.

Lainey

Lainey
Location
Ohio,
Birthday
February 25
Bio
working on restraint

MY RECENT POSTS

Lainey's Links

Salon.com
Editor’s Pick
OCTOBER 28, 2008 1:15AM

On Black Presidents and Live Babies

Rate: 18 Flag

Daytime and evening phone banks are qualitatively different. On Tuesday mornings I wax philosophical with Strongsville’s universe of undecided voters about the local homeless man who registered 79 times at the behest of ACORN (I assure them that not only was the man not going to vote 79 times, he wasn’t even going to vote once—that voter registration fraud is not the same thing as voter fraud); the impact of the sale of a major Cleveland employer, National City Bank, on our economy (Does long-suffering Northeast Ohio need any more examples of the short-sighted, unregulated vision of Republican philosophy? I tell them it’s personal, that my husband is still very tentatively a VP at the bank but not hopeful that his job will survive the consolidation with their new owner in nearby Pittsburgh); the character of Barack Obama and the temperament of John McCain (I assuage concerns, proffered in hushed tones and coded language, about Obama’s now-famous “terrorist associations,” moving them ever so gently toward recognizing that his dispassion is necessary for diplomacy and preferable to his opponent’s inclination toward battle). There’s lots of back and forth, and I endure several asides about Palin’s “refreshing feistiness,” the weather, grandchildren, lawn sign wars, the local gambling issue on the ballot, and even, in one case, a hand-made motor that runs on water (Did I want to bring my sons over for a look?). These people are retired, relatively informed, and looking for conversation.

 Wednesday evenings are a different experience altogether. The contact rate is very low because these young-adult to middle-aged working folk don’t answer for unfamiliar phone numbers and are too busy or tired to engage in conversation when they do pick up. Mostly they are suspicious, having lived in the world of anonymous technology for so long that they are flummoxed by a genuine attempt at dialogue. But these are the likeliest voters, so getting past their defenses is vital to the Obama operation that continues to impress me with its organization and heart.

 *

 I wasn’t a bit surprised last Wednesday to hear the caution in Corina’s voice when I first spoke, identifying myself as an Obama volunteer, wondering if we could count on her support at the polls on November 4. She gave me a reluctant yes, drawn out and imbued with suspicion. At this point, there is usually instant comradeship, like-minded souls finding each other in the midst of an unfriendly mob, a metaphorical high-five, but Corina was different. I asked her if she’d like to volunteer for the campaign, and her hesitance belied the content of her answer. “I’d like to start helping today,” she said, again with that confounding reticence. “And what about lawn signs,” she spoke before I had a chance to develop the volunteer offer. I mentioned that we were having trouble obtaining enough but were doing what we could to let the community know that there were Democrats in this conservative town. She was guarded again: “Well, I don’t think it’s really any of my neighbors’ business who I vote for.” To which I laughed out loud, suggesting it was kind of funny, then, that she wanted an Obama sign in the middle of her yard. “Oh, yeah.” I could hear her sheepish grin. “Well,” she began, slowly, deliberating, “we’re the only black family in our neighborhood, and…”

 And it was suddenly crystal clear. Corina was afraid to be for Obama in her lily-white, Republican-spin-buying, borderline racist neighborhood. And it was never this way for me, ever, even though I live in the same town, because I could love Obama for his cerebral calm and mental agility and ideas of unity and compromise, not to mention his eloquent prescience about Iraq. It never had anything to do with race one way or another, but for this woman it’s always about race even if it’s not. That is, even if every single issue squares for her, if every reason I mentioned resonates with her as well, it’s still about race for her because people assume it is. Then she asked me---and you have to understand that nobody does this on a cold call—she asked me, grievously wary, “Well, why are you voting for Obama?” and I swear to god she just couldn’t imagine that a white person actually wants a black person for president.

 The African Americans I work with on the campaign don’t demonstrate the same vulnerability as Corina, but all I could think about when I talked to her was the theory that, nationally, blacks only supported Obama wholeheartedly once they saw he could win with whites in Iowa. It became real for them then, but for Corina it’s not real even yet. This woman breaks my heart. It’s like she just doesn’t really believe that America has it in her to vote for a black man, like she just won’t believe it until she sees it.

 And I thought about the day my first son was born eighteen years ago. I’d endured seven miscarriages before then, including some heart-rending late ones, and I simply did not connect pregnancy with live birth. I was overwhelmed with gratitude, worshipful of this sacred creature who had been within me only moments before. His very existence was stunning, a surprise. I remember feeling distinctly shocked that things had worked out, that I was going home with a baby. In spite of having bought him clothes and prepared a nursery and taken time off work, I apparently had not believed it was ever going to happen. In the same way, I think that Corina, just a few streets over from me, literally will not believe Obama can be president until he actually is.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Thanks for the perspective, Lainey, both the personal and the political. I'll be doing my very first political volunteering stint here in my red state next weekend, and I've been wondering what to expect. This helps. I'll be more prepared, mentally.
Leigh this is powerful. I am glad you have the tenacity to talk to Corina -- who must feel somewhat alone.

And I'm sure your son is a lovely person.
You'll be great, Rob! What I do is remind myself of what I can't stand about solicitors. I try to be real, even if it goes completely off script. (See my second post, Undecided in Ohio for more about campaigning.) When someone admits they're undecided, I tell them affectionately that they're "political gold" and then ask if there are any positions I can clarify for them. They always say no. Then I--again to respect their undecided status, which is mighty contemptible for many political junkies--tell them "there's a lot of that going around," and admit that on a few issues the candidates are not substantially apart. That validates them (and is true, imo). Then I just throw out my couple of issues, which happen to be the economy (We've tried the Republican trickle-down, no-regulation philosophy--How's that workin' for ya?) and his diplomatic bent as opposed to McCain's more eratic demeanor. (We went the war route and it cost us lives and treasure.) Anyway, that's what I do. Good luck and thanks for the comments!

Thanks, Dorinda!
Lainey
Thanks for sharing this...especially your personal analogy.
Those of us who support Obama, but have stayed on the side lines, owe you a debt.
In my meager effort thus far, I have turned one, maybe two, voters to his camp. I am about to take a conference call from the campaign directed at CA voters...I hope to be more active during this final push.
It is so important, isn't it?
oh, I am so hoping for a live birth!
This is very powerful, Lainey. Here's hoping it all comes true and he is president.
Great piece and solid work. I can't do the phone thing and am really impressed by those, like you, who are doing it. And between the phone and the front door, hey, one way or another we're gonna get 'em all! GO LAINEY. GO OHIO. GO OBAMA.

WOOF
lainey - thank you so much for sharing this moving post. I can't imagine how difficult all of those pregnancy losses and the one with your son must have been for you.

I think you are right that people, particularly some black people, have been hurt too many times to believe it until it actually happens.
Thanks for your supportive comments mah, odette, rev, Tri-C, and lips :)
A really great read, Lainey. I am really impressed that you are not only doing the phone work but that you make the effort to connect personally with the people you contact. It takes a special ear and an empathy that many who work the phones do not have.

Good on you. And thank you.

Monte
Lainey, your post was pure inspiration. I'm in my office waiting for my phone list to start making calls. Your courage and tenacity are helping motivate me. And your other story about having your son after 7 miscarriages? Your analogy is brilliant. You are one strong woman.
Keep up the good work to deliver Ohio's electoral college votes!
You are a saint. I wish, oh I wish, that I weren't such an introverted coward and could talk to strangers on the phone without curling into the fetal position. I send checks and put out my Obama/Biden sign and try to persuade wavering conservative acquaintances, but otherwise I'm useless in this fight. Thank goodness for you.
I really enjoy reading all of the various perspectives that everyone shares on their blogs....very enlightening! I understand Corina's reticence....this is something that we never dared to HOPE for in our lifetime....so we remain reserved.....just like it's probably not the right thing to ask a woman if she's pregnant until you see the baby crowning.....some of us won't believe it until we see his hand on the bible one chilly morning in January.
Helluva title and great metaphor selection!

I live in a Republican stronghold myself - the first time I put on my Obama t-shirt I had to put on an extra layer of nerve as well, as if I was bracing myself for the what was likely to come.
Lovely post and analogy. I am sorry for the babies you lost and happy for the baby (now a young man) you had.
Hey you guys--thanks so much for the compliments. It's been a fun experience and I've met a lot of smart and interesting people in my conservative town. All the liberals crawled out from under their rocks when McCain came to town a few weeks ago and I've got myself some new peeps. Meantime, I phoned banked again this morning and had a riot of a conversation with an old gal who couldn't remember asking for a ballot (my info said she has one now) but could I do anything about the noises she was hearing? She had had someone out to check for raccoons and they'd found nothing, so now she was worried she was going crazy. I told her about tinnitus and said she sounded perfectly sane to me, so call the B of E and vote for change!
This is a great post, Lainey!
What really resonated for me was the idea of the Wednesday evening calls- I know that I have brushed off more than one phone call from campaigners (from both sides), and ignored a countless number more. Honestly, part of what gets me is the fact that I will sometimes get more than three calls a day. It seems like overkill, especially in a historically liberal place like New York.
You bring up such a good point, Lissa, and one that I struggle with. The campaign has done research and knows what works, and included in that configuration I'm sure is a small number of voters who are actually so turned off that they go the other way. That's really hard for me to stomach, and I'm always bringing it up to our field organizer. We want to be the "least offensive" callers out there, but the truth is, our mere invasion into the home is offensive to many, and they don't distinguish among all the calls--that is, if they've heard from moveon.org or the Democratic party or the local congressional or senate candidate along with the Obama campaign, then they just feel inundated without discrimination about who's doing it. They lump them all together. Anyway, I'm a little friendlier now that I've been doing this. Mostly, to be honest, I don't answer unfamiliar phone numbers.
great post, lainey. You have such empathy, I'm sure you are an asset to the campaign. I've been working in sf, cozy liberal enclave, and calling out into the swing states but I haven't had that emotional connection on a personal level that you talk about that would come from calling neighbors from your own neck of the woods...that's pretty amazing and takes some courage.

Although I have gotten some metaphorical high fives from obama supporters who are proud to tell me they've voted or are ready to vote...it's annoying about the duplications of names in lists which mean people are being called too many times. But there's not much you can do about that as a caller except write in the margin "has been called twelve times today. No more calls!!!"

cheers.