L in the Southeast

L in the Southeast
Location
Atlanta, Georgia, United States
Birthday
November 04
Title
Retired PR Director
Bio
Born and raised in suburban Chicago to a multi-cultural family of hardworking, working class people, I was given every available tool to make me a contributing member of society -- Catholic school, Girl Scouts, lessons in several of the arts, even a debutante bow at the ball. I wasn't having any of it. Oh, I DID it all, but always with a flair that was not appreciated by those who attempted to guide me. Although I managed to have a fairly successful corporate career, it would have been so much more so, had I just followed the prescribed rules of the road to the top. Wouldn't do that either.

L in the Southeast's Links

New list
Editor’s Pick
AUGUST 29, 2011 11:01PM

When Did the Weather Become Political?

Rate: 27 Flag

 We are not so good at predicting calamities, but I am getting better and better at predicting dustups between Democrats and Republicans.

Anderson Cooper was standing in the middle of the street in Time Square when Hurricane Irene was downgraded from a category 1 hurricane to a tropical storm.  Cooper, for a fleeting and delightful moment, lost a measure of his celebrated cool.  “You mean this is the worst of it?”  He was sharing a split screen with the CNN correspondent who was assigned to deliver the status of the 400-mile-wide weather monster to the poor fools who were out standing in some part of the New York City geography, waiting, I guess, to be blown into the middle of next week.

At that moment, I chuckled.  Somebody is going to make a federal case out of the fact that everybody failed to be killed who didn’t choose to heed the mandatory evacuations, I said to no one in particular.  This was Saturday, the day Irene made her way up to the Big Apple to toy with the media. 

The next morning all the Sunday talkfests were attempting to discuss the aftermath of Irene’s traipse up the eastern seaboard.  I was writing an op-ed for a California operative, with only half an ear on the pundit drone emanating from the TV.  I looked up just in time to hear the dour George Will characterize the media’s rather breathless coverage of the pre-Irene preparations as “synthetic hysteria.”  Apparently, Mr. Will thinks the pinko liberal media types were all about manufacturing drama around what amounted to a – what? – disappointing hurricane that only killed a measly 20 people. I think I even detected signs of a little smile around the taut corners of Will’s mouth.

I know, George.  It was all Obama’s fault.  He failed to lead, so Irene lost her bearings.

I cannot for the life of me understand why anybody aspires to be a meteorologist.  I don’t even know why they are called meteorologists, since there is seldom any apparent involvement of meteors in the so-called science of predicting the future.  That’s all it really is.  Which totally explains why these poor wind-swept, slicker-wearing brave souls who risk their lives to stand in front of a raindrop speckled lens get it so wrong so often.  Of course they do.  They are predicting the behavior of the most quixotic element of the earth’s atmosphere.   

What the hell is the matter with people?  Would they feel better about all the coverage if we had five or six more New Orleans-like tragedies?  They think because the authorities decided to shut down several of the countries largest cities they are all a bunch of namby pamby wusses? 

I say we have a little more respect for the media’s efforts to save the lives of as many people as possible, even if some of those people are too cynical to appreciate it. 


Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
You're so right Lezlie. Damned if you do and damned if you don't. Thank God it wasn't worse than it was. So if more people died, some would be more satisfied???? Geez.
That or that if they exaggerate they won't be believed next time when the storm is really bad. You should probably hash this out with Alan Milner. Personally, I think that keeping people alive when we're not sure what's about to happen is intrinsically a good thing, but what do I know?
Irene was one damn smart gal...she played up her situation
with the mastery of a ...uh...savage satirist, or something along
those lines.

ha..gonna wipe out NJ,NYC, the coast of New England
with all she can muster.

I think that when she saw her prospects diminished,
due to the intervention of a benevolent God or Gaia (ha!)
she got snarky & said, well, i'll continue on best my poor old body can,
give em a show, and show em up for the weather-porn-addicts they are.

Irene, malevolent social commentator.

(ps al roker on nbc handled this very question of hype quite well
this morning, delivered by a pissed off anderson cooper...
no apologies. lives were saved.)
Maybe Irene was God's public jobs plan for the east, no way to outsource the clean up and repair. It seems unlikely they'd leave those areas a mess like after Katrina. They'll have to suck it up and fix the damage.
L:
To answer the questions who would ever want to me a meteorologist? ME ME ME ME ME! Seriously, if I had to start college all over, I would go into the natural sciences and would happily choose meteorology as a major. The earth fascinates me, storms and natural disasters thrill me (evn when i am affected by them). It used to be the prettiest girl in the TV station got the job. Now with "computer enhancement" they started hiring real meterologists who are at least able to read a weather map.

Those who politicize weather, are just looking for another excuse to bring "God" into the argument and use him to "downgrade" their opponents as we all know God is always on the "winners" side (or so they think).

R
I think Anderson Cooper was thinking at that point in time that he wished he was in Libya and I was disgusted the way CNN handled the whole thing.. Much like watching for the tsunami coming into Hawaii awhile back which it did not.
Waiting for people to be in peril is wrong.
HUGGGGGGGGGGGG
Someone should have reminded Mr. Will that New Jersey's Gov. Christie - a rock-solid Republican - was one of the loudest crying "get-out-of-town now." Public safety is not, and should not be, a partisan issue.
I have a friend there who stepped outside and said,"This is it? A few raindrops." People want peril and more lives lost. Such stupidity! -R-
Some are addicted to spectacle and get mightily disappointed when their craving, their hypo of hype, fails to deliver. I like your stilletoing of George Will. I have a strange ambivalence about him: I think he's a wonderful writer, a stunningly good writer, but I don't like his politics. It amkes reading him a challenge: enjoy the masterful language, but watch out for the perspective contained in it.
I have read several "commentaries" that had the tone of disappointment that it was not worse. I think of those folks as oh...heartless bastards..only interested in their own glory. Political? well when a Republican (and by that I mean Tea Party) candidate for president says that God sent both the earthquake and the hurricane to get President Obama's and the country's attention to change our evil ways....we are in bad shape indeed.
Emergency managers are in a tough spot. They have to take every threat seriously and think worst case scenario because there are lives on the line. The media, however, muddles things by trying to create a "story" and to do that they insert hysteria, and then when the worst case scenario doesn't happen -- because it rarely does -- the public loses faith with public officials rather than putting the blame on the news media where it belongs. We've seen it happen so many times down here on the Gulf Coast that we take all the storm warnings with a grain of salt, and I'm afraid that's going to end up hurting people in the long run.
Read my last poem...is all I'm goina' say. :D Or maybe you did all ready. Than I apologize.
I had the same thought, L, especially when I heard Ron Paul's comment about FEMA being "part of the bloated government." Perhaps after the nightmare of Katrina politicians may be hyper-sensitive to disasters in advance, but still -- any public effort that saves lives is worthwhile, and the "failure" of a disaster to live up to its billing is always good fodder for political backbiting. About the only silliness I haven't heard (yet) is "people shouldn't live in New York because its in a hurricane zone." Rated.
You're a very wise person, friend. r.
It is politicized by evangelical candidates, and that has sadly trickled down into the media. Consciously, or unconsciously, they are reflecting the same hubris of "ownership" over how things are going to happen. Sadly not realizing that the science that evacuated everyone did actually save people- because they were not there to get swept into floods and waves thinking it would all be okay- or worse- in god's hands.
The state of Vermont was expecting flooding, not on the scale they got, but they knew it was coming. Still, there is little one can do about it other than wait it out, pick up the pieces. Our short attention span theatre minds forget that knowing it's coming doesn't stop it, it just gives more people the opportunity to save their own lives. Nature is still more powerful than the federal government- and more powerful than any religion.
We are so used to the sensationalism and drama that when Mother Nature toys with us, we are disappointed. (Except the people who were in the path of expected destruction)
There is no penalty for overestimating storms, only underestimating. If nothing bad happens you can always credit exemplary preparation if you 'chicken-littled" it.
Three cheers for you, Lezlie. What the hell is wrong with people, indeed? I had the same thoughts when I was watching the news on Monday morning hearing the same lament - did the media make too much of the storm, yadda, yadda? I so completely agree with you on this.
Rated for plain old-fashioned common sense!
Obama personally caused the storm. All right-thinking Americans should condemn him both for creating the disaster and for not responding to it by abolishing FEMA. Thank goodness for Michele Bachmann and Rick Santorum and Ron Paul and other clear thinkers who know that assisting the parasites who choose to reside in potential disaster zones only encourages their dependence on the largesse of those of us with the common sense to live in safe areas like Kansas.
So glad to be without power to miss the Sunday talkshows, and Monday Night Football, and Tuesday's programming. Can't wait for the power company to show up...but they have 10 percent less staff to handle these emergencies.
I'm going to sound like a really old bag here, but technology makes it possible now for every individual with a mouth and/or typing fingers to say their blah blah. We blah blah here every day about our citizen lives. If we were media, our blah blah would be to make a great big story no matter what, and if we were politicians, we'd put a political frame around everything, even chocolate chip cookies. Personally, I see little recourse except to stop paying attention to that kind of blah blah. There's just nothing helpful or necessary about it.
Hmmm... I wonder if the folks in Vermont would agree that the storm was "wimpy"? NJ looks pretty bad to me too....
Some people see things differently as to such things as the nature of YWH:
Job 38-4"Were you there when I laid the foundations of the world?"
No of course was the answer, and YWH answered to only himself, like it or not.
So true. It's as trilogy said: Damned if you do and damned if you don't. I like your tags, by the way...~r