
The post I wrote for OS last week, Why I’m Alone, spun into the blogosphere, and consequences were both good and bad. I learned quite a bit from the experience, which might be helpful for you too. I guess this is a meta post.
You can’t always tell. I wrote the piece on March 20, in the morning. Normally I would have sent it here to OS, my beloved home base. But there were many interviews appearing that day, and I felt it would be like an orphan post, kind of out of place, and the topic wouldn’t have worked at that moment. So I sent it into the big, bad world of The Huffington Post, where I’ve been blogging for a couple of years.
Like many non-celeb posts over there, it was off the page pretty fast, into archives. And posts in the Living section often garner no comments, no matter how good. I figured that I’d send it over here in a couple of days where I really wanted it to go, when the interviews meme, and some carping and tetchiness died down.
The next day I checked my own website’s stat counter. Whoa. I had 400 times the normal viewers. The bar chart rose into the sky. Why? So I checked, and they were coming from Huffpost, whose editors had put the post back on the site, on the top of the Big News section's Relationships page (it’s still there, I think), with a graphic. Maybe an editor liked it. And this started a chain reaction.
The post was now also placed in their Living Section, in the left column, with a blurb and photo. And then I noticed that their home page scrawl said that it had become one of the most popular posts in any of the sections, up just a while but with almost 60 thousand on-site viewers, and counting. Wha’ happened? I was delighted but bewildered. A day ago it had seemed like a loser.
I sent the post to OS on March 23, wondering how my friends here would feel about it. Was it a fluke? Well, it climbed to the top of both rated and read for 12 hours. Go know.
Try to figure out why something works. “Why I’m Alone” wasn’t dramatic, or literary or beautifully written (although it was carefully written, as I try for most of my writing). It was just a glorified listing really, which flowed out of me in a rush. I’ve done better, worked harder and gotten less notice.
I learned lots from the comments, which I read carefully. The most frequent compliments were honest, authentic, universal, simple, heartfelt and funny. I wish I could figure out how to do that in every post, but there’s no telling, because I have written other things that I thought had some of that, and they never caught fire.
Rewrite. After reading the comments, I edited the post even more, even after it was up. Writing is rewriting. The OS version was quite different from the original. For example in the original I kept repeating “I’m alone because” at the beginning of each line, which got tiresome. Also I took out a reference to a downer about illness. Too attention-grabbing. I also added a last line about appreciating relationships, so I didn’t come across as a bitter man-hater (I’m not, in case you never read me).
The power of the blogosphere is amazing, with both good and bad consequences. With major sites and RSS feeds, you get spun out and you have your 15 minutes, and then the next thing comes along. But if you put yourself out there, realize you’re up for grabs, and you better not take it personally. I Googled and found that the post was featured on many other sites, including one for young singles, jezebel.com. About 30 thousand young women viewed it there, writing hundreds of comment threads; many of them wrote that they were sending the post around to friends and family.
In this past week I’ve gotten emails through my own website from people all over the world. Touching ones. Funny ones, Invitations to dinner. Mock proposals. And I even was offered a gig to be a contributing columnist from the editor at a well-regarded magazine which caters to singles. (We are in the courtship phase, seeing what might happen. In this economy, when everyone including me is losing work, that is a little miracle.)
However, lots of people now knew intimate things about me. And the post was featured on a site that chooses one post a day to skewer for fun, so it got hundreds of mean comments like "hairy old bat,” and “her husband would have left her if he hadn’t died.” Someone blew up my photo from the “about us” section of my website and said I had “old hair.” But this might be the best part of all: I laughed. It took me a long time but I’m secure enough to not be defined by ranters.
In fact, I took their criticism and edited even further For example, I took out a line about not wanting to get a bikini wax. No need to give them material.
I do realize more now that every time I publish a post, someone may be reading who could change my life for better or worse. I’m more aware of that than I had been, in terms of using names or telling tales or opening up more than I’m comfortable.
Diggs and other connectors do count. Maybe the Digg icon on OS could be placed more prominently, like it is on Huffpost, and put right next to the thumb, so that when we rate we can easily Digg or Buzz or whatever. So if you got a rating of 20, you’d hope for 20 Diggs. That would assure us of thousands of readers beyond OS. I got over 80 Diggs on Huffpost. Probably none here. And I know that helped the post go viral.
Don’t worry so much about EPs and covers. Really. When I sent this to OS they didn’t award it a cover or even an EP. And even without that boost, OSers still made this little post my highest-rated ever.
A week after I posted it, “Why I’m Alone” is still featured in the Relationships section on Huffpost, and it's now ensconced in our new, accessible archives here, and is still floating to other sites and through email. My website stats are still way up, though now only 10 times more than average, and I’m still getting emails from readers.
The visibility of that post is at 14 minutes and counting, but my secret hope is that one of my friends will soon unknowingly include me in a mass emailing, with a “You gotta read this –send it to 10 friends.”


Salon.com
Comments
Rated
this is two fabulous people today for whom OS has been a launching point. well, for you, OS and huff post and digg and all of that. kudoes, sweetheart. love love love and gratitude
I had this happen with one of mine on a smaller scale. I tracked it all over the net. It was stolen and put on other people's blogs who don't even speak English for godssakes. I had to ask people to either attribute it to me or take it down. I'm still getting about 200 hits a month on it after it's initial run in January. Like you, I expect to one day receive an email with my post in it!
I learned as you did that you need to have a thick skin when this happens. The comments that were left on one of the "sharing" sites were quite mean. They basically all said it stunk except for one commenter who said that if I didn't steal it from the Onion, then I should write for the Onion. That comment alone was worth it!
The good news is that it won honorable mention in a humor contest. Not exactly the success that you're enjoying but a taste of it. Even with the mean comments and plagiarism, I'd go through it all again in a heartbeat. Nothing validates a writer like being read.
I like how you've said that you never know what's going to hit. This was far from being anything that I put a lot of time into. I guess all we can do is write and let the readers tell us what works, right?
Good luck on the column and all of the other good things that are sure to be headed your way.
Lainey, yes I'm a featured blogger there. I got that because I commented alot and one of the editors noticed, and she had read my book, Solo Traveler, and she invited me. I had never even thought of it; I was perfectly happy commenting. And of course I don't get paid; only the editors do over there.
Thanks, Kaysong. And featherchicklet, and CoyoteOldstyle too (love that name!)
Justjuli, I was really impressed with the threads there. And the fact that I'm older than the readers there didn't seem to effect their response to the post.
junk1, I did put the edited version here.
Tijo, I can't tell you how wonderful it was to be able to take the heat. And some of it was pretty burning hot. I guess when you get older you just don't care as much.
Theo, you're right of course. More than half of us are solo. And of course, many of the 20 somethings who start feeling pressure are interested in hearing that there are good elements to the state. Thanks for your kind words. Hope you're doing ok with all the recent noise woes.
Lisa, I'm not at all surprised that what you write gets picked up. You write about your life, which relates to so many others with families and problems, and you do it with humor and heart. You know I always tell you to try for a book. You have a warm and wonderful voice.
There are just so many talented voices here and yours is certainly one of them!
LuluandPhoebe, you never know. Pets would be another topic that could get viral if a post got enough Diggs. We really do need to get on that.
Cartouche, we're not even to second base.
Buffy, the thing is, this one just flowed. Not that much work. Maybe that's one of the secrets.
Lisa, I did get a few cute comments from guys. Probably from prisoners on death row. But hey, nobody's perfect.
I can't wait til it comes in an e-mail to me from a friend.... I can e-mail them back and say, hey, I know who wrote that!!!
You could write about an old dog park and make it sound like the finest place on Earth.
I agree with the share buttons being next the the thumb and flag. That makes great sense.
One of these days I'll add one of those counter thingies. They are pretty cool, but I think they may crush my ego.
I learned a lot. I had a little article get on Reditt and was aghast at some of the comments! I learned that this is part of the deal, and if even a wondermous article like yours gets haters, I won't ever sweat it again!!
Yes, Middleaged, I know we're in something of the same boat, and the boat floats.
Dr. Spud, congrats on Daily Kos, and I'll bet you were on more than seven sites. It keeps going. And yes, I thought of that mean site as a classroom and I was the sub teacher getting tortured behind her back.
Cat, quite nice of you to say that.
Michael, you don't have to add a counter anymore. OS has made our lives easier. Thanks for stopping by, despite your busy three weeks.
gracielou, and know you are sensitive to all this and it can be a tough scene.
Brenda, some get off on being mean. That's part of what makes OS a special place, and unique.
Stellaa, I need some Housewives!
annette, we all need to get more aware of Digging. And even though we don't get paid, if you read other posts like LaurelnotLauren's you can see that sometimes good things happen when you least expect it, and besides, it is such a pleasure to write in this safe haven.
Great info, but I also love this: QUOTEBut if you put yourself out there, realize you’re up for grabs, and you better not take it personally. QUOTE
It's what I've been saying since I got here.
Pfffft. What a shock -- but it should have been both, Lea. I thought it was a great piece of writing that explored something real and gave me insight into a state with which I'm thankfully not familar. I don't think they're editors in the true sense of the word, searching out and recognizing excellence. Ah, well, the good is always the implacable enemy of the best.
Rated for your (as always) disarming honesty and writing ability.
Rated
I have a few old posts that I set up Stat counter on (I can't get it to work for me for new posts, for some time now - don't know why) and I'm amazed at the traffic they are still getting. Hundreds of visits each month, even though they are months old in some cases.
I haven't been able to figure out why -- I think it might be because I turn up under certain search terms in Google like "sex" and "masturbation". ;)
I can see why it went viral because you really struck a nerve. When I read it, I was so envious and imagine those women who were in this enviable position were delighted to have it so well laid out to the world. Freedom comes late for women and is all the more loved because of it.
Good on you for standing up to the morons and coming home to us.
bless you.
Boanerges1, thanks so. But even from the beginning, when I was under the radar and writing posts that weren't noticed much, I mostly cared how I felt about them. Sometimes I felt very good and sometimes unsure. The EPs feel good, but I can feel inside me if I'm proud of something.
thanks, Jane. It would be on a freelance basis, but hey, I'll take any paying gig where I can write about what I know and like.
M. Chariot, emphasis on fleeting.
thanks, Sandra and Blue.
the hard part is maintaining a standard, if you are looking to make money out of writing. people who ' have' to come up with 500 words by tomorrow tend to fall into hackery.
that is the virtue of an 'occasional' piece, if the spirit moves you often enough to eat regularly.
O'steph, miss you. Hope your studies are going well.
Cap'n, I am extremely pleased that this offered some insight. As Al, said, if you feel something and can communicate it authentically, it just might zing.
You answered your own question, Lea. Of course the jabs hurt a little, even the most childish, ignorant ones where they make fun of your looks. But as I keep telling myself: consider the source. People who resort to name calling, false accusations and attacking people for the way they look only show their own lack of self esteem, intelligence and compassion. I picture them sitting in their icky basements, sweating profusely, grinning as they deliver another insult unworthy of a second-grader, one hand down their pants and the other on the keyboard. Do I care what someone like that thinks? Not in the least. It works for me!
Thanks for the tips. They're really useful.
I have had a few back-and-forths myself about which aspects of my life and writing I want out there, and thanks for confirming that it can make a big difference.
Rated and thank you for mentoring the rest of us!
Sao, I never checked my stats here. But I do for my own website. It was hilarious. There were these tiny low bars of my normal web readership, and then this humongous one. That's the power of the net.
Helen, because I write under my own name, like you, I do feel a tiny bit vulnerable. But I am older and work for myself and want to write openly, so I'm testing my limits by reading the trash stuff.
Cindy, nowadays it's incredibly hard to earn a living writing unless you have a really safe gig. So many wonderful writers are out of work and freelancing for low pay.
Thanks, Deborah. I'm glad this is helpful.
Good on you. It was a great post.
It was fun reading about this experience. Thanks for taking the time to share it. It must feel a little strange to suddenly feel that directly connected to SO many people in so many places.
palindrome, yes I factor in the time to comment when I post. But then I have the time to comment, lately.
Rick, yeah we're all more vulnerable than we realize. This place is an oasis in a dry, hot, windy, huge desert.
Thanks, Tom. Just so they pronounce my name right, and all that?
Skip, that is one of life's truisms.
Screamin, oh my. I like the way you say that. Many thanks.
You sound like you handled it with aplomb and grace. You are impressive in so many ways.
Of course, you already know this, but you are about as far from dried up looking as can possibly be......"old hair"....ha. From a 17 year old who knows better than you, no doubt. Internets people suck, mostly.
You, on the otherhand...fantastic.
Irritated, yes you can learn so much from the reaction, and then edit more.
traveller1, when you're writing for no pay/no contract you can pretty much write anywhere. Things get picked up anyway.
You have to be invited to become a featured blogger at Huffpost, but even if you comment, you develop an archive of comments, and I was satisified with that, as I wrote in the post. Very tough and interactive commenting there, and you get called out if you make mistakes or say something less than smart. And sometimes you even get praised, which isn't easy.
Now that the new system is in I'm not sure when it's best to post here. I would say if you post at a quiet time you stay up on the feed longer. But if you have a strong post it might be better to put it up in the morning and take on the major competition. Most people post around 9 am-11am, I would say, and then around 3-5 pm, to try and maximize cover possibility. And then maybe in the evening, right after midnight to get the next date.
But I think you have to try it and different times and see what works. One obvious tip: if several popular writers have recently posted, I would wait a bit till their posts die down. They all do. Play with it and let me know what works.
Then I read this post, and realized the audience obviously had been bigger than just OS people. I did a quick google search, and, sure enough, this little bugger had gone viral.
You seem pretty grounded about the whole thing. Me, I'm buying champagne tonight. I'm on minute sixteen already and I didn't even realize it. I missed the whole thing.
Rated, fo' sho'.
shaggylocks, congrats. It means people saw it here, or the feed. Potential for that level is always there when people respond to your piece.
Very illuminating, Lea, and very generous of you to take the time to share all this information. You are a first-rate writer with a lot of interesting life experience, so I'm not surprised your work is getting its share of attention. (I'm way behind on all this stuff... haven't even figured out how to install one of those clickers...)
I don't get the "old" hair thing AT ALL, by the way.
I'm not at OS much right now because I have a new memoir client in Beverly Hills and am spending a lot of time on his story. Glad I didn't miss this.
I wrote what turned out to be the second highest-rated post on OS, with 135 ratings. But even that post only had around 400 views. Now, we have posts with few ratings and comments and literally tens of thousands of views.
For example, currently the fourth most-viewed post in the past month has three ratings, four comments, and almost 38,000 views!
One of the things that people like most about OS is the sense of community. You can now write a post that's wildly successful on OS, but that only garners maybe one percent of the views -- if even that -- of some other post that is barely noticed here. But with Digg and these other tools, one of the most important measures of the popularity and success of a post is now defined by people who aren't part of the community. The success of a post now has less to do with what the community thinks about it, and more to do with how well it was promoted outside of OS. That just seems odd to me.
LnotL, you keep saying you're not techie, but you seem to be doing just fine. And the "old hair" is the style I guess (on my avatar). They were pushing a bit there. They said other nasty things but why write them down?
Hawley, sounds like you're spending your time wisely. BH is one of the few areas left where people can afford to write their memoirs.
Mishima666, it's the RSS feed from other sites, I guess. I think it helps Salon in some way to get noticed, for advertisers. But the nice thing is that we can pick and choose.
Thanks, voicegal.
And I agree - sometimes the extroversion it takes to put your ass out there (in my case almost literally) takes a lot of guts and you have to be...in the mood for it. If not, it can feel like a weird assault, even occasionally and strangely, when good things are said.
grif, I'll take 15. Hell, I would take five for something worthwhile.
I actually had a relatively popular humorous post a few weeks ago that was turning up on the intertubes as well. I was shocked to see almost 36000 people had viewed it. It was nice. Heck, someone even stole it.
Anyway I'm glad about the positive response you got. From what I've read on your blog, you deserve it. As for the mean crud---well, many folks just don't have a lot going for them. I guess this type of thing is par for the course when putting stuff out on the internet. It's cool you took it in stride. Good for you.
MJ
EPs and covers mean jack without readers, this is beyond very true.
I don't think I would want to go viral, get the sneezes and the coughs, be horrible!!
:)
Anyway, thanks for this post!
aim, you can always edit without having to republish. Just got to"More" and "Manage Posts" and then click on edit --can always do that!