Lea Lane

Lea Lane
Location
Florida, USA
Birthday
August 26
Title
freelance writer/editor
Bio
I've been around the block (more like around the world). I've played and loved and lived an unconventional life in conventional trappings. I've been a corporate VP, worked with foster kids, acted in an Indie ("Nurse 1"), was on Jeopardy!. I'll write just about anything, from speeches to comedy sketches to feature articles. I've been managing editor of a travel publication, authored six books, including Solo Traveler:Tales and Tips for Great Trips (Fodor's), blog regularly on major sites, and have contributed (mostly anonymously) to everything from encyclopedias to guidebooks. I was divorced late, widowed early -- and dated lots -- and I survived a scary illness. After being happily, peacefully solo for many years, I just started a live-in relationship. I founded and still edit www.sololady.com, a lfestyle Website for single women. I'm truly grateful for each precious day, each well-earned wrinkle, my family, my cat. Truth, laughter, friendship. And now this blog -- on this wonderful site!

Lea Lane's Links

Some of My Fave Posts
My Website
S is for Surely Special
Two Exceptional World Charities
Editor’s Pick
MARCH 12, 2009 8:42AM

The Abuser

Rate: 73 Flag

  dvbutton

Battered singer Rihanna has returned to her boyfriend, the angelic-faced hip-hop singer, Chris Brown. Young, beautiful, talented and rich, they seemed to be living a fairy tale life. Except for her being beaten, punched, choked and bitten by him.

Rihanna wants to stay and work it out. On average, it takes six attempts before a woman actually leaves an abusive relationship. According to statistics quoted on CBS  yesterday, one in every four women at some point in her life is a victim of domestic violence, and this abuse results in approximately 1,300 deaths a year.

Between my marriages I dated interesting men for 15 years, and had a few meaningful long-term relationships. But for over a year I’m sorry to say that I too was in and out of an emotionally and physically abusive relationship.

How could I have been so self-destructive and stupid? How could I have accepted the unacceptable? Judge for yourself.

I met Lenny in the spring right after a breakup. He was self-deprecating, generous and funny, with an Ivy degree and a partnership in a NYC law firm. He was my age, short and boyish. My friends liked him. He seemed a keeper.

He spoke well of his ex-wife. I noted that. He loved animals, and I noted that. Big on his family. Liberal. Picked up tabs. Fixed things around my house. No children, so he wouldn’t even be distracted or influenced.

I was a freelance writer empty-nesting in the same stone house in Westchester County New York where I had raised my family. I rented out the cottage in the back of the property, rented out my boys’ bedrooms as a suite with an entrance, even rented part of my house and the backyard and pool in the summer to hedge funders who came up maybe twice. I made do, house poor.

Lenny put his shoes --with shoe trees, no less -- in my closet after our second date. We started spending weekdays at his New York City pad and weekends at my house. He wined and dined me, placed bling around my neck when I least expected it, and made me feel lovely and cared for in a whirl of fun.

The largesse kept coming. He offered me his Lexus to drive and keep. And then his maid, to deep clean my house and return every week. He took me anywhere I wanted to go. He told me I was beautiful, and complimented me on how I dressed, and he said “I love you” before I even thought to.

I was writing a guidebook on the Greek Islands and he surprised me and flew to Greece to spend part of the research time with me. My arms were tightly around him on the motorcycle he steered along winding roads. I remember dinner by an ancient well on Corfu, and later the moon flooding our balcony in cold, dreamy light.

But the nightmare was about to begin. Soon after we returned to New York, we were spectators at a seniors tennis match; Conners and Borg were playing. Lenny’s mood was strangely nasty. He glowered for hours about being late. I told him, “I’m not comfortable with you acting this way. It’s not acceptable.”

I found myself saying that over and over in the next months. He started balking and complaining about even small things. Putting me down. Getting annoyed when I’d do things without him. He tried to shut me off from others. He said cruel things, blaming me absurdly. He pushed me ahead in the movie line a bit too hard. He pinched (or did he?) when he grabbed my waist to rush me along. With each gradation, each escalation I debated with myself, and rationalized. If I commented, he would eventually apologize, and then move the abusive behavior a tiny bit higher.

Meanwhile, to distract me he let me choose his new apartment overlooking the East River, and we furnished it together. That kept me busy, and kept me there. And 99 percent of the time, he appeared charming. What's a bit of sadism when he has such nice friends and is such a great guy, deep down?

But one afternoon, when I had missed lunch and had the nerve to say that I was hungry, he pushed me out of a parked car onto the grass, and punched me in the face. Two teens saw this and called the police. I debated pressing charges, but thought he might get disbarred. He kept staring at me. So I didn’t.

He profusely apologized later, but we moved our stuff out of each other’s homes and I stopped seeing him. Then came months of major apologies, supposed “therapy,” notes and emails, more lavish gifts. He played on my positive nature and my hopes, and my needs.

I wavered, and sorry to say, gave him another chance. I know, you must be thinking, “Why? He’s bribing you. He’s not going to change.” I’d think that too, now. Abusers rarely change. Statistics show that violence escalates rather than ends as these relationships continue. But I retained magical thinking.

Things went well for a couple of months, with more good times and better behavior. But on a Caribbean cruise, in a cabin together, he blew up. Cursing. Hitting. Even at one point closing both his hands around my neck.

I fled to a friend’s room and told her all, left him at the Ft. Lauderdale pier and hopped the first flight home to New York. I immediately escaped to New Hampshire with another girlfriend who was kind enough not to tell me ‘I told you so.’ It was over, and I finally got it.

A few months later, arising from the nadir, I met the wonderful man who became my second husband. And not long after I remarried, I took courses and volunteered to be a domestic violence counselor at an organization called My Sister’s Place. Eventually they had me speaking to groups about the sometimes disguised face of domestic violence, and I felt some closure.

Lenny immediately glommed onto another perfectly nice professional woman. When he read about my marriage he emailed me as if nothing had happened, without a trace of guilt.

I saw him by chance last year in Miami at a ballet. His hair had turned silver and he was with a stunning, much taller, much-younger Latina. He sputtered some clichés, and I felt disgust. I was alone. My loving husband had died in 2001.

And so it goes. I do feel for Rihanna. I understand how she can rationalize the battering. But I do suspect what’s coming.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I hope this opens even one person's eyes to the problem ....
but alas, the problem keeps going...
Thank you for sharing your experiences. I also feel that Rhianna's decision to return to Brown (if the abuse is real) is very unwise but also not without it's possible rationalizations.

I want to say something as a man who is no perfect tempered individual that a clear line is crossed with striking of a woman or even the more subtle 'pinching' type actions. I and many men become frustrated and like all humans we say things in anger. Any man who thinks it acceptable to do what you describe are not truly men, in my eyes. They are boys who can't set aside base impulses like shoving or of course hitting. Most men lie and waste everyone's time claiming they don't get that angry. The truth is more than some men like the one you've described seem to almost strive for this unhealthy and maladjusted situation of abusive treatment.
Lea -- you describe very closely my experience with an abusive man. I had the same thought when I finally realized what was going on "How could I possibly end up in this situation? I'm a good feminist, I've read about this!" But no, the abuser is so good at manipulation that it's much harder to get through than most people realize. Thank you for sharing. This was a great read.
"He played on my positive nature and my hopes, and my needs."

"Lenny immediately glommed onto another perfectly nice professional woman."

They have a radar for women with soft hearts and forgiving natures. It is up to us to become strong enough in ourselves to learn who is safe to trust and who is not.

Thank you for sharing that it can happen to anyone, not just stupid or sick women.
Aunt Shelle, your comment is so true. Lea, thank you. I needed to see this post this morning. Rated.
Physical abuse is inexcusable but so is the emotional battering through criticism etc. I put up with years of that from my ex-husband stupidly thinking it was better for my children to have a home with a mother and father. My oldest daughter learned from that experience that it is normal for a man to treat a woman badly. I much regret that. Luckily the youngest cannot remember us ever living together. I hope to be a better role model for her.
Brian, yes the problem keeps going and awareness of how common it is, and how hard it is for some to extricate is extremely important.

Eric, you are saying wise things.

Shelle, I can't tell you how much I appreciate your sharing that with me. I know that it is hard to admit this. People judge and assume that it is evident to leave. But the syndrome is extremely clever when carried out by a charming abuser.

S M, I'm glad this was meaningful to you. Really glad.
This was beautifully written, of course....but more than that, you wrote it in a way that explains your internal struggle....the disbelief, the doubt, the desire to make it ok....so perfectly well.

I am so impressed by the good care you took of yourself.

I would, personally, like to take a potato peeler to his penis, but that's just me.
Dorinda, I grew up in a family that stayed together for the children, and emotional abuse was constant. From what I perceive through OS that you are a terrific role model.

Persephone, you are magnificent in all your abundances. Your figure of speech gives me a feeling that you are one woman an abusive man would know to steer clear of from the get-go.
Great story Lea...I for one understand how you might have gone back to Lenny. The stories DO always end the same way though don't they...
I'm sorry that you had to go through that Lea....thanks for sharing and it and I do hope that it helps someone.
Trig and onecorgilover, I appreciate your understanding. This one was hard to write, but I have exposed my past before and I hope some out there will open their eyes to the hard facts faster than I did.
Lea, as you well document - abuse has no bounds. It comes in all descriptions and by all economic sources. It is that hidden characteristic that does not show its face; until the victim is on the receiving end.

There is no cure for the victim except to move on and not look back.

Thanks & rated
I was lucky not to experience a relationship like this. I know I would have done the same as you. They suck you in before showing their true colors making it so much harder to see the truth.

Thanks for sharing and I'm glad you got out.
I know first hand how a person can get sucked into these thing and how they escalate. It also is a road that runs both ways. I was in a relationship as the abusee, not the abuser. Even though years have past, I still don't fully understand how I stayed so long. Like you say, they prey on our good nature and as soft hearted people, we give them second chance after second chance.
Glad you escaped your personal nightmare.
Lea, thanks for this one. I spent a really long time with someone who was emotionally abusive. He never hit. And I kept telling myself, well, he's not hitting me, right? But it was abuse, just the same. It's a surprisingly easy pattern in which to fall.
George, well said. People think that abusers can be spotted. The best of them are the last people in the world you would suspect. I do think that if people understand that this behavior rarely improves, and most of all can retain their self-esteem, they can break the cycle.

Kaysong, I hope you never do, and I hope you remember this is you ever should.

Yes Michael, women can be abusers and are often excused by society. Kind-hearted people are the ones who suffer the most, I'm sure. Sorry to hear about that.
I think it will Lea. Thanks for sharing such a painful life lesson with us.
I hope she gets out of it before he kills her.

Thumbed. You have depths, Lea. And your writing is exceptional (but you already knew that ;-D).
Thank you for this painful post. I am sure we are all hopeful that the attention brought to this matter will have some influence on the young women who idolize celebs like Rhianna and her abuser.
The question is constantly asked: why doesn't a woman leave the abuser ? and this is an answer I found that makes some sense, unfortunately.... Women stay because the fear of leaving is greater than the fear of staying. They will leave when the fear of staying is greater than the fear of leaving.
Fear can encompass many things...finances, children, being alone.
Another poignant statement .."What is it about smart, savy women and Shitty men?"
Odetteroulette, I'm sorry to hear that but it sounds like the kind of rationalization many of us do.

Sheepdog, I hope you're right.

Bill, thanks alot. I'm complex, I think (like most of us here) and that leads to "interesting" situations.

lorimarie, excellent comment about fear. I think abusers spot their prey like lions. They can tell fast if you have fears or needs and that's why they usually work fast to get you involved. I don't think "smarts" has to do with it; more about emotion and self-esteem.
In addition to the rationalizations, I think your post shows how important it is for everyone to maintain solid, trusting relationships with people who call us out when we fall into delusion, and then help us out, even after we ignored their advice. You were fortunate to have such a good friend. Based on other stories I've read, the first thing a man like this does is cut the victim off from any lifelines. They insist the inclusion of others into a social or familial network "interferes" with the relationship. They don't take lovers, they take hostages.
wow, lea. brave of you to tell, bc there is such shame in it. glad you got out.
Accepting abuse is self-abuse. So all voluntary relationships involve two abusers. The title should read Abusers.

No one has the right to abuse - even to themselves. It's all about shirking responsiblity in the end.
What a gripping story Lea (excuse the pun, not intended). It's very hard to know who one is really dealing with without spending a lot of time with them. I have been fortunate to never have experienced anything like this but feel for you and others that have had to endure even one moment of abuse. Very well written.
I too lived w/an abusive man for 16 yrs. I too came and went in and out of our home. I came back b/c (1) I had nowhere else to go (my family would take me back but not my pets), and (2) abuse or not, home was still HOME.

My epiphany came when now-XB beat me for what became the Last Time--when I called the cops and had him arrested. He came home and made my life hell, but he kept his fists off me. Then I got the chance to move out to my own home, and I ran, literally, for my life.

I live there for a dozen years when I met and married a man who later turned out to be a sociopath, w/his own set of abuse. That endeavor lasted 15 mos--and only that long b/c that's how long it took me to save enough $$ to bolt when I found a safe place to land. That was 6 yrs ago, and I've never looked back.

I and other survivors of abuse had the same delusion that Rihanna now has: she thinks that he'll change b/c he says it'll never happen again--if he even allows that he hit her at all.

Until Rihanna faces the truth--that yes, he beat the shit out of her; yes, it wasn't the first time; and most of all, yes, she'll lose her fan base and consequently her career, if she allows it to happen again--then the beatings will continue til either he kills and/or maims her permanently, or she loses her career as a result.

She MUST lose something of such consequence that she'll do anything to avoid a recurrence. I lost a promising career when I took my first business trip w/2 black eyes; that wasn't the cause, but his abuse made me too weak to fight back. When I got the job back 5 yrs later, and he was hitting me again, then there was no going back.

Reference Tina Turner. Now there's someone who should be speaking up about this topic--and she not only came back, but she STAYED on top. As indeed I did, as I now prepare to retire from a gig in my career of choice for more than 25 yrs. And the next man that hits me better kill me, b/c that shit will NEVER happen to me again.
Jimmy, spot on. Support, interventions, whatever it takes is sometimes the only way people who get into this dynamic can see it. The problem is, people are ashamed to admit it. Friends often have to use clues. I didn't have bruises. But my close friends could tell something was wrong. And when I left him and then returned, most of them were extremely upset with me. The trouble is I couldn't seem to really listen. His pull was masterful and the dynamic was perfect in its awfulness.

jane and Sheldon, thanks. And yes, there is shame, but it can happen to people who look like they should know better, and that's why I decided to write this.

Harry, I can tell you, that if I asked what the time was he could turn it into a rant against me. He was a sociopath. My mistake was staying. I take responsibility for my mistake. But I hope you get a bit more understanding from what I admitted. I didn't deserve it, and I am thankful I got out before getting disfigured or worse.

Thanks, cartouche. Yes, usually their ploy is to get you involved heavily before you do get to really know them. They know the tricks. So beware of moving too fast.
elsmaao3, what a magnificent comment. Thank you for giving your insight here; I know it isn't easy. And congratulations on succeeding.
(And yes, I certainly hope Tina has contacted R.)
Wonderful post. The sad thing about my gender is you can never tell which of us is predisposed to such hidden violence.
Excellent, revealing post, Lea.

I don't get it. But then I have never been physically abusive and was always taught (and strongly believed) that a woman should only be touched gently, and in love; never in anger or violence. You have to wonder about his parents, his father; and the influences that shapes every abusive man (or woman), and what somehow allows them the liberty to think that physical abuse is permitted? I don't get it. Sadly, I realize now that in my youth I was at times more emotionally abusive than I should have been, and regret those moments when I could have been far more graceful and loving; but I have never been able to understand how a man can physically abuse a woman; and I am just as mystified at why a woman abused would return to such a man. Your post helps me to see it all a little more clearly, but I've heard similar stories before; and it seems evident that, even in your case, women sometimes love and live on hope rather than the reality they've chosen. It baffles me. I'm glad you finally left the bastid. I've known more than a few women who stayed too long. It was as if they actually thrived upon the abuse . I hope Rhianna leaves Chris Brown, who deserves to be penned up with a coupla beefy knuckle breakers and given a dose of his own medicine.
No matter what the problem is, and no matter how much our inner optimist wants to think "We can work it out," I can't recall a single instance (in my life or in friends' lives) when a relationship that's started down a destructive path rights itself again.

The damage doesn't go away. It just accumulates until its weight is unbearable.

Thanks for this, Sally.
LEA! I meant LEA! I knew what I meant and my fingers betrayed me!
"...But I retained magical thinking."

Exactly. we believe what we want to be true. Often that is not what is actually true.
Steve, if you haven't done it by now my guess is that you probably won't.

dynomyte, thankfully most men are like you. I never was hit by any on the (ok, many) men I have been with in my long life. I did endure some emotionally abusive types, but didn't stay involved long. This, alas, was a relationship, which made it harder to leave.

Verbal, I know. Sometimes when I read things about S's life I think we were separated at birth. Anyway, I agree. These things run deep and dangerous.

Wayne, I know that now and will always know it. I just tend to look to the positive, which can sometimes turns into wishful or even magical thinking when you're with someone who knows how to manipulate.
Thank you so much for sharing and opening the eyes of anyone who hasn't been there and doesn't get it.

A pathological abuser will never, never stop but I completely understand how long it can take a victim to get that. The non-judgmental support of family and friends is crucial (meaning they don't say I told you so in the end, but keep telling you so until you reach that point).

I was shocked by the details of the beating Chris Brown dealt to Rihanna - clearly it wasn't the first episode.
A friend of mine got in an abusive relationship. The guy was very good at seeming perfect at the beginning. In fact, he was more perfect than real guys, because it was an act. He didn't want her to love him. He wanted to hook her on him, and to do that, he was her dream come true (a nice blend of every woman's dream come true and her specific dreams, confided to him).

Once she was under this control, he didn't keep up the act. She tried to regain, through therapy the wonderful guy she knew he was, but at the first real violence (he had been building up to it) she got out.

I think abusers are good at being charming, since they do it deliberately.
You've added to my understanding. Thank you.
Thank you, Lea for sharing this story. I had a friend who's husband was finally arrested when the police found him beating her head against a curb. But he was well connected in a small town and he "walked". While my friend was in the hospital, he showed up at a dinner I was hosting. He followed me into the kitchen and in private, proceeded to threathen me if I helped her. Well, that really pissed me off and with an iron skillet in my hand I begged him to hit me. "Come on, hit another woman." He knew that very minute (with a lot of prominent folks in the next room) he might have a problem. I was scared to death and mad as hell, with skillet in hand, and I meant every word I said. He backed down and with alot of encouragement from several friends, she did not go back. She told me later that my strength gave her strength. I just wanted an excuse to kick his ass.
Great job, Lea. I think your story is a solid of example of that creeping escalation that happens. There aren't always clear warning signs and then, when you're in it, you're kinda dumbstruck for a bit, thinking, "That didn't happen, did it? No, it couldn't have. I wouldn't let it, right?" I'm glad you volunteered your time. That must have helped with some closure.

Clear, solid writing of a story. Right from the heart with some head thrown in!
Great and insightful post. I am sorry to hear you had to go through all this. I have posted about my experiences here on OS also in hopes that someone out there would think twice and get out before it is too late. They are not stories that are easily written.
I am glad you got out and you have been better since. Thank you for sharing this story.
Interesting that even an insightful, accomplished and confident woman like you can be pulled into such a relationship -- but I guess you could say the same thing about Rhianna, Tiny Turner and others.

Great story...glad you came to your senses before things got any worse.
floridagirl595, yes, friends and support are crucial. I couldn't bring myself to discuss this with my family.

Malusinka, exactly.

rijaxn, that's why I decided to write it.

Fabflamingo, you and Persephone are strong women -- and you were a good friend there.

Beth, yes, it's incremental. And once you're in it's like a moth to a flame.

fireeyes24, yes it does take some strength to tell how stupid you were when some will not get it. I figured the help it may offer was more important than the shame I may feel. Thanks for your stories, too.
Lea, that was a stunning post and I also hope that it helps someone reading this today. It is also good to remind people that abusers come from all walks of life.

I can't tell you how much this meant if it reaches just one woman who needs to hear this. Thank you so much.
Lea, I would say that this is a classic case of someone mis-representing himself. I'm sorry you went through this and can't imagine the bewilderment and pain you must have felt.

I have never in my life been in a situation like this and I just do not understand how any man can do something like this. To be so nice and loving and have a secret side to himself. He apparently is a person who can only love himself and no one else and maybe he dosen't even love himself. Makes me wonder what his relationship with his mother was like, how she raised him. Glad you got out of it and moved on. I would've wanted to do permanent damage to him! Thanks for sharing!
I have this impression that the people who don't get it think that the abuse is all there is to the relationship, and that it started immediately. And that it happens to women who are young or stupid. Obviously there's a lot of fun and enjoyment, the abuse is incremental. I'm glad you trace that increase explicitly, and I'm glad you got out.
Very well- told- I have heard this kind of thing: " He pinched (or did he?)" so many times in abuse victims' stories. The abuser becomes very adept at making you think nothing happened- making you question your memory or even your sanity. And often the abuse occurs when no one else is around to back up your version of events. Thank you for sharing this, Lea.
When I was in my first year of college, one of my aunt's closest friend died at the hand of her abuser with the police nearby. She had returned to the home (where he had a gun in every room) and he allowed her to get all of her things. As she was leaving with the last of her stuff (and the police were by the curb watching), he said "Bitch, you must have another man because your hair is done." He then shot her point blank and then turned the gun on himself. My aunt was so emotionally distraught by this because she kept telling her friend to leave the stuff and she'll buy her some new things. I think subconsciously this woman was tired and ready to stop living. I think he had verbally abused her as much as he physically abused her and she didn't have the will or desire to live anymore.

I am no expert on this, but most physical abuse starts with verbal abuse first. I didn't realize until I was older that my father was verbally abusive to my mom. He tore her down and you can still see the residuals of it now. My dad has gotten better as he has gotten older. I am not sure if it's because he is on dialysis or if he thinks my mom may die before him and he'll have to go to a home. Sometimes my mom gets mad at my sister and I when we say something that may hurt his feelings, but I had to remind her that she stayed with this man for 30+years and he deposited that type of behavior in us. I used to wonder why my mom stayed, but Lea you just gave another perspective.
Oh Lea. Of course you know you're also describing my smart, accomplished, educated, sophisticated mother's relationship with my biological father.

She was married to her abuser, but she rationalized too, he drank, he apologized, not all parallels with Lenny but still... thanks to her, to you and to all courageous women who escape abuse and speak out, that's one mistake I never made.

It's all about the Eleanor Roosevelt quote that we should all live by: "No one can make you feel inferior without your permission."

Such an important post. And so perfectly, excellently you.
LaurelnotLauren, nice to see you back. We miss you.

luluand phoebe, that's why I wrote it.

Just Pamela, yes, he had a bad relationship with his self-centered mother, who didn't show him much love. But lots of people endure that.

Mrs. Michaels, that's the point. The abuser usually sets up a good situation in which to abuse. It is a complex web and hard to describe. I have never taken crack, but maybe that would be similar.

JustJuli (related to Just Pamela?), yes, exactly. The public didn't see the hidden pinches. I did tell friends, as women do, so they began to notice that the kindness was veneer. But even sadists can be generous and funny. I had low self-esteem and that was the glue.

Olga, guns and anger problems equal deadly. That is so sad and awful and unfortunately not that unusual. That should wake up some people. Thank you.

Sally, I remember your mom's story. I don't think you would ever fall for this behavior. But did you see Verbal's Freudian slip in the comments? Sometimes I wonder myself.
Wonderfully written. And yes, abusive relationships are traps. At first, the good seems to outweigh the bad. Lenny definitely sounded good, initially. I'd probably be taken in by him, too.

But you got out when the danger was clear. And I'm so glad you did. I wish the current woman in his life the same good luck and sense and the strength to get out of there in time.
Well told and so clear, in hindsight. I had a college boyfriend who hit me. When I saw his father beating up his mother one Christmas vacation, I realized where he learned it and left him. He followed me begging to be taken back, even quit law school to stalk me. He emailed me last year, in fact. Ugghh!!!
compelling and relentlessly honest. highly rated.
Lea, such a brave and generous post. I'm sure it wasn't easy to relive this, and it takes courage to say you've been through this.

I do think you've done a great service to show how DV works, why women stay or go back, and how it truly can happen to anyone. I'm sure many people would never think it could happen to you, given who you are, inside and out. But I've had several other women that I'd 'never suspect' had been through this confess that they have. It's shockingly common but often well-hidden, especially if people have more financial or social resources (and thus also feel they have more to lose by exposing what they're going thru to the world).

thanks again for speaking the truth.
Shiral, I doubt he's changed. Just gotten older, which may have lowered the testosterone levels. Plus, each dynamic is different. She'll fare better if she's a bitch.

Ardee, smart lady. Wish I was.

Greg, thank you sir.

Silk, yes, most people do not think it could possibly happen to them. And I hope they are right.
an article over at NewsWeek that actually gets it pretty right that i thought about when i read this:

http://www.newsweek.com/id/188353
"Domestic Abuse Myths - 5 mistakes we make when we talk about Rihanna"
Thank you for your story.I'm sorry you experienced this. I hope I do not sound cold when I say, maybe stories like this hurt more than they help. Because as a person who cares for you and admires you, I read this and do not find it 'eye opening'. I find it baffling and confusing. I am sure there are many women like you - intelligent, gifted, normally possessed of sound judgment - who are nodding as they read this, thinking "Now I don't feel so bad, it happened to her just like it happened to me." Getting some comfort in that fact, and maybe using it to become/stay psychologically and emotionally inured from the reality that they are doing something self destructive in staying with the abuser, they are allowing it to happen. They aren't asking "Why do I think I deserve to be beaten? Why do I think a person who hurts me deserves another chance to hurt me? What's that about, anyway?"

I think feminism has let women down in this area. Show me five women who've returned to their abusers and experienced a happy, fulfilled life with an utterly changed man and I'll retract that statement happily. Here's the thing: feminism is about equality. Equality of opportunity, equality of reward, equality of stature. That last one is the falling down place, and the whole sorry history of domestic violence is about the failure of women to aggressively seek equality of stature. Women will never, ever claim true equality while they allow themselves to be abused, of which there are many forms, with physical on one end of the continuum, and cultural control and diminishment on the other.

I see a lot of focus on the who and what of abuse. I still have little understanding of the why. Why women keep going back. Why women don't rise up, enraged, to stop their sisters from killing themselves by going back.

Most women wouldn't retain a job or a friendship in which the other party struck them. But they stay with a man who does so, as if there is some sort of shortage of men, so better hang onto this one who is so great if only he didn't occasionally try to pound my face, choke me and kill me. And I can only ask again and again: Why? That has to be answered. Not "who" - Nicole Simpson and Rhianna prove that money, fame, youth, beauty are not bulwarks against the violence of the abuser. One of them is dead; the other may eventually share that fate.

Focusing on the who lends a false sense of sisterhood to the abused. I have a deep need to hear a conversation on the 'why' - because only then can we fully understand how to help women help themselves to leave a situation that is all to often fatal.

Sorry for the long comment, and I hope you see that I am merely thinking aloud, not directing comments at you personally. There is no judgment here, I am sincerely glad you shared this difficult story with us. This is such an important issue - really, the most important issue facing women today. Lives are at stake. The culture shrugs. Women have to save themselves from this - no one else is going to. And once we stop returning to our abusers, we gain collective strength to claim other equalities.
too carpy to read all the comments. this is brilliant, lea!!! your writing is superb. as is your honesty. sociopaths don't have any guilt at all. nor do narcissists (i now call them narcs.) im' so glad you got out of that relatively unscathed. i'm so sorry about your dead hsuband. no wonder i feel a kinship with you. my richard died in 2003, i think. terrible with time. i'm the opposite, which isn't good either. if someone even raises a hand to me, he's out the door. i have boundaries of steel. moderationa dn balance is always the best. i have a friend who was horriblhy abused but wouldn't speak about it. she then married a quadraplegic who couldn't touch her. it's so vital to talk about it, to get it out and away from you. love love love and huge gratitude for your skill, exceptional talent and courage.
in light of some of the comments herein, i kind of want to ask why we, as a culture, continue to focus on why women stay/why women return to abusive situations. should we be discussing and focusing on why abusers abuse/why abusers continue to abuse?
I sometimes wonder why women are more willing to engage in "magical thinking" with an abuser than to trust that friends and family will stand by them.
kmbearden you have to focus on both. And if you focus on the abused side of the equation, you eliminate the targets for the abuser, and that is of more immediate importance. We can only change what we can control - and women do not control abusive men. But women can control their own choices, and their choices about abusive men - that's the most immediate way to eliminate abuse.
This doesn't sound like Rihanna's situation at all. Let's face it Rihanna could easily be labeled an abuser and should have been arrested. Not only did she strike Chris Brown multiple times while he was driving, but she initiated the violence.
Lea, Thank you for your honest and sobering essay. As the father of two college-aged women, I've been more afraid that they would get involved with abusive men than that they would get involved with drugs. I used to have a co-worker that we all knew was being abused - nobody falls down the stairs that often. The husband would even come at lunchtime and verbally abuse her in the parking lot. Eventually, they moved to Arizona; sadly, I actually Google her name every once in a while to see if there's an obituary.
sandra: i agree to a certain point, in that it is very imperative to get the abused out from under influence and fist of the abusers.
but i think one of my concerns is that we spend a large amount of time and energy talking about the woman's responsibility in these situations and not the man's. or rather the victim's responsibility vs the perpetrator's.
we live in a culture that has a tendency to focus on what someone *did* to "make" someone hurt them, and to try to separate ourselves as people who would never find ourselves in those situations, therefore the victim must have done something wrong. perhaps we unconsciously identify with the power of the abuser, or something. i don;t know... i just think we as a culture tend to focus too much on the victims' responsibility in situations like this.

or something. i find it an interesting and puzzling thing.
I hope you're wrong, as I am sure you do. And I am sure you are right, as I am sure you know.

I am too old for Chris Brown and Rhianna to be in my consciousness. Unfortunately now they are celebrities of dysfunction.
km, will look up the article. Your discussion with Sandra is interesting. The man had no guilt whatsoever. Even moaned that he hurt his hand. He is a sociopath.

Sandra, thank you for the exceptional comment. Why I stayed is hard to fathom. I was somehow in a perfect storm situation-- the perpetrator with a victim who forgives. I had been emotionally abused as a child, my father was basically absent and I have a fear of abandonment. My self-esteem was such that I feared the unknown. I also have an easy-going attitude, I'm told. I don't get to anger easily. I brush things off too easily. I am a "type" that these kinds of guys can spot a mile away.
I can tell you that the feeling when the abuser apologizes is kind of a rush that I imagine someone on drugs would get. That is something hard to explain as well.
I knew rationally that I needed to get out, but my emotional neediness and fear of abandonment were stronger than my mind.
If it makes you feel any better in my case, I wouldn't take it now. I don't even take a bad temper. That's one of the reasons I am content alone. I had a wonderful husband and I won't settle for less than I deserve.

theo, yes we share widowhood, but I am glad we don't share this.

hotrod61, nobody ever deserves an excuse for beating someone like that. There are other ways to deal with it unless he is defending his life. She might have been acting out or protecting herself-- who knows, but he didn't look beat up. She did. He's stronger. He seems to take the blame. Why excuse this? That kind of thinking perpetuates a terrible reality.

High Lonesome, see my answer to Sandra. It's complex. And I think it comes from low self-esteem, and a desire to be "loved." I know most people cannot fathom this. But many women are susceptible.

Cranky, if you offered love to your daughter I doubt she would take this. I didn't have that from my father and that may help explain this too.

Connie, you're welcome.
Lea, that wasn't a challenge or a criticism, and I hope it didn't come across as one. Rather, it was a musing. Although I have been blessedly exempt from such situations as you described, as a "woman of a certain age," I am far more willing to extend assistance than to ask for it. When one is entrenched in a role, whether it be matriarch or fixer or "I can take care of myself and it's none of your business," it's very difficult to step out.
I didn't take it as criticism, just musing. I'm afraid this one is hard to have answers for. I just feel so terrible for the women in danger; tremendous empathy.
Lea, I have been very lucky that an abusive man has never shown an interest in me. I have had friends in abusive relationships, and what you say is so very true -- women in those relationships often blind themselves to what is really going on, making excuses until they have gone so far down the path it is hard to stop.

I will say this....women often make excuses for their men, and the only difference between you and me on that point is the things we make excuses for. I dated an addict and made plenty of excuses for his using. Perhaps the larger question we need to be asking is: why do we women make so many excuses for our men when they do things that are poisonous to our relationship?

Great post, as always, hon.
Lea, all I can say is that you are a beautiful woman with so much that has happened to you. I admire your spirit.
"He played on my positive nature and my hopes, and my needs."

This resonated me. I've had this happen to me in a different way, with a friend who ripped me off for money because I tried to help her go to school and get a new job. You'd never get to me by assuming I had poor self-esteem or appealing to greed or vanity, but you can probably fool me, for a short time anyway, by appealing to my need to make things better.
Lea, Sally, Lea, Sally... who's counting? I am you and you are me and WE IS US! Hawt Cougar Object Lessons who know that Stayin Alive and Lively is really the best revenge.
Thank you so much for sharing this story, difficult though it must have been. It was a very illuminating account of how 'this kind of thing' can happen to a smart, self-aware woman. I am so sorry that you had to experience this. I just don't understand these men (or abusive women), how they can become this way, become so violent. I'm glad you got out. I hope Rihanna and other women in similar situations do too.
This is the first time I'd read that he bit her, that's not a good sign... biting is a classic thing hardcore abuser/murderer/rapists do, normal men don't do that even when they lose their tempers. Ugh.

Thank you for sharing how these things get started.
First, everyone who has commented I thank you so much for not going where so many do --scolding and not trying to understand how complex and difficult this dynamic is. I am again convinced that this is a special place, indeed.

Bill, now many of are aware of this couple. The PR people must have mixed feelings.

Liz, yes, I make excuses all the time. But in this situation it can be deadly.

Jess, thank you very much for the kindness.

new blog, thanks for coming over where not many men have tread. And thank you for being honest.
For me, this was the only relationship ever, of many (!) that was physical. My part was defense, period. It is not normal to hit and hurt, even a little. I hope you can hear me on this. It can get out of hand in a second.

Yeah Sally!

Thanks, Jacey. I never thought it could happen to me either. Go know.
Allie, I read about the beating in a blog in Huffpo. Even if he didn't it looked like he clubbed her.
Wow, Lea. Powerful writing.

You seem like you want to see the best in people, and most of the time that is a good thing… I’m glad that you used this experience to help others.
Lea -- I'm happy to share my experience. It's so much more common than anyone realizes. At the same time I was going through my ordeal (see my posts called "Me and the Gambler"), my best friend was too and she's also an "educated woman" who thought she should "know better." We all knew better, we just couldn't resist the most insidious part of an abusers modis operandi, which is the deeply effective manipulative skills many of them possess.
I can tell you that the feeling when the abuser apologizes is kind of a rush that I imagine someone on drugs would get.

Lea, I found this comment incredibly insightful, and resonant with some of my ideas, formed after watching someone I love stay in an abusive relationship for most of her life, seemingly unable to leave.

It seems to me that neither person in a relationship like this has an authentic experience of personal power. To some extent, they are both swimming in a sea of powerlessness and self-loathing. Episodes of violence, remorse and forgiveness give them temporary relief from those core feelings.
--The abuser has a momentary experience of power when s/he acts it out on the victim.
--The victim has a momentary experience of power when s/he forgives the abuser. (It took me years to understand that!)
Of course the power is bankrupt. But like riders on either side of a horrible seesaw, their psychological needs stay perfectly balanced.

The courage it takes to jump off that seesaw and break the unconscious bond between them is almost unimaginable. Congratulations for having done it, and for publishing this post. I especially appreciate your voice after some of the cold, compassionless pieces that have been published here recently. You are an inspiration!
Denies, yes I do tend to see the positive. Too much of that isn't good.

Donna, thanks for the terrific example and analysis. "A horrible see-saw" indeed. I jumped off.
It's sad that the world when I was growing up is still the same in some ways. I had abusive parents. He abused her. She abused him. They abused us.

Fortunately for me, I never had an inkling to be that way with anyone. Though I've had my heart handed to me on a platter a few times, and more often the platter was removed, I've never encountered anything in my adult life like the way my childhood was. It has been difficult to hear from others how they've been treated and abused physically and mentally. It goes on and on and on. The button says: "Make It Stop". I say, "Don't Even Start".
That goes for both genders. Still the stories are real. The people are real. Life is real. Courage to deal with life realities is speaking one's truth. Thanks for speaking Lea, again. You and all that have responded to this post are really courageous and wonderful people. Every day, I read "No one can make you feel inferior without your permission." on my loved fiance's refrigerator, by someone near and dear to me. (another story). I wish that no one ever goes through disrespectful relationships. I hope the world gets better. I hope your post does succeed with even one person. Rated.
James, you seem to be a wonderful man, and that is a remarkable comment. Thank you.
I love the courage here Lea. I can relate to so much that has been said here both by you and many of the commenters.

Just because we might love someone doesn't mean it is good for us to be with them. It's like forgiveness, it is good for the soul to forgive, but that doesn't mean that we give those we forgive a second chance at hurting us. It just doesn't. We have to love ourselves 1st.
Susanne, you've got courage as well, for sure.
In response to a post that mentioned that an abuser she know had multiple guns.....

If your abuser has a gun -- DO NOT TURN IN TO THE POLICE ... instead... TAKE THE GUN AND KEEP IT YOURSELF!

So the next time, the abuser confronts you, POINT THE GUN AT HIM! And NEVER GIVE IT BACK! KEEP IT FOREVER!

This is the REAL reason why so many refuse to join the gun-control crowd!

Very few gun owners are the stereotypical " right wing neo-Confederate " types. Those are stereotypes!

In fact, some pro-gun advocates were former gun-control advocates who realized that a gun could be a best defense against an abusive spouse 8X their size!

Now you know why so many Americans refuse to jump on the gun-control bandwagon!
If my abuser had a gun he would have probably shot me. I wouldn't want one in the house for him or me. Deadly. That's how many of the 13oo are killed each year.
Your abuser didn't have a gun, but he could've easily grabbed your neck and yank your vocal cords. Or stab you! Or used baseball bats!

In fact, even in the USA (so-called land of AK-47s), you're way more likely to be beaten or stabbed to death than to even be shot at!

I understand.. guns are scary. Even going to a shooting range brings chills up my spine!

However, if you read "Armed & Female" (http://www.amazon.com/Armed-Female-Twelve-Million-American/dp/0312951507), FORMER gun-control advocate Paxton Quigley writes about REAL LIFE CASES in which women used guns against their predators!

This whole idea of "take away the guns, and the world will be a peaceful place" works in one place ... THE FANTASY WORLD!

Some say"too many are killed by guns". Obviously, I don't want to be shot, but I don't to be stabbed or beaten to death either!

Also, I say NOT ENOUGH spouse abusers are getting shot! NOT ENOUGH robbers are getting shot! NOT ENOUGH burglars are getting shot! NOT ENOUGH sexual predators are getting shot! THEY DESERVE IT!

Look, if your abuser even knew you had a gun, he would've hesistate to attack you!

You said earlier that your abuser took advantage of your generous spirit! That's why criminals want their victims to be squeamish about having a gun! They want to take advantage of our generous spirit! They want us to have this "take away the guns and the world will be peaceful" mentality!

You are fortunate to leave the abusive situation relatively peacefully! However, some women have only left their abusive situations when they finally got armed!

I know, I understand the idea of guns are scary. I can't blame anyone for being too afraid to hold a gun! It's not as glamorous as it looks on TV!

But could you please give the mentioned book "Armed & Female" a chance? Even if it doesn't change your mind, you'll understand why so many refuse to jump on the gun-control bandwagon!

Also, check out" Thank God I Had a Gun: True Accounts of Self-Defense " by Chris Bird (http://www.amazon.com/Thank-God-Had-Gun-Self-Defense/dp/0965678458/ref=pd_lpo_k2_dp_k2a_1_txt/182-6009300-0565267?pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_s=lpo-top-stripe-2&pf_rd_r=03E60TMYTQKKH8Q2R9M9&pf_rd_t=201&pf_rd_p=304485601&pf_rd_i=0312951507)
PS: not every gunshot victim was an innocent vicitm! Some (not all, some) DESERVED IT! If you read the books I recommended in my previosu comment , you'll understand that's NOT a "right-wing thought" it's REALITY!

Some who had to use guns to defend themselves are left-wing liberals who are pro-choice, pro-union, pro-government programs. They just understand that criminals, abusers, etc take advantage of victims who have this "take away the guns and the world will be peaceful" mentality!

After all, your abuser didn't need a gun to abuse you. But real people needed a gun to defend themselves against those bigger, stronger, faster, and crazier. Check out those 2 books. It's an eye opener
Thank you for this post, and for having the guts to share this very personal experience. When I have more time, I will read the comments.

Intellectually, I know that anyone can find themselves in this kind of situation. But I was surprised to hear that you had been in an abusive relationship... just because when I look at your photo and read your posts, you have a look of someone at peace, and you seem to have a healthy sense of self-worth and self-confidence... you exude inner peace.

I'm tired, so this is coming out all wrong... Anyhow, I know what it's like to be taken in by someone who is fun and charming (even though in my case, he wasn't physically abusive, it was abusing my trusting and good nature).

Great that you used your experience to benefit others. Rated.
Cynarra, because people would be surpised by the fact is the reason I told about it. Anyone it seems can turn up in either role. The abuser can be pernicious and masterful and the abusee can be manipulated and duped, despite "intelligence" and maybe because of a peaceful nature, which can't fathom the depths of cruelty that this entails. I tend to hope for the best. That's sometimes gotten me in trouble, but this time it put me in danger.
Lea thanks for sharing your honesty. People should know that women are capable of abuse as well. Generally we think of men only but this is not always true.
Ladyfarmerjed, yes, many women are abusive to men who take it and stick around. Role reversal. It's just that men do it more, are usually bigger and more violent, and one did it to me.
My ex-husband was an abuser. He started off by being Mr. Wonderful. He told me I didn't have to work-he would support me. I could help him with his business and stay at home and raise the kids. Then, he wanted me to have nothing to do with my family...they were using me, etc. When I tried to make friends, he quickly found fault with them. Again the lines with they were using me, he didn't me to go anywhere, no one could come to the house and visit. He isolated me. I couldn't go anywhere for long without being questioned that I was cheating on him. I couldn't even go to a hair or doctor's appointment with out the kids tagging along. He humiliated me and verbally abuse me out in public to the point of tears. I walked on eggshells often. He threatened to leave me because I cooked chicken for dinner instead of london broil. When he left me, I was devastated, so were the kids. But, after awhile I was relieved because I finally was able to face the truth. He was cheating and had a drug habit. He thought he was punishing me when he withheld money for child support. He also was emotionally abusive to the kids.
brunettebabe, I'm very sorry to hear about the classic kind of abuse that your husband perpetuated. But I am very, very happy that you got out, and hope that you have a fulfilling life now.
Thank you for this post. I, too, experienced abuse at the hands of someone I thought I loved. In fact, it lasted, off and on, for about 15 years. Weird, now that I look back at it, since no children were involved. I chalk it up to my Catholic upbringing and being the oldest of seven children, having the "good example for the rest" mentality. Also, he succeeded in making me believe I was totally worthless. I look back as if that were another lifetime. The physical abuse was minimal, but the psychological manipulation, the verbal abuse, the financial deprivation, and the social isolation were almost constant after the first few years of marriage (which were okay). I never knew what started it all, and still don't, but now I don't care why. I'm still healing from what happened, and I still find that pool of rage within when I hear of abuse in other's lives. I use it and transform it to send positive energy and healing out.
Awesome post. Rated for self-exposure and self-love. You have privileged us with your experience and enlightenment.
Lairdog, I'm so glad that you got out, as I did. Who knows what made us stay. At least we are safe and wiser.

psychomama, thank you so much for the kind words.