Parents: Please Don't Overreact to Little League Tragedy
Thirteen-year-old Hayden Walton of Winslow, Arizona approached home plate Tuesday with a swagger familiar to any seasoned Little League baseball
player. Eyes locked with those of the opposing pitcher, he adjusts his batting helmet, tugs at his twin wrist bands and scratches the home plate dirt with the toe of his left cleat. He’s about to execute a bunt, probably to draw the infield players away from their positions in order to allow his teammate(s) on base to advance unmolested.
I know this scene. Intimately. For more than 30 years I sat upon the butt-numbing benches of ball fields all over the U.S. watching similar seemingly routine baseball scenarios unfold. From Pee Wee League through the pros, every time my son stalked home plate with the intention of sending “the Pill” into the middle of next week, I held my breath. I have never understood where little children and big men alike find the courage to stand on that plate while an opponent hurls a 2 and 7/8 to 3-inch diameter rock at their heads.
This time it was Hayden’s mother who was probably sitting there breathless. And this time, our fears were justified. When Hayden turned to face the mound, sliding his right hand to the fat end of the bat for the bunt, the pitched ball slammed into his chest, just above his heart. His heart stopped after he took two steps toward first base. It stopped. And it never started again.
There are parents all over the country this morning discussing this heart-breaking turn of events. Many, mostly mothers, probably, are reaffirming their belief that hard ball is far too dangerous for kids to be playing. How can we let our sons and daughters continue taking these unnecessary risks knowing it could result in their deaths?
To all you parents of young Major League wannabes I say this: Please take a breath and think. Yes, it is our jobs to keep our kids safe and out of harm’s way. We make sure the infant seats are installed correctly before we bring our new infants home from the hospital. We child-proof the electric sockets and bolt the kitchen cabinets. We do what we need to do to protect them from their not-ready-for-prime-time selves. But it is also our jobs to raise complete and productive human beings to adulthood. Part of that job is to teach the relationship between risk and reward and how to skew our chances toward success. Facing our fears is a great part of growing up strong and effective. We parents do that every single time we allow our kids to leave our field of vision…because we have to.
My son has had more than his share of serious injuries. Every single one of them has been related to some form of competitive sport. A second-base-stealing slide into the bag caused his career-ending knee injury. Do I regret any of the thousands of games he played, standing at the plate daring a pitcher to hit him? Not one. Danger is everywhere, more often than not when we least expect it. And of the dozens of times my son has been hit by a baseball pitched by men throwing at speeds averaging around 90 mph, not once has he ever been hit in the chest. Does that mean your child won’t be? Of course not. But look at the odds and don’t let your fears for your child deprive him or her of the opportunities to learn about life from the game.


Salon.com
Comments
Kosh: Good analogies. You know, of course, some poor kid is going to be made to quit because of this accident.
JT: My heart breaks for that family. They will second-guess themselves until someone finally convinces them it is not their fault.
rated with hugs
It has always mystified me that we in the U.S. can act as if kids' lives must be free of all risk (with the way leagues dole out trophies, they are even free of the risk of not winning). Then they can join the marines on their birthday. Makes no sense to me.
Linda: I would always have to go to the rest room when my son was pitching. Line drives back to the mound were the scariest things I ever saw. But I could never have gotten away with not showing up at all. It was a rule. :D
Jon: Thanks, friend.
You are so right. This was a tragedy and a freak accident.
But anything that causes ALL of child sports to get a good going over is worth putting up with a bit of over reaction.
I used to teach child and infant CPR, and it takes very little compression to rupture tiny hearts. A baseball will do it, and so will any number of chest compressing missteps in sports and play.
After a time, things can get out of hand, people become complacent and safety gets ignored.
The main principle of safety is that, by going over the events that led up to the death, perhaps something will be discovered that can help to prevent another death or serious injury.
yes, sports have inherent risk.
there are some with far less risk than others. for example, volleyball. sports are generally good for kids, it really does build character, and believe it or not, understanding and *avoiding* injury is part of life.
if the kid was coached well, then every single batter would understand that sometimes they have to dodge a baseball, sometimes dropping backward onto their back if thats the only option.
Im sure he was wearing a helmet, right? thats the basic protection.
Our son took kung fu lessons, to build his strength and confidence and help him learn how to protect himself. I thought it was a pretty safe activity. Well, guess what. At age 16, my son had to have knee surgery because of injuries sustained during his martial arts lessons. The orthopedic surgeon said that is quite common.
The world isn't a safe place. Anyone who thinks it is, is deluding themselves.
To sound like the devil's advocate here, I cannot help but ask if you would have written this post, had you been the mother of that 13-year old. I'm not against teaching youngsters about risk-taking and sportsmanship as well as a healthy sense of competition, but I'm questioning some of the means of so doing. Even if this were a "freak" accident, or the outcome of a previously existing condition, perhaps it is time for adults top re-consider. Because the mothers, at least are putting on a brave face while they are trying to convince themselves to the same tune.
My deep condolences to the family.
♥R
Sweetfeet: Neither can I.
Vzn: As far as I know, he was wearing a helmet. I know a chest protector like the catcher wears would seriously impede the runner’s speed, but I have often wondered why there hasn’t been a protective vest of some kind hasn’t been developed.
Chicken Maaan: Thank you.
Lschmoopie: I believe team sports are extremely useful in teaching children about mutual responsibility, hard work and fair play. But it’s definitely not for everybody.
Babe: True that.
Maurene: I broke my foot irreparably just walking the dog. There is no way to be safe from harm 24/7.
Fusun: If I were the mother of that child I wouldn’t be ABLE to write any post. My point of view would certainly be highly influenced by monumental grief. To me, this is one of those topics that falls into the Venus and Mars category. Children’s fathers, in my own experience anyway, are far more willing for their sons to take risks and put themselves in dangerous situations. They believe it to be character-building. If my son is any example, his dads were right about that. They viewed my concerns as “coddling.” I don’t have any objection to revisiting the safety standards in Little League, or even postponing the use of hardballs until the children reach an older age. I just know there will be some parents who will want to pull their kids out completely and I think that can be harmful to the child as well.
Linnnn: We parents walk a very thin line, don’t we?
Trilogy: Thanks for stopping.
Nikki: If our parents knew all of the stupid risks we took as kids (at least I did. I was a bit of a tomboy) they would ground us for life!
Sirenita: I remember that film. Heck, even being born is one of the biggest risks to our lives we take. Controlling personality that I am, I do understand I cannot control everything – and neither can anyone else.
Good post. Tragic accident!! RATED!
Its crucial to be able to withstand pain, suffering and setbacks as a kid. Danger is necessary for the development of character.
We think we can can - and should - protect our children against every possible danger, but that's sheer idiocy. We'd have our children walking around in a haz-mat suit or body armor.
For any parents who may not be aware, there is a piece of protective gear (a Heart Guard) that can go under the jersey (worn around the neck) to cover the area where a rare chance blow in between heartbeats can cause the heart to stop.
Franky, I recommend it for pitchers, as they are generally the most vulnerable (balls they have just thrown are hit back at them from less than 40 feet away by the time they finish their follow through -- usually with aluminum bats where the ball travels faster than off wooden ones).
I have heard of this sort of tragedy happening before to pitchers -- never a batter.
But also keep in mind that the trip to and from their games and practices -- statistically speaking -- is much more likely to be life-threatening...
What age do they start using hard baseballs? This kid was 13, so not super small, but I know kids who start "baseball" at age 3 or 4. They don't use the hard balls then, do they?
I appreciate you point of view, and as the mom of a kid who made it to be a pro athlete, you have a unique perspective.
While this was a tragic accident, and I really feel for the family, there is something to be learned by all the kids there that day. I'm just sorry that lesson came with such a high price tag.
Opportunity knocks but once