leave it to a person's family & friends. Keep it informal. Personal. Jocular. Serious. Thoughtful. Bring wine and food and stories.

The idea, I've been told, behind a raucous Irish wake was to "wake" the dead. Maybe your idea could be something like that -- a celebration with a living sould at its center -- a successful wake.
anna, for sure the idea of any personal contact is good. But people often travel great distances at great expense to come to a memorial service. Seems like instead it'd be good to spend such money seeing the person.

Rob, birthdays may be a way to start. Thinking about the mechanics, the issue is that memorial services are really not in our control. It would be self-serving for me to take control of mine early and decide who to invite. And for someone else, it's either a group decision of all friends or else it's up to someone to assert sufficient right to get it going. In the end, it's a bootstrapping problem to change the ritual, which may be why it stands as is so securely.

Jeremiah, thanks for contributing the interesting thoughts and experiences. Yes, like a wake, only before one goes to sleep. A pajama party of sorts. :)
It's a good idea Kent and I have a vague idea that I've heard of something like this. It's a sort of roast, not like the vulgar celebrity ones, but I suppose it's usually centered on one those milestone birthdays. They needn't be mutually exclusive.
Abrawang, hmm, you're the second to raise the roast issue so maybe something to it. Thanks for adding your voice.
I like this idea, as well as that of Poetess for a "kind roast."
We tend towards the putdown in the U.S. Perhaps it's time for a change.
R
PW, thanks for the vote of confidence.
Roast beef, Roast turkey,
and thinking 'out loud' . . .
It's courageous if respectable.

I never thought War would linger.
I thought I'd just 'walk-off' to forget.
Some days I seem to wake in blood.
`
Those War Memories are etched . . .
`
Swim-Holes Open Tomorrow.
Hop -In the Green Algae Pond.
Summer-Bath Time Here`Gin!
`
Mu 'rate' button is still broken.
Art, I'm going to take that for agreement. Sounds like you know things best said to the living, if they're still about, rather than to a gravestone. Sorry for memories so hard to let go. While there's value in remembering to some degree, for too many peace of mind is a casualty to such events as well.
Very nice post. I agree with your proposition: "...all of those who’ve affected our lives, even those still among us."

Good job!
Kanuk, thanks for dropping in. Maybe people are just in a good mood for the barbecue weekend. I expected at least some pushback somehow, though I wasn't sure what. I guess it's hard to argue with acknowledging people, though. (I've found that in academic paper-writing, too. The more acknowledging, the better, it seems.)
So here's another model: More like a campout or something. A “Night of Honesty.” It could work for a number of friends to get together and make testimonials about others. My thought is there's sometimes things people stay up way into the night to say to one another that they don't say in the daylight. And as an economic prospect, you could do such an event with a group of people who have some relation, whether it's people who've grown up together, schooled together, worked together, or whatever. I guess there's a risk of people saying negatives, but the purpose could be spelled out to prefer the positives. As a procedural matter, the person being spoken of could be put in a chair with their back turned or were slightly out of sight or something so they could basically listen in on discussions of themselves. Then another could take the role of being the one absent. I suppose the experience could be different for some based on ordering, but that's going to be true of memorial services as they're done now, too. People will speak (at events that allow such and aren't just prepared shows) because someone else said something that triggered them, and there's always an element of chance in that.
I buried my older brother a week ago and you are so right, we reflect on things we never really paid attention to. It occurred to me that throughout our lives, I'd never once seen my brother angry (I'm working on it).

But more to the point, personally I think our present recognitions, funerals, memorials, etc. are morbid things. I don't know what we should do instead but we should celebrate life instead of mourning death. I tell my girls if they can't send me off like a Viking, forget all the other stuff. As for birthdays, they give gifts to me.
Fay, I'm glad you mentioned the morbidity factor. There is some of that, and of course it would go down if there were nothign (or less) to be morbid about. I guess there are various degrees to which people disagree on whether or not to show a body, whether or not to celebrate or mourn, etc. Memorial services are inevitably tied up in such things, but the part of them which is about praising people for what they've done or what they've meant to you is really logically separable.
I'm with you -- like most every other aspect of our culture Memorial Day is schizophrenic. What we are supposed to be memorializing are those who paid the price for our freedom. But instead it's become an occasion for partying and commerce ... for Memorial Day sales, beer bashes, concerts, stock car races, the Indy 500, ad infinitum.

Maybe we should be call it something that reflects what it is -- or at least what it has become. Maybe we should call it May Day, a day of celebration -- because that's what it is now. Maybe we should save the tributes (tributes I regret to say that are too often over the top and politicized and reek of sunshine patriotism) for a more appropriate time like Veterans Day. And let us remember that day with respect and solemnity it so richly deserves.
Tom, thanks for chiming in. I take part of your point to be a bid for proper labeling. I'm with that. As to whether you could offload the remembrance part of memorial day to veteran's day, I dunno. Certainly I was looking to have memorial day used for remembering non-veterans as well. I guess there are a lot of constraints, some potentially conflicting...