Alan Nothnagle

Alan Nothnagle
Location
Berlin, Germany
Birthday
May 04
Company
InterpretBerlin.com
Bio
I am a freelance writer, YA author, and translator/interpreter based in Berlin.

Alan Nothnagle's Links

New list
Editor’s Pick
OCTOBER 19, 2009 6:45AM

Berlin's "New Museum" reopens after a seventy-year sleep

Rate: 9 Flag

  Nefertiti
"Home" at last:
The Bust of Nefertiti in Berlin's New Museum
(14th century BCE)

IT TOOK ONLY A few hours to obliterate Berlin's New Museum, the brightest jewel in the capital's proud crown of cultural heritage sites. British bombs blasted holes through its roof on the night of November 22/23, 1943 and then the flames took over the job. A further bombing in February, 1945 finished off the last undamaged wing. Pitched battles by SS and Red Army forces in the last days of the war destroyed what little had been preserved from the flames, leaving only blackened walls and shattered exhibition rooms behind.

The museum itself had already closed at the oubreak of war in 1939. This means that its more mobile treasures were hidden away in mine shafts and other protected sites, preserving most of them for later  generations to view in a hodge-podge of museums scattered across Berlin. But these seventy years of improvisation are finally over, because on October 17, 2009 the New Museum finally reopened its doors, allowing visitors to admire some of the world's greatest historical art collections at their original site.

Sleeping Beauty awakes

The New Museum was commissioned by Prussian King Friedrich Wilhelm IV in 1841 and designed by star architect Friedrich August Stüler. The king wished to add a new museum to his "Museum Island" at the heart of the city near the royal palace as an addition to the nearby Old Museum and to house his collection of Egyptian art, Greek statues, prehistoric finds, copper engravings, ethnographic items, and other rare treasures. While Friedrich Wilhelm is remembered as "a romantic on the throne of Prussia," Stüler nevertheless made revolutionary use of steel girders and also deployed a steam-driven pile-driver in the construction process, making his building one of Europe's most modern museum structures upon its opening to the public in 1855. The building's dull exterior enveloped a lavish and downright hypnotic interior decoration scheme containing murals and ornaments that represented works of art in their own right.  In the 1930s a further addition joined the New Museum to the nearby Pergamon museum, linking the five institutions on Museum Island together into one of the world's most prestigious museum complexes.

Egyptian courtyard
Egyptian Courtyard in the New Museum (1862)

After its destruction in World War II, the building stood as a ruin for decades. This is what the Germans called its Dornröschenschlaf - its "Sleeping Beauty slumber." By the 1980s the New Museum was the most visible reminder of the horrors of war in East Berlin. The GDR government began plans to reconstruct it in 1986, securing or demolishing what was left of the original structure, and laid the cornerstone for a complete reconstruction of the building in September of 1989. Reunification in 1990 interrupted these plans, so that the actual reconstruction did not get underway until 1999. Another ten years and over 200 million Euros later, the new New Museum stands completed.

Modern Hall
The Modern Hall (1862)

"History leaves traces"

But it is no longer the New Museum of the pre-war era. Instead of restoring the building completely to its original appearance (as with the nearby Berlin Cathedral, which was reopened in all its imperial glory in 1993), British architect David Chipperfield decided to resist public pressure to recreate what was lost. Instead, he chose to preserve what was still there and otherwise create a new museum within the shell of the old. This meant rebuilding completely destroyed sections in a purely functional style, installing entirely modern stairways where RAF bombs had blasted away the marble originals, and otherwise leaving war damage and bare brick walls open for all to see - and to think about. Essentially all that is left of the museum's elaborate ornamentation is what either could be carried away to safety in 1939 or what the war has left us to look at. "History leaves behind traces," Chipperfield explains. While this decision has outraged many patrons, the experience of seeing the museum's world-class collections reassembled under one roof will likely render this controversy moot.

Eingangshalle
Modern entrance and stairway in the New Museum

Egyptian busts and looted gold

The centerpiece of the 27,000 square meter New Museum is once more Berlin's renowned Egyptian Museum with the glorious Bust of Nefertiti, which a German archeological expedition excavated from the Amarna site in 1912 and later smuggled back to Berlin. The bust and the collection's other spectacular objects, many of which had been squirreled away in a mine under what would later turn out to be Allied-occupied territory, had been on display at a museum in Wiesbaden and then in the Egyptian Museum in West Berlin from 1967 to 2005. Another portion could be viewed in East Berlin's Bode Museum on Museum Island after 1958. The two sections were later reunited in a temporary exhibit in the Old Museum and have finally returned to their original location.

Green Head
"Green Head" in the Egyptian Museum
c. 500 BCE

Part of Berlin's Collection of Classical Antiquities will be on display, along with the Museum for Pre- and Early History, which had been housed in a wing of West Berlin's Charlottenburg Castle since 1960. The latter's remarkable collection of Bronze Age artefacts includes the twenty-nine inch tall "Berlin Gold Hat" from southern Germany, whose ritual purpose we can only guess at today.

Berlin Gold Hat
The ceremonial "Berlin Gold Hat"
c. 1,000-800 BCE

This museum had always been best known for the Troy collection that archeologist and Troy discoverer Heinrich Schliemann donated "to the German people" in 1881. But the centerpiece of this collection, "Priam's Treasure," will only be displayed as a copy. The original had been kept in a Berlin bunker during the war. When Hitler personally ordered all of Berlin's art treasures to be shipped westward to keep them out of the hands of the Russians in the spring of 1945, the museum's director refused to part with them. Russian troops promptly seized the treasure along with breathtaking quantities of other artworks from across eastern Germany for a museum of looted art that Stalin had intended to open after the war and later thought better of. The Russian government only grudgingly revealed the treasure's existence to the world in 1994. It has been on display in Moscow's Pushkin Museum since 1996 and, like so many other looted items, it is unlikely ever to return to Berlin.

But the New Museum's directors really don't have a right to complain. After all, the Egyptian government has been demanding the return of the Nefertiti bust for decades, and the Turks probably wouldn't mind getting their hands back on the looted Priam Treasure as well. When it comes to art treasures, "ownership" is always relative.

Priams Treasure
The original "Priam's Treasure" will not be on display

The completion of the New Museum represents both the conclusion of a decades-old effort to restore Museum Island to its original status and also the closing of one of the last great wounds slashed into the city's fabric by World War II.  And yet, Chipperfield's reconstruction ensures that the memory of that horrific event will be preserved right along with all the other memories that are housed beneath its roof. After all, the nightmare of the World Wars is just as much a part of our collective cultural heritage as the Bust of Nefertiti - even though it is a lot less beautiful.


You can take a virtual tour of the reconstructed New Museum by clicking on the image below.

  New Museum Berlin

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Very interesting. This made me want to visit Berlin, something I have never considered before.
Nice bit of history.
I see in The New York Times that Egypt wants that Nefertiti statue back.
@snowball and rwnutjob
Thanks!
@Kathy
Yes, they really do want it back, the same way the Greeks want the Elgin Marbles from the Acropolis back from the British Museum in London. They clearly have a point, although if you look closely, much - even most - of the art in our museums was once looted or stolen from someone. You can't really give Nefertiti back without pretty much emptying this and every other major world museum. It will be extremely interesting to see how all this plays out.
You make a god tour guide. It will have to do until I go to Berlin.

Too much to see, too little time, and too many places closed to an American woman. *Sigh*
Ahem, Mr. Alan
"Home at Last"?

I will take issue with you this one time. Imagine if the Germans had returned the treasures to the lands they came from?

( I still love the Pergamon museum, love the name and location)
@Stellaa
As I wrote in the article, "When it comes to art treasures, "ownership" is always relative." Sure, other countries and regions may well have legitimate claims on these works, but once you start giving them back, there will be no stopping until the museums are all pretty much empty. Art historians have told me that pretty much all art is "looted art," and not just the stuff the Russians have hidden away. (I'm just thinking of all those "pre-Columbian" museum exhibititions in the US.) Maybe we should all give everything back, although somehow I suspect an "art amnesty" might be a better course to pursue. Just learning how a specific work of art made it to a certain exhibition venue is a whole cultural and political history lesson in itself. Talk about "blood diamonds"! (The movie "The Red Violin" dealt with some of these issues.)
Alan, it's not relative, this is the convenient justification European and American museums (looters) use. I am a Greek born in Egypt. I know where the Egyptian and Greek antiquities were made, it's not relative. And the notion that the Europeans/Americans are better at taking care of the treasures is honestly racist and insulting.

It's complicated. A solution, they should be given back with rights to lease for X number of years. For me, the Brits have to give up the Elgins and the Germans Nefertiti. These are archetypical symbols.
@Stellaa
That sounds like a great topic for an OS post! Of course, one could also argue that the world's heritage belongs to the world and the Egyptian museum is already bursting at the seams (although one wouldn't make many friends in Egypt that way). For what it's worth, Zahi Hawass, who is Egypt's director for antiquities, has secured the release of some 9,000 Egyptian artefacts in recent years and he's working hard on the Nefertiti case.

A few years ago a friend of mine was thinking of writing a dissertation on the origins of the works of art (most of which are stolen to one degree or another) on view in the world's museums today. At the time that sounded dull to me, but now I think she may have been onto something.
Anyway, about the museum, I loved the virtual tour.
It looks like most of the museum survived the war. I think the choice to leave what was left intact and build around it was architecturally interesting. It's almost like the museum itself is a partially-restored museum piece.
This sounds like the place to visit when I come back over christmas. rated.
Nothing relative or complicated about this issue.
These are stolen artefacts.
The owners want them back.
The large number of thieves and their boldness in displaying their loot in complete impunity does not make it any less a crime.
And no, when it comes to cultural heritage there is no amnesty or period of prescription.
Thank you for reminding us about this reopening! It looks like a very nice museum. I have seen the Hermitage in Leningrad, now Sint Petersburg, and I was overwhelmed so now I do want to see this one. Berlin is not that far away I suppose. Of course the items have not always been legally obtained. There probably ought to be a law world wide dealing with that. Untill then, let's take the oppertunity to see them. The building, the items themself are worth while, no matter what!
I need to take my cowardly American soul to Berlin to see what the rest of the world sees instead of listening to so much wind which comes over NPR.
There are far more Gold hats in Europe, no?