No, Lee, tell us what you REALLY think...

Leeandra Nolting

Leeandra Nolting
Location
New Orleans, Louisiana, United States
Birthday
July 08
Title
Assistant Guru (not to be confused with Assistant to the Guru)
Bio
Proud native Hoosier who’s settled permanently in New Orleans. Teach English. Live in an old whorehouse with three very talkative and sexually-confused birds and one very talkative bird that isn’t sexually confused at all but just wants what s/he wants, which is pretty much everything and everybody. They appear quite frequently in my writing. Former bedpan wrangler, radio announcer, preschool teacher, and freshman comp. instructor. Once accidentally picked out A Clockwork Orange for a make-out movie. Have a very rational appreciation for the works of Flannery O’Connor and the television show The X-Files and an irrational fear of Meg Ryan. All my friends are drunks.

Leeandra Nolting's Links

Salon.com
MAY 28, 2011 6:08PM

Book Review: Judy Blume Goes to Mortuary School

Rate: 3 Flag

 Putting Makeup on Dead People by Jen Violi

Hyperion Book CH

ISBN 10--1423134818

ISBN 13--978-1423134818

Available May 24, 2011, at Amazon, Barnes and Noble, and independent booksellers

(The following is solely my own opinion and does not reflect that of the author or anyone else connected to the publishing or promotion of this book.  I received no compensation for this other than a standard galley copy for review.)

Donna Parisi’s father died just as she entered high school, and she’s spent the past four years in something of a fog.  She hasn’t been depressed, exactly, at least not enough to make anyone outside her immediate family think that she’s anything but an ordinary teenage girl from suburban Ohio, but she’s just been drifting her way through high school.  With no better plans or dreams for her life, she’s about to go to the University of Dayton to study Communications—a school and a major her worried mother picked for her, as she thinks it will help break her out of her funk.  Then, while attending the funeral of a classmate who dies suddenly during a basketball game, Donna realizes what she’s being called to do:  to be a mortician and help others through the grieving process. 

The entire book, save for the epilogue, takes place during Donna’s last semester of senior year and her first semester of mortuary school, and is geared at audiences between twelve and eighteen years old.  The coming-of-age aspects of Donna’s life—breaking away from her family, realizing that her parents are only human, dealing with sibling rivalry, falling in love for the first time, losing her virginity, going through her first break-up, sussing out what exactly her own religious beliefs are, deciding what she wants to do with the rest of her life, coming to terms with the deaths of her loved ones and the inevitability of her own death—would be cliché except that they are in fact nearly universal experiences, very well-rendered, and haven’t yet become cliché for the target audience.  Donna’s mother in particular is a standout character, a woman who is trying her best to reach her middle daughter but is going about it all wrong. 

Ms. Violi also does a standout job of showing a typical middle-class contemporary Catholic family and parish, remarkably free of the long-outdated stereotypes of American Catholics.  (There are no mantilla-covered grannies lighting candles and chanting in Latin, though anyone who grew up Catholic in the Midwest in the 1970s and 1980s might find themselves laughing and cringing knowingly at the hippie-dippiness of St. Camillus’ Theatre Group.)  The references Ms. Violi makes will put Donna Parisi’s story in a very specific time, place, and culture but I wouldn’t worry about it becoming dated or hard for future generations of kids to relate to—after all, Are You There, God?  It’s Me, Margaret is very specifically about a half-Jewish, half-Christian girl in the New Jersey suburbs, circa 1970, and it yet remains a favorite of pubescent girls of all backgrounds four decades later.

Where the story fails—and this is a minor failure—is in its portrayal of the people in the death care industry.  They are almost uniformly good, and helpful, and kind to Donna, and while the owners of Brighton Brothers Funeral Home are meant to be Donna’s second family (she moves into their guest room while doing her apprenticeship), they lack the nuance and depth of her biological one. 

Overall, I would give this book four-and-a-half out of five stars, and recommend it to any young adult or anyone who enjoys reading young adult fiction.  This is Ms. Violi’s debut novel, and I look forward to many more in the years to come.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
thank you for this review. I guess it isn't as deep and riveting as Six Feet Under - the television series about a funeral home family - but it opens the door a crack for kids of a certain age to at least give some thought to this subject. I have always loved Judy Blume.
A very good review! Informative and thoughtful. The book sounds like a really interesting read. Though death and virginity loss might be a bit heavy for a 12 year old...then again, I guess it depends on how it's done and what 12 year old is reading it. Thanks for this suggestion - going to find a way to procure this book here, if possible.
Alysa, it's very much on the lines of Judy Blume...far better than the silly "Gossip Girl" books the 12-year-olds are reading.
Alysa, it's very much on the lines of Judy Blume...far better than the silly "Gossip Girl" books the 12-year-olds are reading.