Editor’s Pick
SEPTEMBER 8, 2010 8:55PM
A Young Girl Proves Me Wrong on America's Got Talent
Back in June when America's Got Talent started its latest season, I posted my reaction to it. Among my various comments and random critiques, I wrote: "I think children should be barred from the competition unless they are truly remarkable, equal to or surpassing the finest adult performers. Otherwise, they turn the show into amateur hour, or worse, an exploitation of their unrefined talents. Also, they should limit the number of singers who make it to the finals -- there are other talents much more entertaining to watch, but those acts usually seem to be kicked off early for some reason and we end up with a string of b-rate singers, turning America's Got Talent into a poor-man's version of American Idol."
Not only did I disparage young performers, I also denounced singing acts. Well, along came a little girl named Jackie Evancho who proved me wrong on both counts. This child has an amazing voice, terrific stage presence, and definitely deserves to be a finalist on any professional performing arts competition. Her opera singing is good enough for me to want to buy a ticket to see her live on stage.
I'm a fan of some of the other acts that have talents easily suited for Las Vegas, but there is no doubting that little Jackie Evancho made me eat my words by proving that she has the skill to compete with the older, more experienced men and women on the show. Just like the first time I heard Charlotte Church sing, I think Miss Evancho has a brilliant career ahead of her.
Not only did I disparage young performers, I also denounced singing acts. Well, along came a little girl named Jackie Evancho who proved me wrong on both counts. This child has an amazing voice, terrific stage presence, and definitely deserves to be a finalist on any professional performing arts competition. Her opera singing is good enough for me to want to buy a ticket to see her live on stage.
I'm a fan of some of the other acts that have talents easily suited for Las Vegas, but there is no doubting that little Jackie Evancho made me eat my words by proving that she has the skill to compete with the older, more experienced men and women on the show. Just like the first time I heard Charlotte Church sing, I think Miss Evancho has a brilliant career ahead of her.



Salon.com
Comments
Your vocal chords don't fully develop until you are somewhere in the neighborhood of ages 30-35. I was actually turned away from a voice teacher when I was fourteen because she wanted my voice to mature more before we got into learning technique. I waited a year and then started studying right before I turned sixteen. It was about a year before I sang my first aria, before then it was all relatively light art songs. O Mio Babbino Caro was my third aria I think and that may have been a year after the first one.
A good teacher will not give an eleven year old an aria, no matter how pretty the voice. Charlotte Church can no longer sing classically either because of what she sang at Jackie's age.
I may write my own piece on here about this, but I'm not really a writer.