Kevin Lee

Kevin Lee
Location
Mobile, Alabama, United States
Birthday
January 11
Bio
The less said the better.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
AUGUST 17, 2009 5:11AM

I'm cannon fodder in the health care war

Rate: 79 Flag

My breath was shallow and rapid, the rasping attempts futile. I needed oxygen.

I leaned forward on the desk, fighting, focusing against my body’s panic as I pumped my stomach, forcing my diaphragm in, out, in, out. Nothing helped.

I couldn’t muster the breath to phone for help. I knew my girlfriend was at work, at her desk as always. I reached to the computer and logged onto the Web.

The keys clicked as my heart rate climbed. “Can’t breathe call 911.”

My cell phone rang. I opened it and her frantic questions elicited one grueling word. “Call.”

I slipped from the chair and sank to the floor as everything closed in. My dog came investigating the noise, then stood beside me worriedly licking my hand and arm.

“Is this how it happens?” I wondered. “This is how I die?”

… 

 

You make the best of what you’re given, hacking a path through available terrain. For me, in my time and place, that was a living in the bar and restaurant business.

My health was never a concern. I was an active kid, with a love of the outdoors and sports that stayed with me through college and into adulthood. In my early 30s, I gave up the automobile altogether for a bit to feed my hunger for biking. I would commute on the streets and hit the trails in my spare time. I loved riding, the wind, the sweat, the ache and ardor.

The caveat was my tobacco habit. Like all addicts, I rationalized that I would quit soon enough but still felt things were evened out by my exercise. My blood pressure was low and I still bore the appearance of someone ten years my junior.

In my mid-30s, my work schedule changed and I started using a car more until after a while I was hardly biking anymore. I was just too busy. It was then I noticed my lungs losing effectiveness and chalked it up solely to my lack of exercise.

By then, fate had landed me in the kitchen of a locally renowned chef and restauranteur, someone who had spurred a local culinary renaissance and trained most of the town’s hottest new chefs. Initially, all I wanted to do was finish a novel in progress, then market it in hopes of building funds to relocate. But my new boss was highly flattering of my performance, telling me I was as good as anyone he ever employed.

Slowly, I let the literary vision ebb. As I built contacts and a base of loyal customers, I formulated an idea for finding backers and opening my own place like his previous proteges. In that field, health insurance was a pipe dream that would have to wait until I had my entrepreneurial feet under me. When you owned a business, that was when you could afford it.

The restauranteur developed his own health issues and soon closed up shop. I went through a couple of other upscale jobs while my respiratory function kept degrading. Eventually, it began to impair me at work. I would find myself out of breath in the middle of a rush or growing light-headed in the 110º heat on the line.

I quit smoking but my breathing didn’t improve. I had trouble walking more than a couple hundred feet and the simplest tasks became taxing. I feared the worst and needed answers. A visit to a pulmonologist confirmed my suspicions. It was emphysema.

In that initial visit, two reactions from the medical staff stuck with me. First, there was the strange expression from the receptionist when I told her I would pay in full on the spot, then pulled $500 from my pocket and slid it to her.

The other was the puzzlement from the doctor. Lung function tests revealed incredibly low levels. My forced-expiratory-volume-in-one second (FEV1) was 12% of what it should be for someone my age yet there was no “clubbing” in my fingers, no blueness under the nails and my blood saturation levels were just barely below normal. The doctor couldn’t understand how I was functioning.

It was also puzzling that I developed the disease in my 30s, since the condition normally doesn’t progress to that point until victims are twice my age. He had a hunch.

Bloodwork confirmed I had Alpha-1 Antiptrypsin deficiency. My body didn’t produce a normal proteinase inhibitor that balanced an enzyme (neutrophil elastase) used to destroy bacteria. Without Alpha-1, the enzyme corroded my alveolar walls, snipping proteins and robbing my lungs of elasticity. The walls were still gas permeable but they couldn’t expand or contract normally.

They could give me medicine to make breathing easier but without augmentation therapy to replace the missing Alpha-1, my lungs would continue to deteriorate at an accelerated rate. The treatment involved weekly infusions of Alpha-1 derived from donated plasma. It was costly and continual.

Problem was, with my diagnosis, I wouldn’t be able to get insurance to cover it since it was then officially a pre-existing condition. Even the medicine to aid my breathing, a daily regimen of steroids that acted as broncho-dilators and anti-inflammatories, were prohibitively expensive. The doctor’s staff squirreled away samples from the pharmaceutical reps and slipped them to me every month.

But the augmentation couldn’t be handled like that. My doctor had an idea. “Look, you can’t cook anymore, right?” he said. “I think with that and your test numbers, you could qualify for disability so you could get Medicare. They’d have to give you the treatments.”

It didn’t matter whether I was capable of deskwork or not. What mattered was getting me on an infusion program without which I would die soon.

I had to start the approval process as soon as possible, something that normally takes about two years. One cynical theory I heard advanced was that the two-year wait is to see whether you’ll kick the bucket in that period or not, whether they can save every dime possible.

But during that two years, I would be dependent on the samples from the nurses because the out-of-pocket costs were so high.

… 

 

I heard the front door open and my girlfriend’s steps hammering across the wooden floor. She was frantic, putting the dog and cats away before the emergency techs came in. They eventually got me oxygen and an albuterol treatment then monitored me for a bit. My breathing slowed but my blood oxygen levels were still below usual.

“You need to get to the hospital,” one tech said. “Now, if we take you, it’s going to cost $500. If you can get to your car, you can save the money.” They knew I had no insurance and a chronic disease.

I took tentative steps, then had to stop. I would need the stretcher. They trundled me out as the neighbors all craned and whispered.

Inside the ER, I finally began to feel better. A couple of injections later, I felt fine.

One nurse stood over me asking questions and scrawling on a clipboard. My lack of insurance made no difference for admission.

“Are you allergic to anything?” she asked.

“Country music,” I quipped, pulling out an old Buddy Rich joke.

She laughed and said it was good sign that I had a sense of humor. It wasn’t so funny when they took a draw for my arterial gasses, an excruciating thing that began not with “You’re going to feel a pinch” but with “This is going to hurt.”

The cause of the attack was procrastination. I ran out of an inhaled medication over the weekend and was waiting for Monday to get another surreptitious sample from the doctor’s office. The lack of medicine was enough to cause an asthmatic attack. On top of the emphysema, it was dangerous.

I was in the hospital for three days. The total came to over $8,000.

After release, I worked with a liaison at the hospital to find financial help. Luckily, I stumbled across a local non-profit that gave one-time only aid to cases approved by a board. They had pity on me and paid the hospital bill but the ambulance and lab bills came out of my pocket.

The sole office employee for the foundation was a woman who had recently been diagnosed with fibromyalgia and had her own deep-seated worries flowing beneath our conversations. It wouldn’t be long before she would be seeking her own assistance.

… 

 

In 1999, my dog Lakota and I made a daylong, 10-mile hike through a nearby national forest. Four short years later I had to give up the restaurant business since I couldn’t handle the physical demands or exposure to inhalants.

I began work at a local public radio station. It was highly enjoyable but paid poorly.

I also found employ at a new local newspaper, a small alternative owned by someone I knew from years previous. Without my foot in that door, I likely never would have made their pages.

I finally qualified for Medicare and could leave the purloined samples for others in dire straits. My girlfriend married me but the insurance through her job was of no benefit.

My work at the newspaper gained notice when I picked up a few awards. It was common to encounter people who thought I was somehow living well due to local notoriety. The truth was that in order to continue to qualify for my disability, therefore having the insurance for the meds that keep my respiration even, that keep the augmentations that retard the destruction of my lungs, I can’t earn more than around $900 a month. Without my wife’s income, I wouldn’t be able to afford to live while still having the health care I need.

I'm on three inhalants and one infused drug. The inhalants – Spiriva, Advair and albuterol – keep my breathing comfortable in the steamiest region of the nation. Their annual out-of-pocket costs per year are $2,615.88, $3,983.88 and $1,499.88, respectively.

The infused drug is Zemaira, supplanting the Alpha-1 my body doesn't produce. It’s roughly $128,400 if paid out-of-pocket. 

Altogether, that's $136,499.64 out-of-pocket for meds every year. I have no idea the price of the weekly nurse visits to infuse the Zemaira. 

Were I to win a million dollars (after taxes) tomorrow and lose my disability qualification, thereby losing my insurance, the jackpot wouldn't even pay for a decade's worth of medication for me. 

That means my choices are to remain impoverished so I qualify for insurance for which I can't be excluded or to get a job making $150,000 annually just to be able to live at a minimal level. Were I in Canada, Britain, France or one of many other countries, this wouldn't be a question. Their medical systems would allow me to pursue a career like anyone else and not worry about health care. 

And still I hear the snide remarks from colleagues, family and acquaintances, wise cracks about the laziness and despicable uselessness of those on disability or who take part in our social safety net. I catch protestations about the welfare state and the leeches it breeds.

Granted, I’m biased but I think I’m useful, that I serve a purpose. I founded a cultural organization that has added value to our town, enriching lives, educating minds and bringing acclaim to long ignored artists in our midst. We’ve turned kids onto vocations and passions for artistry.

I’ve tried to say what needs to be said in print, to give voice to those who don’t have it. I’ve got a file filled with notes of gratitude from those about whom I’ve written. A story I penned resulted in an increase of aid to a homeless shelter.

Another story I developed and wrote tied together the actions of a corrupt state attorney general that has resulted in a federal investigation.

Meanwhile, my existence is only possible because of a version of a single-payer health care system demonized by those who benefit from my efforts.

… 

 

My lung function has improved to nearly 20%. I’m still not on supplemental oxygen but it will happen one day, most likely before I reach 60. Maybe. One thing apparent from all of this is that I was blessed with a remarkably and mysteriously resilient corpus.

To look at me, listen to me talk and watch my movements inside the house, you’d never know I was ill unless you noticed me pause my walking every 40 yards (depending on the weather) or how I have to catch my breath every time I bend over. Though I was once known for a ringing voice that could fill clubs sans amplification, I can barely sing and play the guitar simultaneously anymore.

When Lakota fell mortally ill at 15-years old, I couldn’t even pick her up and carry her to the veterinarian on that last night. And when she died, my lungs wouldn’t allow me to sob to the depths my heart sank. My breath was too shallow and I couldn’t draw the air.

My life expectancy has been hacked down. I’ll die at least a good decade before I would have otherwise. Still, I never questioned the illness, never wondered “Why me?” I know the universe isn’t unfair, just indifferent.

Emphysema is incurable and eventually fatal but I ultimately didn’t care. I once ran into a friend with the same disease and his wife asked me, “Aren’t you scared?” I just shrugged and said, “No, it won’t change anything except deny me valuing what life I have.” Fear is a prison.

One hundred years ago, I wouldn’t have made it this far and I’m already a decade older than most humans in history have ever reached. I’ve had my shot at life and created memories I’ll never regret. And as long as I can partake in art, in music, even as an observer, there’s more to be enjoyed. Life is between your ears.

That’s where I have to dwell. 

… 

 

After seeing what has become of the insurance business in the last decades, I have little doubt that if I had happened to have health insurance when I was diagnosed, the company would have found a way to cancel my policy. I would have been too costly over the long run.

The protestations about changes in our health care system are ridiculous. Public health and its resultant financial difficulties seem to me to be an aspect of the “general welfare” cited in the Constitution.

I also know that American culture has changed so much, greed and self-interest have become so central that it has eaten our collective soul. But it will change eventually, it’ll just take catastrophe to do so. Sooner or later, enough people will realize that everyone is considered a target of the insurance industry. Not partners, not consumers, but targets. At the same time they become prey for disease, they will also fill that role for the industry that seeks to profit from their misery. When enough discover it, things will change but there will be a lot of unnecessary suffering until then.

… 

 

Though I’ve adjusted, I still miss biking, hiking or just being able to take walks. I miss being able to go hear live music where I wish or even eat in certain restaurants because of the smoke.

I sometimes have dreams filled with activity, where I’m playing football again. Sometimes I’m just running down a street and the joy is overwhelming. My feet are light, my legs strong and the world rushes past.

In other dreams, I'm with Lakota again, loping like we once did across fields, just ecstasy and sunshine and all the crisp air we can pull in.  

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
This is awful. No country should force such conditions on people.

But you're certainly not alone. I remember passing up medical care (though nothing this scary) when I lived in the U.S.

I hope at least one "no socialism in America" partisan reads this and is affected by it.

Thanks.
Just for comparison: I also rely on several different kinds of medication, and has to visit a doctor regularly. I pay the first $275 out of my own pocket. After that, the Norwegian healthcare system takes care of the bill (financed, in part, by my taxes, of course). The situation you describe is just tragic.

To me, the US healthcare debate is missing the point. It's not really about private or public, cost control and tort reform. Fundamentally, this is a moral issue. It's perfectly possible for a nation as wealthy as yours to finance healthcare for all. What appears to be missing is the will to do it.

That's a disgrace.
Christ.

I am so sorry.

You are a very, very good writer. I could read you all day.

I'm very sorry.
Things must change...Different endings will be written al over the country without change.....
benjamin- Needless to say, the "socialism in America" crowd angers me. I feel most of them are merely selfish and know that one day, they'll be in the boat I'm in and their attitude will change.

norwonk- I heard someone say last week that the difference between liberals and conservatives is that "the left takes to the streets when public money is used to harm people and the right takes to the streets when public money is used to help people." Can't say I disagree.

wakingupslowly- Thanks.

Hoop- Looks like Claudette is a whole lot of nothing 'round here. We haven't even gotten any decent wind out of it.
Ron- Things will eventually change one way or another. What's so disappointing about this is that, as norwonk said above, this is basically a moral issue and our failures on it give credence to every slam and slur delivered at America from abroad.
Didn't the vast majority of us demand a public option for health care coverage? Where are all of us? Rated for outstanding writing.
zuma- I thought we did. As Rachel Maddow said yesterday, Obama is about to squander huge amounts of political capital if he doesn't fight like hell for a public option. It's inexcusable considering the mandate in this past November's polling place and the previous years of right wing hegemony in the face of lesser advantage.
I am so sorry and I empathize. I am sorry this happened to you.
I like your attitude, and I'm grateful for your passion.

Rated, enthusiastically.
Re: your comments to benjamin:

If you haven't seen this yet, it's worth checking out. It helps to laugh as your cry: http://www.thedailyshow.com/watch/thu-august-13-2009/glenn-beck-s-operation
Gosh, what a story! As for your statement that "American culture has changed so much, greed and self-interest have become so central that it's eaten our collective soul." I think you watch and listen to too much white male Republican-controlled media. Current media hardly provides a realistic view of this nation. Doggie sweaters and bar-b-que recipes are a smokescreen obscuring the real issues. Ever see any tent cities on TV? Yet they're everywhere! Hear about the new wind and solar technologies, new roofing methods? Nope, unless you have access to "Planet Green", a cable station. Keep in mind, that Republicans and their whores dominate the air waves with the likes of Bill O'Reilly as TV stars. Being rude and insulting in addition to never qualifying anything said and lowering every issue to a purely emotional and visceral level describes the Republican media and Republican tactics.....it's all part of the plan moving this nation toward Fascism. Please don't generalize....not all Americans are greedy and only interested in themselves!
This should be an EP. I am glad that you can still be with Lakota doing the things you love in your dreams.
Dorinda- Thanks for the condolences. Still, there are plenty out there just like me and far worse. Our sympathies will ultimately come to nothing if we don't use them as motivation to bring about change.

shaggylocks- People react to chronic illness in various ways. What I've seen is that keeping the lightest attitude possible (even if it involves "dark humor") about it not only is better for your physiology, but enhances the ability to enjoy what life you have left. And Glenn Beck is an asshat. In the two Alabama cities where I've lived, the election of the first African-Americans into the top leadership positions (mayor) in each city accelerated White Flight. I wish the election of Obama would result in Right Flight, sending conservatives en masse to the libertarian paradise of Somalia.

Soap Box Amy- I didn't say all Americans were greedy, I spoke of American culture. And I'm sorry, but the people I encounter and the things I read in local media give me that perspective. Just look at the dichotomy of how the different ends of the economic spectrum are treated. Compare the reaction to the concepts of laissez faire capitalism and socialism. One is catered to or handled gently while the other is outright demonized.

As far as I can tell from my interactions with other media members, programming follows the path it does because people flock to it. If the ratings weren't there, they wouldn't head in that direction. The media outlets that are in the business of illumination rather than preaching to the choir are those in public broadcasting.
Emma- I'd be happy if it were an EP as well but only because people need to hear how easy it is to slip between the cracks of our system. I'm also glad to see Lakota in that manner. My wife and I both still dream of her all the time and miss her terribly.
Horrible story but very necessary. Addressing the "pre-existing condition" problem is essential. My son, much like me has allergy induced asthma. His Pediatrician has not deemed him as "asthmatic" as he doesn't need daily Albuterol, just occasional. Same for me. If he does get designated as "asthmatic", under our current system he would pay for it the rest of his life.

Before the smoking ban in most clubs, I had problems dealing with smoke and other inhalants/irritants myself. I find it a bit easier today.

I wish you the best and thanks for sharing this with us. Important stuff.

Rated
Kevin - thanks for writing this. We need more stories, I think, even though any one anecdote doesn't "prove" anything, the preponderance of stories like yours ought to be persuasive. Then again, that counts on people having a heart, and thinking beyond themselves and what the media tells them, and it seems like that's in short supply. Dammit.
I second what Emma said. You've brought the issue around to the proper perspective.

I can't believe the amount of energy devoted to denying the common good. May you outlast the thugs who would deny you a share of the"general welfare."
Kevin: My heart goes out to you. You deal with this problem with aplomb and grace. You write equally so. Wish your story were one of those that everyone in this country read given its relevance to the health care debate. I've written something today further on this issue at my blog.
KOB- I was lucky. Before the emphysema, I never had problems with asthma, much less allergies (hell, I wasn't even allergic to poison ivy, believe it or not). I guess the pendulum is swinging back the other way now.

Another kicker to this whole thing is that of all my meds, albuterol is the least expensive but it's the one Humana covers least. I don't pay for the other ones, but I have to kick in a co-pay for the albuterol. Go figure.

The smoking in clubs is a weird thing. People always act like they are being infringed by a "nanny state" with the bans but they fail to see it's not what they're doing to themselves that is the issue, it's the "going in the lungs of others." No one cares about the alcohol consumption because when you take a drink, everyone else in the room doesn't sip it too.

One of my bosses told me once that there had never been proof second hand smoke does anything harmful. I immediately said that was bullshit, that I WAS the proof because if I'm exposed to it, I can feel the difference and have barely been able to make it back to my car at times due to it. His response was that I'm "a special case" and "that doesn't count." Of course, he's a hard core rightie, too...
For what it's worth, I reddited and dugg it.
Owl- The way I see it, the only thing that really matters with health care is the anecdotal as the issue is the most personal imaginable. Thanks for the furthering of this, too.

Stacy- Thanks for the well wishes. It's a shame what contortions people often do to rationalize not doing "the right thing."

Dennis- Thanks for the kind words. I wish more people could read this because this could very easily be any of us in my shoes.
" . . . people need to hear how easy it is to slip between the cracks of our system."

To speak of "cracks in the system" implies that these are somehow unintentional or accidental. But they are not.

They are large chasms built into the system, the result of conscious decisions and policies over many years. When someone falls into the chasm that doesn't meant that the system isn't working. It means that the system is working as designed -- that the system functions by excluding tens of millions of people from affordable health care. Who falls into the chasms may be a matter of chance, but the existence of the chasms is how the system is designed.

We could have improved the system, but we chose not to. It remains to be seen whether the current movement to reform the system will result in any significant improvement.
You have my deepest sympathy. I cant imagine anything worse than being constantly out of breath. The biggest threat in this country is not socialism but out-of-control capitalism. What did they do for you in 3 days that cost them 8000? We're being charged for junk coming and going and receiving few if any services in return. I am tired of people like Bill Maher blaming us for our own poor health when corporations who release huge amounts of toxins into the environment go without regulation and our time is worth less and less and our leisure is nonexistant, not to mention chemicals put into the food chain that can cause disease. It's like being told that changing your lightbulbs can stop global warming. It may help on a small scale, but not without the cooperation on a larger scale. I know you smoked and didn't exercise as much as you could, but newsflash! That's most of our population. You do not deserve to die for it.

I have epilepsy which I do not really feel is my fault, if you can believe it. I also smoked. I was also on medication for most of my life that made me really, really sick, rotted my teeth and is the cause for my son's spina bifida. You can bet the pharmaceutical company that provided me with medicine for years is taking absolutely no responsibility for my misfortunes, nor will the cigarette company that supplied us with our vice. Why must we pay for poor choices with our lives?
social support for health care is a matter for the congress of the usa to decide, with the possibility of a presidential veto. i'm sure they will do what's best. not best for you, of course- best for them.

but i'm not sure the people of the usa would want to support your continuing expense, for while they are generous with other people's money, they seem reluctant to help the unfortunate with their own. that's socialism, you know. it used to be christianity also, but american christianity is like american democracy: neither christian nor democratic.

mind you, learning that smoking causes health problems came late to america, obscured by the sacred right of cigarette manufacturers to get rich. americans deserve to pay for the consequences of defending that sacred right.
This is just devastating, sad, and wrong on all levels. It's maddening. I'm not sure how many stories like this we will have to read before people will "get it". As a matter of fact, you have just inspired an idea. Why don't you create a website where people can submit their healthcare nightmare stories and pitch it to a publisher?
This moving post points out all that's wrong with US healthcare. I know of a catastrophic illness; I wish you well.
I am glad that you are here. What Obama needs to do, is to get people like you on TV telling their stories over and over again. Healthcare for all is not socialism, it is HUMANISM.

(I have had trouble breathing for some months now, and I can't see a specialist because I have no insurance.)
Latest:

A buddy in New York suggested I send this to the NYTimes but its previous publication on this blog would prevent them from running it.

So, I've gone another route. I actually met Surgeon General nominee Dr. Regina Benjamin about six years ago. We have mutual friends and they suggested I see her regarding treatment when I first was diagnosed. I drove down to her clinic in Bayou La Batre and we spent some time talking about my situation.

I wrote Dr. Benjamin an e-mail just a while ago, reintroducing myself and including this piece. I told her it was my dearest wish that she use her access to Pres. Obama to get the essay into his hands. We'll see what transpires.
I, like Owl, added a "digg" to your post. Enough of those and our site's editors may notice the traffic and place this on the cover. Fingers crossed.
this is a powerful read. thank you for sharing your story, and thank you for writing it so beautifully. i would carry you into the sea of conservative activists on my shoulders if i could, so they could see exactly what kind of choices they are defending.

thanks for pointing me here emma! we need to start a 'nother cover for e.p.p.s... emma peel picks.
Thanks too to Emma for pointing me here. Other than pointing out the obvious -- that there is no alternative to universal healthcare in this country -- the one thing that jumps out at me in your story is that had you had insurance your bill would have been a fraction of what you actually paid. It's always the uninsured who are hit with the biggest bills because there's no 'group' rate. Sounds like you had caring doctors, or doctors who didn't want to mess with a journalist? But everyone should know that they need to try to negotiate better rates with their doctors.
Kevin, my heart goes out to you. I just wanted to let you know that because of some things I have going on at the moment, your courage and grace were just what I needed to read. Thank you.
mishima- I understand and agree. Of course, the unspoken aspect of that is the callousness of a people who can abide by such.

latethink- I don't want anything from cigarette companies. I chose to smoke just as I chose to quit. I didn't, however, choose this disease as you didn't choose epilepsy or spina bifida.

al loomis- I agree with this, "american christianity is like american democracy: neither christian nor democratic." But how does that factor into SAILBOATS?

cartouche- That's an excellent idea and evidence of a mighty healthy right brain.

chuck- If we all looked, I'll bet we could find similar stories in our local communities.

delia & bstrangely- I would gladly tell whoever wants to hear about this. Of course, my nature is also to tell dissembling, rambling and disingenuous politicians to "shut the the hell up" because I know their games and don't cotton to them.

crabby- I wasn't a journalist when this all started so there was none of that involved. Although I will say my pulmonologist is Filipino and I've wondered how much his foreign value system has to do with his compassion. He and I get along great and caused my then-girlfriend some alarm when she saw us joking around to the extent we did during my hospital stay.

natalie- Thanks, that's high praise considering how full your plate is.
we need more real stories like yours to remind people why we need a health care system that puts people ahead of profits

I admire your courage and resilience, as well as your ability as a writer
This is a great story. I went through something similar myself. I am now as good as housebouind. I go nowhere. OS gives me the only real happiness I get now. Shame, I use to love to walk, go to restaurauts. No more, I hope you get better my man, i really do!!
Rated!~~
roy- Thanks. To me, "people ahead of profits" should never leave health care. It's not like the industry is selling toasters or other products. We're talking about the core of survival itself.

scanner- I hate to hear that. At least I can get out of the house. I don't know your particulars but I hope things improve for you.
"Sooner or later, enough people will realize that everyone is considered a target of the insurance industry. Not partners, not consumers, but targets."

No truer words were ever spoken.

Great post. Stay well.
My heart goes out to you. Yours is an amazing story. I appreciate reading it.
Thanks for this story. I lost my lung function once and almost died due to pulmonary embolism. But I had insurance, and I kept seeing doctors until it was diagnosed just in time. It was a Cobra plan, and when that ran out, I became "uninsurable". If it wasn't for HIPAA and my ability to pay through the nose, I'd have none now. I'd never be strong enough to carry on as you do. You have my deepest respect and empathy. Best wishes.
You are a shining star in the darkness that is America. I respect and admire you. If there is a god, I pray for you. I will share your story with others...it is a very familariar one. The light in my heart honors the light in your heart. Namaste.
I'm sorry for your illness. Thanks for sharing your story. This should be read on the floor of Congress. Important post. I hope Salon promotes it. I hope it goes viral.
Take care.
My sympathies for your situation Kevin, and my thanks to you for writing this important post.

"American culture has changed so much, greed and self-interest have become so central that it has eaten our collective soul. But it will change eventually, it’ll just take catastrophe to do so. Sooner or later, enough people will realize that everyone is considered a target of the insurance industry. Not partners, not consumers, but targets. At the same time they become prey for disease, they will also fill that role for the industry that seeks to profit from their misery. When enough discover it, things will change but there will be a lot of unnecessary suffering until then."

More people need to read this; there are still people in this country capable of empathy and reason, though to hear the discourse going on right now it'd be easy to think otherwise.
:(

A great story that hopefully someone/s of importance will read and feel that tinge in their heart to get something done!

Rated.
brie, paddle, umbrella- Thank you. I'm just a guy who was forced into a situation. I wrote about it because I think there's something to be learned that could help far more people than myself.

kelly- Man, that stinks about the embolism! Most people don't realize how severely your brain resorts to primal behavior when respiration is compromised and it can be frightening. As you know, "necessity" has more to do with facing it than "strength."

Remember Ma Joad's quote to Pa in the film version of "Grapes of Wrath" about how us "common" are tenacious, "Rich fellas come up an' they die, an' their kids ain't no good an' they die out. But we keep a'comin'. We're the people that live. They can't wipe us out; they can't lick us. We'll go on forever, Pa, 'cause we're the people."

Good luck with your battles.

C Berg- That's pretty flattering. Mucho gracias.

MJ, nan & tink- I hope that Dr. Benjamin can aid in my quest to have this read by someone in power, to have it disseminated wider and to make sure it doesn't happen to others. I'm naturally skeptical of politics, but I guess I can stave that off for a while.
Most of us on OS write our hearts out, but mostly we fall short at making anything like, oh, let's call it a "New Yorker" piece. And even the professionals (and brilliant amateurs) here mange to pull out a polished gem only once in a great while, that MIGHT be, someday, with some work, a NYr level piece of writing.

You, Kevin, have done it with this piece. From stem to stern this is intimate Voice, clean prose, well-organized storytelling and reads like a rush of wind on the high plains. If it were a movie it would be one long shot, you sitting, catching your breath, on the dog walk by the shore, with an empty leash in your hands, telling us this.

(Many of us know from this. I still cannot quite bring myself to do as you have done, tell my own version of this American Tragi-Farce, because it hurts too much. You give me courage to try it again.)

THIS:
"And when she died, my lungs wouldn’t allow me to sob to the depths my heart sank. My breath was too shallow and I couldn’t draw the air."

You break my heart, Kevin. For real.
Dear Kevin, I can't praise this piece enough! I live and work in an extremely "red" state where people just don't get it. I'm lucky, I have good employer supplemented health insurance but I know many, many, many hard-working people who don't. I plan on sharing your story so maybe more people will understand. RATED.
Been away from OS and just aw this. Great piece...personalized makes it stand out.
I hope your past connection with Dr. Benjamin can take this post to other ears.
Take care and good health wishes.
Aside from the shocking inhumanity of what you've had to endure from the American health care system, this was just so very sad to read:

"And when she died, my lungs wouldn’t allow me to sob to the depths my heart sank. My breath was too shallow and I couldn’t draw the air."

You have combined so well your own personal story with the big picture of exactly what is wrong with our system.
Must add my voice to everyone else's: The experience you relate in this piece moves and shames beyond words. It is New Yorker- or Harper's-worthy.

But therein lies the classic problem: publication in just about any medium will reach mainly people who already understand the tragedy of the American health care non-system. A whole other contingent remains unexposed.

And so every time a new wave of health reform takes shape, we descend into an epic conflict between two camps with differing age-old premises about what American society is about. Your case illustrates what the premise of the progressive camp is.

Those opposed to substantive reform do not base their case on evidence, or experiences in other countries, or compassion for others. They base it on something far more primal: two deeply inculcated ideologies that are impervious to demonstrations of fact because they are belief-based:
collective action for the collective well-being is socialism, anathema to American sensibilities and an absolute evil to be shunned or purged, whatever the consequences of doing so
the profit motive always works better than collective action
The experiences both of other, "foreign" health care systems and of individual Americans then, conveniently, become irrelevant to their case.

Thanks for posting an archetypal nightmare to which any of us could fall prey under the wrong circumstances. Unless miracles are considered pre-existing conditions, I hope one happens for you.

May the Public Option be with us.
To everyone who has commented and rated this, I thank you. Those who have deemed it worthy of New Yorker and other exalted publications flatter me to say the least.

Thanks again. If we all band together, we can make a difference but only in sufficient numbers.
To all the anti-Obama haters. This could happen to you! rated & favorited.
Beautifully written. You should send this as a letter to the Whitehouse. The more examples Obama has of health care not working the better.
Bravo Kevin for sharing your story. I know exactly your type of situation as I share the pre-existing situation, it is my wife but it has the exact effect. I could get a job paying 200k a year, but one monthly medication is 10k. I choose then to just get us by, it is depressing for me. I have two shit jobs that keep us afloat, but I have to turn down employment constantly as not to hurdle over the magic number of Medicaid. I have even been told of people getting divorced on paper to avoid this situation, which is just a horrible concept that given the time I would launch into a tangent on marriage and its sanctity. I hate it for you Kevin, thank you for your story.
For your sake, for my sake, for the sake of this nation's people, we need to change the healthcare system. If we are a nation, we need to be a caring one.
oh Kevin, this is an incredible post. I am so glad that your words are being spread. I know how you feel and you have given me the courage to tell my similar story. Both my parents died from Emphyzema and I fear I'm in the early stages. I won't go to the doctor ...guess why?....no insurance! Continue to have courage, my man.
"Life is between your ears."

Love that line. Great post!
Front page of Big Salon!
You know my story with lupus and why this hits home. When I had insurance and the doctors suspected lupus, the insurance quit covering tests and meds. After I lost my job due to illness, the "suspected" lupus made any illness which might or might not have been related to lupus a "pre-existing". I had doctors refuse to write anything which might lead to a diagnosis of lupus in my charts so that the insurance agencies could not consider it a "pre-existing". Still, it meant having insist that my symptoms were brand new each and every time I saw a new doctor, because if it was assumed I had the symptoms prior to seeing a doctor would have again made it appear as a "pre-existing".

I also looked into getting disability but as a single woman it would have meant homelessness. There is also no way I could have gone a couple of years without income while trying to prove disability. Yes, I have known people who died waiting for their disability to kick in. This is a joke.

For a country which prides itself on being Christian it is amazing how we have no Christian values. The same people who brag about their church and who are have both social security and Medicare seem hell-bent on not allowing others to have the same rights. I'm tired of fighting this fight. I am relieved to see the number of people who have read your post and hope others will find it. Redditt, dugg, etc hoping for that chance.
marcelle- If you look up further in the comments thread, you'll see I'm trying to indeed get this to the White House.

andrew bridgers- My wife and I were fully prepared to get divorced had the situation threatened my qualification for disability.

fabflamingo- If you're contracting emphysema, you at least have a familiarity with it to help cope. I hope you live somewhere that's not humid.

RL- When it gets to the point that doctors are willingly gaming the system by lying on reports because it's required to aid patients, that's a huge sign something is drastically wrong. This can't go on much longer.

While there are indeed doctors out there who are greedy asses who've lost compassion, there are also others who still cherish the ideals that put them in the profession initially. If you're lucky enough to find those folks, as you and I have been, you better hang onto them.
This is the most amazing personal story I have ever read. Forgive me if it seems disrespectful to compliment you on your writing, and in so doing, appear glib to your immense suffering.

Tell me that this is not happening in our country. Tell me that this is some work of Dickens, or Sinclair, or Shakespeare. I felt more pain from this story than from anything I have ever heard, save the news of the death of a close relative. Amazing!

I have some relatives who own a bed and breakfast in Mobile. I think its time for another visit. Wanna write a screenplay? Who would want to play you?
Kevin,
Go to Whitehouse.gov. In the right hand corner is the "contact us" button. The staff reads every letter that comes in and you can make your letter public so that anyone can read it. It's one way, at least.
Karin- I think immigration into Canada is limited by various factors including age, occupation and health, is it not? That's a might magnanimous offer, by the way. Thanks.

Bill- Oh, it's no slight to pass on kudos for writing. Giving someone a sense of self-worth is never wasted.

And I wouldn't classify my suffering as "immense." Compared to people I can find within a few miles of my home, I've been through nothing. My wife and I have a moderately comfortable existence when compared with the world at large. Ever see "About Schmidt?" Aside from it's mega-tearjerker ending, it clarifies that a lot of us are luckier than we often realize.

marcelle- Thanks for the tip. I'll do that.
You point out a very common problem for people with chronic, progressive illnesses, particularly diseases such as MS, lupus, Crohn's, and myasthenia gravis. People diagnosed with these conditions may be able to continue working full time for some time, but eventually as their condition worsens, their ability to work is compromised. They either must cut back to minimal hours or give up work entirely. This is particularly true for people with diseases that flare up for long periods. Contrary to what most people think, employers are not required to keep employees who require long absences due to illness. Once you're out of the safe harbor of employer-provided coverage and in the private market (assuming you took COBRA coverage), you learn the hard way that your condition makes you uninsurable. Being cut from coverage is all but inevitable. No insurance, no disease management. no treatment. So people with progressive conditions try to do what you've done, which is apply for disability coverage, which allows them to obtain Medicare coverage but with strings attached. I know many women with autoimmune disorders who were forced out of their careers in the prime of their lives becasue of illness, and they would love to be creative and contribute in whatever way they could during their brief periods of remission. But if they earn $900 a month for any nine individual months, even over the course of ten years, they are out of Medicare. And they are back without a job and without health insurance, which is essential to survival. So they are stuck. These people are far from lazy; in fact, most of the women I know with these conditions were high-achieving workaholics who continued to pay their substantial student loans long after their bodies failed them. If Congress ends the pre-existing condition exclusion and offers a well-priced public or public/private hybrid option, many people with chronic illnesses will choose an option other than Medicare. They may not be able to hold down a traditional job, but they could try to be productive in their own way, even if it's for two months every year.
You say it all so well. I'm glad you're here to write it down.
Thank you for sharing your story. The cruel travesty of being identified as having a "pre-existing condition" can happen to anyone - especially if they have lost their job-with-benefits. Ironically, if one is lucky enough to live long enough, they WILL have a pre-existing condition.
American culture has changed so much, greed and self-interest have become so central that it has eaten our collective soul.

As many have pointed out, this single sentence pretty much describes how we got into the damn mess we're in. The whole "Up yours, jack, I got mine" mentality is killing this country.

Kevin, as a former smoker (smoked for about twenty years, gave it up for good something like eight years ago and never looked back) I can so easily relate. I never developed emphysema, thank goodness, and if I'm lucky I quit in enough time to help repair the damage I did. Time will tell, I guess.

Your story deserves to be front page news and turned into a book deal to be featured on Oprah. It is the very heart of our health care crisis, and why things need to change radically and now, not in another four years. You should not have to jump through flaming hoops to get medicine or appropriate care. It is, pardon my plain language, fucking inhuman to do that to people.

Thumbed. Please keep us posted as to whether you get interest in this piece from publications - I'd like to read it in print somewhere besides Open Salon.
Kevin, I am very late getting to this, but also very glad I got to read it. You put a real life face on this national medical crisis, and show that there is really only one way out of the quagmire we are in.

I admire your courage and your attitude, not accepting defeat in any aspect of your own medical problem. I salute you.

That you continue to live your life to the fullest possible, and continue to have a positive outlook, reveals a man who understands life and the tragedy it can involve, and accepts what he has to work with, helping others in the process.

I am proud to call you my friend.

Monte

BTW: this post is extraordinarily well written. You capture your readers immediately and we walk beside you all the way. That is a rare talent.
ameshall- There seems to be a fair amount of confusion with this. While at times, I've heard what you and I state, I also hear that once you're on Medicare, you're there for life regardless of your disability status. There have also been times I've heard my Medicare won't cover all medical and dental procedures, just those related to my disability. One OS poster even messaged me and volunteered to get clarification.

But beneath all of that ambiguity is this: the confusion itself is yet another symptom and product of how screwed up our health care system is. It shouldn't be this fuzzy.

cindy ross- Lung volume reduction surgery is normally not recommended for those whose emphysema is caused by Alpha-1 deficiency since the damage doesn't start in one area and spread from there. It has a tendency to attack the lung in various areas at once.

In January of 2008, I traveled to the University of Alabama in Birmingham to look into the possibility of lung transplant. Among the things that stayed with me about the visit was 1) the beauty of the building we were in, which was designed by acclaimed architect I. M. Pei, and 2) my health in comparison to others that were there.

During the evaluation process, you ascend up a series of floors, undergoing a different battery of tests on each. They were looking at good number of potential patients then and I noticed that I was the only one not on supplemental oxygen. The other patients noticed as well and I could see it in their "What is this guy doing here?" looks.

After all was said and done, I consulted with a doctor who told me I was a great candidate. Getting in line for such would involve moving from Mobile to a location within two hours of UAB and undergoing a pretty drastic lifestyle change.

He also pointed to a chart that showed their "success" rates for transplants was 80% two years out from the transplant and 50% five years from the transplant. In less fanciful language, five years from the operation, were it in the next year, there would only be a 50% chance my body wouldn't reject the new organs. I might not be the most robust middle aged guy, but I'm pretty confident that in my present pulmonary state (with the treatment underway and my deterioration holding firm), my lungs aren't going to off me in the next five years. My pulmonologist at home agreed. I didn't get on the waiting list.

Also, what I saw in those lobbies with the other potential recipients was so heartbreaking, I felt guilty for being there. At one point, I saw someone in dire straits receive word there was nothing that could be done and it was all I could do not to begin crying right there.

Bill S- Don't apologize for the language as it expresses only a fraction of the outrage I've felt decades before it was "my butt in a sling." To call it a travesty is only the beginning of it.

Monte- Thanks. As you might be aware, I was raised in a fundamentalist Christian household. As such, the values that were imparted to me regarding our treatment of others fall along those lines. While I have since grown skeptical of the ascribed supernatural aspects of Christianity, I have retained a belief in the espoused tenets attributed to its central character. I think the direct teachings of Jesus, regardless of his ostensible deity, are a first rate guide for how we are to treat each other, a handbook toward creating the best world we can for ourselves as a whole.

Oh that I could say the same for so many of the supposed Christians I've encountered. I find the absence of voices from the Religious Right on the health care issue ear-splitting.

Thanks again for your kind words and support.
I didn't think I could read one more piece about health care, but I kept seeing this one pop-up and thought I'd peek. Then I started to read and wanted to stop but I couldn't. I kept reading and my children called to me and I told them to figure it out themselves. I was so droawn into your words. This was so well written and your story is so powerful. Really, you should be doing the talk show circuit, published in the best papers, etc., etc. My heartaches for you and I wish you a peaceful and easier road ahead.
UPDATE:
Still no word from Dr. Benjamin. I called her clinic earlier and left a message for her to call me at the first possible opportunity.

I've sent copies of this to Andrew Sullivan and Ed Schultz. The NYTimes is unwilling to receive letters to the editor longer than 150 words, so I'll have to make a hard copy of this and send it to them.

I will have to make a query to Harper's to see if they want a copy of it.

The New Yorker appears unwilling to receive anything with a "don't call us..." attitude flowing from their Web site.

The piece was too long to e-mail to the White House in the space alloted so this morning I sent it via snail mail with the following dated cover letter:

"Pres. Obama,

Enclosed you will find a personal testimony to my trials in pursuit of treatment for a rare, chronic and fatal congenital condition. It has elicited a great deal of favorable and enthusiastic response from those who’ve read it and I hope its message finds a receptive audience in your mind and heart.

Last year, I put aside my growing cynicism about the American political system, motivated by what I heard in your words and the hope I felt you stirred in many others like myself. Chief among my concerns was a belief you would seek real reform for our broken health care system, reform that at the very least would include a public option for insurance that eradicated the dreaded “pre-existing condition” and exorbitant rates that effectively eliminate quality care for many who need it most.

The fight for this reform is a moral imperative in this nation, perhaps the most important one since the movement that shook our country in the years you and I were both born. We must not fail at this since to do so is to drop the torch handed to us by those who believed in a refinement of our national dream, people who paid for its promise with their very lives. Their faith is in our hands.

Thank you for your time.

Sincerely,

Kevin B. Lee
(snail mail & e-mail address)"

We'll see if it elicits anything.
This extraordinary (and sad) story illustrates the absurdity of our current health care system. As a physician who's never seen a case of alpha-1-antitrypsin deficiency, I find your story fascinating. It is beautifully written. Wishing you a long life, filled with sunshine, crisp air, and open fields.
beautifully written
Americans think they are so "independent"
in this they are just ignorant and provincial

my husband also has reduced lung capacity from polio
it will shorten his life too

we must get national health
we can't fail
I'm late in reading this, but I'm so glad I did. Your story needs to be heard. Why don't you revise this to fit an op-ed style, rather than a letter to the editor? The New York Times accepts open submissions for op-eds, though it is very selective. I'm guessing the word limit is between 500 and 1,000 words, so you'd probably have to re-imagine the whole piece as something shorter. I'm sure there are other national publications that accept op-ed submissions as well. I really hope this reaches the audience that needs it most. Do keep us updated!
"I also know that American culture has changed so much, greed and self-interest have become so central that it has eaten our collective soul." - that sums it up so well - this is what I fear exactly. I guess I am hoping against hope that we find our soul after all..

So sorry that you have had this terrible experience. It's bad enough becoming ill, but to have to face all this monetary pressure at the same time is horrible.
I haven't said a word at Open Salon in several months, re-adjusting to life in The United States and Spokane, Washington in particular where summer just started a few days before the fourth of july. But this morning I saw one of Ms Emma Peel's brief exhortations to read a new contributor . . . and read this I have.

Mr, you and I are contemporaries; I'll be 59 on August 11th, and I know from what you've said that you must be that age too, or close to it. I'll tell you one thing, buddy; I hate the laicism, liaison between physicians who are STEADFAST members of the American Medical Association and drug salesman who are STEADFAST members of the Chamber of Commerce and corporate one-time or former biochemists who are now STEADFAST members of some grand nameless lobby whose STEADFAST financial contributors certainly include Phizer, Baush & Lomb, Proctor & Gamble, Johnson & Johnson, etc., etc., etc. . . . And I'll just say one more thing here before I go to my own untended blog to let off some more steam (and there's a goddamned site more where this much has already come from!) . . . when I had my own asthma attack one night last week, at least a friend was standing near by yelling encouragement to me (well, not really yelling) "Suck it up, you gotta just suck it up, man." That sort of thing. So, after this bicycle enthusiast finally got to his feet he stumbled or staggered toward the gate which opens both ways, and he goes along the alley in a brief fit of mortal terror of losing his life to the bodiless grip of suffocation. Yes, it felt like I was being suffocated, as though someone were pushing a pillow down over my face. So, I KNOW how you felt, and how you feel whenever that happens: like you're 100 feet underwater, and someone has just shoved his hand into your stomach forcing out the last of the air in your lungs . . . and you still have to swim, swim up to that shimmering light called a surface.

Don Stacy