Despite Rare Crashes and My Own Near Misses, Flying is Safe
My daughter-in-law, whose family is from Buffalo, flew there just two days ago from Newark, so when I heard about the tragic crash of the commuter plane on approach to that Great Lake city, I felt both awful and grateful.
Flying is an incredibly safe means of travel, and Thursday night's tragedy was the first American commercial plane crash with loss of life in years.
But after two recent crashes, it doesn't seem so.
As a writer who has traveled extensively throughout the world on assignments for over 30 years, I've had my share of dicey flights, and many in small planes, in bad weather. I've entered some that look like buses with bandaged wings, and DC-3s and other beat up old craft that were so ragged I've debated staying put on a faraway island rather than boarding again.
I've been in scenic flights in storms, helicopters over volcanoes, and blimps over the ocean. I've flown close over mountains, pulled up last minute on approach to fogged-in LaGuardia, made an extra stop somewhere in the jungle on Aero Peru.
Near misses are like fish stories in the travel world. Lightening once struck my plane (it does that pretty often, I'm told), and I did fly on TWA 800, Athens to NY, a month before that plane went down in 1996.
I was on a flight in 1987, returning from Europe to New York that had to make an emergency landing in Nova Scotia and then aborted the first take-off. On the second, I held my boyfriend's hand and I'm sure my knuckles on the other were whiter than a model's teeth.
I was on the virgin flight of Virgin Air in 1986 from Gatwick. It was having a delayed take off, and we were apprehensive that something was wrong. The fleet consisted of one old jet from Argentina -- and we were on it. I knew the thing had to go, or it would be a PR nightmare for the fledgling airline. Richard Branson himself was aboard, complete with captain's uniform, and Boy George music filled the air. Later we found out that one that of the engines had conked out over the Atlantic, but we were too filled with copious alcoholic beverages of choice to notice.
Then there was the fire that broke out in the lavatory on a trip from Cleveland to LaGuardia and our jet was met by yellow fire trucks and a foamed runway. The passengers remained calm as we smelled the smoke, and there was only a smattering of clapping when we landed. Mine.
Small planes take extra nerve. I was in a tiny plane on a flight in Patagonia where the constant wind whipped us around like in a carnival ride and I was petrified. On a flight past Angel Falls in Venezuela, the door to the cockpit remained open. Or was there one? You could see the pilots studying a map, shaking their heads, arguing as we meanwhile seemed to be able to reach out and touch the cliffs.
And sometimes, it can be absurd: Take the first flight of my babysitter Lynn. She liked it fine, except when the oxygen masks came down. "You didn't tell me that happens when you fly," she said in all innocence. That, thankfully, has never happened to me.
My brother Stu in California flies a Cessna, (so far I haven't joined him), and he assures me that air travel is exceptionally safe and statistically you have as much chance of crashing as say, being hit by a meteor. He also is a physician who provides mandated physicals to pilots, including, he tells me, Sully Sullenberger, the hero of the US Air Hudson crash.
Stu does admit that pilots often worry when they are about to fly. About the drive to the airport.


Salon.com
Comments
(rated)
I wondered if you knew the etymology of the term. Thanks
Give me a train for long distance travel! If for no other reason, simply because there is so much less hassle before you leave.
I have never felt any anxiety on a commercial flight but with a few of those helicopter trips there was some. One was the pilot who I very soon aborted the trip as it was obvious for what we were to do he was woefully unqualified. Another was when high winds kept us from landing where we had lifted off. We had to find another area and have someone pick us up. The last was when we were in the high Sierras trying to return back to the landing area. The fog and clouds came in behind us as we were completing our emergency line patrol. When the pilots turned the ship to our return destination we couldn’t find a hole in the clouds to fly through. (it is a rare helicopter that is equipped for instrument flying) We kept trying to find an open area with an eye on the fuel gauge as we were quickly running towards the reserves. We finally found a canyon that seemed to have enough clearing to fly under the clouds. We were just above tree level at 30 to 40 knots. We finally broke through to where we could return but it was dicey for a while.
I keep hearing people talk of how dangerous helicopters are. Quite frankly many accidents are due to pilot error, as was the case when Steve Van Zandts pilot took off into the clouds (prohibited) and straight into the side of a mountain.
Statistics show that they are the third safest form of flying, after commercial airlines and corporate jets. Considering where we flew and what most helicopters are pressed in to service this is an outstanding safety record. Unlike those larger aircraft piloting a helicopter is far more difficult. One of my best pilots I used termed commercial piloting as “flying your desk”. Piloting a helicopter takes supreme skill, a cool head and experience. I did have a few hours of stick time so I know what it takes to fly one.
Another little known issue is if you are to have mechanical problems in difficult terrain you are far better off in a helicopter than a fixed wing. A fixed wing needs glide space to set down, a helicopter can auto rotate for up to several miles and look for a spot to set down in a space just large enough to clear the rotor blades. It can set down tail first to lessen the likelihood of injury as well.
I hate flying, even though I know it's safe. I suspect it's because I'm a control freak.
Thumbed. And an OMG, you flew over Angel Falls? If you have pics, post 'em lady! I'd love to see that.
Folkmuse, I agree that helicopters are more dicey. And they tend to fly over spewing volcanoes (I did Mt. St. Helen's and the Big Island in Hawaii). Just recently I passed on a great scenic helicopter trip over the New Zealand coast because of the wind, and then went the next day anyway and it was glorious, to the top of a mountain. Risk and reward. And as I get older I take more risk.
Still, very sad...my thoughts are for the victims families right now...
It was not something I would be normally involved with doing but to acquaint me with the process so I was aware of the procedures. My job was more on the decision to use this method.
I was looking forward to it and disappointed that I couldn’t do the training. Cindy was relieved.
My heart goes out as well to all affected. Thanks for your story, Lea.
Hey, look at that! Those two nearly missed each other!
And From the Midwest, what is it about European airports that warms your heart? Most of them are pretty sterile and similar. And btw, the most beautiful small airport I've ever seen is in Cambodia, an adaptation of the ruins of Anghor Wat.
Where the "payout" is essentially infinite (you are annihilated in a plane crash), the miniscule empirical probability of a fatal crash matters not, psychologically.
I went back to the check-in counter and asked about the weather, repeating what I had heard. Instead of reassuring me about flying, the official suggested I take a later plane. I wanted to get home so I swallowed the tranquillizer my dr. had prescribed to diminish anxiety when flying in turbulence while still allowing me to be sharp enough to drive from the airport.
The plane and I both made it, thanks to pilots who flew when they knew even they might find conditions daunting.
Sandra, that is the most dramatic suicide I've heard of. Once the locals discovered a small crashed plane in the preserve near my house where I walked. It was missing for a day. No one seemed noticed the pilot's absence, which was sad.
The heart feels what it wants, but the head knows better. Reconciling the two is not easy. I'd rather walk.
coogansbluff, sounds really scary! I once has a proper English lady next to me grab my thigh during a rough ride. After it was over she was proper again.
But flying got you to Denali!
Rated.
Have a nice VDay Peter!
Make that two pillows,please.
Reminds me of the flights from the mainland to Puerto Rico. My folks lived in the Caribbean islands for about 10-years, and on every single flight I ever took to Luis Muñoz Marín International Airport – everyone clapped on landing. Even on the smooth ones. And I’m really not sure why.