Lisa Solod

Lisa Solod
Location
Savannah, Georgia, USA
Birthday
January 03
Bio
Writer, Mother, Mother, Writer Visit me at www.lisasolod.com

Lisa Solod's Links

New list
Editor’s Pick
AUGUST 11, 2010 2:08PM

Do I Want to Know I Have Alzheimer's?

Rate: 20 Flag

 

 

                Five years ago, right before her seventy-eighth birthday, my mother was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s.  The symptoms had been apparent for several years but alcohol masked some of them and denial, perhaps, masked others.  Once my mother finally entered a rehabilitation facility and was no longer drinking, it became obvious that something was seriously wrong.  Within weeks my sisters and I had cleaned out and sold her house and moved her into a secure assisted living facility with an attached unit for when her memory finally and completely gives out.  She was given Aricept to try and slow the progress of the disease and it seems to be working.  After a couple of years of railing at her fate and moments of clear and painful lucidity she has stabilized.  Although her short-term memory is completely gone, she still knows family and friends, can still dress herself, and enjoy certain limited events, although she has no recall of any of those events as little as hours later, and conversations with her are repetitive in the extreme.

                More than a dozen years ago, my grandmother, her mother, died after a long battle with what we now believe was Alzheimer’s, although at the time was diagnosed as senile dementia.  Her symptoms were the same as my mother’s, although she became progressively and more quickly worse:  unable to manage even the simplest of tasks.

                I know that my chances of suffering from Alzheimer’s have increased exponentially, perhaps as high as fifty percent, by  having both a mother and a grandmother who suffered from the disease.  And now, science has made breakthroughs which may well lead to an early diagnosis, as early even, as the age of fifty.  I am fifty five. 

                So, do I wish to know?  Do I wish to take  the new spinal-fluid test which, according to the New York Times is “100 percent accurate in identifying patients with significant memory loss who are on their way to developing Alzheimer’s disease”?  Do I wish to live with the knowledge that ten years down the road I will be unable to think, remember, perhaps even dress or recognize family and friends?

                I don’t think so.

                Although I admit that part of me wishes to know, if only to put to rest my fear of the disease, the larger part of me just can’t cope.  If there were a cure, yes, of course.  But the fact is that the medications that are currently available may only slow the progress of the disease, and only in some persons.  And the new medications being tested have side effects I am simply not ready to cope with.  Although I sympathize that early detection may well help scientists to “save the brain” as they put it, of patients who otherwise would degenerate swiftly, I am not ready to offer myself as a guinea pig.  Call it the ostrich syndrome but at this point I prefer the knowledge of no knowledge.

                In addition, what if, like the early tests for AIDS, I got a false positive on the spinal-fluid test? The stress of waiting for another painful test would be nigh unbearable.  And ultimately,  and perhaps most crucially, if I should test positive, that particular information would severely limit my sense of my future and my ability to enjoy the life I lead now.  Even should medications be able to slow the progress of the disease, the mere information that I had it would, for me, lead to impossible despair.

I assume I have “biological markers.”  I can live with that.  I also assume that in ten years time the research will be perfected to a point that it may well make sense to take the spinal-fluid test and, should I show the markers, begin treatment.   But for the present, doctors have run the usual tests for early memory loss on me and I seem to suffer no symptoms.  A check of the ten early warning signs of the disease lets me know that none of the more serious incidents:  repeatedly losing things, acting inappropriately, forgetting simple tasks, personality change, have reared their ugly head.  But do I worry?  Of course I do. My mother was a brilliant, accomplished woman.  To see her reduced to a shattered shell of her former self is heart-breaking.

 I have watched the progression of the disease in both my grandmother and my mother.  My mother, five years after her diagnosis, remains physically healthy; she could easily live five more years at the least.  But what is her quality of life?  She can no longer read,  no longer remain interested in a film or a television program.  Her beloved stereo sits gathering dust.  She gets anxious and disoriented if taken out of the safe haven of her assisted living for more than a couple of hours.  She forgets her children’s and sister’s visits, can’t remember what she did a day earlier.  Her joy is fleeting, her grief palpable, and her life an endless stretch of things she can no longer love.  The possibility of that sort of  future for me is painful enough in the abstract.  I do not wish to know for certain.

                .  

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I hadn't heard of this test. I'm not sure what I'd do. All of the men on my father's side have died of Alzheimers. I know that my father feels cursed and is just waiting for it to set in, the desease that is.

As an aside, your banner is beautiful. Thanks for the posting!
I understand what you are saying completely. My grandmother died from Alzheimers so I may be in the same position as you. The only reason I would want to know is so that I could prepare: choose what facility to go into [or home care instead]. Make the connections with people I want to see before I go into that grey night. Make sure I tell everyone I love them and goodbye. Maybe I'll take the test in 5 years. Good post.
I would be reluctant to take the test, too. If this disease could be prevented, I'd want to know. Knowing that it can't be would only cloud my view of the world until the day when I wouldn't remember. I would feel like I was serving a sentence on death row.
Yes. Exactly. Death Row.
What a tough decision to make, and I can certainly understand your reluctance to find out. I look at every day that I have my health, and have no knowledge of a serious health condition, as a blessing. Because knowing something like that, I agree, would surely be a cause for despair.
I wouldn't want to know. This is so hard. Thanks you for sharing with us.
I've know I've got the biological markers. Should any of my pre-existing symptoms (like repeatedly losing things, acting inappropriately, forgetting simple tasks...most of these since childhood...wait, what was I saying?) grow noticeably worse, I intend to spare my loved ones.

I'd like to order a nice vodka-valium-xanax-ambien-tini with a festive umbrella in it, please. Hold the olives.

I do understand what you're saying here but for me, forewarned is forearmed.
I agree with you. I wouldn't want to know either. If it's nothing we can do to thwart its arrival, why be burdened with the knowledge that we're going to be afflicted? My grandmother also died of alzheimers. My 74 year old Dad is starting to show some signs, but I'm convinced it's because of his drinking while on so many different medications. It's all so sad.
This one hits close to home - my foster mother suffered with this for years. It was without a doubt the worst experience I had as an adult watching her suffer. My heart goes out to you and your family.

I do not know if I would want to know if I was headed in this direction or not. I do not envy your position. Well written post, Lisa!
I took live-in care of my maternal grandmother for the last 5 years of her life, so she would not have to go into a home, because that was the only thing she asked of me. While grandma herself was mentally intact, we watched her boyfriend OC go through a frighteningly rapid decline from Alzheimer's, and it just broke her heart.

So I know what you're saying, and I'm 50 now myself.

As for an answer to your (semi-rhetorical) question, not for me, thanks.

Primus, I don't trust doctors to get it right.

Secundus, Nobody is effing around with my spinal fluid in anything less than an emergency; again, I don't trust them not to screw it up and do me permanent damage.

Tertius, I'm not convinced that they really understand the actual causes of Alzheimer's.

I'd rather just go on "...truckin, like the doo-dah man, once told me, ya got to play yor hand, sometime, the cards ain't worth a damn, if you don't lay em down, uh huh~!"
This is one of those posts which resonates. No easy answers.
Oh Denise, I am with you there. If I start to notice, then yes.... But do I want to know now that in ten years I will not be me? Nope. When I start to get there, then I shall make the decisions.
First - you're 55? Your picture doesn't show it!

I, like you, would probably take a day at a time approach. Who wants to be a foregone conclusion? Best to you and your mother.
Have you been looking in my window the past ten years? Because this parallels my mother's situation so closely that it's kind of scary. Especially the last paragraph,although my mom is still able to decode words, but has virtually no comprehension. I've written a couple of posts about it here on OS. I'm with you, I don't want to know. I'm just going to live my life and if the ineveitable happens, so be it.
I just keep hoping for some kind of cure. Watching them go after my mother's cancer has given me hope for most diseases. All we need is time, which is in shorter and shorter supply for most of us.
I am pretty sure I will be gone before they find a cure.
My genome is mapped. I have no genetic markers favoring it. No family members with it. And yet I have parkinson's. Would I have wanted to know ahead of time? Because there is no cure as yet, no.

Every day is new. I am incredibly blessed. The moment is now. Do what your heart tells you.
I once spent an afternoon with a couple. She had fairly advanced Alzheimer's and he was her memory, constantly entertaining her, reminding her of who she was and what she loved. I can't say for sure, but it seemed that she was happy, or at least protected.

That's rare though. We aren't all blessed with a devoted partner willing and able to be there 24/7 and attend all our needs.

If medicine can't offer treatment, there's no reason to know. One can only make the most of each moment because none of us knows the future.
This is a timely post, given the new spinal-fluid test. Our ability to predict diseases of all kinds will only improve over time. Years from now, we'll be able to map our genomes at very low cost and create a list of conditions to which we are predisposed. And you can count me out. Heck, I don't even read about the diseases I already have, much less the ones I might get. Knowledge is sometimes helpful, sometime harmful. Wisdom is knowing the difference.
Wishing you a long lifetime of good health. Excellent post!
Lisa, my grandma had senile demetia and 3 times a week I practice counting backwards from a hundred by the number seven. If I get Alzheimer's I will want to fool myself for awhile--I've taken those "Alz" tests before and I drive myself crazy with them.

I think you are so right about choosing normal instead of playing detective with your future.
My mother was my father's caregiver with Parkinson's and though he's gone now, she recently asked my sister if she wanted to know if she might get it--she said no. I said yes--well, there's no crystal ball but I ending up with it--go figure. Last time I open my big mouth! LOL
Lisa, my mother is in a slow decline from Alzheimer's at age 82. Do I have the same potential? If I discovered I did, I sure as hell wouldn't want to reach 82 myself...

Thanks for a brave essay.
Rated.
As of years ago my step mother had no idea who I was. I don't visit her because I want to remember who she was. I know the face, but I don't know the lady.

Take the test? I don't think so. Not now. I would however make all the arrangements, appoint a guardian for financial matters, a different one for health matters, and have all my ducks in a row just in case. If you do it now when, or if, you get to that point all the decisions were made before anyone can claim you were under the effects of the disease when you made them.
I would take the test. I would rather know, and prepare. Also, I would rather know and not (hopefully) not have to be worried about it all of the time.
Either way, the truth will set you free.
Interestingly enough, and this makes sense, an article from Psychiatric Times, sent by a dear friend who is also a shrink, advises caution in testing. In part it reads:

"It is pretty easy to show that a promising laboratory procedure yields different group mean values when comparing Alzheimer's to a control group. It is very difficult to prove that it has sufficient reliability, accuracy, clinical utility, and cost effectiveness to become a useful diagnostic test worthy of use in routine clinical practice. It will require years of testing in very varied populations before we will learn if any if the currently available candidates is indeed the long awaited diagnostic test for Alzheimer's.

It is understandable that Alzheimer's experts have a strong desire to become preventively proactive. Can amyloid be the early marker of Alzheimer's, analogous to cholesterol and heart disease? Can early identification and early intervention prevent the ravages of the disease? The problem is that you simply cannot skip the middle steps. Do the research first - then publish the guidelines."
I have thought about this question myself, although I don't have the history you do. I have come to the same conclusion as you--I wouldn't want to know. Still, intellectually, I think it's a good idea. But I wouldn't do it.
Thanks Lisa for mentioning that article- bookmarking it now.
it's bloody brutal ain't it. my mother just got diagnosed with dementia and it's incredibly hard because she's otherwise totally intrepid and it's hard to see someone otherwise so strong go down. i don't agree with you however about knowing. i've lived long enough in denial about other issues and i'd rather know. that way at least i'd know what i was fighting and i wouldn't mind offering myself as a ginnea pig. at least, that way my daughter might think i am half the person my mother is and that will be a great victory. will i go out of the way to get the test? no.
My mother had alzheimer's and to see her slowly disappear was excruciatingly painful. To have her not remember who any of us were and to see her struggle with losing her former self was unbearable. She passed away last year and ultimately it was a relief, we had lost her years before. Would she have wanted to know? I think so, I think there were many things she would have liked to communicate and do before the decline. We also would have been prepared when she got lost taking a walk or a drive. And she might not have been as confused and upset when she started misplacing things and getting lost.

As difficult as it would be I would like to know, though not via a spinal-fluid test, too painful and too risky (there will be a better test in the future, perhaps not in time for me, but progress is being made). I would want to know for the same reasons, putting things in order before I can't, but also because I would completely change my approach to life. I would try and do and see the many things that I have always wanted to, I would communicate differently and not get caught up in life's trials and tribulations. I would see the world through a different prism. We never know when we are going to go, but knowing that something so difficult for me and those around me was approaching would allow them to be more prepared for the heavy road ahead. Though I do like Denise's idea of having that martini ready and waiting. I suppose it would make the most sense to approach life this new way even without knowing.