When you’ve lived long enough in the fast-track environment of New York you tend to run into situations that are “interesting.” So let me tell you how I wound up having lunch in the Von Bulow’s Fifth Avenue apartment in 1997.
As you probably know, the heiress Sunny Von Bulow was in a coma for 28 years, and she died over the past weekend. Her husband, Claus Von Bulow, was found guilty in 1985 of trying to kill her for her money by injecting her with insulin. A couple of years later, lawyer Allan Dershowitz led a team that overturned the previous verdict, and Von Bulow moved abroad. A movie was made of the whole sordid tale called Reversal of Fortune, starring Jeremy Irons and Glenn Close.
So where did I fit into all this? I was writing a book on inns and bed and breakfasts and met a smart and curvey middle-aged innkeeper named Andrea Plunket, and her tall, debonair English husband Shaun. Their B&B, The Guest House, was not a teddy bear and lace accommodation. When I first stayed there I noticed a painting on the wall that I assumed was a Matisse print.
“Actually, it’s an original,” Andrea said in her mildly Hungarian accent. “It’s a painting of my mother.”
Andrea turned out to be a sassy international socialite-cum-journalist with three past husbands, an intriguing past, and a resume including an interview with Saddam Hussein. She grew up in Hungary, Switzerland and Morocco. Her stepfather was murdered. The late Florence Gould, daughter-in-law of robber baron Jay Gould, was the godmother of her daughter, Caroline. And the late Babe Paley was chosen to be the matron of honor at her third marriage.
And Shaun was no slouch. On their piano were several framed photos, among them the Queen Mum of England. He explained that his Lord and Lady parents were killed in a plane crash, and the Queen Mum and King George VI raised him along with the Princesses Elizabeth and Margaret.
Shaun told incredible stories of his lineage, and his close friendship with the Queen. Some were funny, regarding the Queen Mum’s propensity for gaseousness (she’d warn people), and her love of tippling throughout the day. And some stories were simply astonishing. For instance, with a straight face, in his posh accent, Shaun told how he had gone to Rome to attend a ceremony that would be establishing a long-past relative as … a saint.
That’s right. As in St Francis of Assisi. But that’s not all. As Shaun told it, he and one of his previous wives were sitting on chairs in the Vatican’s main piazza for many hours at the sainthood ceremony. And when the Pope was speaking, Shaun’s wife had to pee but felt it was disrespectful to walk out in the middle of such an important ceremony. So she stayed put, and peed right in her seat. And he was pretty sure others did too.
Oookaaay. Now this tale gets even stranger, with even more familiar names.
When I first came to the property I noticed that on the piano next to the Queen Mum’s photo was one of the infamous Claus Von Bulow. That’s because ten years before, Andrea had been Van Bulow’s lover and staunchest advocate, known then as Andrea Reynolds, and she accompanied him day after day at his second murder trial.
But that was then. When I met her, Andrea had been married to Shaun Plunket for almost eight years (“You can’t expect to find great love over 50,” she told me presciently, as I had no idea that I soon would, “so when you find it, grab it.”). The Plunkets settled down and turned the home that she had shared with one of her previous husbands, a producer named Sheldon Reynolds, into her dazzling B&B.
Shaun acted like lord of the manor, playing a top tennis game with competitive guests and telling those amazing stories at the bar by the spiral staircase. Andrea flirted like a younger Zsa Zsa Gabor, but with wit that wouldn’t quit, although she rarely spoke of Von Bulow.
Sometimes Andrea would cook dinners in the open kitchen that was the heart of the house. Her specialty for breakfast was French toast, but she would knock herself out if guests requested something. “Some Japanese guests asked for a banana split,” she remembered, “so I ran right out to get the best ice cream and fresh toppings. But all they wanted was a cut-up banana.”
Andrea took a shine to me, kind of like a glamorous big sister, and she periodically invited me to her private house parties. I was between marriages, and would turn up each time with a different man, and she would call me afterwards with opinions and advice, which usually turned out to be right. (That’s a whole other story, which I’ll eventually tell when I feel more secure about it.)
The Plunket parties were always special. At one, neighbors entertained with country songs. Fireplaces crackled even on July nights. And at a glamorous country weekend birthday celebration I sat at dinner between Carolina Herrera and the pathologist Michael Baden who had testified at OJ’s murder trial. Could it get any weirder. I mean, what do you wear sitting next to a fashion icon? (I wore black Chicos!)
That weekend I lounged around cluelessly, trying to act like I belonged -- trout fishing in the stream that ran through the property and skeet shooting at the neighboring estate of a lucky assistant to Tommy Hilfiger, who had cashed in on the designer’s success. Heady stuff for someone who didn’t like to kill a fly, let alone set one at the end of a hook.
The most memorable, and last invitation was to lunch at the Van Bulow’s Fifth Avenue apartment, the home of Cosima, the sweet, highly educated daughter who always supported her father’s innocence, and who remained close friends with Andrea.
I sat on the silk sofa under an oil portrait of Claus in his prime. (And Claus in his prime did not look like Santa.) On the side table, in a silver frame, was a stunning, smiling photo of Sunny Von Bulow. Knowing that she was a few blocks away in an everlasting coma gave me chills. What in the hell was I doing there? I felt like I was in some film noir where at any moment Von Bulow himself might appear from the study, leering in a smoking jacket.
Andrea always insisted that he was innocent, which I doubted, but made me feel better about hanging out with her. “I knew everything about that case,” she told me. “I would have picked it up somehow. I knew him too well.”
Like most over-the-top relationships, the novelty wore off. I married again –a husband who happily didn’t fit in with the fanciful Plunkets -- and I lost touch and put that whole time of life out of my head. But when I saw the article about Sunny Von Bulow’s death this past weekend I thought about her smiling picture in that frame, and this fragment of my past reappeared like her ghost.
***
When I finished writing this I googled to find out what had happened to the Plunkets in the past decade. A year ago someone wrote an article that their main house burned down with all their personal property, but that Andrea and Shaun still open the cottages by the river. Andrea, now over 7o and ever interesting, is the executor of the Arthur Conan Doyle estate (as in Sherlock Holmes). And she stays in touch with Von Bulow, who has cancer and does charitable work in Europe.
I feel terrible about the fire, but life happens in all its complexity to all of us, and sometimes when you look back and it doesn’t feel right you just have to shake your head and keep moving.


Salon.com
Comments
You are a magnificent story teller. How do you go back to "normal" after all of that? When is the book of memoirs due to be out? Sure to be a best seller.
I've always secretly suspected the Queen Mum might be a farting old drunk with a sense of humor. Thanks for confirming my suspicions. (Just kidding, of course.) I'll be patiently awaiting your next post.
Thanks for letting us peek at the past.
Thumbed.
Dick, I think they were running the B&B because of "business reversals." (Kind of like what's going on now?) But yes, a B&B where there was a Matisse of her glamourous mother who had been married to an heir to a Swiss pharm conglomerate. I do think Andrea Shaun him for love. As for the Arthur Conan Doyle stuff, that's Andrea. If you google Dominick Dunne and Andrea Reynolds
together you will find many more fascinating tales. And if you want to read more, Andrea has a piece about Von Bulow in the Daily Beast today. She rightfully so, is writing a memoir.
Michael, I'm not sure what my normal is. Like many of us, I have many aspects and many phases. Luckily I think I'm centered enough to plough through all. As for a memoir, I'm starting to open up here and if I'm not too uncomfortable will go further with other tales. I need all the encouragement I can get
It is interesting to find yourself in a situation like that though Lea. I can visualize sitting under the oil painting of Von Bulow. I used to call him Count Von Bulow because he reminded me of a vampire. :-)
Perhaps I was right, who knows. Pompous and arrogant for sure.
rated
Rosie: Yes, that whole world of socialites and jet setters has an overlay of manners and smugness. These people are often rich and beautiful, but many are just plain lucky. Andrea happened to extremely smart and funny and a bit offbeat and so she was/is interesting in her own right.
dynomyte: Yes, Newport is a fascinating and fabulous place, filled with "cottages" of 100 rooms where all kinds of hanky panky went on through the years. What a special area to grow up in, even if it wasn't in a "cottage."
Geoff: Thanks. (Like your post, too. I've been called a cougar lately and not sure what to think.)
The bit about Shaun and the Queen Mum got me to thinking why, as Mel Brooks said, "It's good to be the King." When royalty does it, stories of their "love for tippling throughout the day" are cute and funny. That kind of love brands your average person a plain old alcoholic.
I chuckled at Lonnie's comment - yes, and when the rich pee on their seats, they are being polite, but when others do it, they are homeless swine!
Ms Snitten (and I do love your name) : I do, so, appreciate what you wrote. It is hard to write about this without being tarred with them. It was fun, but there is much more to me and always will be. I have fun observing, but have no interest in more.
Both Claus & Ms. Reynolds were oh so grand in style and substance… dressed to the ‘nines’ and carrying an air of ‘I am special’…… some would call it snobbish. They both were aware of people watching them and casually pointing at him, saying, “He tired to murder his wife.” They seemed to enjoy their fame…
It is good that Sunny von Bulow can now truly rest in peace after 28 years of who knows what.
Thanks for yet another gem! You're a great writer, Lea!!!
Great story.
Stellaa: You are so right! They are lucky to have those roots and some are just zero, and some use them.
Voicegal: It is a little corner, but it's a big world I gaze into.
Thank you for posting this. It's a great, great story.
Wow.
PS: nice line-up of tags there
: o
(And as to your post from yesterday, and our dialogue within, has anyone volunteered for the threesome yet? 8>) )
I had a good giggle too. I've been stuck out of my world once or twice in something a little tiny bit similar and I never ever knew how people like that ever managed to buy a tomato let alone toilet paper....
great story!
And yes, the tags on this piece are pretty hilarious.
Luluandphoebe: They not only buy toilet paper, they (usually) use it!
I heard once that the Queen of England never uses the facilities when she's out and about. They always have one specially arranged for her at her every public appearance but apparently no matter how long an event goes on, she always waits till she gets home (and doubtless must go before she leaves, as our mothers always told us to). They say she was trained from childhood to have this kind of control. Made me feel sad for the old girl.
Wouldn't you know it, an old, sick, probable murderer out and about with a young girl. And I don't kill flies let alone people and I'm home with my cat. (I guess I don't have his money either, but even if her were poor he'd be dating around.)
Also, isn't there some brouhaha with the Conan Doyle estate? I seem to recall reading a NYer article on that a few years ago.
I always thought Claus did it but my information came from news reports and the movie you spoke of. And a feeling, nothing that would hold up in a court of law.
And I just have to say, I don't care if it was the pope and St Francis of Assisi. I could never sit in a church pew and pee myself. Ewww.
Yes, there are a whole bunch of questions about who is doing what with the writings. But that seems a part of this group's methods. (We need a modern Sherlock Holmes to figure out who killed Sunny.)
pretend_farmer: I believe they were on folding chairs in the outdoor piazza and I gather the service was extremely long and they weren't warned, and to get up you would have to make everyone else get up in a long, long row as you go along the row, all the while the pope is talking. And then you have to find a portpotty if they even had them. Still .... I guess if I ever go to a sainthood ceremony I will take all precautions. (See answer to Silkstone.)
jimmymac: I do so appreciate the words of encouragement. I'm not a great self-starter, life has usually just happened when I wasn't looking. But I will remember those short, sweet words of yours.
Got a feeling this is just the tip of the iceberg for you as far as stories are concerned, which is great news for all of us!
Glad I helped provide needed diversion.