Editor’s Pick
SEPTEMBER 9, 2009 1:58PM

I Was That Little Girl Under the Table

Rate: 30 Flag

 

 

 

        It’s not often that television shows speak to my life.  Mostly they provide entertainment, escape, and, if I choose wisely, elegant writing and some humor and pathos.  Thirtysomething is the last show I recall that hit me where I live:  I was the same age as the characters, having children and struggling with issues of motherhood versus work.  But now I find myself strangely drawn to Mad Men, a fantasy of a show that somehow seems to strike me right in the heart.

            A recent episode where Sally Draper hears about her beloved grandfather’s death and, uncomforted by her cool and aloof mother, runs and sobs under the table, almost made me weep.  I could immediately recall my own grandfather who died when I was ten years old.  I had been staying alone with him and my grandmother the night before he got sick.  It was a wondrous visit:  he took me out to his boat and we sat and talked about how he would teach me to fish.  The next morning, Papa lay in the beautiful carved bed (that my daughter sleeps in even now) and I knew he must be very sick.  I crawled up into bed and lay with him until the ambulance came and took him away.  I never saw him again; he had another heart attack in the hospital and died that day.  My mother, wrapped up in her own grief, didn’t even think of the impact on me.  And both of my parents decided that attending the funeral would be too “traumatic” for either me or my two younger sisters.

            This was not an incident of my parents protecting me.  It was just another in a long line of evidence that my sisters and I were, mostly, too much trouble to deal with in any significant way.

 

            I was seven years old in 1963, a year younger than Sally Draper is in Mad Men. I recall that year quite clearly, as my friends and I were playing on the playground at school when we were all rushed inside and told our president had been shot.  But I remember a lot more about that year and the years since.  Although we did not live in Manhattan, my father worked long hours and was often inaccessible when he came home.  My mother was glamorous and unhappy.  She smoked a lot and drank a lot and dismissed my sisters and me most of the time.  Before my father came home we were fed and put to bed (so as not to “disturb” him).  When we were older we would watch them sit and have cocktails on the couch:  my mother freshly bathed and in a pretty dress.  Although I wasn’t sent to a closet for bad behavior, I was sent to my room and for inordinate amounts of time.  The rest of the time we kids played outside for hours unsupervised while my father worked more and my mother drank more and grew more unstable.

            The truth was that my parents probably shouldn’t have had children:  like Betty and Don Draper, they did it because it was expected, although I will admit that both Don and my father share a certain romanticism about love, marriage, and babies:  before those events actually happened, of course.  And if it can be believed, Don Draper is far better father than mine ever was to me.  For all Don’s philandering, at least he has a soul in need of searching and it is clear he loves his babies and takes joy in them.  I was mostly the object of both my parent’s indifference and derision, depending on the day, the week, the event.  Now that my mother has been diagnosed with Alzheimer’s she presents a stunningly different picture:  she is kind and generous and tells my sisters and me that she loves us.  But her memory is decaying exponentially and even those precious few great moments do not completely make up for a lost childhood.

  

            My father is another story.  For reasons not completely known to either me or my sisters, he doesn’t like me.  Never has. He might deny it but mostly he wouldn’t even want to discuss it.  I know, I’ve tried.  He has said I remind him of my mother but then he DID marry her and stay with her for 25 years.  They also had a pretty easy separation for 15 years in which they continued to see each other and travel together.

            What I think he means by saying I am like my mother is that I am serious, deep, and honest. Those qualities confound him. What I am not is bipolar. I am neither a drunk nor an hysteric.  Nor am I a neglectful mother. I am also not entirely self-absorbed.  Those traits I do not share with my mother. Who I am is a whoman who lives a life of intention and integrity, who is often kind to a fault, who is loving but honest, decent and truthful and full of love; a woman who is serious but forgiving.  A woman many people wish to be around.

            But he will never discover this because he doesn't want to.

             He knows none of that, of course, because he has never bothered to find out anything about me.  He never asks questions or has an ounce of curiosity about my life.  When I try to talk to him about anything at all, he shuts down Or he turns vicious and insulting as he was last summer and as he was this past weekend when I took my daughter down to see him.

            In some profound way, he has frozen me somewhere in time and I can’t get out.  He knows nothing about me, doesn’t get me, and doesn’t want to. He doesn’t know me and he doesn’t get me and he doesn't care to.  And all that doesn’t bother him. I can’t imagine having that kind of relationship with my own children and I am grateful I do not. But make no mistake of it:  it is the parents' duty to do the heavy lifting.

             In the past I tried to challenge my father to talk about something other than the weather and what’s on television. I gave that up.  What I do now is just try and be as nice and helpful as possible and to get along for the two or three days of a visit.  In the past I have taken care of him for weeks at my house. I have called and visited regularly.  I have made every effort to have my children know and care for him.  But none of that matters.  The older and sicker he gets, the more unhappy and mean.  Rather than cherish what he has:  three grown and successful and happy daughters, loving and interesting grandchildren, and a second wife who nurses and puts up with him, he would rather stew in his own angry juices.

 

            For years, the lack of my parents’ loving kindness made me risk adverse, afraid to open up, to love and be loved.  For too many years I thought I was not worthy or love. That was the lesson I had learned at their table.  But over time, I grew healthier, and though I still struggle with my past, mostly I get around it and go on.

Yet even though I can tell myself I have no expectations,  every time I see my father some tiny part of me thinks:  this time it might be different.  Maybe he will finally talk to me, maybe he will finally say he is sorry, maybe he will recognize and be thankful for all he has.  Maybe he will be grateful to be alive instead of furious.  But his anger is not just at being alive.  It has always been there.  I know that and still I hope.  I don my bulletproof vest and walk into his war with me. But the barbs and bullets always find their mark.

Our parents can wound us in ways that leave such an opening it never heals quite completely, no matter how hard we try to close it up with the salve of the love of ourselves and others.

 

            My previous visit had been to his hospital bed.  Told he might well be dying, my middle sister and I drove down and stayed for four days.  We sat in his tiny room and tried to keep him company.   It was a draining experience, emotionally and physically, but in a miracle of sorts, by the time we left he had sort of rallied.  Two weeks later he was home.

            I decided that I should take my daughter and see him over the long weekend now that he was his back to a semblance of his old self and not in the hospital. As he could deteriorate at any time, it seemed imperative. I did it for my daughter and for my father.  And I did it because I wanted to have an image of him not lying wan and weak in a hospital bed.

              Yet thought it had been clear that he scarcely seemed to notice my sister and me on our last visit  and what I found this time should have come as no surprise, my father didn’t seem to care that we had come this weekend, either, after the first few moments.  And what I hadn’t accounted for was my daughter, who is now able to understand things as an adult, see him be so ugly to me, her mother.  Her mother whom she loves.           .

            Still I struggled to maintain conversation, and this time, with my daughter in tow, I danced the old dance:  keep the man entertained.  We told stories, had conversations around him,  asked him questions, tried to make him laugh.   He scowled, he watched television, he contributed nothing.  Then, in his only contribution, he began to insult me and ask absurd and intrusive questions to which I seemed to have no right answer.. On our last night together, all hell broke loose and I told him I was tired of him treating me as he did.  He responded with another low-lidded angry look and then......nothing. And even though I had, as always donned my bulletproof armorn before the visit,  somehow his barbs pierced my heart anyway.

            I don’t know if I can continue to put myself through this. There are times I still feel a lot like that little girl, crying all alone under the table.

 

*****************

  

            I watched  the shows where Betty Draper’s father treated he like a princess and wondered why she couldn’t make that happen for her children.  My papa treated my mother the same way: she was deeply loved but could not pass it on to us, her children.  I watch now as Don Draper struggles to overcome his very humble background and be happy with his success.  My father grew up poor and was also a self-made man but he gave even less to us emotionally than Don does.  I see Sally and Bobby stealing and lying and smoking and remember my sisters and I doing those things, too.  I see those two television kids spinning around like tops to please mommy and daddy. I did that dance, too:  anything to get their attention.  And I want to tell those fictional kids:  stop. Stop. Nothing will help. 

            I want to tell those kids, even as I repeat it to myself:  Home is not necessarily where the heart is.  Until, that is, you get out and make a place for heart and others, on your own.

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I hear you. Well written, heart touching post. I had different but similar experience when my grandfather died. I learned years later that adult children have a difficult time dealing with their own grief, and never even consider that young children have the intellect and emotional need to grieve also. Rated.
I suspect that I may be the only member of this community that hasn't seen even one episode of this series. But this doesn't diminish in the slightest the impact of this piece upon me.
This was heartrendingly brilliant.

And I feel a little guilty for squeezing so much enjoyment out of this tragic story.

Absorbed, loved and rated.
So very sad and frustrating, Lisa. But our parents' lacking makes great fodder for writing; at least we can take comfort in that. Well done.
Lisa, my story is somewhat different, but I share that feeling with you about being ignored in the face of major loss and death. When my mother died, I was 10. I wrote about it here: http://open.salon.com/blog/yekdeli/2009/08/25/the_shape_of_a_sigh Like you, I related to Sally in the last episode of Mad Men. The feeling of being a fly on the wall in the face of adult grief.

The grown-ups were heard to say, in my hearing range, "It was the kids that killed her...they were just too much for her. She was overwhelmed." She had 6 children. This statement was made several times during the immediate aftermath of her death. It was devastating, and had an odd subconscious affect on me for years in how I felt about motherhood in general. I WAS allowed to go to both the Rosary and Funeral of my mom, and we were actually given the choice, except for the littlest. It was held on my little sister's 8th birthday. She chose not to go. Can you imagine your mom's funeral being on your birthday at 8? Wow...

The rest of your piece is heart breaking. It is really sad how many people had children in the '60's and earlier...that really should not have...or who didn't bother to learn how to parent. I feel for you.
Thanks, guys. But I don't want a pity party here:) I am just glad you get it. That show really is about so many of our lives....luckily most of us get over it, and like Lea wisely said, use it as fodder for our work. I mean, GOSH, if we had happy childhoods what the hell could we write about? (Just kidding)
I too am that girl under the table, or between him and my sister, or twirling for attention. You say you want to tell those kids to stop because nothing will help...I agree. I wonder if we can get ourselves to stop though...that would be a miracle.
I do not intend to do this dance for the rest of his, or my, life. I plan to take my control and sanity back. I plan to feel good about myself regardless of him. I plan.
Sometimes I'm convinced that no word exists to describe the emotion I feel when I think about him and the past. Disappointed, angry sadness is the best I can come up with.
It is the parents' job to do the heavy lifting. And if he/they can't bear the load I'm not going to assign myself the misery of carrying it for him. I have my own life now...I have my own loads to carry.
Thank you for writing this. I take a certain comfort in what you've shared.
Have we led parallel lives? I have lived, and still live, much of this. I wonder at what point we just throw our hands in the air, admit defeat, and move on?

This was beautifully and eloquently written, Lisa. The way you've woven your own experiences amid those from a pop culture hit show is genius. Who can not feel this piece?

When thinking of my own family, I like to remember something Wayne Dyer once said: Friends are God's apology for giving us family. I hope your friends can be a source of support when your family cannot. XOXO
Angus MccFlop, I've never seen Mad Men either but if Lisa's heartfelt post is any indication, it stirs up strong feelings in people. And I agree -- happy childhoods are anathema to artists!
powerful post, Lisa! There is much of what you write that resonates with my own life, as well, which is why this show speaks to me so powerfully, too (and I think why it does to so many viewers of our generation - it's so real to us).

Reading this piece, I viscerally feel for that little girl under the table -- you and me and Sally and all of us who did time there.
Thanks all! And thanks, Lisa, for that wonderful Dyer quote. I am blessed to have two awesome sisters, a aunt who is a real mother to me, fantastic kids, and superb friends, including all those on OS whom I also admire. In that, I am supremely lucky, and I do count my blessings every day. This past weekend was just such a downer..... but I shall survive:)
I have great faith that your parents were meant to have you...maybe your Dad wasn't very good at being a parent...but you are very good at being you. xox
I've never watched the show,

"Yet even though I can tell myself I have no expectations, every time I see my father some tiny part of me thinks: this time it might be different."

but I get this statement perfectly.
Well said Lisa. You watch the show (as do I), feel it, put your talent to work to create this---and then somebody somewhere you might not ever even know--reads it: and they are not alone.
You deserved much better and I am sorry you were not valued. I hope that you feel valued now.

Watching Mad Men is rough for me too not because I see myself as the children but as Betty/Helen/Peggy during phases of my life and it is rarely the infrequent happy scenes that make me feel that way. That means those female writers on Mad Men are doing an excellent job. I do see the Draper children and the Drapers as a couple as being similar to my ex- and his family. He had a sister the same age as Sally and I don't know if she could get through an episode because the father/mother dynamic those kids deal with is eerily similar.

Rated and appreciated.
This was a difficult post to read because of its sadness. I just can't understand parents who do not truly love, appreciate or enjoy their children. My kids are at the center of my life. That's probably not the best either, but at least they know they are truly loved and appreciated. Thank you for sharing this post. It must have been difficult to write and yet, hopefully, somewhat theraputic.
It is so frustrating to be an adult & recognize that your parents didn't love you in the way that parents are supposed to love their kids, in the way that you love YOUR kids. We keep giving it a shot, but a withering glance, a sharp retort, & we are back being those unloved children (as you so aptly write) "crying all alone under the table." It had to be especially painful losing the loving male figure of your grandfather. I remember as a child that we were also not allowed at funerals & were sort of distractedly told: Grandpa's-dead-go-outside-and-play. I was 35 years old before I ever went to a funeral & was so freaked about it I had to sit with the little kids & hear the kindly funeral director talk about butterflies dying & heaven.

this post is really heartbreaking -- that sense of "what COULD have been" if only your father had opened his heart. I like that it ends with a dose of wisdom.
While I love the coments and so appreciate them, I am sorry that so many of us have lived lives like mine.
This single line alone ties us together more than anything:

"But he will never discover this because he doesn't want to."

You know this echoes in my heart and reverberates right back to you. Big, big hugs.... xoxo
I find myself drawn to "Family Guy." Don't ask.
I have not seen one episode either, but I will do it because of the parallels everyone who does write about. I feel the tinge of recognition too.

How we deal with death with children is an important emotional building block. (((HUGS)))
I loved your post in every way. I loved the sad but powerful picture of the little girl crying under the table. The truth is that the lack we all experienced from our parents due to their own humanity and pain seems to be the thing that helps us to be compassionate and loving adults, if we stay open. That can be the tricky part. You have navigated it well.
Great piece Lisa. I too loved thirtysomething, even in my twenties. I went to college for a brief while with Tim Busfield when he was teaching drama and I was in undergraduate at my alma mater. We used to play basketball together. That show was a gem.

I too love Mad Men.

It's spooky sometimes how we connect early life events with a TV show or more likely, a film. Even though I never lost a brother, and never tried to kill myself, when I saw "Ordinary People", I could so relate to Timothy Hutton's character and his frustration with life. For me I always felt more mature than the other males I went to school with and played sports.

Thanks for sharing.
Rated
Thanks again to you kind readers and posters:)
Lisa, this was tough to read. My heart hurts over your father's utter detachment from you. It is unthinkable to me. My father was my rock. My friend. I was so lucky, as I see it. It wasn't even that way for all my sibs. I am so sorry he was incapable of being a loving, supportive father. His loss more than yours. You grew from this and made your own way, fashioned by your own, strong heart. Ultimately, we do make our own joy. We make our own bed. Thanks for this bittersweet sharing.
Wish it hadn't been so.
Moving, powerful, true. The parents of that generation were so clueless about and neglectful of their children, it's astonishing we all made it out alive. Nice work, Miss Lisa. KO
I've never seen Madmen, but when you say there are some people, your parents among them, who should probably never have had children, I recognize the truth in it. I'm sorry for what that meant for you, but if it helps any at all, you seem to have turned out well despite their dysfunctionality; you've transcended them.
Great post. Half of my family was crazy, so I know what you mean about making your own.
whew.

Unfortunately, people didn't have kids then because they were 'supposed to'

They didn't have much opportunity for sex prior to marriage and they were lousy at birth control.

That is the sad, sad truth.