An Imqerfect Place

...screws fall out all the time

lorianne

lorianne
Location
California,
Birthday
March 05
Bio
I live & write in Southern California. I would like to buy a little monkey if they are not too expensive and put him in the basket of my poetry bicycle then ride around in big, lazy circles while wearing a pair of combat boots and a sun dress with no panties. ______________________________________ I have published and been published, but what matters most is what I am writing today. ______________________________________ I did not write this bio and I am not nearly as serious as my photo suggests.

MY RECENT POSTS

Lorianne's Links

MY LINKS
MY LINKS
MY LINKS
MY LINKS
MY LINKS
MY LINKS
MY LINKS
MY LINKS
MY LINKS
No links in this category.
MARCH 1, 2012 6:42PM

The Unbearable Whiteness Of Being (for Joan H.)

Rate: 40 Flag


I take my job as a mother very seriously. I want my daughter to grow up in a world better than the one I grew up in. Alexis turned 13 the other day and I realized this could never be so.


I grew up in suburbia. I went to good schools in good neighborhoods with the sons and daughters of good, hard working people. My daughter’s world looks much the same. I park my mid-sized car, in front of my middle class home in my middle class neighborhood where my daughter plays with the sons and daughters of good hard working people. Our worlds look so very much alike, but there is something in her world I can never see, touch or reach, no matter how much I want to.

I grew up white, in white America. My daughter is growing up brown. To those who know her casually, this may seem a misstatement. She is as fair skinned as any of my red-haired ancestors. But her delicate features, wide almond eyes and sheen of straight black hair speak her father’s Asian heritage. To the casual observer, she is a beautiful physical amalgamate of two worlds. Look more deeply into those dark eyes and you will see. In her soul, she is brown. Brown like her daddy. Brown like her grandma. Brown like her many aunts and uncles and cousins… her people, who bear her same features, carved in caramel skin.

When Alexis was born, pale as a fish’s belly, her paternal grandmother patted my arm and said “She is mestiza. Fair Asian beauty”, sounding slightly surprised that her own family’s dark skinned, Pilipino genes had been overwhelmed by my pasty Anglo ones.

For many years, her racial identification was not something I ever gave a thought to. She was simply my daughter. There were a few awkward moments for strangers who assumed her exotic features counter-pointing my own white bread ones meant she was adopted, but those were quickly resolved with an icy “No, she’s mine. Wanna see the stretch marks?” to anyone rude enough to ask.


Starting her in school gave a brief moment of pause when filling out forms that insisted I make an ethnic selection. ‘Other’ sounded like she was an alien; there was no choice to describe her, and so I went with “Asian”. It wasn’t something I gave a lot of thought to. She was simply my daughter.

The last few years, this subject … the subject of color, race, ethnicity has forced itself into my consciousness; from my daughters world, into mine. As she began to explore the world and bring home stories of her day, I realized that although our worlds looked the same, they were not. That even though our worlds looked the same, the way the world looked at us was as different as night and day. That my daughter has experiences with the world that I cannot empathize with or even truly understand. I worried about this.

There are things my child understood too soon. The subtle underpinnings of being different. The blessing and burden of not being homogenized. The reality that sometimes, different is seen as less than. She bears this knowledge with as much grace and style as a 13 year old can muster. Painfully, (for me) she must bear it alone.

I can never know what she knows. I can never feel what it is like when classmates call her chink or gook. I have no real explanation why that grown man at the restaurant snarled at her to ‘get back on the boat she came here on’ when she accidentally bumped into him.

I cannot deny the racist tone of a teacher who suggested that she should be better at math, because “she is Asian after all.”


These experiences are a foreign land whose borders I cannot cross.

I worried about how she would steer herself through these treacherous lands without me.

Today we went shopping for the Halloween costume she has coveted since seeing it in the mall last week. She had finally nagged and worn me down enough to convince me that this was as good a time as any to break my ‘I hate the mall and will only go there at gunpoint’ rule.

She was so excited, she chattered the entire way there describing every minute detail of this beautiful costume. We arrived at the store and she pounced on the costume immediately, excitedly pointing out every detail just as she had described. It was adorable and I knew she would be adorable in it.
I handed her the cash and she went to make her purchase while I absentmindedly browsed (ok, maybe I don’t hate shopping, but I still hate the mall)

As the clerk was ringing up her purchases, I heard her say “A Chinese Alice In Wonderland?” the sarcasm dripping from her words.
I was about to step in, irate and ready to fling demands to see the manager, when I heard my daughter sweetly say “yeah, isn’t it great? Here in America, you can be anything you wanna be.”


She then leaned in closer and looking the girl straight in the eye, in an icy tone I didn't know she possessed, said, “Of course that probably doesn’t apply to the truly ignorant… get used to being a cashier.”

With that she collected her change and her purchase, smiled sweetly and literally skipped out of the store… leaving both the clerk and myself in shocked, jaw dropped silence.

Today I learned what else my daughter got from me besides fair skin.
Today I learned to worry a little less.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
She'll be just fine....Go young lady!!
Lorianne, I could not love this more if I tried. I love this. For so many reasons, on so many levels. Thank you so much. (Our daughters would be such good friends. :)
Congratulations on making an Alice in Wonderland with an ass kicking mouth!
Your daughter had the perfect comeback. Congratulations to her presence of mind ...and yours.
it's so great when the steering works.
Nice goin', Alexis. Nice goin', mama ~
Wow. Just wow. What a wonderful girl. She will grow up to be someone amazing. I am speechless. Congratulations for helping her find her confidence.
... not that there's anything wrong with being a cashier.
thanks you guys! she is a great girl who always seems to land on her feet with grace.

joan - i read your piece & it just spoke to this idea of how we can't 'really' understand the depths...how we think things are a certain way & are disappointed to learn they are not. *sigh*

kim - not a darn thing wrong with it! i believe all work is good work.
This was such a great story. I'd be feeling she could take care of herself. BRAVO.
Cool! What a relief it must be to you to see her cope like that. Hoping that underneath there isn't too much hurt accumulating... (People are such assholes...)
Sounds like me as a kid. I hope she continues being so punk rock.
You GO, Alexis! Like my white mother always told me: "Kill 'em with kindness. Never stoop to their pitiful levels."

Lezlie
“Of course that probably doesn’t apply to the truly ignorant… get used to being a cashier.”

I'll likely never meet your daughter so please tell her from me that by the Gods yes, she can be anything or one she wants to be, here in America or anywhere else, she's surely got what it takes ;).

Rated for the survivors.
My own grandson is something like your "brown" daughter, and you post helps me to know ways I can help or understand his journey through his own life.
thanks for the comments. i will show the girl-child and i'm sure she will love them.

after reading joans piece i thought about this issue some more. i think the reason joan's husband & my daughter dont get nearly as angry at these things as joan & i did (do) is this:

they happen so often in so many subtle ways, that if they got that angry every time...they would be angry ALL the time.

i also think their anger is tempered with a strong lack of surprise. unlike joan & myself, her hubby & my daughter are all too well aware that things arent really different,,, so theyre less shaken because they already know the truth.
13? Ok... when she was. I get it. I've seen pics- think you posted at least one at OS, long ago, and she is no less than stunningly beautiful.
We are 'the melting pot' or so we're told, but still so damned prejudiced. Guess it comes down to, as Alexis so scorchingly noted, ignorance. And ignorant people are mean, and smart people adapt. She's a contender, no doubt. As you once long ago said at my blog regarding Eli, that made me smile, "something about apples and trees" .... I think that's what you said, and now me back atya.
XOX... ha.. love ya
I'd pay to see that idiot clerk's expression! Great post.
I wish I was as smart and quick as she is . . . I'm soooo cheering her on!
I am cheering for her. A Chinese Bad Ass Alice. There's a fine reason to love America, and your daughter.
Great story and great comeback, Lorianne. I'm Asian and my husband is white, and we have hapa kids. I really do think that when you marry someone of a different race, you get a taste of what it's like to be them. Especially when you see your kids being treated differently. I'm going to share this link with the followers of my HapaMama.com. blog, too.
I know, literally, hundreds of, and related to, dozens of, Hapa/Pilipinas.

The sooner your daughter comes to the Islands, the better. She will see nothing but people just like her, and, she will obviously fit right in temperament wise!

Imua Keiki Wahine!!! (Onward Little Girl!)
"i also think their anger is tempered with a strong lack of surprise." My husband's cousin just wrote me on FB and said that although it bothers him when this happens, he is never surprised by it. blows my mind.
Quick witted comeback! Would have loved to see the look on the nasty cashiers face. And what an incredible rude thing to say, to anyone but especially to a child.
I know whose child she is. And I'm not worried about her at all. **terrific** piece, L.
thanks to you all. i posted this in a hurry because i wanted to share it with joan after reading her piece. i think this might be the original first draft of this...which is an older piece of mine. the girl-child is now 18 and still doing fine.

thank you all for your comments, but i am a lil chagrined at the fact that this unpolished draft is getting this kind of attention... that'll teach me.

i do enjoy the comment "conversations" we have around here though.

to oahu - i know exactly what you mean! this story was from a time when we lived in Iowa. we have sinced moved to the much more diverse southern california, where she sees lots more people who look like her! i think she prefers it.
Oh my Lorianne, this is a tremendous essay. RR
Someone has their wits about her. Great comeback.
I really loved your essay until the end of this:' “yeah, isn’t it great? Here in America, you can be anything you wanna be.” (r)
Your daughter kicks ass! Yeah, baby! Woot, woot! You go girl! Sounds like she got a lot of character from her mama. :) BTW: I have the opposite situation going on in my world: My son is half Irish/half Hispanic, and looks like Hugh Grant. I kid you not. No one, and I mean no one, believes he's half Hispanic. But, he calls himself "mestizo" to anyone who will listen. ... Brave new world!
Your daughter kicks ass! Yeah, baby! Woot, woot! You go girl! Sounds like she got a lot of character from her mama. :) BTW: I have the opposite situation going on in my world: My son is half Irish/half Hispanic, and looks like Hugh Grant. I kid you not. No one, and I mean no one, believes he's half Hispanic. But, he calls himself "mestizo" to anyone who will listen. ... Brave new world!
First: Thank you for coming back today.
Second: speechless and just learning. I have found it's not what we say: it' not what You said at all. It's what you modeled what you told her with who you are.
I miss your voice here, we need it, and I hope you continue to contribute.
Yes some folks can really speak their minds alrighty.
Damn, your daughter has chutzpah! Bravo. Very well-written piece.
I remember reading this some time ago. It's still fantastic.
Wow! Read and appreciated.
Grrrreatttt post, what a gurrrllll!!! No need to worry, be proud!!
JMac
I grew up being "the only one" in virtually everthing I did....Your daughter's response clearly shows that nothing has changed....When you're "the" minority person, you learn quickly how to defend yourself emotionally and intellectually...I'm surprised that you were "shocked". Glad to know that she's doing well...no shock or surprise there I'm sure.......

RATED!
What an amazing young woman. You must be very proud.