
www.holocaustresearchproject.org/.../hun.jews.gif
I met Cecile Klein in the early 1980s. Fragile, intelligent, in her fifties, she was a Holocaust survivor finally ready to tell her story. She had written some narrative and had shown her poems to Elie Weisel, who had encouraged her. She now sought a writer to help her.
For almost a year we spoke and met. I edited her prose and poems, sorted through the remaining pictures of her family, and talked with her for many hours about her early years. We polished three chapters and several poems and sent them to a few editors. Some expressed interest, but some were abrupt: “Too many Holocaust stories coming in right now.” Cecile was put off by this and didn't want to face possible rejection. The project ended, and I lost touch with her.
But I never forgot her. And with Holocaust Remembrance Day -- Yom Hashoah -- coming up this weekend, I want to share some of her tales, as I remember them.
When Hitler came to power Cecile was a sensitive girl living with her sisters and brothers and her widowed mother in the mountains near the border of Czechoslovakia and Hungary. A couple of her siblings moved to Palestine. One brother became politically active and was sent to a concentration camp early on.
As the Nazi menace flared in Hungary, Cecile's young, well-off boyfriend asked her to join his family, who had paid a farmer to hide them. She wanted to be with him, but decided she couldn’t leave her mother, and said no.
Not long after, the farmer betrayed her boyfriend's family, and they all disappeared.
Cecile and her mother stayed together for awhile. Later, to hide out more safely, Cecile moved to Budapest with some Catholic friends, slept with a cross over her bed, and worked in a dental office. A clever, bold teenager, she’d walk around with an anti-semitic newspaper to throw the authorities off.
But eventually the police brought the girls to a station and queried them, one by one. Cecile was last, afraid she had been outed as a Jew by her friends. But she not only got through the interrogation, she persuaded a policeman to walk her home, figuring they would never again suspect her if she actually wanted to extend time with the gestapo.
In 1944 time had run out for Hungarian Jews, the last European Jews to have escaped deportation. Cecile was rounded up along with her mother, her sister, her brother-in-law and her two-year old nephew, Nathan.
One of Cecile's poems describes seeing the stars through slats in the cattle car on their way east. Of that awful transit she writes of the darkness, throwing out the buckets of waste, the stuffy heat, the fear of the unknown, the fainting, frightened captives, the slivers of sky and clouds above.
When the train stopped at Auschwitz, Cecile's brother-in-law gave away his hidden watch to a man in stripes, who rushed the Jews out of the train. The man whispered, "Have the old woman hold the little boy. Otherwise your wife will die along with him."
Cecile's sister didn’t hear those dire words, but her mother did, and she pleaded to her older daughter. "Let me have Nathan. Otherwise they'll assign me to hard labor." Cecile’s sister resisted giving up her son, but to save her daughter's life the grandmother took her grandson in her arms, knowing that they were doomed.
Cecile and her family lined up for selection before Dr. Josef Mengele, just beyond the train. Her mother, still holding Nathan, was sent to the left. Her sister cried, but still did not fully understand what would be happening to her son and her mother. Cecile did.
One day when we were working together, Cecile called me in a strained voice. "Look in The New York Times Magazine. The story about Raoul Wallenberg." There, spread across the page, was a grainy photo taken by the Nazis. Bewildered people were walking on a train platform. The focus was a sweet-faced woman in a head kerchief, holding a small boy in her arms. It was Cecile's mother. Cecile had never before seen that photo.
Incredibly, it is the photo above.
Cecile and her sister managed to stay together at Auschwitz, surviving day by precious day, through luck, cleverness and support. Sixteen year-old Cecile volunteered to write love poems for the Jewish leader of her block, to arouse the woman's Nazi guard lover. When the affair ended, the despondent woman cried, "Now we're doomed."
At one point Cecile actually stood at the door of a gas chamber, awaiting certain death. But at the last minute her group traded places with another group, and she was sent away to dig potatoes. She often kept a few of them to supplement the watery soup that barely sustained her and her sister. One day the guard asked the laborers to empty their pockets. Those who had potatoes in their pockets were shot.
Cecile, ever wise, ever bold, had hidden her potatoes in her cap.
The sisters stayed alive through the degradation, illness and constant danger. Even at the end after their camp was destroyed and they were liberated, many of the starved victims ate their fill, became ill and died. Cecile had cautioned her famished sister not to gorge on the food provided, and they remained safe.
But the story is even more remarkable. On the train taking them to their freedom, Cecile recognized one of the fellow passengers, the boyfriend she had known in the village. They had both somehow endured Auschwitz, living close to each other for months and never knowing it.
They fell in love and married, but returning to a now Communist Eastern Europe they encountered anti-semitism once again. They eventually managed to get to America, but were treated poorly by sponsors, and lived for a long while on scraps such as beef lungs and wilted vegetables.
Years passed, they raised a family, worked hard, and prospered in suburban New York. Cecile's husband lived the American Dream, and put the past behind as much as possible. But when I met Cecile, the sadness in her eyes still reflected the loss of her siblings and her mother and nephew and the relatives and friends who had perished in the Holocaust.
This weekend I will light a memorial candle and once again think of Cecile's story, and the stories of millions of others.
And I will especially remember Nathan, the little boy in the photo, who was only two years old.
Part 2, Remembrance: A Walk Through Hell/Cecile's Closure


Salon.com
Comments
Again thank you and if I could rate it I would.
It took me 3 readings to understand this, not because of the writer, but because of the content. Somehow it's still unbelievable.
I wasn't going to comment, just rate, because I'm stupefied, but the rate button doesn't work.
D
I tried to rate it but couldn't.
What a heart-rending tale. At this time of remembrance, it is incredible that you have this photo to help us visualize Nathan and his grandmother.
Thank you for passing Cecile's story on, so that we may continue to always remember and honor those who died.
לא עוד
Never Again.
Never forget.
Unable to rate, will try later,
Stephanie
(I'll rate this story when possible, too.)
patie, she was amazing, and amazingly lucky. She looked fragile, but was tough as could be.
Thanks Pilgrim. This story has to be told as simply as possible. Dramatic effects are unnecessary.
holly, you are so empathic. I cry too, at what goes on.
As far as I know she is alive, Sheep. And she has written a book. I will refer to it in the second part of this tale.
Kathy, when it's one face --a face in a photo --we can understand better than an abstract number. I remember Nathan's little face.
Denese, it reminds me of Sophie's Choice. A decision too horrible to comprehend.
Nancy, beyond ratings, it needs to be remembered.
ladyfarmerjed, most important is to read it. Perhaps that's the lesson of the lost ratings.
Thanks Jim. Appreciate it.
Kyle, I wish it were inconceivable.
designanator, there were few pictures taken and few retrieved. That is why this is so amazing. Of so many millions, there is her mother and Nathan.
Smithery, the small, personal story is always the most effective way of telling something.
Mary, this tale is something profound all right, and frightening. It tells us to be careful of what can happen again, and has.
Thanks Stephanie. There is something about lighting a candle that calms and slows things down and lets us focus.
You're welcome, Bonnie.
Sophie, I understand. The photo is heart-rending.
Owl, thanks, as always, for your heart.
aim, we all should grateful. And we shouldn't let anyone take it away.
...heartwrenching...there are tears in my eyes right now...I hope that people one day will understand that "Never Again" means never again for everyone. Thank you so much for this post and much love to you.
Steve, as a history buff I know that you understand how this kind of evil has been part of the human condition.
Scupper, you are a poet.
Jill, yes it could be anyone, anytime if we aren't vigilant. I don't like the tone of what's happening in our own country right now. So now is the time to nip the Becks and Limbaughs in the butt (excuse the visual and the pun).
femme, yes that face tells the story.
Cranky, each story is worth telling.
Spud, her cleverness and bravery and coolness were astounding. She was inspired to keep her sister alive.
Kim, yes always, always remember. Genocides continue. We must try to avoid them by remembering.
Outside Myself, millions of stories remain untold.
I've been thinking about the travails of my personal situation, which I keep deeply hidden from the readers here, and then I come upon a story like this that gives me literal chills and makes me ashamed to think that I ever allow a moment's despair to affect me.
I've known many survivors, heard many stories, read more, but it never ceases to amaze me, first of all, how much we have suffered as a people and, secondly, how we always seems to rise up again afterward, which is an even greater miracle than the ones the survivors recount.
I am also profoundly impressed by how many of us, here on OS, are Jewish, are of a certain age, between their forties and their sixties, and sometimes write here under the most unlikely names, not to mention how many of us are actually established writers. Go figure.
And every time I hear vituperations against Israel, no matter how logical the premise from which the more intelligent argue, or how morally correct those arguing for the Palestinian opinion seem, I remember again how little they understand about what it really means to be Jewish in this world, or how they give aid and comfort to our enemies. This story is another tip of the iceberg.
Born in 1948, I have never known a world without the nation of Israel as an established fact of my life....but I can remember how I felt in 1956, when Israel first emerged as a military power, and how the 1960 film Exodus changed the way that others in America changed the way they looked at Jews.
Somehow, somewhere along the line, we have once again become the bad guys, the scapegoats. It doesn't help that so many of the major players in the economic disaster we're in now were themselves Jewish.
I have always appreciated your work, and I love how you pull these nuggets out of apparently thin air. Very good work.
I can't seem to rate this. I wonder why?
Which of the women in the picture is Cecile's mother? There are several older women holding children, or with hands on children's shoulders. It does not matter which one I guess. What unimaginable heartbreaking suffering.
sagemerlin, thank you for this special comment. I was alive during this time, and often think that I could have been one of these innocent babies who perished.
Sally, I think those of us who have known survivors look at this differently. It was real. It was not long ago. And genocides have continued. We need to speak for all of them.
Gail, relentless suffering. Continuing....
greenheron, she is the lady on the left, in a kerchief, holding two-year-old Nathan, who looks frightened, as any baby would be.
Appreciate it Trilogy. Not much more can be said.
Thank you for posting this. "It's better to light a single candle than sit and curse the darkness." When I go to church on Sunday, I will light a candle for Cecile and all her relatives who were not as fortunate to survive until the liberation.
V
The photo is gut-wrenching. The entire Jewish population deserves honoring for what they have endured during this sad period in history - this post does that and then some.
A prayer is going out for Cecile and all she had to endure - and for the ones like beautiful Nathan and her grandma who weren't even given a chance.
Thank you Lea - this is painfully gorgeous.
Yay! It IS fixed.
So, RATED.
Violet, thank you for that candle. This weekend I will think of the candles that came from this post.
Sparking, I know you too have suffered tragedy. I especially appreciate your commenting here. Cecile said that Dr. Mengele was cold-looking and handsome.
Bill, you're a stand-up guy. Much appreciated.
kissinglessons, I agree. But real, alas.
No matter how many survivors' stories one hears, the sense of horror never diminishes.
Well told, Lea.
Shalom, Robin. Peace to all.
Oh Donna, yes there was that bit of grace. They had a happy life together and her husband lived a fairly long life. Cecile I believe is still alive. More in another part.
GeeBee, I agree. The stories are universal in that evil doings can be anywhere and at any time. We must call them out. They are going on right now in The Congo.
Silk, I think her story is especially compelling because there were many facets. And ironies. And close calls. But each story has its own drama.
Lezlie
Sorry.
Thank you for posting this, Lea. Time indeed to light a candle for Nathan who died far too young in a terrible place.
madcelt, I write this to represent the millions of stories that were never written.
Lin, in that place and time that was the look. The babuschka.
shiral, luck and wits. You needed both to have a chance of survival.
May G-d's great name be blessed forever and ever.
Blessed, glorified, honored and extolled, adored and acclaimed be the name of the Holy One, though G-d is beyond all praises and songs of adoration which can be uttered. Let us say, Amen.
May there be peace and life for all of us and for all Israel. Let us say, Amen.
Let He who makes peace in the heavens, grant peace to all of us and to all Israel. Let us say, Amen.
bobbot, thank you for this spiritual comment.
asianshoebox, we need to do this if we are able.
I'm sorry to hear Cecile seemingly never found the Dream. Perhaps that can come later. Thank you for sharing this.
For Nathan. For Nathan's grandmother's sacrifice. For Cecile's memories. For your caring Lea, to commemorate them and all of the others with similar stories..
Mary, I hope they were tears that brought some deeper understanding of human nature.
seer, believe it or not there are people on this site who disbelieve history. They have written just that on other posts of mine.
Scarlett, light is better than heat.
Thanks, Roy.
Deb, I too have visited Auschwitz --another story. And yes, the photo is astounding.
Bellwether, yes everyone in that photo was murdered out soon after it was taken-- and millions of others, one by one. No wonder it is haunting.
Rod, thank you and so glad you are back.
Boa, with your sense of history I know this confirms the sense of survival that has always been the other side of darkness.
Caroline, there is a second part to this story. Cecile found her voice, and I will write about it.
austin, that it is.
Sunday is my daughter Eliana's birthday, too. Her grandparents are survivors. Both were hidden children. I will be writing about them and the man who saved Deborah's mother soon, and I hope I can write with the feeling and clarity that you have shown here.
“Too many Holocaust stories coming in right now.” Lea - The sad enormity of that sentence. The black irony in it.
"One of Cecile's poems describes seeing the stars through slats in the cattle car on their way east. "
"Sixteen year-old Cecile volunteered to write love poems for the Jewish leader of her block, to arouse the woman's Nazi guard lover. When the affair ended, the despondent woman cried, "Now we're doomed." "
“Too many Holocaust stories coming in right now.” Lea - The sad enormity of that sentence. The black irony in it.
The watch. Given away. And not needed anymore.
Thank you, Lea, for telling me Cecile's story.