Lisa Romero

Lisa Romero
Location
Salfordville, Pennsylvania, USA
Birthday
December 31
Bio
Welcome to the AMEROCENTRIC ECCENTRIC - challenging the way we look at things from our American perspective, while cherishing and celebrating our unique culture. I'm an average American, on-again-off-again journalist of 20 years and astute student of humanity with too many questions, never enough answers and an unwavering, if not at times pitiable faith that people (even the most twisted specimens) are inherently good.

Editor’s Pick
OCTOBER 2, 2008 9:55AM

America's Got Talent - but do we have brains?

Rate: 3 Flag

I almost didn't tune into NBC last night to see who won America's Got Talent on its finale show.

It was so damn obvious the winner was going to be Nuttin' But Strings, the violin-playing Escobar brothers from Queens, NYC, there seemed little point in wasting an hour watching Jerry Springer announce it. (Although I must confess Jerry is a main draw for me. How can a guy I laughed off as a sensational idiot for all these years be, well, so endearing?!)

But I figured I'd already invested all this time so far.... So I did dishes and ignored the first part of the show, where the top 10 finalists sang Kelly Clarkson's American Idol theme (shameless cross-promotion from AGT's producer Simon Cowell), and the crazies from earlier in the show got in their last 15 minutes of fame with a mediocrity extravaganza.

Watched Queen Emily get the boot. Bummer, but she'll succeed somewhere, no doubt.

Watched Donald Braswell get the boot. Reminds me of a guy I dated briefly in Lansing, Mich., when I was in college. I'm pretty sure it wasn't him, but I still sort of wondered and rooted for him.

And then, right when I was sure we were about to watch young piano man Eli Mattson get the boot, Nuttin' But Stringz was gone.

What? I just looked at my husband in disbelief, and we both watched as the team was honored and then kicked off stage.

Look, America. NBS was the only act that actually created something never seen before - a fusion of hip hop and classical music that was utterly spellbinding. And my 40-year-old, easy-listening self more or less HATES hip hop, so that's saying something. See a clip of their early work on the show here: NBS on YouTube. It only got better from that point on, trust me. They played their own compositions. They incorporated dancers and Vegas-type background animations. Great stuff!

I'm still shaking my head. Right. Now.

Who knows the reasons why NBS didn't make it? Maybe it was the show's demographics. Maybe people really love opera or hard-luck stories that much. Maybe fans just wanted to vote for the top two finalists based on the fact they wore hats.

And don't get me wrong. I'm happy for Neal E. Boyd, the opera singer going to Vegas. Nice guy. Cries a little too much. (Almost keeled over when Jerry called him a "cry baby" and suggested he pull it together for the final performance. Ouch.)

I'm happy for all of them. Proves anything is possible in the United States.

But for sheer talent, I stand firm on my view.

Nuttin' But Stringz was the only finalist worthy of a Vegas show. If you have to fly that far to see something amazing, that's the only one that, for me, came close to defining the word.

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
If someone's trying to convince me that America does indeed "have talent," then this show is NOT the way to go about it!
This was not great stuff. It was insipidness designed to appeal to 40 year old easy listeners who more or less HATE hip hop. There's nothing intrinsically wrong with that, but it's NOT a sign that America lacks brains. Noe if John McCain wins...then you'll have a story! :)
I didn't watch it through. I love some of the weird acts, and watched a lot of the prelims. But when that ventriloquist beat the incredible pop vocal stylist in last year's finale, it should have told us something about the show's demographic.