
Between my marriages I dated interesting men for 15 years, and had a few meaningful long-term relationships. But for over a year I’m sorry to say that I was in and out of an emotionally and physically abusive relationship.
How could I have been so self-destructive and stupid? How could I have accepted the unacceptable? Judge for yourself.
I met Lenny in the spring right after a breakup. He was self-deprecating, generous and funny, with an Ivy degree and a partnership in a NYC law firm. He was my age, short and boyish. My friends liked him. He seemed a keeper.
He spoke well of his ex-wife. I noted that. He loved animals, and I noted that. Big on his family. Liberal. Picked up tabs. Fixed things around my house. No children, so he wouldn’t even be distracted or influenced.
I was a freelance writer empty-nesting in the same stone house in Westchester County New York where I had raised my family. I rented out the cottage in the back of the property, rented out my boys’ bedrooms as a suite with an entrance, even rented part of my house and the backyard and pool in the summer to hedge funders who came up maybe twice. I made do, house poor.
Lenny put his shoes --with shoe trees, no less -- in my closet after our second date. We started spending weekdays at his New York City pad and weekends at my house. He wined and dined me, placed bling around my neck when I least expected it, and made me feel lovely and cared for in a whirl of fun.
The largesse kept coming. He offered me his Lexus to drive and keep. And then his maid, to deep clean my house and return every week. He took me anywhere I wanted to go. He told me I was beautiful, and complimented me on how I dressed, and he said “I love you” before I even thought to.
I was writing a guidebook on the Greek Islands and he surprised me and flew to Greece to spend part of the research time with me. My arms were tightly around him on the motorcycle he steered along winding roads. I remember dinner by an ancient well on Corfu, and later the moon flooding our balcony in cold, dreamy light.
But the nightmare was about to begin. Soon after we returned to New York, we were spectators at a seniors tennis match; Conners and Borg were playing. Lenny’s mood was strangely nasty. He glowered for hours about being late. I told him, “I’m not comfortable with you acting this way. It’s not acceptable.”
I found myself saying that over and over in the next months. He started balking and complaining about even small things. Putting me down. Getting annoyed when I’d do things without him. He tried to shut me off from others. He said cruel things, blaming me absurdly. He pushed me ahead in the movie line a bit too hard. He pinched (or did he?) when he grabbed my waist to rush me along. With each gradation, each escalation I debated with myself, and rationalized. If I commented, he would eventually apologize, and then move the abusive behavior a tiny bit higher.
Meanwhile, to distract me he let me choose his new apartment overlooking the East River, and we furnished it together. That kept me busy, and kept me there. And 99 percent of the time, he appeared charming. What's a bit of sadism when he has such nice friends and is such a great guy, deep down?
But one afternoon, when I had missed lunch and had the nerve to say that I was hungry, he pushed me out of a parked car onto the grass, and punched me in the face. Two teens saw this and called the police. I debated pressing charges, but thought he might get disbarred. He kept staring at me. So I didn’t.
He profusely apologized later, but we moved our stuff out of each other’s homes and I stopped seeing him. Then came months of major apologies, supposed “therapy,” notes and emails, more lavish gifts. He played on my positive nature and my hopes, and my needs.
I wavered, and sorry to say, gave him another chance. I know, you must be thinking, “Why? He’s bribing you. He’s not going to change.” I’d think that too, now. Abusers rarely change. Statistics show that violence escalates rather than ends as these relationships continue. But I retained magical thinking.
Things went well for a couple of months, with more good times and better behavior. But on a Caribbean cruise, in a cabin together, he blew up. Cursing. Hitting. Even at one point closing both his hands around my neck.
I fled to a friend’s room and told her all, left him at the Ft. Lauderdale pier and hopped the first flight home to New York. I immediately escaped to New Hampshire with another girlfriend who was kind enough not to tell me ‘I told you so.’ It was over, and I finally got it.
A few months later, arising from the nadir, I met the wonderful man who became my second husband. And not long after I remarried, I took courses and volunteered to be a domestic violence counselor at an organization called My Sister’s Place. Eventually they had me speaking to groups about the sometimes disguised face of domestic violence, and I felt some closure.
Lenny immediately glommed onto another perfectly nice professional woman. When he read about my marriage he emailed me as if nothing had happened, without a trace of guilt.
I saw him by chance last year in Miami at a ballet. His hair had turned silver and he was with a stunning, much taller, much-younger Latina. He sputtered some clichés, and I felt disgust. I was alone, as my loving husband had died in 2001.
And then I saw him again at a charity event, this past year. He had gained weight and didn't look well. I was with my new beau. He saw me and I looked away. And beau and I left.
The new man in my life is good and sweet, like my late husband. I've learned the hard way.


Salon.com
Comments
Here's a quote from an article which delves into the same topic:
"Women do not like being treated like crap, but they will even sleep with a sexist pig if they haven’t known him long enough to know he’s a sexist pig . . . "
http://thehathorlegacy.com/the-misogynist-who-gets-the-girls-is-a-male-fantasy/
(1) it can happen to anyone of us. And,
(2) it is possible to make other choices beyond the ones determined by the abuser.
Rated.
Travis, I can't explain what happens when the slow drip, drip of abuse starts. But the dynamic can cloud your rational self. And an abuser chooses his partner knowing she is likely to forgive.
So true, psychomama. And to add another truth, the abuser can be a charming, professional person, well-liked and well respected. In fact, often is.
designanator, I learned from that abusive relationship and have understood the wonder of a good man ever since.
"What was I thinking?" Thank you for sharing this.
Jane, maybe I was blinded by the bling and his charm, but I did not get it until well into it. I suspected he was acting up at the tennis match, but figured he would return to his pleasant ways again. I realized later that he wouldn't and I was already so enmeshed and frightened that I went into some sort of denial. And when he apologized, I wanted to believe him. I don't know what that was, except mind-bending.
Emma, thank you for showing us that another woman who "should know better" can fall into this mire.
LL2, we all have things in our lives that are difficult/painful. I guess some won't admit them, but by talking to groups and writing about it I feel that at least I am offering some reality to learn from.
C.K. DH, so sorry about your mom. I hope you understand how hard it is for her in many ways.
Tragically it seems that many women experience many abusive relationships, one after another, attracting brutes like moths to a flame except they are the ones who are burnt.
I am so very happy to know that you have found love again, and no one would begrudge you a bit of schadenfreude at the site of the now bloated abuser while in the arms of Mr. Wonderful!
Jane, thanks for coming back. I put this out again just for the reasons you said. And also, for support, like yours, which makes me feel strong enough to keep telling my sad story whenever I have a chance. It's about the only good that can come out of something so bad.
Steve, in his case he was addicted to marijuana "for recreational purposes." He didn't drink. Oh and he loved animals and his family and was funny and self-deprecating and generous. And I kept looking at those traits.
C.K., so very, very glad that you learned from your mom's situation. Sometimes, as you know, it goes the other way and you seek what you have experienced in your past or what your mom did. And yes, it is complex. Tremendously.
Shit happens sometimes, you don't even realize how we came that point. Only one feeling I remember from those days "HELPLESS"
Glad to see you are doing fine sister! :)
It's time for women to stop accepting the consequences of men's poor behavior. Strong women like you are leading the way with essays like this.
Momsacomic, I wondered why, but I think his lack of remorse to this day just proves he and many other abusers are sociopaths, lashing out without empathy or a conscience to make them understand the abuse in what they do. And many women wouldn't stand for it. So the abusers know to trap the ones that do.
Kitty, I'm sorry to hear you had such an awful time. And sorry you are not in a good relationship now. Can you leave? Do you have support to leave? There are many domestic violence facilities and hotlines to help. Good luck and please remember that violent people rarely change.
Sandra, it's extremely hard to empathize with an abused woman. I cannot tell you the comments I got from "friends" who were in comfy relationships and who were disgusted with me rather than understanding of the perfect storm dynamic of an abuser and abusee. One is usually without conscience and the other often too understanding, too easy to forgive, too hopeful, too needy. And frightened. Fear played a big part, both real and imagined.
I figure the best I can do after having been in this situation is to at least write about it and call attention to it. So I really appreciate your support of that.
Michael, many men are on the receiving end and few talk about it. I don't remember if you wrote about that, but it would make for an enlightening post.
Kitty, I'm so sorry. He sounds verbally abusive. I hope you can gather the strength to do what's best for you.
latethink, children make it especially hard to leave. I understand. And yes, it was sweet to leave the event with a far better man.
Thanks, Lisa and Happy Bday.
Denverdarling, words can't kill and I guess that's the main thing. But abuse of any kind is degrading, and taking it is mystifying.
Reminder to all: most abusers are sociopaths, the smoothest charmers on earth... and potentially the deadliest. Ted Bundy was one. Just sayin...
So glad the new beau is clearly at the other end of the spectrum. And now, thanks to Chaim (olev ha shalom) and your own hard work, so are you.
R
catnmus, every word is true, alas. Why would I wish to embarrass myself? I do hope it proves your point.
Sally, thanks for adding the Bundy/Charm connection. The charm can be like perfume. Just scintillating, covering the dirt beneath.
Buffy, why aren't you out on the dance floor with an officer or two?
yes. that's it. magical thinking. great post lea.
Thanks for thinking it up, Bonnie. I think we can overdo open calls, as they take a bit away from the casual fun which is a great thing on this site, but this was a valuable topic.
monkey, I still retain magical thinking in wishing our country could do better, but that's another story.
tammie, so true. When women stop listening you can't do much. Maybe a powerful note that could be read in private. But the grip of this thing is strong, like a magnet and lead.
stim, thank you for coming by. You are a loyal friend.
Jill, I have a feeling many could share similar stories. But it's no fun to.
Spud, he was with a more age-appropriate woman the second time I saw him. I hope she has more balls than I did, and if she does, it won't last long.
Patie, yes there's lots of gray. But violence is black, and should be fled. The problem is how hard it is for some of us.
There's the two-question illustration that explains it beautifully: If someone blackens your eye on the first date, what would you do? Of course, no one would ever date that person again, right? But what if you had two children with your husband when he first blackens your eye? What would you do? The pendulum starts to swing toward second and third chances, etc.
Abusers are often charming people, which enables them to attract victims, and they usually don't strike until the victim has some stake in the relationship.
Good for you, Lea, for getting yourself out as soon as you did, and for following up all that with positive energy: taking training, volunteering and speaking about your experience. It's important that people know abuse is an equal-opportunity problem that cuts across all geographic, social and economic lines.
I am printing it, and sharing it with my employees ... most of who come from foreign backgrounds that are highly chauvenistic. Within our staff, we've had several events wherein our female employees have been abused at home. When we become aware, we try to get them help ... albeit counceling, shelter, etc ... but even so, most return to their past. And one who did exactly that, was thereafter gunned down in the streets by her abusive husband.
Rod, I am thrilled that you are using this. The way for me to deal with the reality has been to be open, and I have given many talks before women's groups, based on training at My Sister's Place in Westchester County. Abuse knows no barriers and can occur in any relationship.
I don’t know how to adequately compliment you for this piece other than to say I’m going to share it with my daughter in hopes it will help her with her choices in the same measure as it moved me.
Rated and appreciated very much.
Kathy ( my "copyeditor," :) )thank you for indexing these. I shall get back to them.
Silk, yes, when I first wrote this I had no idea there would ever be that kind of postscript. Feels especially good.
I used to work in the 'field' of domestic violence, because there actually is a field for it.... and I remember something we said all the time at our volunteer trainings and whenever we did public speaking: Every woman is one relationship away from being abused. It can happen to anyone.
People didn't always like when we said it, but of course, it is so true.
Best to you.
lainey, abject honesty is one of my traits as I get older.
rita, lots of us out there, alas.
greg, thanks for reminding me I'm not a sap. But I think I once was. (You sure aren't and have suffered abuse, as you've written.)
I have to tell you that I am still very mixed up and am longing for he man I fell in love with so many years, the problem is that that man never existed. I have spoke with many people since then who knew him then and they tell me that he wasn't a nice man then. How on earth did I fall for him?
By the way, all of his friends did adore him and told me how lucky I was to have him on more than one occasion. After awhile he said such odd things as "you need to get Mrs ____________'s house and I will get__________________. I thought it was so weird and told him that their family will get their house when they pass and that is not for us. Later he told me that he could make a million by killing for money. He mentioned several times, in a joking fashion, that he would do things to me (that he had seen in a movie). Luckily the kids had moved out by this time. I was still ill and by this time thought that I could never support myself (it is hard) so I would have to learn to be happy there. Soon after I found some things from an insurance company from a small town near his hometown, and another. He told me he didn't know why someone as sick as I would want to live. A couple of years later ( I had moved out of his bed after some denied relationships) I found him hovering over me in my bed in the middle of the night, on two occasions. I then had to sleep with a knife under my bed. I snuck to see my attorney and for a second time in two years asked for a divorce. The year previous I had also asked for a divorce but we sought counseling, where he lied about things. He insisted he wanted to stay with me and acted a bit nicer but would slip up once in awhile and say very mean things to me. His drinking had increased but he was spending more time at home, instead of disappearing all day.
I will never forget the day I had to ask, in front of many people, for a .79 head of lettuce, or when we were taking my son to the airport and he kept putting out his hand to me, I would grab for it and he would pull it away again, if front of other people. I did this twice before I walked away from him.
I was just so crazy to me and now I am having trouble moving on from this. I tried a new job and failed. I was mentally, physically and emotionally exhausted. I must try again, as I will be out of money soon. Have you learned of resources to help you get past such emotional pain? Some days seem too overwhelming to do anything other than sleep all day.