Hallowe’en is on the way, and little ones are deciding whether to be a Ninja or Spiderman. It’s a cute tradition as Princesses, Xena, Batman and a few ghouls arrive at the door, exhibiting childhood greed. We give out handfuls because we figure if they are brave enough to make it through three barking dogs, they deserve a good pat on the back with more chips and Cadbury bars. There are the 6 foot ones who come to the door and grunt, but we usually just toss in a can of beer and they lumber off.
So when did Hallowe’en become controversial? Ah, when the fundamentalist Christian Right decided it was demonic. I don’t know why they had to pick on Hallowe’en. Maybe hugely sweet toothed parents took their candy away when they were kids, or Mom made them dress up like a ghost every Hallowe’en with nothing but a sheet on and two holes. But they are at it again already. Fundamentalist communties seem to feel that children in Mutant Ninja Turtle costumes are more prone to become minions of Satan. And how do these kids feel at school the next day, when lunch boxes of the others are filled with 'stolen' treasure? "My Mommy and Daddy think you are all demons" as the poor kids drool over candy apples and bags of chips?
Even the age old 'trick or treat' has become relatively meaningless. The only time I had a trick played on me was when I turned out our porch light to indicate no more candy left and someone VICIOUSLY took a stroke at the front door with a piece of soap. Deviltry.
Now I understand parents taking their kids to a church hall or community constructed 'haunted houses' to take their little ghosts and goblins to get their candy and show off their costumes as in many neighborhoods. It’s just safer. But at least they get to dress up and are not burned at the stake.
Even in Canada, which is not particularly known for fundamentalist ‘fun’, still have whole communities at work to ban Hallowe’en in it’s entirety. It is supposedly evil. In fact it is a tradition going back to the early Middle Ages when the ghosts of the dead were supposed to rise, and flour was sprinkled on the floor to indicate ghostly foot prints or on chairs to indicate whether a ghost was sitting there. Why a ghost would need to rest his dogs I don’t know, but they seemed to think this would protect them and they would pray and probably do the vampire cross thing. The priests didn’t mind, (I’m not saying Middle Ages priests were the brightest in the bunch) but they didn’t label it satanic. It was just a ‘thing’. The tradition then became fun over the years, once the flour sprinkling ceased and celebrated in its own form throughout the Western world in many different ways, most notably in the Latin American countries where wonderful skeletons parade through the streets on ‘The Day of the Dead”.
Our version is much more refined and not so Middle Age-y. The kids are afraid only when some goof jumps out at them from the bushes in a Scream mask, but even that is fun. I fail to see the connection with this and the demonic. I think it is possible that it is just another way for the Christian Right to flex it’s muscles. Kids dressing up as Satan! Abominable! I have only seen Satan at adult parties and he seemed quite pleasant.
The whole thing of banning Hallowe’en is a mystery to me. Maybe I’m just missing the point, but those that wish to outlaw Hallowe’en in it’s entirety would be robbing kids of one of the best days of the year. Who wouldn’t want to eat candy till they puke? I will never understand what this has to do with the demonic. Maybe someone out there can explain how our children can be cute little Johnny Depp pirates when they leave the house, and become the spawn of Satan as soon as they hit the streets.


Salon.com
Comments
Seriously, the fundies are starting to piss me off. What's next - banning everything that's not mentioned in the bible? Oh wait - that would take their guns away (which would be a good thing) and would make them members of the Taleban!
They aleady are our own version of the Taliban Cymraeg. They already are.
They wear this costume in the South sometimes, but they're not dressing as ghosties.....
Rated.
St. Lucy is traditionally depicted carrying her eyeballs before her on a platter--there's a statue of this in the back of my church.
St. Stephen was flayed alive, and is often depicted holding his removed skin.
And of course, there's always St. Joan of Arc being burned at the stake.
You can have a lot of fun with going as various saints on Halloween.
By the way, St. Nicholas of Myra is the patron saint of murderers.
But don't Wiccans eat children?
Rated.
They are not the only enemies of Halloween. Now that it is becoming socially unacceptable to ban gays from having sex, maybe we can substitute banning kids from eating candy.
Great post, rated of course.
The rest of you gang - right on for being supporters of Cadbury and Nestle. I don't know what I'd do without the left over candy.
and lest you think this an exaggeration, do a quick search (I'm too lazy to do it for you) for "halloween liberal plot" and see how many loony tunes actually believe your kid dressing up a spiderman is subversive and will lead to moral decay and corruption of society.
Still, curious that much of that marketing entices women to embrace their inner slut. Repressive culture, much?
Repression? How many people do you know dress up as their alter ego? Many, many, many....
or, "no, you can't be a slut, unless it's a costume, and we're meant to infer you're not really like that, as much as the person next to you isn't really a vampire."
Except that people's alter egos are usually what they wish they could be, daily, without restriction. But they don't, for fear of ridicule, ostracism, etc., ergo repression.
Although raised a fundamentalist Protestant, I escaped, but still believe in the essence of Christianity which is simply the Golden Rule. In fact, every religion has a version of the Golden Rule, even Judaism, although they don't seem to be practicing it in Israel in their relations with the Palestinians which is very, very sad to me.
What's strange to me, also, is that the "Christian" Right seems so afraid of the Harry Potter books, Halloween, Wicca, and so on. They don't have much faith (no pun intended) in their religion if it can be undermined by Halloween, do they? If they really believe that reading a Harry Potter book can undermine religious belief, then they don't understand how children's minds work for one thing, not to mention failing to understand that parental views are the dominant influence on all children....at least until they grow up when some do learn to think for themselves and do reject what they were taught in childhood as I did, at least some of it. One of my earliest Sunday School lessons that has stuck with me ever since is that I should "help God make a happy world". The "Christian" Right does no such thing!!
Whenever these so-called "Christians" start one of their hate fests against something, and something usually innocuous at that, I laugh. They only demonstrate their own lack of faith. No true Christian engages in the hateful and negative as they do. They are telling me loudly and clearly by such behavior that their own faith is weak, nor are they truly spiritually enlightened or spiritual at all.
THEY MOCK AND UNDERMINE THEMSELVES WHEN THEY START SPOUTING HATE!!
At least in the community I was raised in, no one thought the children were demons, but "we" did think that real witches, devil-worshippers, and the like were up to no good at Halloween. We even prayed extra hard to keep the evil away.
I'm excited about going to the Halloween parade in Boystown this year. Ah, my dad would lose it if he knew. His only daughter dressing up and going to a Halloween parade in the gay neighborhood. It's going to be so much fun.
Soapbox Amy - you've said it all so well. What about the 'Christians' that stand outside gay funerals with signs saying 'God hates fags'. None of this is about love - it's about fear mongering and loving only other fundamentalists.
Gwendolyn - I think you should go holding eyeballs.
I think they just don't want us to have any fun.....meanies
Or maybe they just need something to bitch about!
We have to be miserable in life or we'll burn in hell. But having to spend eternity with the Fundamentalists definitely sounds like my picture of hell.
On Halloween, I see cute kids in costumes getting candy and having a spooky sort of fun: Fundamentalists see tiny demons in training.
Did anyone ever tell these people they take religion WAY too seriously? I refuse to give up on Halloween!
rated
I mean, there's a reason 1% own 96% of the wealth...it was all based on Halloween. Trick or Treat?
I remeber a few years back when Chico had the halloween clusterfuck and they started having the "don't go to downtown Chico" on halloween bit.
Rated!
Explain the difference to me of being dressed in a pirate costume and asking for candy, and being forced to wear a sweater with reindeer crocheted on it and asking for a candy cane.
Which is more damaging to a child?
Shiral - NEVER give up on Hallowe'en!
But Kate - I wear that costume for a whole year!
Phaedo - we are returning to the Middle Ages - pretty soon they'll be sprinkling flour again.
Del - you made me laugh
Odetteroulette - maybe all the fundies should wear black hats.
Lady Miko - can you tell me where Chico's is?
BRBJ - I personally would never put a child in a reindeer sweater. Humiliating to child and most thinking grown ups. I would much rather my kid go as Ted Bundy.
HJ - Yes, people are nuts