Lisa Solod

Lisa Solod
Location
Savannah, Georgia, USA
Birthday
January 03
Bio
Writer, Mother, Mother, Writer Visit me at www.lisasolod.com

Lisa Solod's Links

New list
MARCH 5, 2009 6:28PM

A Mind is a Terrible Thing to Waste

Rate: 13 Flag

Now that we have officially elected an elitist as president, I can finally come out of the closet. Although close friends and family have known for years that I am an elitist, I guess it is time to announce myself publicly. It seems that people are enjoying casting stones at both the president and others who value education, the arts, and other elitist values -- such as speaking in full grammatically correct sentences, reading books and talking about them, and other such unnecessary activities, so I thought perhaps I might come out in support of such frivolous wastes of time.

I know that these are hard and difficult times and that looking for jobs and finding jobs and saving money is all that people seem to have time for any more. In fact, I read today in an article in the New York Times that people don't even have time to read a newspaper any more they are so busy. On The Daily Show the other night, apparently people are so busy tweeting and twittering that they don't even have time to listen to the president talk about how bad everything is and how it might even get good again some day.

Which is why, of course, moviegoing is way up and reality television shows are stronger than ever, and television viewing in general hasn't gone down, and no one has noticed any reduction in the time people spend on Facebook or Internet surfing and I would sure like to see the statistics for the number of visits to porn sites: have they gone down since people are out of work? I mean, everyone has time to do all that and tweet, but no one has time to read a paper or a book or go to a museum or figure out how to keep arts in our schools. That we don't have time for because that kind of stuff is elitist and unimportant. Right?

But, hey, I'm just postulating here.

So the main thing is that we all have to figure out ways to get jobs and make money and anything that doesn't have anything directly to do with that is a total waste of time. So says a recent http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/25/books/25human.html?_r=1&pagewanted=1&th&emc=th article in the same (elitist and apparently unread by the masses) New York Times which basically says that a traditional liberal arts education is in trouble (again and forever, it seems) because it can't easily be translated into a job that one can get paid money for.

Although some in the article are apparently trying to figure out ways to "market" a liberal arts education, because, hey, it's really all about marketing, right. Not value. Even though the market-driven economy has proven to be a big bust.

There are some holdouts, thank God, like Derek Bok, the former president of Harvard, one of those liberal elite education institutions that routinely gets shat on (no, I didn't go there; I went to another elite college that really gets shat on) who says, wisely: "There's a lot more to a liberal education than improving the economy. I think that is one of the worst mistakes that policy makers often make -- not being able to see beyond that."

The article further quotes Andrew Delbanco, director of American studies at Columbia (one of the universities, you may remember, from which Barack Obama graduated) as saying that "(Obama) makes people feel there is some kind of a common enterprise, that history, with its tragedies and travesties, belongs to all of us, that we have something in common as Americans." This is, Delbanco, reminds us, a president who reads and invokes Shakespeare, Faulkner, Lincoln, and W.E.B. Du Boise, men, whom the more educated among us may indeed have heard us, but few have actually read, and names, other than Lincoln and Shakespeare, which would not ring a bell on many a city street.

But mostly the holdouts are outnumbered.

And even though the actual numbers of those humanities majors has remained stable for about a decade at eight percent, according to the article, the "humanities share of college degrees is less than half of what it was during the hey-day" of the mid to late 60s."

But so what? Right?

Who needs 'em?

Who needs to read books by old dead people? Who needs to look at art by old dead people? Who needs to listen to music by old dead people? And who the hell needs to have his or her mind challenged by stuff that is hard or difficult to understand at first glance? I mean, really! Don't you go to college just to get a job in the first place? Isn't it a place to lay your money down and get some, well, marketable skills so that you can go out into the marketplace and find gainful employment and work the rest of your life at some job and make some bucks?

But a university education was never meant to prepare men and women for the job market. It was mean first for only the privileged class, of course, and then with the wonderful GI Bill after World War II, for our fighting men and women to be able to go to college and better themselves. Better themselves. When my father graduated after serving in the Navy, he was not prepared to be the businessman he became; but he was an educated man in a way he would not have been had he stayed in the abject poverty in which he was raised. He had been exposed to art and science and literature and history; he had been taught and those lessons made him a man of the world who could do anything. A good liberal arts education serves not as a stepping stone to a job in a bank or driving a truck or working in a business or even becoming a doctor; it serves to help one think critically, read with great pleasure and a keen eye, observe the world with something other than the prejudices and callowness of youth. A liberal arts education makes one wish to continue that, it makes museums and books and photographs and music and paintings that challenge not a difficulty but a bridge to climb with delight at the journey. Because one knows that one can accomplish it.

Who needs literature?

I don't know who else does. But I do. And not because I am a writer, but because I am also a reader and a thinker and because I believe that a mind, one of our most wonderful of God's gifts, is a terrible thing to take for granted. Roger Cohen, one of the Times' best writers, says it beautifully in a recent essay on reading and connecting and wondering: "Perhaps the Age of Excess had to end before we could all turn inward just enough to rediscover the gold standard of the perfectly formed phrase and make connections again."

We need to read so we can think about things other than ourselves and our problems. All of us right now are suffering. But so have people in the past. And so will people in the future. An education in the humanities shows us that; it puts it all in perspective. If it is true that larger universities "routinely turn away students who want to sign up for courses in the humanities" what does that say about us? Isn't that just as horrible a sign as the fact that so many students can no longer afford to go to college at all?

If being an elitist means that I still and will always care about nurturing my mind and the minds of others along with my body and that no matter what job I have or do not have I will make the time to read and think and wonder-- that an inner life will live with any outer life I make, then I will wear that banner proudly. Too much is made of our society's preoccupation with its busy busy busyness, but stop and think: how much time do we waste: On hours of terrible television, on endless useless activities that get us nowhere, on being bored and angry and tired, on surfing the net for nothing, on feeding our various addictions, on buying self help books to aid those addictions: you name it. I think we have more time than we think. I think we have more head space than we realize. I think we can do more with our minds than we ever dreamed possible. And I believe that we need to open up those minds to things that scare us or we think are too difficult to deal with or that we never imagined we might like. That's what education does for us. And that's what an education in the humanities is meant for. Get rid of that and we risk getting rid of our very humanity itself.

 

(This piece appeared in the March 5 Huffington Post)

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I warn you I am leaving the country for a week so I won't be able to respond to comments very quickly!
Thanks for sharing your Huffington piece Lisa. We get worn down by the drudgery of day to day existence. Elitist? Conjures bad images right...your point. I certainly would not disagree with people using their minds for the sake of pure pleasure, for appreciation of art and literature. Nice reminder here to do just that.
At the same time, I would not encourage my son who is 15 to major in humanities at college if he is so lucky to get to go. His prospects for higher education aren't that great to begin with. I will, once again if it is even possible for him to attend, encourage him to major in something that pays. Free time afforded by a good salary and lack of stress due to poverty is the best way to free time and free your mind. So that you may be able to better appreciate the finer loftier things...ideas, art, etc.
I think I love you, Lisa. I love that you are an elitist. I don't get to associate with many elitists in my real life. I don't think you can spend enough money on education or the liberal arts. I don't know what the military budget is, but I think if we spent a little less on killing people we don't know in foreign lands that most Americans will never see, The world would be a far, far better place for all of us.
Ah, Trig. NOTHING pays.... in terms of "education" per se. What can you major in in college that pays? I majored in English (well, semiotics, really) and got a job as a journalist. If you major in history, how does that pay? Biology? How does that pay? I personally don't think a kid should go to college to major in Banking or Accounting. That kind of stuff should be taught in a trade school. One does not need four years of university to be a banker or an accountant. Most trades need a trade school. University is for an education, THEN learn a skill. Or learn a skill and then take courses for an education. See where I am going with this? If you major in economics, you still have to go to graduate school to "become" an economist. If you major in biology, you still have to go to med school or graduate school to "become" a biologist or doctor or researcher. My feeling is even if you are a truck driver but have a good education in the humanities, well, your truck driving days are a whole hell of a lot more interesting.....think about it.

Michael, you are just infatuated. True love takes at least six months:) But yeah..... I agree with you re the other stuff.
I forgot to wish you a safe and prosperous trip! Have a safe and prosperous trip!
Great post. I am elitist by the standards you mention, and damn proud of it too. I HATE that people have tried to make me feel less than simply because I value things other than money and status. Fuck 'em all!
Thanks, Emma...... yes, it's okay to be that kind of elitist, isn't it. Which is why I came out of the closet.

Thanks, Michael, I hope the trip will be very safe. It will not be prosperous except in terms of my mind:) but it will be fun to see old friends and my old city.... we leave in the late a.m.
I'm afraid already that I'm probably going to run into you some day in a cemetery in France.
Engineering for one Lisa...an art in itself
Lisa, with me you're preaching to the choir. Of course, I'm one of those people who thinks education is for the sake of being educated. I see what's wrong with our country in that we don't feel the need to learn history, geography, political science and so forth. Education lasts a life time yet we change careers often repeatedly.

Have a safe and wonderful post.
Great post! I too am an unreconstructed elitist! I use big words like disingenuous and rebarbative and fungible and diaphrastic (I just made that one up). When I sold encyclopedias we gave people a little piggy bank, to illustrate the fact that it cost just ten cents a day (for several centuries -- shhhh) to own this crap set of reference books. Anyway, there was a famous quote on the box, from Benjamin Franklin: "An investment in knowledge pays the best interest". We had to say ... "Do you know who said that, Ma'm?" And because the diabolical salespeople who wrote our little script KNEW that nobody would ever know, they used the perfectly calibrated moment of discomfort to seal the bond between salesman and stooge. The final answer, after an artful and uneasy pause: "Joe Pal, the president of our company." Much relieved laughter all around. Ugh. It's enough to turn a regular fellow into an elitist.
Good point about 'not having time to read' , too-- I always hear that from people who manage to carve out a few hours for their x-box and their TV shows.
And as far as the ' negotiable' arts degree -- when I say I just got my MFA, it's always ... what new job do you get from that? Just becoming a better writer and learning how to think isn't enough, I guess.
It's sad.
Keep up the fight, fellow elitist.
This: "I think we have more head space than we realize. I think we can do more with our minds than we ever dreamed possible."
This is a frightening prospect to too many people, Lisa. As such, it is easier to call the people that realize this "elitists". God bless each and every one - we need more.
Well done. Travel safely and eat well! Rated.
Hey Trig: No reason one can't be an engineer and also be a great reader, too! I have met some wonderfully interesting engineers in my life--there is room for both. I just don't want the humanities to disapper. Not EVERYONE can be an engineer (and not everyone wants to nor should be:))
Thanks to everyone else who responded and gets it. We need to use ALL of our minds.
And Ben.... let'se meet at Jim Morrison's grave at the Pere lachaise!
Yes! Since when did education come to equal elitism? Oh, right... During the last 8 years when ignorance and illiteracy were trendy. We can all see how THAT worked out!

Thanks for another winner, Lisa.
Thanks, Lisa. Yes, education, bad. Ignorance, good.
As the proud owner of 2 "useless" liberal arts degrees, I enjoyed this rant. I do feel my BA helped me to get promoted into professional jobs. I became a tech writer for a large bank and later a manager and then went into HR. I wouldn't have gotten that chance without my little ole BA in English.

With communication skills (especially written ones) declining in general, there will always be a need for people who can write well and think clearly. And the critical thinking skills that I gained are what I most value from my education. And we certainly could use more of them in our populace, judging by what happens politically here.

What I'd like to see is more of an European model of education (even though that's going to get those hysterical "we're descending into European socialism" folks all riled up) in which much of what we learn in undergraduate college years is taught in high school. Give those kids the equivalent of at least a couple years of liberal arts education, not to mention those general education requirements and then when they get to college let them specialize more if they wish. I've heard more than one European express shock at the "remedial" work that is done in our colleges, and they're not just talking Bonehead English - they're talking classes in Shakespeare and European history and the like. Whereas their undergraduate programs are closer to our grad programs. In their eyes, Americans don't start to really be "educated" until at least the Master's degree level. And increasingly that seems to be the view of Americans, too -- today's job market often demands grad degrees where undergrad degrees used to be sufficient.

Upgrade the mandatory education system and then refine the college experience, I say.
This is an excellent discussion of the same topics you're dealing with, Lisa:

http://open.salon.com/blog/dmtbrown/2009/02/26/science_entertainment_art
I stay at the Hotel de Bain on the Rue De-Lambre, just in back of the cemetary. Usually room five. Morrison's grave is too American for me. When in Paris...
Read in on the HuffPo. Glad to read it again. Go Elitists! We needs a world where it isn't elite to be an elitist. Where everybody reads, and looks at paintings and understands history. And that seems to be exactly what the First Elitist wants. I have my (manicured) fingers crossed ...