FEBRUARY 17, 2010 12:21PM

I Am Giving Up Hope for Lent

Rate: 33 Flag

 

 

 

 

 

                In the Christian tradition, Lent is a period of forty days, beginning today, Ash Wednesday, when the observant go into a period of denial, penance, and prayer, and, more commonly give up something important to them until Easter.  While, as a Jew, I do not subscribe to the risen Christ—and can’t really reconcile giving over the suffering of someone else’s punishment as reparation for my own sins-- it’s more than clear that the Catholic church in specific, with its direct lineage from Judaism, understands guilt and denial almost as well as we do. So, in the spirit of ecumenical understanding, I hereby deny myself indulgence, for the next six weeks, in the most important thing in my life: Hope.

 

I give up Hope that Dick Cheney will ever stop lying, no matter how much video and audio there is that completely discounts whatever he says at any given moment.  I also give up the Hope that the national media will stop giving him a soapbox on which to pontificate.

I give up Hope that a decent national health care reform proposal will even be discussed seriously, never mind that anything that denies the power of the insurance companies and big pharma will pass.

I give up Hope that the American public will actually educate themselves as to the issues facing our country today.  I give up Hope that they will read a newspaper or two and do some of their own research, rather than just accept the inane meanderings of the mainstream electronic media.

I give up Hope that Rachel Maddow will receive a Pulitzer Prize for just being the smartest, bravest journalist in the United States.

I give up Hope that Birch Bayh will shut up.

I give up Hope that the Republicans will suddenly realize how idiotic it is just to say “No,” and will actually consider thinking about things before they don’t vote for anything.

I give up Hope that the American public will put the universal good before their own selfish needs.

I give up Hope that the recession has done anything to change the national mindset about carbon emissions, big business, the banking cartels, the lobbyists, taxes, or anything else that adversely affects our country.

I give up Hope that corporations, national and internal, will take responsibility for the harm they do.

I give up Hope that the Corporate Destructive Officers will suddenly see the light and work for the better of their companies, rather than taking the money and running.

I give up Hope that people who comment on articles on the internet will actually stop and think before posting snark and cruelty.

I give up Hope that the supporters of Fat Awareness will realize how silly their cause is and pause to consider that in this nation of obesity 47 million Americans are starving.

I give up Hope that fanatics will no longer feel the need to push their agenda on everyone who does not believe as they do.

I give up Hope that the future generations has any idea how dangerous plagiarism is and that all one has to do in a given piece of writing or literature is acknowledge both source and influence.

I give up the Hope that the American public will suddenly become readers of great glossy magazines as opposed to internet sound bites that pass for “magazines.”

I give up the Hope that reality television in the main will die a quick and painful death.

I give up the Hope that people will actually choose substance over style.

I give up the Hope that American Idol will no longer be the most important venue for an aspiring singing star.

I give up the Hope that people across the world will finally and unequivocally realize that war sucks and gets us nowhere.

I give up the Hope that we won’t have to personally donate to every disaster out of our pockets in order to save lives.

I give up the Hope that parents who seem to mean well will actually raise their children to be decent, well-mannered, and thoughtful human beings, rather than pals who “like” them.

I give up the Hope that girl children will no longer be paraded in pageants like mini-whores.

I give up on the Hope that Americans will stop ignorantly disrespecting other countries’ health plans, culture, lifestyles and the rest, as distinctly inferior to our own.

I give up Hope that patriotism will get its good name back.

I give up the Hope that the huge discrepancy between the rich and the poor in this country will disappear and also the Hope that people will idolize capitalism as a false prophet.

I give up Hope that chicklit, and vampire novels, and self-help books will disappear, en masse, from bookstores.

I give up the Hope that fame is the ultimate goal in life.

 

On a  more personal note:  I give up Hope that  fathers who actually take a day-to-day interest in their  kids’ lives, and husbands who stay home with the kids will  no longer be the subject of “trend” newspaper and magazine articles, but become, instead, part of the norm.

… the Hope that men and women will stop circling each other like wrestlers and actually really get along, the Hope that Spring will come before Summer, and that the six feet of snow piled outside my door will actually melt; the Hope that losing ten pounds won’t seem insurmountable, that we don’t have to all have Botox and plastic surgery to compete in the market, the Hope that good conversation hasn’t really died a hopeless death, the Hope that  people will be nicer rather than meaner, that examining one’s life will not be seen as a throwback and a weakness but as an important element to becoming a whole, functioning human being.    I give up the eternal Hope that most people won’t see life as drudgery but as journey, no matter how many bad things happen to them.  And lastly, I give up Hope that people will no longer wallow in their victimhood but will grow courage and strength from their adversity.

This list of Hopes is a lot harder to give up than, say, eating chocolate or red meat, but my feeling is that if one is going to make the effort to give up something for Lent, it should be a biggee.  So, in the next six weeks, every time I find myself Hoping that people will come to their senses and that the world really is on the road to better understanding and awareness; when I find myself Hoping that education will triumph over ignorance, I’m going to stop myself. Quickly.  And go and find a chocolate bar as my penance.

 

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
but pandora had hope, even with all the evils released.
Yeh. Well I am only giving it up for 40 days:)
I hope that we don't have to give up. That humanity at large, and people in particular will become rational and kind and think beyond greed and self-serving deeds. And I hope that your passion is contagious.
Better passion as a contagion than despair, right, Lea?
I'm grateful that you will be free to hope again in 40 days. Hope is essential to mental health and to any conditions that require change.
Very well said. I hope at the end of Lent, you'll embrace what you gave up - with a passion. I don't know if I have the same will power as you do. :o)
Rated
And thanks for the post. It makes me feel better about giving in to hope again and again.
Love this...... Why, indeed???
http://www.stumbleupon.com/su/24CwaA/news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/8474611.stm
When are you going to tell us what you really think?

Maybe I'll give up the worrying about those seven deadly sins and just go for it.

Rated.
agreed, Bonnie. Or just ask a man.
Nick... I dunno. Someday I might just write an honest post. Who knows:)???
Come on, what's wrong with chicklit, vampire novels and self-help books? ;D

This is a great post, I loved it. What an original idea, too.
Thanks, Jane. There's hope in numbers. WHOOPS!
Well with the 40 day timetable, this should be easy to keep up with.

Guilt is a gift that keeps on giving. Mazel tov!
And I just gave up Ice Cream. . . Thanks for this!
wait, you get it back after 40 days? (where did I put all that hope...)

I found some, like I find some every time I read someone with a bit of sense

(that would be here)
Good luck with that Lisa. I'm giving up Lent for Lent.
R
I enjoyed this even though it is a sad commentary on the state of affairs currently surrounding us. Inanity seems to trump intelligence time after time. Though not Catholic, I'd much rather give up something like liver or hemorrhoids than Hope any day.
I'm giving up Lent for Lent. That should cover all the basis and take a big load off of hypocrisy. However, I am not giving up reading your posts.
R
I'm giving up hope that the issues that matter to me (what's being done to the women of the Congo, the suffering in Haiti, the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq, the people starving in this country, ad nauseum) will trump our attention and get front page OS status rather than summaries of t.v. shows, attention-whore celebrities, what someone is wearing, or whatever pop culture phenomenon happens to be on the cover. If we want substantive news and a chance to change the world, we could start right here. But rather than give up writing on those things, and commenting on blogs in which other people write on those things, I'll keep writing. But I'll no longer hope that life-or-death issues will be the stuff that greets us on the front page.

Man. I sound bitter. I think I need a long walk in the snowy woods to restore some sense of balance.
Thanks, Lisa, for this thought-provoking piece.
NOOOO!! Don't give up hope! You are just doing this for Lent, right?
Wow, that's a lot to give up. Fortunately I gave up religion itself a long time ago, so I can have hope and chocolate in the depths of winter when both are needed most.
Well said, Lisa. Rated.
Thanks, guys.....
and I LOVE you Lorraine. Keep the faith, doll.
I saw this on Huffington post and now here. Excellent writing Lisa. Leave it to Nick C. to leave a comment like that (I say with a smile). I'm with Lea...I'm the eternal optimist. It may not be reality but it feels a whole lot better. A 40 day break from hope? I can't do that but I sure could take a 40 day break from believing in illusions...that's something I'm sure we could both agree on.
I am just pleased anyone still had any HOPE left...
Nick gives great comment.
(Says Password) "Bonnie sent me."

Well written! Glad I was sent here. But I am not giving up hope, old as I am, because there are still people like you who give me hope ('cept for the next 40 days [and nights] during which time I will hide somewhere and cower - until you once again find hope). Hurry back! *Hoping* to read you again. {{{ R }}}
I totally forgot to say that I give up HOPE that the Democrats every grow a set and that Glenn Beck lapses into a coma..... sigh.
Second day of temporary no hope......
When idiots continue to do things like fly planes into buildings as a "protest" hope seems like a good thing to give...hope that there is indeed enough intelligence to go around.
Okay I will start hoping double then because with beautiful, inspired women like you in the world there simply must be good things on the horizon!
Rated for being a rant worth reading.

I give up hope that healing the world will happen in my lifetime, but I hope I never stop trying.

I take exception personally to the fathers not taking time/interest/responsibility with their kids, but who am I kidding? too many fathers don't. But I do.

And this: "the Hope that good conversation hasn’t really died a hopeless death" --?

-- there's a writer on OS who posted this thoughtful, original give-up-hope piece that contains a hundred good conversation starters, and at least a dozen of us will respond. More, even.

I hope you keep writing.
"I give up the Hope that people will actually choose substance over style."

Amen. Love Chocolate...
and now we all have to give up hope that the MSM won't go on and on and on about Tiger's apology when there are so many real news stories out there. Good grief.
Sure glad you gave up that hope. If I never hear about Tiger Woods again I would be happy. :)
every year i give up being nice to people i don't like
I loved this.

I also noted that you chose to use the word pontificate in reference to Cheney. That made me laugh, especially since this is a Lent post.

Last summer I took a break from the news -- a five week break. When I "came back" we were still hearing about Jon and Kate Plus 8. I was completely disappointed.

A thought about corporations, aren't they beholden to their stockholders? And who are the stockholders? Citizens of many countries. Perhaps the demands for change needs to go to the stockholders. Just a thought....

Again, this was a great piece. R
Thanks..... I am grateful this post still has some legs:) Yes, certainly the stockholders should exert a lot more power, as should "the people" over our own selfish and sickly society. Alas....
Thank you for this thoughtful and funny share. Only three more weeks and you can have your Hope back. I love Hope very much and would never dream of giving it up. Someone says "Hope is faith reaching out its hand in the dark." I love that. This is a great read. R.
For giving up hope, this sure is a hopeful piece in its own right. Smart, sharp, real and damn good!
Lisa, I am glad there is alimited time on the hopes you give up. Wouldn't it be wonderful if altruism was understood as a broard endeavor that involves heroism, a goal of the wealthy and powerful?

I think there are many who force greed at bay in their lives and activities, but they are not lauded in a public way that makes their sacrifices finer examples of humane efforts.
It's been a longgggggg forty days..... I mean, it isn't over yet!:)
In the bigger scope of things Lisa, hope is not an easy definition to adhere to, as are the other virtues hope, faith, charity and love the most beautiful of all. We are to give it freely as in it's many incantations it comes back to rejoice in our ears when we least expect it. Love has no bosses nor seeks leadership it just is, hope is what is expected when there is nothing else left, faith is what keeps people in live, knowing that even in the most pervasive ways, if it is not a God you believe, then you need to know someone is watching. Charity is the ability to give as though blind, not seeing the poverty of people, or their beings, but being able to give as God has given, and you shall be richly blessed. When we look for our return, Gods reply is "you have been richly blessed already", when you don't look , you will find.
Yikes. And this was written before the oil spill!
It was indeed, Steve....