
It’s important to know who your friends are. In the digital age, it can be very hard to tell.
I have a Facebook page. I have also experimented with MySpace, though these days that’s really a means of keeping tabs on certain musicians and actors whose careers I like to follow. I have an account here on Open Salon. For a while earlier this decade, I had a journal on Diaryland that is now defunct and locked up tight. When most of my Diaryland friends made the migration to LiveJournal, for reasons not worth mentioning I did not join them. For a long time I have been a participant in a bulletin board community known as Teh Soapbox, and it’s previous incarnation courtesy of actor Wil Wheaton, The Soapbox. For a long time after our son was born, my husband and I played the MMPRG game called “City of Heroes” and we both maintain high ranking “alts” proudly in the Stars of Paragon, one of the highest ranking supergroups in the game.
Welcome to the Digital Me.
Identity is a thorny enough process in the real world. People spend years in therapy trying to answer the question “who am I?” Great philosophers throughout history have contemplated the question, writing books and books full of answers that mostly leave people confused. Like anyone else, my relationships with people that I encounter as I move through this planet in the context of my body are complicated. I am blessed with many friends who love me. There are people who hate me. I have done my share of hurting people and screwing up. I have a marriage and a son, both of whom I love beyond reason, who are the light of my life, and who at times are not happy with me, and who sometimes I wish would just go away.
I have had jobs – lots and lots of jobs – over the course of my nearly 40 years on this planet. I have been a daughter, a lover, a wife, a mother, a friend, an enemy, a whipping boy, a student, an intern, a lawyer, a consultant, a tarot reader, a shopgirl, a jewelry designer, a recruitment director, a volunteer, a public relations specialist, a living history enthusiast, a historian, a speaker, a teacher, a fall guy, a confidant, a co-conspirator, an instigator, a cheerleader and a host of other things. Some of them I got paid for, some I didn’t. Some I enjoyed, some I didn’t.
Living my life in the “real world” and grappling with the higher order questions of identity is hard enough. Now, however, we all have digital lives too. And the thing about digital living is that it is even more open ended and confusing than “real” life. After all, “real world” me has some limitations – I have but one body, such as it is. And while I can change things like my hair color and (with enough work) my weight, and even adopt accents or mannerisms or clothing at my whim, there are certain facts that can never be changed because I am rendered in an earthly shape. I can only be in one place at a time. I have no control over the accident of my birth. The government will always be able to find me because altering certain things like my fingerprints and retinas is prohibitively difficult for average people. I will die.
Digital me has no limitations except those that I choose. If I want to build my digital life in the persona of a 13 year old boy, I can. If I want to pretend that I am a seventy five year old grandmother with a sex addiction, I can do that too. I could even pretend to be different people in different places, or even more confusing, maintain two separate personas in the same place. I’ll state for the record right now that I am largely truthful in my digital life, choosing to be who I really am online in almost every venue I participate in, with the obvious exception of City of Heroes, mostly because in the “real world” I can’t just stamp my foot and make stalagmites appear to impale my enemies (but damn that would be cool if I could…). I may use a screenname in many of these venues, but that is not unusual – after all, plenty of people use “handles” to refer to themselves in the “real world.” We just call them nicknames.
The most important difference, however, is the nature of how real world me and digital me make “friends.”
In the “real world” I make friends hesitantly. Indeed there are many, many people in my life who might call me a friend who I consider to be acquaintances. Not that I am not friendly to people. I enjoy meeting people and getting to know them. People matter to me. I try to be kind to people and treat them with the warmth and respect that I enjoy receiving. But to me the word “friend” implies an intimacy that I simply do not make available to everyone I meet. My life is a little like an archery target – there are plenty of people whom I like and enjoy in the outer rings of my life. But to reach the innermost circle, to hit the bulls-eye, your aim must prove relentlessly true, and there are few who actually have what it takes.
My friends are the people who accept me exactly as I am, even knowing how much of a pain in the ass I can be, who have shown that they will walk beside me when I am in need or in pain, and who will answer the phone at 2 a.m. if I am calling upset and crying. I reserve the word “friend” for people like these. Other people in my life are “people I know.” These few are my friends.
I do feel blessed in that I keep my friends for the most part. There are a few instances where people who were my closest intimates, chosen family, people I had thought were “friends for life” proved not to be. Some went without a fight, others were painful separations. While it is true that there are friends that you make for a season who fulfill their purpose in your life and then go away, generally speaking those who become chosen family in my life tend to remain that way, even in the years when I freak out, lose my motivation and fail to send Christmas cards.
Once the gloves are off with me, if you are my friend (as opposed to being “someone I know”), as far as I am concerned, there are no lines to be crossed. You will know my innermost thoughts. If you want me to, I will tell you the things that I don’t advertise to the world, even the things that would be more properly termed secrets if I was more ashamed of them.* Friends are always welcome in my home and at my table. I will drop everything to come to the aid of a friend, and will offer whatever is in my power to give that might help. I will forgive much from a friend – short of betraying my trust or deliberately injuring me, there are few things you could say or do as my friend that I would not try to understand.
But in the digital world, friendship is astonishingly easy to acquire. On Facebook I have over 90 friends and the tally grows larger every week, and honestly, I’ve only been on the dang thing for a few months. On Open Salon I have dozens of “friends” that are the people that I have put in my friend list. I have been added to other people’s friend lists, people who I have no idea who they are consider me their friend. And the access to information that my friends have, particularly on Facebook, is rather invasive. They can see all my pictures, see who else is my friend, see all the info I choose to post. I can communicate with them via writing on my wall (which means all my other “friends” will see it) or by posting a status that tells every single one of my friends what I am doing “right now.” I mean, how many “real world” friends really have all that information right at their fingertips?
What makes this all the more disconcerting is the fact that while I am mostly honest in what I reveal about Real Me in constructing the Digital Me, that is not to say that I am making a full disclosure. One thing I have learned (the hard way, which is a post for another time) is that there is a point at which the Information Age can become the Too Much Information Age. The Internet is public. And it is forever. Make no mistake, anything you put out here can be dug up by anyone, and bite you in the ass.
Because Open Salon is such a friendly space it is easy to forget this. It is easy to think that you are writing your stories for the hundred or so folks who are “regulars” here in the OS. But in fact, even from the very beginning, we have always had more folks reading than writing. We’ve always had “lurkers” who like to read but for one reason or another do not want to write or comment. And while you need an OS account to post or comment, any old fool can add your latest post to their Facebook page and introduce you to their 200 friends.
For that reason, there are a lot of things you won’t find me discussing here. There are parts of my past that have been difficult, relationships that have gone horribly wrong, and pain that I have both received and inflicted. And I have no need to recount most of it here except in the most generic way because there is always the possibility that those involved in these emotional clusterfucks could find it and all those wounds could be reopened with an added dose of betrayal that comes from posting things in public places.
There’s also the fact that this medium lends itself to editing. I am not someone who writes my post directly into the OS interface. I spend several days writing most of my posts, and I spend considerable time editing them. I leave things out. Sometimes it’s because it detracts from the story. Sometimes it’s because it’s something about me that I’d rather folks not know, personal information that could be used to work injury on me and mine. Sometimes it’s just stuff that isn’t all that flattering, and there’s no way to twist it around and make it funny or endearing or cool. The literary equivalent of admitting you pick your nose. So there’s lots of stuff that y’all don’t know about the Real Me, even though you are “friends” with Digital Me.
That said, the thing I find most intriguing about OS, having participated in plenty of other Internet social exercises, is how quickly some of you have crossed the line, going from being friends with Digital Me to being on your way to being friends with the Real Me. I know I am not alone in this. I’m still jealous about Lonnie getting to meet Sandra and Mary and Cathy and Joan. But I have met other OSers, corresponded with even more, and hopefully will meet more of you during Inauguration weekend. I don’t know how some of you (and you know who you are) did this thing – crawl into my soul the way you have – but I’m very happy to know you. All of you.
So much for the line between the Digital Me and the Real Me.
* I learned a long time ago that being human is to be imperfect, and that being actually ashamed of something that merely comes as part of the human package is a waste of energy. Regret is so much more reasonable an emotion when you screw up.


Salon.com
Comments
I feel a very kindred spirit - I have loads of "friends" on Facebook and lots of "friends/more than acquaintances" whom I adore hanging out & spending time with, but only a handful of trusted souls in my life.
Salut!
It engenders reflection: I love my pseudonym but I am, since your post, considering just how easy it would be for anyone who knows me even slightly to break that code, or to even find me here through some fairly open-ended websearch, should they want to go to the trouble. Hmmm. Luckily I have nothing to hide... (sure, O'Kathryn).
Your bullseye analogy is a good one and perfectly describes my own approach to making acquaintances and friends.
I don't worry much about posting under my real name - it's no more dangerous than publishing a book that is subsequently bought by 100,000 people. If someone is determined to look you up and bother you, they're going to. Hiding your whole life behind a pseudonym just limits the pool of people who can do this but it does not eliminate them. Using my real name keeps me more civil than I might otherwise be - I notice that the pseudononymous are much more likely to get nasty and prefer to learn from this rather than emulate it.
So Sandra, what's the new name already???
Thanks for sharing all you do share on your blog. I really enjoy reading.
In grad school we read case a case study of a woman whose avatar was raped in some primitive online society. People in my class were incredulous; why didn't she just sign off? But the bonds and deep immersion into this other thing are very real to the people involved, and now, with so many venues, it can become confusing. Great post, Liz.
hard to find the balance between revealing oneself, and hiding all of those things that make me identifiable.
that being said, I'm loving this cocktail party and am looking forward to making more friends!
very nice post Liz.
There was a very important condition you mentioned, the core of any friendship, honesty.
Yes, there is a TMI factor, but there is also available in this eWorld an opportunity to open, be you, say all that you wish, with the benefit of 20/20 hindsight.
So we, I certainly, get to craft the heat, the cold, the warmth I wish. There is an opportunity of reveal here as well that I, for one, do not find at all in real life. I sing in two groups, choir and opera, and I doubt that there are more than five who know I write out of hundreds. Maybe one has ever read a poem of mine.
I find this venue liberating, honest, comforting, and a playground among many brilliant and insightful people.
We crawled into parts of your soul, because you left a clear trail of bread crumbs throughout your excellent posts.
Do I know you? No. But yes, I do.
Dean
And somehow, between the fence posts of words, there is meaning and feelings.
Formal friends are the nice neighbors down the block, likable people I've done business with, friends of friends and online friends. All great people with whom I share stories, parties, laughs, respect.
Intimate friends are people with a shared history, people who support me when I'm not at my best, people I have known and who have known me through various episodes and phases and have the intimate perspective. The people I can "hang out" with.
I am always a little apprehensive about my expectations when meeting someone, but those expectations are unfair and not true to any experience of another person.
In the art biz I face that all the time. Clients who are hot to meet me sometimes let their faces drop when they discover I am not the type of person who slays dragons, or pisses in their fireplaces,(see Jackson Pollack). It used to bother me......now I find it........well, I don't find it.
Very Good piece Liz. Good will at the end. And I wish the best for all of you going to Washington. Raise a glass, or two (or not) for all of us at OS!
I know that so much of this rang true for me. I have been online for over ten years and there are pages with stuff I wrote long ago over which I no longer have any control. So be it. I use my name, like you do, and am happy to do so. It has led me to connect with old friends a bit and to find out sometimes why those relationships grew apart. My relationships online have caused me as much growth & insight as anything or anyone in the rest of my life. For that I am grateful.
I am very aware that friends here are not the same as friends in the flesh. But since everybody on my friends list is there by mutual agreement at least I don't have to wonder why they are on the list.
Everyone does the friending thing differently, and that is OK with me. What has surprised me is how several people on my list have taken the next step in becoming closer to me by PM and regular email. And I have done the same with others. That next step to deeper intimacy is also mutual.
So while I see a difference in the two worlds, like you I find that some here have worked their way into my heart -- which I could not have imagined would happen.
Monte
And who btw is going to the inauguration?
I count you among "people who if I met IRL would be my friend." I actually wish OS had that qualification.
Allow me to use this space to pimp our Inaugural Texas OS Taco and Margarita Fiesta (see http://open.salon.com/content.php?cid=63714). You don't have to live in Texas to attend. Saturday, January 24th at Guero's Taco Bar in Austin. A list of luminaries has already responded. Y'all come, ya hear?
Brella, you have an excellent point that pseudonyms seem a lot more protective than they actually are. But they do provide some plausible deniability with friends and relatives.
lps-- I think that really is my point...in this brave, new strange world, something that I thought I understood (friendship) is now so much more complicated....
O'K -- hiding in plain sight is sometimes the best way to go....:)
Sandra nl Miller -- I think anyone can forget themselves and get uncivil under the right circumstances, but some people do use anonymity as a weapon. See you soon!
Rich -- It's good to know you too.
Sally -- sending good vibes your way.
Somyr -- I actually use the "friend" function here in much the same way. Thanks for being here.
P-F -- you're definitely one of those people who've managed to crawl in, sweetie. I hope you knew that. But if not, know that you are.
Procopius, here's mud in your eye, friend....
Mary Joan (who will always be Red in my mind) -- I think your approach is most sensible. I know you've tinkered alot with your identity here on OS, and those kinds of struggles are exactly the kind of thing that make our digital selves so confusing. And let me know when you do the NYC meet, because I will be there.
Marcelleqb -- cheers!
Rob, thanks!
Undertow, my family is a big reason why I keep myself so cirumspect. Many times the fragile peace we have in our homes exist because of what we don't let on.
sciencechick -- I am sorry you've been stalked. I know how invasive that feels. Good for you for not letting it shut you down entirely.
Michael, thanks for stopping in, but as someone already mentioned, stalking isn't nearly as fun as you might think.
Cartouche, it's mutual, I assure you.
Catamite....only in your dreams? *sigh*
Dean, one thing I don't think I adequately explored in this is the fact that the online world does allow some increased intimacy. There are things you will say through a keyboard that you just won't when you see someone face to face. And thank you.
Monsieur, as always, you find a way to put it much more elegantly than I have.
Gary, it's funny how people place expectations on how you're supposed to be based on the label you've been socially assigned. You tell folks you're an artist and they think they know how you're supposed to be, feel, think. Same thing happens to lawyers and others. Always good to see you...cheers!
As always, an interesting and intelligent post on a thought provoking subject.
So much of what you said about "real" friends mirrors my thoughts and experiences. So much of what you said about "digital"places, might as well have been written in Greek---OS is my first and only digital love. And so much of what you said regarding what to post and how exposed one feels after posting---these are thoughts I've been grappling with lately.
But in particular, what touched me where your comments about how people here have "crawl[ed] into your soul." It has certainly happened with me. I'm pretty new here, and I sometimes feel like I'm the new kid in school, meeting people and hoping they'll like me---but in this case, it is specifically that they'll like me as much as I like them. It's really a bit odd---but I'm just going with it.
I'm generally not your warm and fuzzy kind of gal---but there is something about getting to know someone solely through their writing that is making me melt for my compatriots.
Thanks for letting me know that it's not just a case of my meds needing adjustment.
And I absolutely loved your list of jobs.
You must be crazy with anticipation over the upcoming inauguration and all the juicy comradery that will ensure during these exciting days and weeks ahead.
I envy those of you who can celebrate and whitness this together and wish you all the joy and fullfillment of experiencing this as one.
Know that I will be with you in spirit and friendship and will look forward to hearing all about it as the thrills unfold before this nation.
Keep the "left coasters" in the loop, will ya?!?
Your post - appreciated and left me wanting more.
xoxo Cathy
Matter of fact I'm heading to facebook right now to find and friend you.
I still chuckle at using friend as a verb.
Because Open Salon is such a friendly space it is easy to forget this.
you can run, but you'll just die tired..." You speak truth!
As the old soul tune goes, "what you see - is whatcha get."
Your post has made me think about my writings here, I'm going back to do an earnest editing job.
Rated.
I was/am shy around women in person but met my wife online in a chat room, 11 years and going strong.
It seems to me that because of Facebook and Myspace that the word "friend" has lost some of it's meaning. It used to be that a friend was someone who gained and was given your trust, but in the digital word a friend is someone you click a button to allow them to view pictures.
rated and appreciated
Greg
Susanne, you are absolutely right that friends online have just as much power to make you grow as "real" friends. I know that has been true for me.
Monte, I have to say that your style of "mutual friending" is pretty cool. Me, I tend to "friend" on OS someone whose stuff I want to keep track of. There's a lot about the OS interface that is probably pretty clunky, but chalk it up to being part of version 1.0 of anything on the Internet. But it's the people I think that keeps us all putting up with it.
Lea, I've heard from a number of folks that they are coming, and I think we've even done a Yahoo! Group ....I think I'll leave it for a surprise who's there because I would love to find a way to live blog it for OS.
Julie, s'mutual, believe me. I wish I could make the Texas thing....hmmnnnnn. The chance to meet folks AND have genuine tex-mex may prove too much for me to resist.
Ann, I agree....being more vulnerable here than I've been in other places has felt right somehow.
m.a.h. -- I think one thing that's been cool is how conscious we are of the notion that new folks who are trying to contribute should be made to feel like they belong here. I agree that you can almost fall in love with a writer through their words if you aren't careful. Yet another aspect of the line between "digital" and "real." Although you really should try City of Heros sometime. Nothing like becoming a superhero to really get your confidence up....
Cathy! Thanks. I've long suspected you were an insanely cool person that I'd love to actually meet. I think we may try to live blog the Inauguration weekend, we'll see.
LuLu&Phoebe -- I think OSers for the most part share a lot of common interests including writing. But I think it is also true that there are people I am becoming friends with here who I would have never in a million years would have guessed I would care for so much.
MoniqueC -- I've come to accept that the digital world doesn't treat "friend" as a big thing. But I do agree that in the beginning it was a little confusing.
Dave -- noun-verbs are my pet peeve! But I'll friend you anyway, sweetie!
Emma Peel -- I will have to write that post someday. I pretty much broke a friendship with a poorly worded journal entry on Diaryland.
AJ -- look forward to seeing you at the party!
JRDOG -- thanks! And the tagline is an old archery saying....I got it from my husband the traditional archery enthusiast.
Lonnie, I think in this case you've trumped me by making brevity the soul of wit. And I'm glad to get what I see with you, friend.
Moana, your writing has been among the most honest and quite frankly most moving stuff I've seen here. Don't you dare edit out of shame. You want to make it better, great. You have regrets? Well, then so it is. But don't you dare be embarassed about putting yourself out there as you have.
Geoff, imminently sensisble. And I still think you ought to show your ass up for the party, man.
Scott -- Thanks for dropping in! I'm so glad the Internet helped you find your spouse. I think the decreased inhibition of the screen communication can be a boon to shy people who have trouble being vulnerable. Good for you!
Thanks, Greg!
I have many online acquaintances now, thanks to Flickr and OS. Some of those have turned into real-life friendships; others may in time as well, who knows what tomorrow brings.
"Well, we all have a face, that we hide away forever;
And we take them out and show ourselves, when everyone has gone.
Some are satin, some are steel; some are silk, and some are leather;
They're the faces of the stranger, but we love to try them on."
Thumbed.
I think there is so much to discuss here. I don't know where to begin. I found most of what you were saying so true.
I think that we have as of yet to realize the implications of our on-line personas. I have noted of late that law enforcement and employers are making use of social networking sites like Facebook as a way to track down criminals; and make decisions about hiring/firings, etc. Living anonymously as well as perhaps being able to shed ones' past is increasingly becoming a relic in history.
She shall see what will become of it all with time.
Me, too, and wish so much I could be joining you for the Inauguration. Only thing is that it is COLD up there and so toasty warm down here in sunny Florida. Believe it or not, I put two homes under contract over the past week, and have two more buyers to work with tomorrow and Tuesday. So, that must have been the reason for me to miss something I certainly would have enjoyed!
I was thinking about you SOOO hard about a half hour ago that I think we had a psychic linkup. So, had to come to OS just to say that if wishes had wings that cut through snow and ice and made a body double that could take my place, I would be warmed by your friendly welcome this week.
You are very easy to love -- no doubt you have LOTS of friends online and in real life. Have fun these next few days -- don't forget to write about it?! ??