Why You Should See District 9
Since my last attempt to thwart the trend of mediocre movies earning box office receipts out of proportion to their actual level of quality fell short, I'm going to try a different tactic this week. This week I'm not asking you to avoid a movie that I suspect will be bad. Instead, I'm asking you to take a chance on a movie I strongly suspect will be one of the best films of the summer.
Before I launch into my tirade, let me get this out up front:
I have not seen District 9, and therefore it's possible I'll be wrong and the movie will be awful.
Let me tell you why that doesn't matter:
You bitches owe me for G.I. Joe.
Anyway, this movie's been on my radar for some time now. It has been getting great buzz among the geek and nerd community for awhile. While there are a few red flags with this film (no-name cast, a director with almost no resume to speak of), overall, all signs point to a good experience.
Reasons why you should see this movie:
1. The critics are going crazy over this. Right now, it's at 97% on Rotten Tomatoes (though that number will fluctuate as more reviews pour in). Now, let me put this in perspective. I had a commenter in my G.I. Joe post accuse me of "needing critics to tell me what to think about a movie." Well, no. I'm capable of making up my own mind. However, critics serve as an important litmus test, especially when looking at their scores in a batch, like Rotten Tomatoes does. If everyone universally loves a movie (or hates it) - that's a pretty strong indicator of what to expect. When a movie in a genre that traditionally doesn't appeal to the high brow set of critics (Ebert, the Village Voice) garners praise, you really need to look at that and say, "Wow, if [critic X] can be persuaded to love a sci-fi film, it may just be as good as he says." I don't take much notice of Roger Ebert when he bitches about a film having giant robots fighting, because frankly, that kind of movie isn't for him. But when I see an Ebert type raving about a film in a genre he normally isn't into, that makes me take notice.
2. It's a movie you probably know almost nothing about. And that's a good thing. Before you run out and read all the glowing reviews mentioned in #1, consider this: when was the last time you really got to see a movie without knowing all the details in advance? I went and saw The Hangover, and it was pretty good - but I didn't love it as much as my friends, and part of me thinks it's because the damn trailers gave all the jokes away. When you know too much about a film in advance, it colors the way you follow the action, because there's always this part of you going, "Well, I know so-and-so doesn't die, because he was in a scene in the trailer that didn't happen yet. I'm also pretty sure that the big twist will turn out to be [whatever]." What I'm chasing as a movie goer is that amazing feeling I had seeing The Matrix for the first time - the "holy shit, that blew my mind, I never saw that twist coming!" sensation that to this day makes me happy to even think about.
3. Peter Jackson is involved. Now, he's not the director, but he's been a big part of producing and promoting this film. And when you see Peter Jackson, you know that his WETA special effects shop is probably involved as well. That's a Very Good Thing. WETA's work in the Lord of the Rings trilogy was the first time I really felt like a CGI effect really looked real - you don't detect any hint of a green screen, and the actual physical work the shop does in terms of costumes and makeup is simply top-notch.
4. There are aliens (and what appears to be a giant robot).
5. It's set in South Africa. Face it - aren't you kind of sick of seeing the same locations (Paris, Washington DC , New York City, L.A.) blown up in movie after movie? Well, here's a change of scenery for you to enjoy. Also, aren't South African accents awesome?
6. I know almost nothing about the plot, but the tiny hint that I have picked up hints that story will be just as important as special effects in this one. Here's all you need to know on that front: aliens have landed in South Africa, they're shoved into a special ghetto (the "District 9" of the title), and they may be oppressed in some fashion. Hmmm... sound familiar to a social problem from that country about 2 decades ago? This is a movie that will hopefully provide more than the usual "shit blows up, heroes posture, bad guys lose, the end" plot for once.
7. Despite the promise of plenty of plot and character moments, don't despair action fans. I'm pretty sure lots of things are still going to blow up. And again... with WETA involved, those things that blow up are probably going to be freaking awesome.
8. Show Hollywood that a movie can be a success even without an obnoxious marketing campaign and a trailer awash in douchey rock music. Check out the excellent viral site for the movie.
9. You already saw G.I. Joe and Inglourious Basterds doesn't come out till next week, so nothing else is out.
10. Maybe they'll show an Avatar teaser before this one. Who knows?
I'm not saying you need to buy into the hype, and I'm not 100% sure this will be the greatest action movie ever made or anything. But when I see a small budget film like this come along that I fear will slip under a lot of people's radar, I like to promote it and give it a chance.
If you really need to be persuaded by a trailer, watch it here in HD: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d6PDlMggROA
If you do see the movie, please post your spoiler-free thoughts here (or wait till I review it early next week, where you can spoil all you want).
Since my last attempt to thwart the trend of mediocre movies earning box office receipts out of proportion to their actual level of quality fell short, I'm going to try a different tactic this week. This week I'm not asking you to avoid a movie that I suspect will be bad. Instead, I'm asking you to take a chance on a movie I strongly suspect will be one of the best films of the summer.Before I launch into my tirade, let me get this out up front:
I have not seen District 9, and therefore it's possible I'll be wrong and the movie will be awful.
Let me tell you why that doesn't matter:
You bitches owe me for G.I. Joe.
Anyway, this movie's been on my radar for some time now. It has been getting great buzz among the geek and nerd community for awhile. While there are a few red flags with this film (no-name cast, a director with almost no resume to speak of), overall, all signs point to a good experience.
Reasons why you should see this movie:
1. The critics are going crazy over this. Right now, it's at 97% on Rotten Tomatoes (though that number will fluctuate as more reviews pour in). Now, let me put this in perspective. I had a commenter in my G.I. Joe post accuse me of "needing critics to tell me what to think about a movie." Well, no. I'm capable of making up my own mind. However, critics serve as an important litmus test, especially when looking at their scores in a batch, like Rotten Tomatoes does. If everyone universally loves a movie (or hates it) - that's a pretty strong indicator of what to expect. When a movie in a genre that traditionally doesn't appeal to the high brow set of critics (Ebert, the Village Voice) garners praise, you really need to look at that and say, "Wow, if [critic X] can be persuaded to love a sci-fi film, it may just be as good as he says." I don't take much notice of Roger Ebert when he bitches about a film having giant robots fighting, because frankly, that kind of movie isn't for him. But when I see an Ebert type raving about a film in a genre he normally isn't into, that makes me take notice.
2. It's a movie you probably know almost nothing about. And that's a good thing. Before you run out and read all the glowing reviews mentioned in #1, consider this: when was the last time you really got to see a movie without knowing all the details in advance? I went and saw The Hangover, and it was pretty good - but I didn't love it as much as my friends, and part of me thinks it's because the damn trailers gave all the jokes away. When you know too much about a film in advance, it colors the way you follow the action, because there's always this part of you going, "Well, I know so-and-so doesn't die, because he was in a scene in the trailer that didn't happen yet. I'm also pretty sure that the big twist will turn out to be [whatever]." What I'm chasing as a movie goer is that amazing feeling I had seeing The Matrix for the first time - the "holy shit, that blew my mind, I never saw that twist coming!" sensation that to this day makes me happy to even think about.
3. Peter Jackson is involved. Now, he's not the director, but he's been a big part of producing and promoting this film. And when you see Peter Jackson, you know that his WETA special effects shop is probably involved as well. That's a Very Good Thing. WETA's work in the Lord of the Rings trilogy was the first time I really felt like a CGI effect really looked real - you don't detect any hint of a green screen, and the actual physical work the shop does in terms of costumes and makeup is simply top-notch.
4. There are aliens (and what appears to be a giant robot).
5. It's set in South Africa. Face it - aren't you kind of sick of seeing the same locations (Paris, Washington DC , New York City, L.A.) blown up in movie after movie? Well, here's a change of scenery for you to enjoy. Also, aren't South African accents awesome?
6. I know almost nothing about the plot, but the tiny hint that I have picked up hints that story will be just as important as special effects in this one. Here's all you need to know on that front: aliens have landed in South Africa, they're shoved into a special ghetto (the "District 9" of the title), and they may be oppressed in some fashion. Hmmm... sound familiar to a social problem from that country about 2 decades ago? This is a movie that will hopefully provide more than the usual "shit blows up, heroes posture, bad guys lose, the end" plot for once.
7. Despite the promise of plenty of plot and character moments, don't despair action fans. I'm pretty sure lots of things are still going to blow up. And again... with WETA involved, those things that blow up are probably going to be freaking awesome.
8. Show Hollywood that a movie can be a success even without an obnoxious marketing campaign and a trailer awash in douchey rock music. Check out the excellent viral site for the movie.
9. You already saw G.I. Joe and Inglourious Basterds doesn't come out till next week, so nothing else is out.
10. Maybe they'll show an Avatar teaser before this one. Who knows?
I'm not saying you need to buy into the hype, and I'm not 100% sure this will be the greatest action movie ever made or anything. But when I see a small budget film like this come along that I fear will slip under a lot of people's radar, I like to promote it and give it a chance.
If you really need to be persuaded by a trailer, watch it here in HD: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d6PDlMggROA
If you do see the movie, please post your spoiler-free thoughts here (or wait till I review it early next week, where you can spoil all you want).


Salon.com
Comments
they used to call Hollywood dream factories; my calls the mexplexes germ factories. rated for a great write up.
Having said that, I didn't see GI JOE [saw Julia & Julie instead and Funny People before that] this movie I want to see. Anything like the original Terminator, I like. Keep us posted!
i expect we'll be front and center at the nearest IMAX.
woop woop.
So what was the point of this post then?
Silly me. I've actually been listening to all the music before opining on it. Perhaps that's why they're not that successful posts.
So I'll try your approach next time.
This post is meant to be sort of like the conversation you might have with a friend before deciding whether to go see a film. You weigh the apparent pros of the movie versus the cons. As I said, I don't rely solely on movie reviews to make such a decision. This post merely lists other things about the movie that make me want to see it.
As for this one, I'm on the fence. I'm pleasantly optimistic because they aren't releasing a lot in terms of plot line on the trailers. It has to be better than most of the swill that has come out this summer. Action films suck as a general rule of thumb, but if this one is more Alien than Armageddon, it has a great chance.
My money is on you this week again. Great observation and not ALL critics suck! I know I don't. :-D
RATED
http://pcillu101.blogspot.com
But my SigOth wants to see The Cove, so I'll have to wait until next week. So he can see his fishflick.
Men and their dolphins!
I find interesting I don't think it ruins the film but it helps weed out the bad ones.
[url=http://allaboutbreakups.com]get your ex back[/url]
[url=http://allaboutbreakups.com]how to get back with your ex[/url]
I hate it when stupid Hollywood ruins everything for everyone.
The Road, however, is so adaptable. There's nothing but atmosphere. I'll probably like it better than the book, which was too much like Waiting For Godot After The Apocalypse for me.
Also looking forward to Inglorious Basterds which is getting great previews...
read you soon.
IT WAS AMAZING...AN ABSOLUTE MUST SEE FILM.
I just got back from a midnight showing and it completely blew me away. Nothing better than realizing you just witnessed an instant classic. Granted...it can be a little violent...but you are going to be soooo surprised just how much (and why) this film is going to move you. Wow...and I mean...WOW.
danbloom - LOVED the book version of The Road, and am cautiously optimistic about the movie version. While it's rare that a movie can equal the book it's adapted from, I do think that it'll be cool to finally see the doomed future McCormac described. And having Viggo Mortenson there to do the heavy lifting, acting-wise, makes me happy. I promise to post on it as the date gets closer (remind me via PM, if you would)
Erik Lars - I prefer you not spam links to content that has nothing to do with the topic at hand. However, to respond to your comment about trailers - depends on the movie for me. Some movies I prefer to get a taste of the trailer, so I can get a feel for what kind of movie it is (the trailer for 300 was particularly awesome and really helped sell that to me). A good trailer CAN be constructed such that it communicates the essence of a film without betraying its plot points. The trailer for the first Matrix is a textbook lesson in how to cut a compelling trailer that gives nothing away, but still whets your appetite for more.
Glenn - great to hear. I've got my nerd herd assembling this Saturday night to go watch it, so I hope we enjoy it as much as you did! :)
It's really good, and really depressing.
I'd be interested to hear if you have any agreements or disagreements once you see it.
Best,