The Broccoli Blog

It's Almost Good for You

Kevin Broccoli

Kevin Broccoli
Location
Providence, Rhode Island, United States
Birthday
July 19
Bio
Thoughts, musings, ramblings, and occasional insight from the outside.

MY RECENT POSTS

Kevin Broccoli's Links

Salon.com
MARCH 3, 2011 10:31AM

The "No Comment" Syndrome

Rate: 5 Flag

I have a new pet peeve that's developed over the past year as I post more of what I write online.

I call it the "No Comment" syndrome.

It occurs when someone feels the need to comment on an article they've read by saying, essentially, that they don't have an opinion about it but just felt like commenting anyway.

For example, I wrote a post about a reality television show I watch to have someone respond by saying--

"I don't watch television. Nothing good on it."

Ooooookay.

So why did that person feel the need to tell me that they have nothing to add to what I said?

I don't mind a good discussion, or even an argument, but commenting on an article only to say you have no opinion on it seems sort of pointless, doesn't it?

It makes me wonder if these people actually thought about how they'd sound saying something like that in a social situation.

If you were at a party, and a group of guests were talking about New York and you piped in to say--

"I've never been to New York. Never cared to go."

You'd get a few looks. Most people would consider you rude.

Yet online it seems perfectly reasonable.

As someone who writes a lot about pop culture, I find the "No Comment" people seeking me out even more frequently.

The fact is, nothing about pop culture is necessary--that's why it's pop culture. I write about it and talk about it because it's fun, not because I think it'll solve the problems of the world. I think this seems pretty evident if you read what I write, and yet I still get people who say things like--

"Why get so excited over a movie?" or "What does this song have to do with soldiers dying overseas?"

Well...nothing, but thanks for your input--or lack thereof.

For some people, being online has the intoxicating feeling of being important. They feel that their point of view is crucially needed regardless of what it pertains to, even if it's a point of view without any view--or point for that matter.

I've decided I'm going to start deleting those "No Comment" commentators. Since they're not adding to the discussion anyway, why bother having them there to clog up the works?

Think perhaps I'm going overboard or getting too worked up?

Well then, please--

Feel free to comment.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I don't know where to start.
I agree with you that it's stupid to comment unless you have an opinion to share about the blog. Another pet peeve of mine--people who leave glowing feedback about a story, yet forget to click the "rate" button. I don't generally comment unless I like the blog, and nearly always remember to click "rate" when I do so. Perhaps it's because the comment and "rate" field are so far apart & people forget.

I also think it's common courtesy if someone comments on your blog, to take a look at their latest postings, and comment if you feel so inclined. I generally do so & think it would be a far better site if people reciprocated more often. Rated.
they're sounding off. it's a terrible temptation sometimes hard to resist like eating too many cookies. an alternative is ripping off a few of your own. (just don't do it on my blog.)
Perhaps you should rename your blog: No Comment? or, Comments Only? or, Real, Honest To Good Comments Only That Prove You Read My Blog Post And Can Contribute In A Meaningful Way?
Come to think of it, shouldn't we be able to customize our Comments header with a similar warning/disclaimer? What's up OS?
Where do I begin?

"You are a cool chick."
"Wow, L (another blogger) is late this morning."
"Wow A____, wow!"
"First !"

I'd rather see "read and rated" or "read and appreciated" instead of such inane comments.

I'm glad to see you address this in your blog.
♥R