Alan Nothnagle

Alan Nothnagle
Location
Berlin, Germany
Birthday
May 04
Company
InterpretBerlin.com
Bio
I am a freelance writer, YA author, and interpreter based in Berlin.

Editor’s Pick
DECEMBER 7, 2009 9:13AM

Berlin newspaper erects provocative new artwork

Rate: 18 Flag

 Friede sei mit euch
Peter Lenk's sculpture "Peace Be With You"
on the
taz building in Berlin

IT'S STORIES LIKE THIS that drive home just how different Europe and America can be from one another. On 15 November, 2009 the left-wing German newspaper Die Tageszeitung ("taz" for short) unveiled a provocative artwork by sculptor Peter Lenk on the exterior wall of its Kreuzberg headquarters featuring a naked man with a five-story, fifty-two foot porcelain male member that narrows into a cobra head at the tip. And the man depicted in the installation is not just any man, but Kai Diekmann, chief editor of the right-wing Bildzeitung, whose highrise headquarters is within spitting distance - with an unobstructed view of the artwork.

If you seek to understand what could motivate the management of a cash-strapped newspaper to invest a small fortune in such a bizarrely counterintuitive image you first need to know something about the German press. Diekmann's Bildzeitung, founded by publishing tycoon Axel Springer in  1952, is Europe's largest-circulation newspaper, selling three millions copies daily across forty-four countries. The Bild tabloid is to German newspapers what Fox News is to American TV. Decades before anyone in the US had ever heard of Rush Limbaugh or Glenn Beck, Bild was already out there rousing the rabble with anti-communist horror stories, faux populist outrage about the latest public sex or finance scandal, lurid celebrity gossip, a lavish full-color sports section and, its most popular feature, a daily topless photo of a buxom blonde model on the back page. While it has gained a lot of competition in recent years through cable TV and the Internet, Bild is as big as ever and its role in fomenting anti-student outrage in the late 1960s and early 1970s remains legendary. The German Left still blames Springer and Bild for whipping up the hatred that led to the killing of student Benno Ohnesorg in 1967 and the assassination attempt on the revolutionary Rudi Dutschke in 1968. (Readers who have watched the German movie The Baader-Meinhof Complex will recall the dramatic scenes where young demonstrators try to storm Berlin's Bild headquarters and, later on, where the RAF explodes a bomb in its editorial offices). Bild is the newspaper the Left loves to hate, and out of sheer spite the district council of Kreuzberg renamed the street on which the building is located "Rudi-Dutschke-Strasse" in 2008. However, calling Bild "right-wing" only makes sense in the German context. After all, in America many of its editorial positions - particularly in regard to health care and the environment - would likely be regarded as somewhere to the left of Leon Trotsky. But in Germany, aside from the neo-Nazi press, Bild is about as "right" as the Right can be. And yet somehow, despite its daily excesses, Bild still manages to remain vaguely respectable, which drives its critics so utterly bonkers that they are even willing to shell out good money for... But I'm getting ahead of myself.

Diekmann 
Stroking his ego:
Kai Diekmann, editor-in-chief of the
Bildzeitung

The spunky and cooperatively-owned taz, by contrast, is Germany's premiere leftist rag, and while it sells a mere 65,000 copies a day, it regards itself as the messenger for all that is noble and progressive in the world and thus as Bild's natural rival. This has led to an almost daily tit-for-tat between the papers that is vaguely reminiscent of the rivalry between Fox News and MSNBC.

The idea for the unusual wall decoration first began to take shape back in 2002, when the taz published a satirical editorial poking fun at Diekmann's disastrous (and almost certainly apocryphal) penis enlargement surgery in Florida. The newspaper has also been known to make rude allusions to Diekmann's last name - while it is unremarkable in German, most people here know enough English to understand the joke. The tongue-in-cheek  Florida article was only one example of the constant sniping between the two papers. This time, however, Diekmann sued the newspaper for damages and lost, thus engorging a mild and otherwise forgettable jab in the ribs into a nationwide incident. Some time later, the taz cooperative decided to commission a suitable work of public art that would give this David-and-Goliath victory a visual and more or less permanent - and virile - form of expression.

The taz has made its point all right, but Diekmann may well end up having the last laugh. Somehow the cooperative thought it would be a good idea to award the commission to Peter Lenk, a sculptor from the shores of Lake Constance in southwestern Germany who had already made waves in the coastal town of Ludwigshafen in 2008 with a sculpture entitled "Global Players." It features five leading German politicians, including Chancellor Angela Merkel, all stark naked and gleefully clutching each others' genitals. With a track record like that, it's hardly surprising that his latest masterpiece, "Friede sei mit dir" ("peace be with you"), now popularly known as "Der Pimmel über Berlin" ("the c**k over Berlin," a takeoff on Wim Wenders' film Der Himmel über Berlin, a.k.a. Wings of Desire) would not only raise eyebrows but also blood pressures - even inside taz headquarters itself.

Global Players 
Peter Lenk's sculpture "Global Players" (2008)
featuring  (from left to right) politicians Hans Eichel, Gerhard
Schröder, Chancellor Angela Merkel, Edmund Stoiber,
and Guido Westerwelle

Even though the new editor of the taz, Ines Pohl, began working for the paper just four months ago, she wants the sculpture gone yesterday. "If the artist Peter Lenk has his way, I'm going to have to lock up my bike every morning under a sixteen-meter-long schlong for the next two years," Pohl, a no-nonsense feminist, told Spiegel-online. "What a pathetic provocation. How tedious. I'm just not interested in this inflated smugness that revolves around the sad, never-ending male rivalry over who has the longest penis." Pohl's critique is bitterly ironic, since the original purpose of the sculpture was allegedly to provide "therapy for the sexual obsessions of the Bildzeitung." Indeed, the rest of the installation consists of caricatures based on vulgar headlines that have appeared in the newspaper over the decades, while a nude Friede Springer, the widow of founder Axel Springer and current publisher of Bild, sits at the top and "charms" Diekmann's "cobra" on a pipe. (The artwork's title "Friede sei mit dir," i.e. "Peace Be With You" is a pun on her name, since "Friede" also means "peace".) But the Diekmann caricature stands supreme over the rest. As Shakespeare might say, in unfurling Lenk's installation the taz has been "hoist with its own petard."

Ines Pohl 
Not amused:
Feminist and 
taz editor Ines Pohl

But it isn't just Pohl who has been left frigid by Lenk's display. Complaints are swelling, both among readers and Berliners in general, as the already flailing taz meekly collapses into two roughly equal factions - pro and anti. But neither Pohl nor the other opponents have any real say in the matter, since the taz is managed by its feisty and heavily ideological cooperative, few of whose members want to back away from this bracing encounter with their tails between their legs. After all, taking offense at the image is just so "bourgeois." But now even Diekmann, who was admittedly taken aback by the project at first, has since learned to play along with the taz's banter - the sculpture "strokes my ego," he wrote in his blog. He even joined the cooperative himself six months ago, which has provided him with a full frontal view of the ongoing self-abuse of his favorite rival.  And when the issue came to a climax at a cooperative meeting in late November, he duly cast his vote, going along with the majority in giving Lenk's sculpture a rousing heads-up.

Peter Lenk 
Detail of "Peace Be With You"

In any case, the newest member to join the Brandenburg Gate and Charlottenburg Palace in Berlin's august club of public monuments is unlikely to shrink away anytime soon: the taz is contractually obliged to keep it up for at least two years. Otherwise the increasingly flaccid daily would have to pay Lenk 130,000 Euros in compensation. Lenk himself admits that he is enjoying a good laugh over the controversy, regretting only that his sculpture had to be so small. "To reflect the acceptance the Bildzeitung enjoys among the elite, I would have required a surface taller than the Victory Column," he said in an interview. Berlin's Victory Column, with its iconic golden angel on top, is 222 feet high.

So Lenk's latest erection is here to stay, although this extended joke is fast losing its tone. The only question that remains is: What will Lenk, the taz or anyone else in this country do next time to provoke a reaction? I have no idea - but you can be sure that someone is hard at work on it this very moment.


You can watch a German-language video report on "Peace Be With You" here.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
@Ramesh
You are probably right about this. The sculpture hasn't done taz any good. While some people probably saw it as a clever idea, taz's large feminist readership doesn't think it's funny and in any case people stopped laughing in November. Now the paper is losing subscriptions because of it.
Nice job, Alan! You've managed to take something that in America is so unthinkable it is laughable and make it even more amusing. There is no giggle more fun than a naughty giggle ;-)

Actually, though, both this piece of artwork and Global Players are genius if your desire is to poke the hornet's nest. The symbolism cracks me up. Hope it doesn't hurt taz too much.
Didn't the Romans do this? I'd suggest somebody do it to Rupert Murdoch, but the result would be more nauseating than erotic.
R
Why can't American newspapers be more like this?
I like that he's depicted with his socks and shoes still on. Classy!
Wow, Alan. Your revised title on the cover of Salon got a lot of attention. Nothing like the 'p' word to stir up a little interest.
Art for art's sake. Berlin is an alright place. German art seems to be reverting back to the boldness of the 1920s. It is exciting. Soon American artist will be flocking to the freedom of Berlin like was done in the 1920s.

Listening Howe's What God Hast Wroght on CD, I realized that history is a circle where if you don't study it, everything appears as if new--but it has been there all the time burried under layers of what we see as the present.
Who knew the Germans could be so much fun??
"Who knew the Germans could be so much fun??"
Wait until you see the sculptured marzipan pigs sh***ing gold coins in the windows of fancy bakeries... I think "gleefully crude" sums it up. This can be either endearing, or offensive. It all depends on the mood of the onlooker, I guess.
I'm just glad I don't live in the neighborhood and have to explain it to a small child...
Thanks everyone (and Caracalla, I checked out your clue and will naturally be launching an investigation into my identity theft :-) )

@Stellaa
Precisely, I find the dynamics of this fascinating, particularly the way the taz has fallen into its own trap. You'll recall the silly elections posters from last summer. Same irony! In the end, this artwork says infinitely more about taz than about Diekmann. If they had been smart, they would have ordered it in papier maché and pulled it down again after a week.

@Sgt. Mom
You touch on an interesting point that I didn't want to go into in my article. The "humor" expressed here owes a lot to Catholic western German, and particularly Cologne and Düsseldorf-centered, Mardi Gras culture, where this sort of thing is standard (although only on a few days out of the year when it is the exception to the rule, which is the whole point of Mardi Gras). Giant, often downright pornographic floats depicting politicians and other public figures roll along in big drunken parades and a good time is had by all. It doesn't go over so well in Protestant/atheist Berlin, though, where Mardi Gras just seems like bad taste. So while the Berliners certainly have a sense of humor, this sort of thing doesn't really fly here in the big city. So while I don't know if Lenk was born Catholic (coming from Nuremberg, it's not particularly likely), his work reflects a familiar - and not universally appreciated - satirical style.
"Global Players" has a pretty clear precedent in Ed Keinholz's well known sculpture "My Country 'Tis of Thee". There's a photo online at http://www.lalouver.com/html/kienholz_bio_80s.html, though it's hard to see that each of the men straddling the pork barrel has his hand around the "Diek" of the man behind him.
Talk about your Edifice Complexes!
A five story penis? Freud would have been prowd. I do feel sorry for the editor who must park her bike under this thing for the next two years.
And Rainee174 wins the thread! Edifice Complex, indeed!
Yeah, though- I have to agree with Stellaa that taz kinda 'stepped on their d**ks on this one. With one five stories tall, it's hard to miss.
Although - can you imagine how interesting it is, giving directions to someone having reason to do business in a nearby building?
"Just look for the five story ..."

Ahem. I shall take my ribald sense of humor and go away, now.
Unless someone tops Rainee175.
There is a very German tradition with this sort of art though. My aunt has a piece of Weimar folk art that features the popular folk story character, Till, as one of those string-pull jumping-jack toys, but where the 'string' is fashioned into a long dangling penis, literally as long (relative in size) as this sculpture of Mr Diekmann. The art isn't venal because it isn't meant to be seductive or predatory. It is more typical of a snickering12-year-old, or of the extract from David Mitchell's book which got him nominated to Literary Review's last batch of bad sex writing awards.
Awesome, entertaining story! And I always thought the British papers were the wacky ones.
this is the kind of globalization i can approve of. germans with a sense of humor! who knew?
Great post! I'll go anywhere to read about phallic symbols.

And Europeans are just, well, more open and accepting than prudish Americans, I think. My favorite phallic moment in Europe was in Bruges, Belgium - window shopping, I stopped in wonder in front of an optometrist's shop: all the glasses were propped up beside, on, or held up by many sizes of penises and testicles. Some were 3' or so high, others more 'life' size ....

Wait - I forgot the guy (large statue) in Rome who has a giant cornucopia coming out of his lap - it's so large he has to hold it up with his hand. (must find photo and do a post)

Rated for great commentary on the state of newspapers and insight into Germany!
I would rate this on the title alone, but the content, ahem, rose to occasion.

I have to give props to for pulling off such a grand gesture, er, so to speak. How fortuitous that the wall of Taz used for the "display" was situated in such a way that it faced the object of their ridicule, the office of their nemesis, editor Kai Diekmann. How convenient for them that his last name brought to life the thoughts and feelings so many have had about Diekmann but we unable to express adequately till now.

Real life is so much crazier than anything Hollywood can dream up, I mean, c'mon, who would have thought of this?
Great post. Can't come up with anything better having read the brilliant comments. I'm awestruck. I thought Germans were (stereotypically) taciturn and grim, but they do have a sense of humor after all. Actually, wouldn't this be flattering to Diekmann?
that is a great story.
Why didn't anyone else pun this as in:

"That was en excellent job by the erectors."
It is provocative, but it is also hideous.
This is why I love Berlin. There is so much new art going on there and naturally, some pretty crazy stuff pops up (no pun intended). Congrats to artist Peter Lenk for being the artist of the moment.

But WTF is going on with editors these days?

Rupert Everett gave an interview where he discussed Vanity Fair editor Graydon Carter's "monster cock" as Carter pleased a rather loud woman in the suite above Rupert's.

Kai Diekmann, editor-in-chief of the Bildzeitung, gets penis enlargement surgery in Florida, blogs that his competitor Die Tageszeitung's sculpture of his penis "strokes my ego," and then votes to keep the sculpture up so he can view it.

If this trend keeps up, can't wait to see the new Broadway play, "The Penis Monologues."
I really like Peter Lenk's work. I think this work says something about male pride, body image, shame, and the cock fights that are going on everywhere in media. I think it's a beautiful addition to the building, and I'm surprised other feminists wouldn't see it as an expression of male fear and insecurity. xox
By far the most interesting read I've enjoyed this morning. To be honest though I'm surprised the Taz contracted Lenk given his previous work at Ludwigshafen. To me it seems as though the sculpture doesn't just poke fun at Kai Diekmann but at the rivalry between the two newspapers in general which is a bit like two guys comparing their d*ck sizes. And perhaps that makes it very fitting afterall. And whilst I don't find the sculpture appealing in any way I think I'll be keeping an eye out for Peter Lenk's future work none-the-less as he certainly seems to have the guts to make bold statements with his art without worrying about whether people will like it. As seems to be the case for the US though, I have yet to see something comparable in my home country South Africa...

Kev from South African Galleries
Very interesting post. Well written and informative.Thanks

Annonce gratuite
Great article - i have found you on google, im working in berlin and I can see the sculpture from Übersetzungsbüro Berlin. I like this sculpture but they are very straight!
I would like to say that I'm surprised about this, but there is no surprise at all... Let's put it like this: when countries in the communist block managed to get rid of the communist regime and started to have cable TV... well, Germany had already an established porn industry... a legal porn industry... so when you tell me that a newspaper has an artwork with a man that has a 5 story high pride for everybody to see, well, I'm not surprised... This is normal and nowadays, we should just see that as something normal, because the artist surely has a hidden message behind that...

custom lapel pins
interesting and imaginative..great thinking..great idea, good photos.
its hilarious! www.probicon.de
Very interesting post. I'm just glad I don't live in the neighborhood and have to explain it to a small. Terrasse verfugen
really great article! thanks for posting it.recently i´ve read a nice article about the profi holzspalter. and a lot of the information about profi holzspalter were new for me.